Bio
I'm an editor in Iowa. I used to live in Chicago, hence the BlogHer name.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Single? Then You Know The Pity Face

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 50
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I first noticed it at my 10-year high school reunion in 2005. When asked if I was married or have children, I said no. I'm single. And then it happened: The Pity Face. It's a look of genuine concern. Like something is horribly wrong with you. Like you've just admitted you have a terminal disease and have roughly one month to live. I had no idea how to respond.


Pity Face
Image: alan.stoddard via Flickr

After that, I noticed it more often. At first, I couldn't find the right words to describe it, but then "Pity Face" joined my vocabulary. I recognized it instantly as pity when I actually got a light touch on my forearm and an "I'm so sorry" from someone. Sorry? Really?

It didn't take long to recognize that these people -- men and women both -- were feeling sorrow about my singleness. It's one thing for a good girlfriend to give me a hug and express her love and sorrow for me when I'm crying over a cocktail about being single. It's an entirely different thing when I'm just going through my day and someone points out My Dreaded Singleness in such an awkward way. Hey man, I was just going to the post office. No need to start crying because I don't have A HUSBAND AND FOUR CHILDREN LIKE YOU.

Here's the thing: I'm single because I currently choose to be. I have chosen to not date men that aren't good for me. Yes, this makes me sad sometimes. Yes, in my private moments, I long for a life partner to share my world with. But most of the time? I'm just doing my thing. Working, going out with friends, visiting with my folks, gardening, reading, blah blah blah. And because I don't have a partner or children, I'm able to do whatever I want whenever I want.

In fact, my 7-year-old niece has now started telling my sister (BlogHer's own Rita Arens) that she wants to be like Auntie Blondie when she grows up -- not married with no kids so she can have her freedom. It's adorable. She's learned from her own family life that family means compromise -- something Auntie Blondie doesn't really have to do. (If only she knew the truth. Compromise is a part of life. I'll tell her when she's older.)

Anyway, what is the best response for a childfree single (or a single mom) when she gets The Pity Face? I wrestle with this one. You can respond in a number of ways. You can get defensive and angry with the person and over-defend your singleness. You can agree and start complaining about how lonely you are. You can be aloof and pretend you don't notice. Or you can be blunt and point out how rude the person is. I've done every single one of these responses over the years, and I'm still confused. What is the best response? Which one seems to get the message across that singleness is NOT a terminal disease?

I will admit that as I've gotten older, I get less Pity Face than I did before. It signals a change in the wind -- my girlfriends' marriages aren't quite as sunny as they were back in their early 20s. Life and kiddos have happened, and now they are reflecting back on their single days and getting -- yes, they've said this to my face, too -- jealous of my freedom.

In a strange twist of fate, it used to actually p*ss me off when people said something like that. I got all angry that they didn't understand that it made me sad to be single. (Yes, I'm a Gemini. I realize I'm contradicting myself.) But now I've grown up right along with these women, and I know how hard relationships and offspring can be. I agree -- my freedom rules.

But sometimes? Sometimes some otherwise friendly person will go for the jugular. I actually had a woman (we're the same age) say to me (after I told her I'm 34, single, childless, and work from home) that she would "hang herself" if she had my life. She wasn't joking. I was so shocked that I said nothing in response. I'm still upset with myself for not responding right away, and I still wonder what would have been the right thing to say at that moment to keep my dignity.

Have you ever gotten the Pity Face for being single? How did you respond? What ideas do you have if it happens

  • 50
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
wdolderer 13 pts

I have seen that face..I was 38 when I was married, and then widowed at 40...got another "pity" face...  Oh boy...  

jayellehughes 7 pts

awww, the pity face. LOL

I've seen it a few times, it's annoying but a little funny and makes me smile ;) how ironic that I sometimes secretly pity them!

Kare1810 5 pts

I congrates you! Pity face or not, Your a women with your own accomlished women! Lucky to have made your way! I have had two beautiful chidren, but many abusive realationships!

