Bio
Writer, facilitator, researcher, coach, avid reader, enjoyer of life, opinionated about everything.  Love to dance, cook, walk, break bread with...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Pink Frilly Dresses Phase (PFD): Will Our Girls Outgrow It?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Portrait of a young girl (6-8) wearing a princess costume

I know that little girls like to dress up. I was a young girl once. I raised a daughter. I have a granddaughter. Dressing up is fine.

When my daughter was young, her daily uniform consisted of bright Oshkosh overalls and t-shirts. For her, dressing up meant going through my closet and jewelry box as well as her Dad’s closet, and picking things to try on. From her father’s fedora and baseball caps to my tie-dye t-shirts and lone bridesmaid’s dress, she tried it all. She pranced around in my high heeled shoes, loaded with bangles, necklaces and scarves.

I populated a dress up box with things I found in thrift stores that would assist in her fantasy play. I even bought a wooden stage and portable tent for her and my son to act out scenes from “productions” they staged and recreations of their favorite movies and TV shows.

There is something different happening with my granddaughter and her peers today. They have gone frill-crazy, with an avalanche of tutus, princess dresses and other such raiment in a narrow range of choices. (You have to search hard to find non-princessy, fantasy play, dress up options for girls. For young boys, one finds a predominance of pirate gear but also carpenter belts and fire hats. And, yes, I have gotten these for my granddaughter as well.)

My granddaughter is all about being a princess and a vamp. She’s 3½ years old.

Pink-Pink, You Stink and Pepto-Bismol Nightmares.

The there’s the predominance of pink. I know that pink is a predominant color for girl babies and little girls. Growing up with the nickname Candi, I was awash in pink as a girl – pink ribbons on my pigtails, pink dresses. My bedroom walls were painted pink. So much pink that I hated pink.

I see pink everywhere in the clothes aisle for little girls and tons of black clothes (a color I was forbidden to wear except as a skirt paired with a white blouse on the Sundays my choir sang at church). This obsession with pink pared garishly with black and purple takes it from pale to putrid in such places as Club Libby Lu (which targets "tween" girls ages 6 to 12).

Melissa Fletcher Stoletje does a great analysis of the princess craze in an article, Little girls carried away on a pink wave of princess products.

Yes, little girls have loved princesses for eons, ever since Cinderella lost that fabled slipper on the castle steps. But in recent times, shrewd marketing by retailers has pushed preadolescent princess worship into the stratosphere…

Does princess worship hurt a girl's self-image? Are we training a generation of damsels in distress? The jury is out on that, but some experts say the princess marketing overload is actually limiting girls' choices about what it means to be, well, a girl.

Too Soon Grown? (Painted Toes and other Salon Services)

Then there’s the trend of girls as young as preschool age getting pedicures and having their hair styled in professional salons, some of which cater to young girls exclusively. A few years back, before and even after the flood of inexpensive nail salons opened across the country, getting a first pedicure was a rite of passage. It usually happened as a special treat around a girl’s 13th birthday or graduation from middle or high school. Now it’s come to the preschool set. If you are getting a pedicure when you’re 3 and 4, to what do you graduate?

There are a number of things that have influenced this obsession with a narrowly defined girlhood, including the stealth-marketing of princesses by the Disney Corporation a few years back and, for adult women, the fashion styling of the Sex and the City crew where delectable, expensive and over-the-top femininity was pushed over comfort or athleticism. (Makes me glad my daughter came of age during the reign of the girl group TLC, with their over-sized t-shirts and baggy pants.) Even seemingly innocuous role models such as Dora the Explorer have even princessified.

As a culture, the media magnifies, codifies and promotes the importance of how women look above and beyond what they do and achieve. Adult women over the age of thirty-five have the ability to make choices about who to be, having grown up with less emphasis on how they look and

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Candelaria Silva 5 pts

I experienced the same thing with my daughter and son who were 22 months apart. They had the same toys but he gravitated toward the active toys and she gravitated toward the nurturing toys even though they both had cabbage patch dolls (during the original craze) and trucks, etc. It is fun to see how they change and grow and the childhood years are so precious and lovely as they explore and become. Enjoy!

