Bio
The Mouthy Housewives are Kelcey Kintner, Wendi Aarons, Marinka, Kristine, and Tonya Vernooy. Together, they've been neglecting our familes to give y...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Should I Save My Kid From An Obnoxious Classmate?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Life is complicated. Thank goodness there are experts to help us untangle some of the vexing issues that, well, vex us on a daily basis. The Mouthy Housewives are here to help, three times a week. Today, the Housewives answer an exclusive BlogHerMoms question!

Mouthy Housewives logo


Dear Mouthy Housewives,

My son starts the fifth grade next week and I just found out that a boy we can’t stand will be in his class. This boy is loud, disruptive and picks on all of the kids (including mine.) I really, really don’t want my son to have to deal with him for an entire year.

I’m thinking about talking to the principal and asking to have my son put into another class, but my husband says I’m being ridiculous and to just deal with it. Am I overreacting?

Signed,

Worried Mom

lego clown

Credit Image: mac_filko on Flickr


Dear Worried Mom,

As a mom, your first instinct is to protect your kids at all costs. So it’s completely understandable that you’d want to shield your son from this supposedly "bad” kid. However, here’s a little saying I want you to mull over: “Better the devil you know than the devil you don’t.”

Meaning, you could go through all of the hand wringing, angst and drama involved in making such a move only to have your son wind up with a classmate who’s even worse. Then you’d feel like one of the schmucks on “The Price is Right” who turns down the new car showcase and winds up bidding on a room full of teak furniture and Rice-a-Roni. Even Bob Barker would say it’s a risky move.

But besides that, is this really the lesson you want to teach your son? That mommy can fix all of his problems and make his life 100% smooth sailing? You haven’t said that this kid specifically bullies your son or that he’s violent, just that he’s sort of a jerk. And guess what? Life’s full of jerks and sooner or later, he needs to learn how to deal with them. Today it’s the fifth grade, tomorrow he’ll have a co-worker who won’t stop stealing his stapler. And is he going to have his mommy call his boss when that happens?

My advice is to just leave things the way they are. Then, once school starts, listen to what your son has to tell you about the kid’s behavior. Ask him how he reacted, how the other kids reacted and what the teacher did about it. Conflict Resolution 101 right there, baby. But most important: Trust that the teaching professionals know what they’re doing and are handling the situation responsibly.

You’re a good mom for wanting to protect your son from jerks. But at a certain point, he needs to learn how to protect himself.

Good luck,

 

Wendi, TMH

 

 

 

 

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
aaustin13 6 pts

I think Wendi's advice is right on. Who knows, maybe LW's child can be the friend that this child needs to overcome whatever is troubling him and causing him to act out. With my daughters, I've taught them that some kids behave this way because they don't have a "happy home." The kids who are bullies need even more love and understanding than regular kids.

'Course, I've also taught them that if someone else starts a fight, they finish it. I mean, I don't want to raise pushovers. :)

Overall, though, I think the advice that you have to learn how to deal with jerks, eventually, is sound. If kids don't learn to deal with jerks in 5th grade, how are they going to deal with a horrible co-worker (just quit? Not always an option! Bills have to be paid.), or worse, a horrible in-law (may she rest in peace.... in a shallow grave in my backyard. LOL). You can't always run away from the people who make your life hell - especially when you're married into their family. The minor scuffles of childhood prepare us for the major difficulties of adulthood. Way to go with the good advice, Wendi! You win the internet.

didavis 5 pts

I believe that no one but you can answer a question about your child. If you believe that you need to move your child, do it. You are the expert on your child. Children under stress cannot learn and it is not acceptable for the school and/or teacher to allow this child to control the classroom and the people in it. Were I in this situation, I would be at school everyday "volunteering" in the classroom so I could assess the situation for myself and then I would take (or not take) action based on my own knowledge and not from the guessing about the dynamics of this and of other classrooms. It is also a good chance to build relationships with the school so they know you as a person and not just as an unreasonable parent.

didavis 5 pts

AND- I believe that sometimes Mom needs to "save" her child by showing them how to remove themselves from unhealthy situations until the child is developmentally old enough to do that for themselves. Children have parents for a reason- they need protection and someone to show them appropriated patterning. Letting someone abuse you because it is how it is done in the "real" world is not appropriate- ever. Perhaps if more children were taught to remove themselves from unhealthy situations appropriately we would have way more healthy people in the workplace that would not accept abuse and far less abusers because no one would accept it.

Conversation from Twitter

HeartofGoldGirl
HeartofGoldGirl

Good Q raised by a parent -- what do you think #teens? // blogher BlogHerFamily Should I Save My Kid From Classmate? http://t.co/Z4aojCg

PeriwinklePapi
PeriwinklePapi

MarinkaNYC Hey you, You getting out of dodge?

Conversation from Facebook

Viqi French
Viqi French

There has to be balance, because mom won't always be able to protect her daughter. The youngster will have to be taught conflict resolution skills. That said, I have a problem with parents who don't protect their child.

BlogHer
BlogHer

Beckett I can help you with your BlogHer.com password. Email denise@blogher.com and we'll get the account reset for you. :-) - Denise

Beckett Graham
Beckett Graham

Since I can't seem to recover my password, I'll re-post here - Why ought she to condemn her child to a year of dread and conflict? Fifth grade is too young to throw your child to the wolves and hope he can handle it. Follow your instinct and pull him out now, before the school year begins.