Concider yourself awesome not to put yourself in those situations for the old school purposes! I love my kids (Now that II Know them LOl) Your niece is yours too! Tc be happy! If it is ment to be it will happen!

niseag03 14 pts

Here is what is funny about The Pity Face... IT NEVER ENDS.

I didn't get married until I was 26. So, I got The Pity Face for many years through college and several years out of college. I got married and seriously, atleast once figured, "FINALLY I'll stop getting hassled about being single." (No, I didn't get married for that reason, LOL, I truly love my husband and am a huge fan of being married.) But nooooo...

The Pity Face then became, "Oh you don't have kids yet?"

SERIOUSLY PEOPLE!??! I am happy in my life. I will have kids when/if we want to... not because you think its sad it just the two of us.

You know whats funny? I have friends who have kids... and they STILL get The Pity Face. Why? "Oh just the one child?"

*headdesk*

BlondieChicago 24 pts

I want to hang out on the couch with all of you and blabber about our lives right now. You all rule -- love this community.

Simone8765 7 pts

Im 23 years old and I get the pity face too! Its crazy, im still learning about life and love and all of my girlfriends are looking for boyfriends and planning there weddings as we speak. GROSS. never. Not right now.

I always said if I decided to get married I'll do it at city hall and then have a beautiful reception. Of course when the time comes for such things.

But right now Im enjoying my freedom and if I dont ever get married, I think I'll be ok with that too. That is a hard pill for some people to swallow though.....

anneisanne 25 pts

Simone8765 Oh my! No one should get the pity face. But NOBODY should get it at fricking 23!!! Seriously, though, I get where you're coming from. I'm from a town where you're a freak if you're 25 and you have no children. Trust me, you're on the right track. A good percentage of those people are divorced by 30. Not that I'm dancing for that stat, but in this day and age, it's just too young.

Durante 5 pts

I get the pity face ALL THE TIME, I think it's worse when you have four children and have had a divorce, I also get the weird wacko telling me how brave I am to take the children shopping just about every trip.

Kare1810 5 pts

Durante

I can realate to that! LOL

Overland 5 pts

I really enjoyed this post & as far as your question goes. What would be my response? I would say since I'm still in that situation of "Singlehood" I would go with my first impression. I don't think we can't have a ready response at every experience to people who give us "The Pity Face." Because we have different things pressing on our minds & hearts everyday. And so how you react will be different everytime or at least I think it would be. But I think the key thing is to be good with yourself & if your able to respond in an honest way w/out allowing people feel sorry for you. Then maybe they'll do less inflicting of "The Pity Face" on other singles. But again it doesn't matter cause we can't control other people. We can only control our reactions. So rule of thumb if your happy & you know it go w/it. Clap your hands if you have to for these "Pity Face Bandits" if you have to but don't get down on yourself. And as for that person who said they'd hang themselves if they were in your shoes. I would just immediately brush them off cause obviously they just don't have a filter & should've thought before so blunt. But yeah brush that off...

Sincerely Overland

http://overland23.blogspot.com/

MyPixieBlog 7 pts

I can't believe anyone would actually say those words out loud. WOW. Some people... I just don't understand. I have been single for two years, am also in my early 30s, and have received the pity face more times than I can count. What people don't get is that, sure! I'd like to meet someone... but why not also have a little fun while I am able? Why must I feel guilty because I'm not yet married with children? I'm sure that day will come, but I feel like we're always looking/hoping for something else and then we're unable to enjoy what we have when we have it.

Just my two cents.

Great post, btw!

Kare1810 5 pts

MyPixieBlog

Do it while your young! Fit /happiest not a mother with tons of worry!

lifeinflux 7 pts

I have found, in my experience, that people who are really happy and content in their own lives have no need to give you, or anyone else, The Pity Face[tm]. So anytime I am on the receiving end, I remind myself that there is a good chance that face is a projection of their own feelings or a need to justify their own life decisions and really has nothing to do with me. Great post!!

