Bio
I am a co-founder of BlogHer and manage its events, marketing and corporate operations. After 13 years of marketing in Silicon Valley, I left high te...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

So You Think You Can Dance Recap: The Finale, The Top Four, The Meh

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Was it just me, or was last night a big old let-down?

Maybe it was that there were just too many damn routines.

Maybe it was that the routines were therefore too short.

Or that the high number of routines made the dancers tired.

Or maybe it was that Kenny Ortega and Katie Holmes make very boring guest judges.

But last night left me a bit cold. Which was surprising after honestly thinking this was the best season in quite some time.

About the only thing that got me excited was seeing Cat in red lipstick and a simple silhouette. (Please Cat, no more bizarre monstrosities...especially Tribbles on your neck.)

Each contestant danced once with an all-star, once with each of the other three contestants, and once solo. I'll recap the pairs first, then briefly comment on their solos. To fit in all of that, as I mentioned above, the routines seemed short. And many of them seem under-rehearsed.

But, you know, it didn't bode well when the first number was the dreaded...

Courtesy of FOX

1. Melanie and Marko danced a Doriana Sanchez Disco routine, to I Feel Love by Donna Summer

Love the song. Hated the number. Talk about pulling faces! Dial it back, Melanie. And just overall, this was rough, including some rough dismounts from some lifts that should have been as easy as the numerous lifts Marko and Melanie executed flawlessly in Contemporary routines. So, we started off rough.

Courtesy of FOX

2. Sasha and all-star Mark danced a Sonya Tayeh contemporary routine to Raise your Weapon by Deadmaus

So, side note: Did Mark always look that buff? I kinda remember him being a scrawny guy. But now. Whoa, Nelly. Here's the thing: I would love to see Sasha do something graceful. I feel like she never was asked to stretch this season...it's all about her flexed feet and crawling on the ground. She does that very well, but gimme something elegant and let's see if she can go outside her comfort zone.

3. Tadd and all-star Joshua danced a Lil C Hip-hop routine to Ace Hood's Hustle Hard

This was another rough routine. Mostly because they were not well-matched at all. It went beyond not being entirely synched. Tadd was better at anything that required litheness and agility, but Joshua was so much more hard hitting, so much more hardcore (except his belly, I think). Rather than seeming complementary, like they filled in each other's blanks, they just seemed awkward and poorly matched.

4. Melanie and all-star Robert danced a Stacey Tookey Contemporary routine to Sinead O'Connor's cover of Elton John's "Sacrifice"

I loves me some Robert. And this was lovely. But I feel like I've seen it before. Lots of lifting and splits in the air. And much easier landings than all those disco lifts. Lots of emoting too. But still, didn't feel original. But yum yum Robert. That is all.

5. Sasha and Marko danced a Spencer Liff Broadway routine to "Whatever Lola Wants" as sung by Ella Fitzgerald

So, this was Story #14 out of the 15 stock stories these choreographers pull out of the hat: Geeky guy and femme fatale. But herein lay the Sasha problem. You know how above I was wishing to see her do something graceful and elegant? Yeah, well, I take it back. It's not her thing. Clearly. To the point that her toes don't point that well, and her leglines aren't that pristine. And when she tries to have long and graceful lines, we are left wanting more. Or at least, better. The whole routine made me say "whatever".

6. Sasha and Tadd danced a Cha Cha routine by Mark Ballas to "Raindrops" by Basement Jaxx

Oh. My. This was terrible. Don't know who was worse. He had terrible posture. They seemed to be missing grips. She had no spark. Katie wussed out completely, along with Kenny, and muttered something positive about their overall performances all season. But Mary and Nigel could not hide their disdain. Neither of them deserves to win for this routine alone. It was like it was week one all over again.

Courtesy of FOX

7. Marko and all-star Lauren danced a Tessandra Chavez Contemporary routine to "Shirk" by Me'Shell Ndegocello

Now this one? It moved me. Same old story of unrequited love, but some really interesting movement to a unique tune. This was actually the first duo of the night that intrigued me...which is a little sad, no?

8. Tadd

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
muralmaker 5 pts

My bad - at first I thought you were talking about the finale results. I'm in agreement with nearly everything you wrote save for Sasha. I agree that most of the choreography she was given used angled lines and flexed feet, but when she did dance a contemporary #, she had awesome technique.

I also thought Melanie would win, hands down. Her hair grew on me throughout the weeks, or actually her technique won me over.

I don't agree w/some other commenters who thought this season was "meh". I thought this was an exceptional group as a whole. The dancers cut in Vegas did things we never thought about trying when I was dancing a few years back.

I'm not a huge fan of some of the choreography though. And I think the judges put way too much stock in interpretative dance. Not every dang dance has to tell a story, for heaven's sake!

Just my opinion though.

Elisa Camahort 8 pts

muralmaker Hilarious...I also think that it gets incredibly boring that each routine has a story...particularly since the story is always some form of dysfunctional relationship :)

snarkymomma 5 pts

I think the whole season was "meh" and the finale in particular. I hate to say that because I'm such a fan of the show. My favorite parts this season were the group routines on elimination nights.

I think what it was for me was that there weren't enough big personalities this season. In the past we had people like Twitch, Eleanor, Robert, Mark, Laci, etc., who were interesting in addition to just being good dancers. I didn't get any of that this season. Bummer.

tryitmom 5 pts

Totally agree! They were tired and Katie was sooooo annoying. I was glad I wasn't watching live so I could fast forward through her telling the dancers they were "strong" for the 14th time. Ugg

natalied6579 5 pts

I couldn't believe they capped off a lacking night with the worst routine I have ever seen. I know the judges didn't want to crap all over the last competitive routine of the season but that stepping piece was a monstrosity. I'm happy with the results though, Melanie had me at her audition.

Fourth Breakfast 5 pts

I agree with you on almost all counts. There was a lot of awkwardness for a finale. Was thinking a Mia Michaels routine would be good.

Elisa Camahort 8 pts

Well, it's not on here in the PT yet, so I hope you're right Julie :)

Conversation from Twitter

erinz1
erinz1

I'm going to predict Sasha wins it, although Melanie should. RT blogher So You Think You Can Dance Recap: http://t.co/O1TgFjf
.

ClowerCottage
ClowerCottage

blogher Disco and rubber boots, really? Travis Wall should have created something.

coffeewithjulie
coffeewithjulie

blogher agreed. But tonight has been fabulous...

Conversation from Facebook

Shannon Moyer Szemenyei
Shannon Moyer Szemenyei

oh my gosh!! LOVE LOVE LOVED it!!! I wish they had a musical act, with the dancers doing backup or something. I was disappointed that Tadd didn't make it further, but am 100% pleased as punch that Melanie won!

Nikki Bisping
Nikki Bisping

I like Katie Holmes, but she said the same thing after every single dance! You are so strong, I can feel the story in how you dramatize and portray the dance, and I loved it. Blah! I agree she makes a boring judge. Everyone knew it would be either Sasha or Melanie, but I'm pretty sure most people knew Melanie would be the winner several weeks ago.