About
This BlogHer Spotlight was picked by the editor as a post you'd love to read. Learn more about the BlogHer Spotlight program.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Do You Respond to Comments?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 36
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

To respond to comments or not; in the comment thread or directly through email; to use your time to read more blog posts or to hold more conversations... these are the dilemmas many bloggers grapple with, including Sophisticated Dorkiness who asks what people tend to do with their comments.

Do you respond to all of your comments, taking the time to let the person know how you processed their words? Or do you instead go to their blog and read their top post and leave them a comment? Or do you not see commenting as a reciprocal act, choosing instead to comment where you wish to comment rather than feel tied to reading every blog that reads you? Do you email your response directly, or do you leave it in the comment thread below your own post?

As Sophisticated Dorkiness states,

Everyone loves to receive comments. That’s basically the single blogging truism I can think of. But do bloggers who leave comments like or expect to receive responses to those comments? I’m not sure.

Go over and read all of her questions, and then let us know how you approach comments: do you respond or simply read and return the favour with a comment on their blog?


Photo Credit: Comment Button via Shutterstock.

Read more from My Conundrum Over Comments at Sophisticated Dorkiness

  • 36
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Retire In Style Blog.Com 8 pts

Comments are wonderful...but....they need to be meaningful. Commenting for the sake of getting your name on the page does not have much meaning. I have some faithful readers (a few) and over the years we have developed a blogging friendship of sorts.

When I comment on something I am interested in I will check back to see if the author has responded.

A canned comment is a bit like being damned by faint praise!

b

http://www.retireinstyleblog.com

HomeRearedChef 1786 pts

Retire In Style Blog.Com "Comments need to be meaningful." I totally agree. I've had bloggers visit once, "follow," and then not visit again. I've also visited and left comments with bloggers that will never respond. Now knowing how I feel about this, I really do try to get to everyone that leaves me comments. I will respond! And most of the ladies I've come to know here on BlogHer are faithful to visit, comment, and respond. It really feels like we've begun a friendship. :)

~Virginia

latindancercj 17 pts

If someone's getting over 30 comments on a daily basis, I can certainly understand how responding to every comment and visiting every blog is not really practical. But when one is trying to build readership or relationships with individuals, I think that it is vital. It really doesn't matter to me whether the person comes back to read it or not. I want something to be there just in case. If someone bothers to take the time to comment, I should take the time to respond. Truth be told, if I'm commenting on someone else's blog, and they don't respond, I'm offended. I usually check. I consider it good blogging etiquette ... unless they're getting too many on regular basis, like I said. Great question. Thanks for featuring this post. :)

HomeRearedChef 1786 pts

latindancercj I like what you've had to say here. Thank you for putting it so eloquently. :)

Carly Thurman 6 pts

Getting better at it! It's easy to comment on blogs that are particularly interesting to me. This is one of the biggest "issues" we have had with our blog Illuminate, simply because comments are an easy way to measure "success" and leave you with a feel good feeling that people are listening to what you have to say.

SpinsterJane 6 pts

I'm definitely getting better at it. I try to respond as soon as I approve the comment.

Red Dirt Kelly 177 pts

I respond when I can. I don't when I can't. It seems that about every 2-3 days I get a couple of hours to sit down and peruse, and respond. However, there are some that are just "hey" - - so, at that point, I just smile. That's my response.

Ms Batman 7 pts

I reply to every comment left on my blog. I comment on the blog, but since I use WP, an email is automatically sent to the commenter with my reply. If I think it warrants further discussion I will also send a private email as well. I comment on a lot of blogs over the course of a day, and very few people that I leave comments for return the favor. I figure it's a personal choice of theirs.

kdwald 9 pts

I'll respond to a comment unless it's clearly simply to acknowledge "I was here." Sometimes there's not much to say back - "I'm glad you stopped by!" too many times doesn't sound sincere. Even if I am doing the "happy comment dance" while I type it.

That said, I've never felt like I had to respond through email. If I ever received a comment that was offensive or full of vulgar language not directly related to the post, I would write to the author to explain why I didn't approve it.

I don't always check back to see if my comment has been answered - many times because I'm not looking for an answer.

Carmen S 12 pts

I respond to comment via email. If someone has taken the time to read my blog and leave a comment, they deserve to have their comment heard and acknowledged. I have some really devoted readers who have become good friends and I would have missed them had I not bothered to reply to them. I know that I've stopped reading blogs, many of them by so called "A-List bloggers", simply because I don't feel as if I matter to them.

Kristen Daukas 25 pts

Carmen S I unfollowed one of my favorite bloggers on twitter this week because all she did was push, push, push. Although, I shouldn't feel too bad - I took the time to look at her twitter stream and she didn't respond to ANYONE. Either she has no clue what she's doing (and is there because someone told her she HAD to be on twitter) or she's just flat out stuck on herself.

Kristen Daukas 25 pts

If someone leaves a comment on my blog, I'm commenting back. If I comment on someone's blog and they don't acknowledge or repsond back, after a couple of times I don't read their blog again. Same goes for Twitter and Facebook. It's about engagement.. and engagement takes more than one person to make it happen.