AdrienneRoyer 8 pts

Great post! Having just moved back to the South as I turn 30, I completely relate. It's nice to know that other people feel this way.

I want to get married, and I'm sure that I will someday. However, looking back at my 20s, I'm so thankful that I remained single. I just wasn't ready for marriage and a family. I'm glad that I didn't stand before God and make a vow to build a life with another person just to get the big day and a permanent "plus one." Far too many people get married -- and subsequently divorced -- because they're either afraid of being alone or bend to social pressure.

What gets me is why people feel the need to ask such invasive questions. It's none of your damn business why I'm not married. I think people who don't have children are in the same boat. Questions like, "Why aren't you married?" or "When do you plan to have kids?" should not be a part of polite small talk.Those are things you discuss with your close girlfriends, not acquaintances. It's just rude to ask those questions.

BlondieChicago 24 pts

I used to ask newly married couples when they would have kids. Now I NEVER do it because of the way I feel about the single questions AND I know many women who suffer from infertility. I think you are right on in comparing the two no-nos. AdrienneRoyer

lainierenee 23 pts

I am over 35 and I get the pity face for being single. Admittedly, I have also given the pity face to folks whom are "trapped" in loveless and toxic relationships because they are too scared to be single.

kisschronicles 19 pts

See, thing is, I can take that Pity Face to a whole new level with my situation.

I'm 30 and haven't had my first kiss. Upon informing different people about this, so far I've gotten sheer amazement, incredulous doubt, laughter, and even a hug in one case.

Welcome to my blog and project, Kiss Chronicles. I'm going to monetize my first kiss and donate it to a cancer-related charity. Bring on the pity faces and whatever other reaction occurs!

Simone8765 7 pts

kisschronicles :( Im doing a pity face for you right now!! lol but all jokes aside, I think your idea for your blog is brilliant!!!

Go GIRL!

venece 5 pts

I'm starting to get the "pity face" and people trying to play matchmaker because seemingly, to them, my life must surely be worthless and I must surely be sad because I'll be exiting my 20s and won't be married yet. What's sad is them not seeing me actually enjoying and loving my life. Single or not, life was meant to be enjoyed. I have nothing against people who marry young (early 20s) but I do strongly believe that many times neither he nor she have had the time or opportunity to discover their true self as an individual, what they really love, which, in my opinion could bring life long passion to a relationship and make it more interesting. Who would want to be with someone who doesn't know who they are, never experienced life and seems to have nothing to offer (in terms of sharing their life experiences)?

Of course, I would love to SHARE my life with someone one day but that's just not where I am right now. I'm content and that's where I want to be. :)

As for the lady who said she would hang herself if she was in our shoes, I'd say, "right back at you". CHOOSING to love life should never be contingent upon another person being in it.

lauriewrites 27 pts

venece Yes, yes, one thousand times yes:

"What's sad is them not seeing me actually enjoying and loving my life. Single or not, life was meant to be enjoyed. "

Why people can't see us for who we are as independent people I'll never get, but I can tell you that I expect the people I care about to do just that.

Enjoy your 30s. I wish I'd had more fun -- that's my only regret. ;)

isthisthemiddle 1641 pts

venece Your last statement struck a chord with me. I've been thinking all around that issue, and you said it wonderfully well.

BlondieChicago 24 pts

I agree!! This comment reminded me to have MORE FUN! I'm going to work on it. venece

Rita Arens 219 pts

I think this is such a great conversation. I do think -- especially in Midwest small towns -- the cultural norm to settle down and have kids is so deeply entrenched that people don't even question it. The idea that you would do what you wanted despite social pressure to conform makes people uncomfortable.

I'm remembering what so many people have said here on BlogHer in the past few years about what people say showing more about them than about you. I also agree that as we grow older we understand truly that our paths are not the only ones available and maybe just what we did whether it was "right" or "wrong" or whatever at the time.

