About
This post was highlighted for you to read from our BlogHer Publishing Network, read by 26 million readers every month.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Are Victoria's Secret Models “Athletes”?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 17
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

(Editor's Note: Is walking a runway in platforms the same athletic achievement as running 26.2 miles? Does an intense regimen of dieting and exercise make a model “athlete”? Are bodybuilders athletes? Does the fact that someone works out hard and diets with the singular focus of manipulating the way they look make them less of an athlete than one who does the same but with the emphasis on performance? Charlotte Hilton Anderson, author of the "Great Fitness Experiment: One Year of Trying Everything", tackles these questions and more in her recent blog post Is Model Adriana Lima an “Athlete”?  ~js)

Adriana Lima at Victoria Secret fashon show Nov. 9 2011. Image credit Zumapress.com

Groaning in a puddle of sweat while holding a pose that would be considered obscene in any environment outside of the gym (quite a few exercises fall in this category, to my constant amusement), I considered taking a rest but just then Turbo Jennie yelled, “Come on athletes! Don’t quit now!” That was exactly the first time in my life anyone has ever called me an “athlete.” And I liked it!

So what exactly makes someone an athlete then? If it’s not their sponsorships or salary or sex-crazed groupies then what is it? Talent? Achievement? Recognition in their sport? How about dedication and training hard? I could argue that I have those. And so do a lot of other people. Even… Victoria’s Secret underwear models? This issue of what constitutes an athlete came up when Victoria’s Secret supermodel Adriana Lima gave an amazingly honest interview about what she does to prepare for the annual Victoria’s Secret show.

Read more from Is Model Adriana Lima an “Athlete”? at The Great Fitness Experiement

  • 17
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MauiShopGirl 8 pts

Is the act of modeling an athletic event? No. Is engaging in athletic activity being an athlete (regardless of the reason why). Yes.

I have friends who run marathons, canoe paddle, ride motocross, play tennis, body build and roughwater swim. All of them are athletes even if most of them have never won or competed in an actual competition.

I don't consider myself an athlete because I play tennis to maintain my weight or due to the fact I've made it to State and National championships but I do consider myself an athlete because I play, pure and simple. I should say former athlete because my physical endeavors have gone by the wayside lately :-)

lauriewrites 15 pts

No.

Putting yourself through physical pain and suffering nutritionally to achieve a certain physical appearance for a monetary reward? No.

It's a job.

JessicaRae21 8 pts

If modeling is a sport because it's tiresome and physically demanding then parenting should be labeled a sport as well.

HomeRearedChef 453 pts

I did modeling when I was young, and though holding a pose and walking on the runway under hot lights can be exhausting and even at times strenuous, I don't believe I would have qualified myself as an athlete. But then times have changed, and meanings of words have been altered to mean something different too. I guess I would hate to argue that point now.

~Virginia

April Byrd 7 pts

Hi Charlotte! Great post! curvy writer is right. Athlete means a participant in a sport. especially a competitive one. It is from the Greek word athlein, its very meaning is Compete.

April Byrd 7 pts

Not the type of competing that models do either, LOL.

curvywriter 21 pts

No. --ath·lete- a participant in a sport, exercise, or game requiring physical skill.

curvywriter 21 pts

I'm not minimizing the work they do...but athletes? No!

Conversation from Facebook

Ojavan Products
Ojavan Products

Does a person that plays Chess become an athlete? It depends on ones definition fo the word "athlete" a qucik check of my i-phone dictionary says, "a person trained to compete in sports" find your "sport" and you can be an athlete too.

Abby Harper Slate
Abby Harper Slate

An athlete is anyone who pushes themselves to the point of forgetting everything else but their physical pursuit.

Note to Self: a love I deserve
Note to Self: a love I deserve

I think the fact that she is torn over the identity and the definition points to what we really should care about... Not idealizing others but redefining the identity within ourselves... learning to be healthy and active only works when we can identify with it.

Tanya DeBuff Wallette
Tanya DeBuff Wallette

Sure, who cares.

Breath Of Life Daily
Breath Of Life Daily

Read the post. Good One! Athlete means a participant in a sport. especially a competitive one. It is from the Greek word athlein, its very meaning is Compete.

Arianna Loucard
Arianna Loucard

As a gal who played competitive soccer, including on an otherwise all-male team, for almost twenty years, I'd say "no way". I've played in rain, sleet, mud, sweltering sun, on astroturf and football field. I've eaten dirt so hard I've bleed or embedded stones in my flesh. I've ruined my knees. Prancing around in underwear doesn't make me think of an athlete.

Arianna Loucard
Arianna Loucard

A very interesting question. I would say an athlete is one who pushes their body to physical limits. Instinctively, I wouldn't say lingerie models are athletes, but they do require a very strict physical regimen. If VS Angels are models, than wouldn't other models also be considered athletes?