Bio
I am a journalist living in California, and this is my first foray into the virtual world. I worked as a reporter and copy editor for five years in v...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Shut up or die: Media gags in South Asia

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It's not news when an autocracy denies its citizens a free press. Freedom of expression is a fundamental right enjoyed only by democracies and free societies, right? In the last two weeks, two south Asian neighbors, both democracies, saw that right seriously threatened.

A Sri Lankan journalist was killed in broad daylight for running a newspaper that was critical of the government. Neighboring India came this close to clearing a legislation that could ban live TV coverage of national emergencies a.k.a Mumbai terror attacks.

Sri Lanka: 
Lasantha Wickrematunge's obituary, his "Final Ed" that he is reported to have saved on his office computer to be published after his "assassination", is probably the most chilling indictment of the Lankan government's failure to protect a free press, or its complicity in strangling one; its relentless trampling of basic human rights and anything that comes in its way in its war with the separatist Tamil Tigers. On January 8, the editor-in-chief of English language The Sunday Leader was shot dead on his way to work. Apparently he knew it was coming. In a column about his impending death, that rattled the world more than his work as a journalist, Wickrematunge says he was spoiled for choices: he was advised and offered many ways out of a profession that he anticipated would take his life some day. But he decided to stay on, to persevere:

 

But there is a calling that is yet above high office, fame, lucre and security. It is the call of conscience.
[...]
People often ask me why I take such risks and tell me it is a matter of time before I am bumped off. Of course I know that: it is inevitable. But if we do not speak out now, there will be no one left to speak for those who cannot, whether they be ethnic minorities, the disadvantaged or the persecuted.

Painting a dismal picture of how the free press has been consistantly browbeaten by the Lankan government -- and why he and his paper have been regular targets of threats and attacks -- he holds the government of president Mahinda Rajapakse, a former friend, responsible for his death:

It is well known that I was on two occasions brutally assaulted, while on another my house was sprayed with machine-gun fire. Despite the government's sanctimonious assurances, there was never a serious police inquiry into the perpetrators of these attacks, and the attackers were never apprehended. In all these cases, I have reason to believe the attacks were inspired by the government. When finally I am killed, it will be the government that kills me.
[...]
As for me, I have the satisfaction of knowing that I walked tall and bowed to no man. And I have not travelled this journey alone. Fellow journalists in other branches of the media walked with me: most of them are now dead, imprisoned without trial or exiled in far-off lands. Others walk in the shadow of death that your Presidency has cast on the freedoms for which you once fought so hard. You will never be allowed to forget that my death took place under your watch. As anguished as I know you will be, I also know that you will have no choice but to protect my killers: you will see to it that the guilty one is never convicted.

 

As his letter points out, the editor was not new to intimidation. The constant acts and threats of violence against Wickrematunge and his family, forced his first wife and co-founder of the paper to flee to Australia with their three children. One of his friends, quoted anonymously in The Guardian, said:

"I sensed he was seeking martyrdom. He wanted to die," a close friend, who regularly discussed the subject with him, says. [...] "He knew he was walking with death. There was this inevitability. I think he felt that everything he stood for would be proved
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
avflox 5 pts

An excellent point, my dear. Thank you for writing the post.

snigdhasen 5 pts

Anaiis, thank YOU for the link and your wonderful post.

I believe a free press is invaluable to any democracy. The structure, organization and reach of news groups are essential. What the Net has done is allow for feedback and dialogue and corrections and perspectives

As I say, will we ever ban a film-maker from making/producing movies just because they are crappy? No. We just don't watch his/her films and write reviews to tell how we feel.

So why treat other forms of expression differently, especially such an important arm of free society like the press?

snigdhasen 5 pts

Thanks Tre! Would love to do the Birds of a Feather meet-up. Only, I am not sure I'll be around for the conference (I do want to, though!!)

Please do check out the guys at Global Voices Online ( http://globalvoicesonline.org/ ). They are doing a great job of highlighting bloggers worldwide.

Tre - 5 pts

You are now living in California....should have read your profile before assuming.

But grateful none the less for your focus. Maybe we can do somekind of birds of feather for people interested in blogging to promote freedom of journalism...bloggers w/o borders kind of thing. you're more than welcome to email me...and i've subscribed to your blog's feed.  

Tre~

http://thoughtbythought.net

tre@thoughtbythought.net

snigdhasen 5 pts

Tre, thanks for your thoughts. You are so right about journalists putting their lives on the line to get the job done.

Thank you for feeling so deeply about it.

But I must clarify my position here: I come from India where the media experiences nothing remotely as challenging as circumstances in current Sri Lanka. Weve had regulation issues, but we are free.