There's a great book I read my daughter early on called Princess Bubble. Everyone tells her she should get married and all the fairy tales say she could get married, but she would rather be a flight attendant. We talk a lot about options and how Aunt Blondie didn't get married and Mommy did and you know, whatever works for you. It's true -- right now she thinks it would be way more fun to be single and childfree. I tried to get my tubes tied when I was 18 because I thought kids would only drag me down. And then my first book was a parenting anthology. You just never know how you're going to feel about something later on -- you just have to live the life you have in front of you, right?

I also think our culture has maybe just gotten ruder. When I was pregnant, people were rude, when I had a young child, people were rude, they're rude to you for being single, they're rude for me for having an only child. I know I try to watch my own tongue a lot more now than I did when I was younger because I've become aware of how my comments can fall on someone else's ears by being called out on it. It can be kind to point out the rudeness of someone's comment if you do it nicely, I think.

BlondieChicago 24 pts

I love all of these comments. I often feel like I'm totally alone in this situation, so hearing your stories makes me feel so much better (and of course, horrible for anyone who recognized exactly what I'm talking about). I have also gotten the "hurry ups" and have been absolutely bombarded with suggestions about Match, EHarmony, etc. One person (a married man) even told me I should let HIM look my profile BEFORE I put it up. Because obviously I would do it wrong. (I've chosen to not date online.) It's amazing the things people feel comfortable saying to my face -- unsolicited. Thank you for the wonderful suggestions. Go single sisters! And a big thank you to my married sisters who are reminding me it's NOT always sunshine and roses. I know that deep down inside, but it's helpful to be reminded sometimes.

DonnaFreedman 14 pts

I like everyone's suggestions for responses. Here's mine: A big smile and a "Why, fuck you very much!" See if the person is really listening.

I'd bet not. Anyone that self-absorbed, i.e., "My view of the world is the only one worth having," is probably busy thinking about other ways to convince you how right she is and how wrong you are.

Or you could do the interrogation thing. With just the right amount of polite shock, respond by saying, "Good heavens! What do you mean by that, exactly?"

Rude Other Person: [[shocked that someone called her on her BS]] "Well, um, I mean I couldn't imagine life without my kids."

You: "So you're saying that your life is the only kind worth living?"

ROP: [[unsure what to say because her worldview has never before been challenged]] "Well, no, that's not what I meant."

You: "But it's what you SAID. Tell me: If someone couldn't get pregnant and was unable to afford adoption, should she go hang herself?"

ROP: "No! Of course not!"

You: "But I should do that, apparently? Because I don't have a spouse or kids?"

ROP: [[looks panicked, trying to pull herself out of the hole she's dug for herself]] "No, I mean, I just wanted you to know how wonderful kids are."

You: "I already know that. But I have learned something from this encounter. You are incredibly intolerant. Thank you for judging my life, about which you know NOTHING, as inadequate and sad. I'm sorry that you're so locked into your own narrow little worldview."

And if you really want to twist the knife, add this little coda: "I'll pray for you."

If you don't have time or don't want to get into it, the "fuck you very much" should do it.

anneisanne 25 pts

I love your term "pity face." Pity? Nobody needs to lament my singleness but me. On the other hand, I still do get pretty pissed off when married friends express their jealousy- mostly because they seem to think I spend my weekends at keggers like I'm 19 just because I don't have a toddler.

Suzanne86 6 pts

I am so glad you blogged about this! I am a late bloomer bride (married for the first time after age 40), and before I walked down the aisle I used to dread family gatherings in particular just for the things you've written about. What to say to the woman who would hang herself? Well, now that I'm married, I'll tell you. I'd say to her: "Yes, it's tough being able to get 8 hours of sleep every night, go shopping when I want, eat what I want, when I want, and meet friends for cocktails and dinners and theatre and, well, all that international travel is just DEVASTATING. I am so glad you understand." Then, walk away from her sleep-deprived, over-worked self. Is that mean?

sarahemily 5 pts

Great post! I've just started to get the "pity face." If people start to say anything, I usually just go, "Oh, I'm happily single. I like being able to do what I want when I want." It's usually enough to stop them from saying anything more. I think I would have inappropriately turned the situation around on the woman who said she would die... Probably better to say nothing though. I get that a lot with being gluten-free... everyone tells me they'd die if they couldn't eat bread.