SunbonnetSmart.com 778 pts

Kristen Daukas Engagement...great concept...well said! Fondly, Robin

robotheart 16 pts

I try to respond to comments most of the time. For one, it's just polite, and for another, it's the best way to start a conversation. :)

HomeRearedChef 1786 pts

robotheart It is a great way to start a conversation, but also a great way to get to know our fellow blogging Ladies. :)

SabrinaBlogs 48 pts

I respond to every comment and leave a comment on their blog but I don't always remember to go back to see if they ever responded. I've wondered if there is a more efficent way of commenting on sites but I haven't come up with one yet.

Ms Batman 7 pts

SabrinaBlogs WP has threaded comments that sends emails to commenters when you reply to their comment, and also if they reply to to your reply and so on so that you don't have to remember to go back and check.

HomeRearedChef 1786 pts

SabrinaBlogs So far, Sabrina, you've answered all my comments. Thank you! :)

Big hugs dear friend,

TCStream 7 pts

I think that truism above says it all. Comments let me know that people are hearing my words - to the point that they proactively say something.

I won't lie - two years into this blogging endeavor, I still do a happy dance every time I receive a comment.

So I respond. To keep the conversation going. And also, to let my readers know I am very much part of the *social* aspect of social media. I also look at the blogs of all commenters. You never know what new gems you'll find.

Mikalee Byerman 5 pts

I look at my writing/blogging as a conversation -- which implies 2-way communication, of course! So I do respond to each and every comment. Unless it's a creepy guy asking if I have supple hands and feet as he only imagines I do...

(Seriously. I do not make this up...)

However, I do notice that by responding to comments, I take time away from my writing. And since I have a pretty active and healthy conversation going on in my comments section, I am facing the reality that someday, I will not be able to respond to every comment -- and also post frequently.

...which means: It's going to be very hard to break that precedent at some point in the future. My readers know I respond (and some -- not all, I have no delusions of grandeur) have come to expect it.

So I do wonder: Will that change my blogging dynamic?

kimthedork 5 pts

Mikalee Byerman That's part of my question too. My blog certainly isn't at a level where it's impossible to respond to every comment, but it's not impossible to imagine getting there either. The balance of all the things that go into maintaining an active, interesting, conversational blog can be hard!

Mikalee Byerman 5 pts

kimthedork Agreed! And once you go down that road (as I have), it's hard to turn back.

But fundamentally, I believe blogging is about conversation, so I think it's a road worth traveling.

...until I find myself having to hire an assistant to write responses for me...

;)

Nylorac 7 pts

If someone has taken the time to comment on my blog, I comment back. Of course, I don't have 100+ so it is not that time consuming for me :)I do read each comment and like getting them.

I also try to visit their blog too.

talleygilly 5 pts

I love comments and I also love the chance to respond, even if it's brief. I really appreciate people taking the time to read my blog, so it's the least I can do, I think!

cinnabubbles 12 pts

99% of the time I do! However if it's one of those "New follower! Follow me back..blah blah blah." comments, I'll ignore it. Save that kind of stuff for a quick email. -sigh-

thosegraces 8 pts

I respond to every single one. Comments are the best part of blogging :)

justinelorelle 6 pts

I do for the most part. I only get a few comments a day, so I like to respond hopefully to encourage more. I always make a point to reply if it's a new commenter. (I don't respond to all of my dad's comments ha.)

Cindy La Ferle 12 pts

I wrestle with this issue often. If blogging is supposed to be a conversation and not a monologue, then I feel I should respond to the comments left on my blog -- especially if they are more than a quick sentence. The fact that there is a special space for "Comments" implies that blogging isn't just a one-way street. But I know that's up for debate.

On the other hand, when I wrote columns for print editions of newspapers and received snail-mail letters from readers, I never felt that I had to answer those letters.

The problem, as always, is finding the free time to reciprocate visits to other blogs, as well as responding to comments left on your own blog. It can be overwhelming ...

kimthedork 5 pts

Cindy La Ferle That's how I feel too -- blogging is a conversation, so I like the use the comments to interact. But there's some level where just a comment like, "Great review! I should look for this book!" doesn't really seem conversational, you know?

texasebeth 78 pts

I do respond to the comments 99% of the time. I *think* I've finally got it set up where an email goes back to the commenter showing I've replied. I do try to go the the commenter's blog as well to leave a comment but am not as consistent in that.

sassymonkey 688 pts moderator

I try but it was much easier when my comment notifications emails worked. I can't figure out why they are not. I need tech support. sigh.

Conversation from Facebook

Slim Down U
Slim Down U

I try to respond to everyone that leaves a comment on my blog. I feel such a connection with most of the people that leave me comments and I love interacting with them.

Leslie Whitney
Leslie Whitney

I like to respond in the comments because as a reader, I like to read the authors response to comments also.

Mikalee Byerman
Mikalee Byerman

This is a great topic -- as I indicated in my comment to the piece, I DO respond to every comment -- but given that I've had posts with 100-200 comments, this takes a HUGE chunk of time...time that I should be writing! It's a total conundrum. ;)

Christa Brammeier Grabske
Christa Brammeier Grabske

I love to respond to comments, but it depends on how busy I am the day I publish my post. I always make return visits to the commenter's blog, though!

Celeste Lindell
Celeste Lindell

I do respond to almost every comment. They're all emailed to me, so I just reply.