Second, I am writing from the U.S. now, so I am quite alright. I am a CE with BlogHer, so I guess I can take a trip to Chicago without the scholarship :)

I will do my best to keep you all posted about South Asia. especially India.

Thanks again! 

Tre - 5 pts

To be sure,

When I read the story, I cried much.

First I felt completely selfish for wondering which blogpost to draft that day.

GEEESH as if a plethora of options was a real dilemma.

Next because how dare me--HOW DARE ANY OF US--take our freedom to write so superficially....

I didn't always. Hell, it's only been recently in my 40yearsyoung life that I've finally given myself permission to voice my thoughts and carve out their niche whatever it looks like.

But then I panicked. I wondered if I've waited too long to voice my thoughts.

And then I felt empowered. Because with every one of us who can, at least where the political climate endorses it to some degree, how the more we do the more --one would hope--it paves the way for sisters and brothers around the globe to do so.

But then I got really still. And haven't stopped thinking about this today: if my life was in jeopardy and I knew what I penned risked my own assassination, would I write?

And if I was a mother or a wife, would that affect my conviction?

Your story reminded me of how I felt when I read BIKO about the life of Steven Biko in South Africa in the 70s (I think)....

Your story reminded me that no matter how cozy i'm getting (now that the blogging platform mechanics are down and I'm not having trouble really posting and linking) access to the internet is still a privilege, freedom of speech is still just that--a freedom I enjoy but haven't really ever experienced the infringement of.

You've made me ponder deeply how my own writings can pave the way for greater implementation of such liberty for all writers, especially those trying to tell of atrocities.

And then I began to hold concern for you....and wonder what risk writing this story places you amidst. and if you have any way of gauging any kind of repercussions that could come...and knowing this what it took to write this piece anyway.

And then more (um, I'm not ever at a loss for ideas :) ) I wondered if you know about the international blogger scholarship BlogHer is offering for this summer's conference in Chicago...and so I'm asking: do you know of it and if so or if not, do you object to me nominating you for it?

I'm grateful for the piece for several reasons, not the least of which is shaking up my sometimes too comfortable self. There's a ton I need to learn how to do better when it comes to really feeling fluent on the possibilities of social media tools, but if I shut up the condemning voices within enough to realize that I have the privilege and ability right now to use my writing to help liberate others around the world just by writing...that's enough ammo to blog daily....and then how hold hands with writers of a similar mind/focus....

I'm humbled by your courage, surely, your devotedness, your willingness to share this piece on BlogHer.

Please consider the scholarship--I'd really value nominating you for it.

And please if it's not too much trouble keeping me in the loop of what you know about women in journalism who are writing as you are...to expose truths and so to help defend freed of the press. I'm grateful to now know of reporters w/o borders...

Looking fwd to your further writings...

http://thoughtbythought.net

tre@thoughtbythought.net

snigdhasen 5 pts

Tre, thank you for your support. The Sri Lankan story shook me, too. I hail from a relatively free society (India) where the media has a free reign, and not always competent (I was part of it, too). But I am very wary of any attempt to shut anyone up for lack of quality. You allow one "small" freedom to be taken away, you open a floodgate.

Every freedom is worth protecting. The best way to improve poor quality use of that freedom is to reject it, not take it away altogether. 

avflox 5 pts

Excellent post.

Ramachandra Guha's question is very relevant: "who will watch the watchdog?"

We are lucky, the rise of the web and citizen journalism is changing the way we see the world. I know the arguments leveraged against this kind of gate-less reporting, but look how much we have gained from it, too.

When that plane landed in the Hudson, pictures were on Twitter in seconds. It beat media outlets by hours. Reporters still play an important role, especially in a more in-depth investigative capacity, but citizen journalism is bringing something to the table every day. Not just information, either--entirely new perspectives as well. This is key.

"Expose their weaknesses and challenge their biases on another medium which is accessible to all: the Internet."

Absolutely.

PS: thanks for the link love. ;)

Tre - 5 pts

How does one leave a comment when so moved to tears even in reading this to be reminded of the privilege of freedom to voice thought.

I must re read and post another comment later when I can think of something more specific but for now: thank you. for giving this window. for telling this vital story...vital because it underscores the essential need to never take for granted the value of truth telling and the need to do so...till we can all across the globe share ideas freely.

thank you for the courage it took you to obtain and share this story. i call it courage. maybe for you it's self defense or what you must do to honor your own voice.

oh, to keep perspective on how many millions still seek and need this freedom.

thank you for waking me up and reminding me.

Tre~

http://thoughtbythought.net

tre@thoughtbythought.net