I keep thinking of the Daniel Gilbert TED talk in which he shows how people who win the lottery and people who become parapalegic are equally happy a year later.... She's trying to increase her satisfaction with her choice by elevating it in her mind while deriding your choice because it's the one she didn't pick. I'd just say "to each his own" and move on.

kitibelle 6 pts

How about, "Gosh, is that your suggestion for how I spend my evening? Maybe I'll consider that after I get back from my singles cruise. And after I take a totally spontaneous trip to Paris. And by the way, finish your own work, I have plans tonight."

lauriewrites 27 pts

A coworker once said to me, as she dumped another pile of work on my desk that she could have handled, that if she didn't have her husband and kids to go home to every night, she didn't know what she'd do, because life without them had no meaning.

She meant my life.

I do believe that, culturally speaking, most people do still feel sorry for a woman who is of a certain age and has no partner or children. I've gotten the vibe that I'm considered damaged goods or unmarriageable. I chose not to marry one person who would certainly have committed to me. The other longterm relationships I had didn't end in marriage.

I said nothing to that woman and how I react to these kinds of conversations depends on the situation. Can't fix mean or stupid, and I knew that she was saying that to make me feel bad about my life.

You and I have a lot in common -- I wish frequently that I had someone to share my life with and I'm already grieving the likelihood that I won't be a mother. But I don't need pity. Compassion is okay, maybe. That's different, just like I have for people who are in crappy marriages and who struggle with the stressors of being a parent. Often, the people who give me the pity face are people whose lives and relationships I could not be paid to take. It's amazing what people will do to make themselves feel surer of their own situations -- even if it means demeaning someone else.

BlondieChicago 24 pts

OMG if you even KNEW how much work I had to do for my coworkers when they went to pick up their kids from daycare over the years!! lauriewrites

Mymonday 5 pts

BlondieChicagolauriewrites At work, the office manager said something very, very inapropriate to me. When I asked to leave an hour and a halr early to wait for a cable technician, she said "it is hard not to have a husband or a teenager to do something like that around the house." What a moron! Of the 5 women in the staff there are two who are punctual, reliable, focused on the work at hand, not usually on the phone handling personal matters, rarely absent and mostly only after having asked permission in advance, and they are myself and an older single woman. The moron doesn't notice that her and the other married women with children often leave work early like a chicken with the head off to go tend to their offspring, and their husbands, fine thank you! She doesn't notice that her and the other married women with family are often absent without notice, sometimes for extended periods of time. What a jerk!!

isthisthemiddle 1641 pts

Being a married and childless woman, I get more shock than pity when people find out I'm 50+ and don't have children or grandchildren. In my 30s I got the "you better hurry up and have kids or you'll be sorry" threat from random people who had no clue as to why I might be childless.

Why do people have the right to judge someone on their marital or child bearing status, assuming we need advice or pity? I don't go around commenting "gee, did you plan all four of your children?" or "wow, did you marry him as a last resort?"

But I've learned to laugh off these comments for the most part. They usually come from people whose opinion I shouldn't give a moment's thought to.

karabuntin 42 pts

For the woman who'd hang herself, I think a "Wow, that's incredibly rude" in a bemused tone of voice would be all you need to say. Because that was an incredibly rude thing to say.

I'm married and have kids, and I know people who are single with no kids and happy about it, and people who are single with no kids who are unhappy about it. I also know people who are married with no kids and happy about it, and married with no kids who are unhappy. So it doesn't matter, the grass is always greener on the other side.

