Most Popular

To Spank or Not To Spank?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

 

I remember the first spanking I received as a child. My mother was attempting to do my hair and as usual I was being fidgety and didn’t want to sit still. I just remember not being in the mood to sit there for an hour as she wrestled with my curly hair. She told me several times to keep still, but I wasn’t in the listening mood. As I look back on that day, I will say that I was in high brat mode. I remember taking the brush and throwing it the glass living room table and it cracked the table. That’s when it happened. My mother grabbed a belt and  as my grandmother would say, “went to town on my behind”. I was 7 years old. At almost 33 years old, I can look back on that day, and say that I deserved every lash I got. 

After that and every spanking I received from then out, my mother always made sure to explain to me why she spanked me and what I could have done to prevent it. I wouldn’t say that I was a bad child; I can probably count on two hands how many spankings I received growing up  but I will say that I learned as an adult, there are times when spankings are necessary.

I totally believe that spanking, when done when the parent is not angry, is not a form of abuse. Also, when a child is a child is trained right, lessens the need to discipline. As a parent to a 9 year old, my son knows that when I tell him to do something, and it’s not done the first time he’s bound to get spanked. My son has received only two spankings so far in his childhood. The most recent one he received was because he didn’t come home directly from school two days in a row. The first time he didn’t come home he was put on punishment, but the 2nd time was when he received a spanking.

What I can’t deal with is when I see people spanking their children in public. I think that spanking a child in public is one of the worst things a parent can do. I think embarrassing the child in public will only make the child rebel even more at a later time. I realize that a lot of people are anti-spanking and probably feel that people are spank their children are abusive, but everyone is entitled to their own opinion. There is a fine line between being a parent who spanks and one who is actually abusive to their children. What it boils down to is if children are trained to be respectful and obedient then it lessens the chances of having to resort to spanking.

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
mysailorsmistress 5 pts

I was spanked as a child.

The only ones I remember where when I was getting my hair done. I would yell and move after I was told not to.

I have no regrets on being spanked.

My children get swatted on the rear, sometimes with threats of wooden spoons but I think the 4 year old realizes I won't do it so that trick does not work anymore ;o)

I have known people who go out of bounds with it. I think that is horrible. I also do not spank in public. I think the humiliation is worse thtan the actual spank.

I think I turned out okay and I hope my babies do too. Our generation of mom's now is hit or miss with it.  

Jennifer

www.mysailorsmistress.net ( http://www.mysailorsmistress.net )

AmberS 5 pts

I was spanked as a child. I don't feel it was abusive. However, I do not agree that it was the best choice, or that I 'deserved' it. I don't believe that it's possible to completely remove your emotions and anger from the situation, or at least that's my opinion based on being on the receiving end. I should say that for parents of their era, mine weren't terribly strict or punitive, so I don't think my home was an example of 'spanking gone bad'.

I have two children, and my husband and I agree strongly that we won't spank them. We also don't use time-outs or other methods of punishment. I found Barbara Coloroso's book Kids Are Worth It! to be very helpful in formulating my discipline style. I am not permissive, and I don't let my kids run all over me (or others). But I don't believe that exercising your power over your children in arbitrary and punitive ways is helpful. And all of the reading I've done, and recommendations I've seen from medical and psychological organizations, confirm that belief.

We're all just doing the best we can as parents. I respect your choice to discipline your children as you see fit. Just as I will exercise my choice, and never hit a child.

~ Amber

www.strocel.com ( http://www.strocel.com )

see_saw_sam 5 pts

Since this is a topic my husband and I've been discussing recently. He's against spanking, for the most part. We both agree that if a spanking is to occur, it should only be administered by the parents (perhaps grandparents, as well, should they share the same values and opinions as the parents).

He sent me the following link: http://www.apa.org/releases/spanking.html

I've seen and experienced both sides of the argument for spanking, where is has been given in a proper way and where it was on the side of abuse.

My mom spanked me when I needed it. We'd sit and talk about why I was getting the punishment and how I could have avoided it. It wasn't a means to an end, but a 'you knew this was the consequence" type of situation. My aunt, on the other hand, spanked her sons almost any time they acted out. I watched her chase them around the house with fly swatters and belts, always acting out in anger. My mom only used her hand and usually cried as much as I did when she did it.

For me, the difference lies in how mom handled it. My mom believed it was a hard thing to do to me and didn't enjoy it. She only did it when she felt she had no other way of getting me to understand how wrong whatever I did was and that the lesson needed to be learned because it was important for us both. She was never abusive and it was never done in anger. I should also note that my mom raised me all on her own. A single mom working as many hours as she could to make ends meet, and she loved me above everything else in her life (and I'll always be grateful for her love and support, and discipline).

We're expecting our first child to be born late this year and I only hope that I'm as good of a mother as my mom was/is to me. I do believe in spankings and hope that I have the same good judgement as my mom did to know when it is right or wrong to spank my child.

mashadutoit 5 pts

I remember being spanked also.  I remember puzzling out that it was not the pain that I minded, but the humiliation.

I have no children, so I dont think I can have much of an opinion of this.  One thing I do believe, though, is that focusing on spanking alone as abuse is short sighted.  It is possible to do great harm through verbally humiliating a child, isolating them, being vicious and nasty in all kinds of non physical ways.

I sometimes wonder if people focus so much on spanking being bad, because its arelatively simple act.  Spank = bad.  In the end, it must all have to do with the intention behind the act.

But then - as I said - what do I know? :)