Twitter Tiff: Did Amanda Marcotte Mind Her Manners?

BlogHer Spotlight

[Editor's note: Have you ever been flamed by someone you admire on Twitter? In a chat that started out perfectly lovely and polite and then quickly dissolved into a snarkfest? Well, Neely Steinberg recently did with no less a feminist than Amanda Marcotte in a complicated exchange that involved feminist detractor Kate Roiphe, sexual harassment, the New York Times and the word slut. Steinberg recounted the whole ugly tiff at The Good Men Project, part of which I’ve excerpted here.--Mona]

She writes:

@NeelySteinberg In other words, to believe in the concept of a “slut”, you must believe women are inferior to men on some level.

@AmandaMarcotte - Can we agree it’s not just a term used toward females? What about misandry – women calling men “sluts”? That happens too.

@NeelySteinberg If you believe that, I have a bridge I can sell you.

After you read the post, I'd love to hear what you think. What went wrong here? Was Marcotte in a bad mood and that's why she got testy with Steinberg? Should Steinberg have kept challenging Marcotte about the fact that men are called "sluts" too? Was the "bridge" comment over the top? Has anyone ever been mean to you on Twitter? What did you do about it?


Credit Image: Emilie Ogez on Flickr

Read more from When Feminism Flames: A Twitter Conversation Gone Wrong at The Good Men Project


In order to comment on, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.