Mymonday 5 pts

karabuntin I married at 22 years of age. My former husband is 20 years my senior and although any American man would have thought he hit the jack pot when he married me, I have never been lonelier in my life. There was no communication, or consideration on his part. He had me babysitting his grandmother with alzhaimer. His mother was alway pressuring us to move in with grandma so that my mother in law could have the Senior single life she wanted to have with no responsibility or concern for her own mother. My seven years of married life, were hell to me, to say the least. So, forget it! No one is going to tell me what I need to be happy, because I already have what I need to be happy! I have God in my heart. Yes, as a human I hope to marry someone who truly loves me and cares for me. I would like to be a mother. I think I would make a wonderful mom, either adoptive or biological. I know what it takes to raise a happy child. However, God is funny, I'm 36 and I have no prospects. Not that I haven't tried to find love. It is just so elusive! I hope I don't give up, though sometimes I almost do.

mysophisticatedlife 6 pts

I'm now married (just last year at the age of 40) but was always single and childless by choice. I was once told that only selfish and lazy women choose to not have children. When people said things like this I just smiled and walked away. It's not worth consideration or time. Truthfully, I would hang myself if I had children. I absolutely worship my nieces and all of the kids in my family...but it's just not for me. However, I would NEVER say this to someone and I know that what makes me happy isn't for everyone. Just continue to be the bigger person and walk away. It's always better when you let them have the last, nasty word.

eleanore 15 pts

Yeah, I'm familiar with the pity face. I'm over it, so I usually laugh...which confuses the Pitier. But here's what I know about the woman who would "hang herself...". She's pretty miserable with her own life. Only someone who is hurting inside would make such a heartless statement. Eff her.
-The Spi sterlicious Life

Heather Clisby 24 pts

I used to get this Face all the time and it would enrage me. I remember one woman, "Awww! If you want to catsit this weekend, you totally can, if you get lonely."

Unfuckingbelievable.

subWOW 8 pts

Just ask, "How are the kids? Is your husband 'babysitting' (remember the quote fingers) so you get a break? When is your curfew?"

That should do it. ;-)

Conversation from Facebook

Nicoletta Ven
Nicoletta Ven

http://www.anotherway.org/2011/09/getting-out-of-a-bad-relationship/

Michele Morris Cohen
Michele Morris Cohen

When I was single, my friend's husband told me I needed to start a group: PWP People Without Partners. He teased me alot about being single, but it was all in good fun. I got married the day before I turned 30... all my friends were pretty much married with kids. I never got the Pity Face, though.

D.j. Westerfield
D.j. Westerfield

People DO act that way. It's really freaking annoying! I'm married now, but that does not make me more of a person than I was when I was single. I will never act that way, but boy, so many do! I do still get the pity face when they find I have no children of my own because of fertility issues. UGH! Get a life people. I am perfectly happy as I am!

Cyn Stern
Cyn Stern

My first thought, too, as that maybe it was actually an "envy face."

Katie Cortes
Katie Cortes

I get the pity face when I tell people I don't have kids yet or if they find out about my fertility issues. I don't want anyone's pity! My life is perfectly fine. I hate presumptuous people!

Cassandra Cluderay
Cassandra Cluderay

Are you sure it isn't the: I'm stuck at home with 3 kids and a husband jealous look ?

Mary McNally
Mary McNally

Women, especially, can be very unkind about this. I've had several relatives and "friends" tell me I would end up alone. What was implied was I was too quirky, too unattractive, whatever... Thank goodness there are guys out there who ARE interested. So there...

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

I'm married and have kids. It's not always unicorns, sunshine and roses. That being said, people need to mind their own business. Next time you get the pity face, girl, I want you to know there is NOTHING wrong with you, that whoever is shooting you that is a nosey judgemental person, and tell them "WTH?! It's not cancer or anything!" I'm sending you a hug. Keep your head up.

Gwen Stackler
Gwen Stackler

See, I must be doing something wrong. I don't get the pity face, I get the what in the heck is wrong with you face. Honestly? It makes me want to slap them and laugh maniacally at the same time. There is nothing wrong with me, I have just made a conscious decision not to have kids and it has taken me a long time to find the right guy that accepts that choice.

Laurie White
Laurie White

People say crazy things. I reserve the pity face for myself when I was in a miserable relationship. :)