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

and hang out in Charlotte so...I don't think it's a concern limited to the coasts. Like most issues, it's a both/and not an either/or. We each see and experience what we see and expderience. Perhaps I've become hyper aware and sensitive to the dress-up and what I see as narrow clothing choices and therefore don't notice those that don't fit in that category.

Thanks for your thoughts.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

I,too, see some girls creatively accessorizing and engaging in a range of activities but I also see plenty of times when this is not the case and when the mothers themselves dress up mostly all the time. Anyhow - just spoke my mind on something I've noticed. For many girls, it is a phase. The commercialization of it I think disburbs me the most. There are so many choices of frilly clothes not really made for hard play. Even some of the pants sets aren't really designed for hard play. But then, not all children get the opportunity to play hard and dirty, either.

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Candelaria Silva 5 pts

I am not a prude or old-fashioned in most ways. I do think childhood is precious and I do think we have to work harder than ever to have little girls dress like little girls and not teens or grown women. I'm visiting my granddaughter now and her predilection for dresses over shorts is bothering me because "of course" she can't play in the dresses (outside) and she keeps getting told to remember how to sit in a dress. (This wouldn't be a worry if she were wearing shorts!)

http://blog.candelariasilva.com ( http://blog.candelarisilva.com/ )

Good and plenty!

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I have boy/girl twins who share the same toys, were raised side-by-side, and still--he gravitated towards cars and electronics. She gravitated towards princesses. She marches to the beat of her own drummer and tends to layer a lot of princesses dresses over one another along with a winter scarf and boots--but still, a lot of pink. I've been letting her go with it in the same way that I've let my son go with his car fascination. I'm just wondering where this fascination will lead.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

diera 5 pts

I don't know, I wonder if this is one of those 'trends' that is really only an issue in LA and Manhattan and other high-fashion places. Is it really relevant what Suri Cruise is doing? She might as well be a daughter of royalty in terms of the wealth of her parents and the unusualness of her life. My daughter is square in this age range and goes to day care, so I see a lot of girls her age, and they all dress appropriately as far as I've seen. When my son was about three (just a few years ago) there was a bit of a flap in his day care group because some of the girls had begun refusing to play with other girls if they weren't wearing dresses - but even so, they were normal little girl dresses, not garish fluffy princess nightmares worn with corsets and high heels.

JennaHatfield 10 pts

I didn't get hair for a long time. I kind of looked like a boy. My mom taped bows to my head and constantly dressed me in pink (which might have something to do with my shunning of gender stereotypes...) but people still thought I was boy. It didn't quite help that I preferred trucks to dolls and mud pies to playing tea. I did play with Barbies but in the mud. I was kind of awesome as a kid.

I shunned pink all through high school and into college until I fell in love with a gorgeous dress for a formal. I now wear pink on occasion though my favorite color is green.

I see my friends with daughters and know that there is hope for our girls. Among the seven young girls in my friend group, there are a wide range of interests. One loves basketball, another karate. One is taking violin lessons while another is thinking about piano. Two take dance but so does their brother. (YAY!) There's an occasional Princess tutu floating by but often paired with rain boots and some other creative ensemble addition. Point being that the craze doesn't extend to all girls, everywhere, nor will it likely ruin them for the time they live within the phase.

Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )), from Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ), is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

FabGrandma 5 pts

I have two daughters, both of whom were dressed in frilly pink with ruffles for as long as I had control over what they wore. But that didn't last long--Becca started picking out her own clothes by age 3. I had to bribe her to wear dresses for some occasions by the time she was 6. Now, though, she loves looking like a girl.

With the clothing choices for girls looking ever more "slutty" at ever younger ages, it is difficult to find things to buy for my granddaughters these days. I want to buy them pinafores and puff sleeve dresses but can't find them. I don't feel like it is because I am "old fashioned", more like I want them to look like children for as long as they can.

Read the latest at http://fabgrandma.blogspot.com/