Bio
I'm the BlogHer Contributing Editor on parenting children with special needs, and I'm at your service.  I am more than a parent, but with three...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Special Needs Community Outrage: Where are the Marissa's Bunny iPads?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Toca Tea PartyI spent yesterday morning at a local university, participating in an autism study. Part of the study was an interview about my experience as an autism parent -- including whether there were any benefits to my son Leo's autism diagnosis. "Absolutely," was my immediate reply, "We have become part of an amazing community -- full of people who support, understand, and trust each other unreservedly." But what happens when someone in our special needs parenting community abuses that trust? That's what many of us are worried about, after the Marissa's Bunny Foundation solicited donations from parents of kids with special needs for the chance to win iPads -- and those iPads never materialized.

The father of Marissa, a four-year-old girl with infantile spasms, raised over $29,000 from the special needs and the gaming communities with a stated goal to both finance a surgery for Marissa, and give other parents a chance to win iPads for their own kids with special needs. Marissa's dad said that his boss would contribute matching funds. Forty parents were even selected and notified that they'd won iPads, and that the iPads would be shipped ASAP -- except now parents are claiming their iPads never arrived. And the community is outraged. What happened? Was this a scam?

Here are excerpts from an email the Marissa's Bunny Foundation sent out yesterday, and which special needs parenting powerhouse Ellen of Love That Max included in her own, must-read post:

"There are no longer any iPads. I've never had access to the matching funds I've been promised. Something along the way changed and I'm getting hung out to dry by my bosses.

"My reputation is now screwed with the SN community but I have to be able to give Marissa the best chance for as close to normal as possible and will happily work under whatever conditions I need to. I'll dance with the Devil if it gets Marissa what she needs."

It's possible that this statement is true, of course -- which would make the crisis even more tragic. And some parents have pointed out that a donation is a donation, and we shouldn't expect to get anything for free. But we do have the right to expect people in our community to make good on their promises, especially when, as Emma wrote in the comments on Elllen's post, iPads are expensive and many parents who entered the contest did so because they can't afford to buy one:

OF COURSE people who were promised something have a right to be angry or upset. Most of us can't afford to just go and get an iPad and we thought this was the answer to our dreams. I was skeptical from the start but I was still hopeful.

[Marissa's dad] was NOT obligated to give anyone anything for free but he made promises that he didn't have to make. Here is what troubles me - much of his fund-raising was based on the fact that people thought he was giving back to the special needs community.

Emma also indicated that Marissa's dad may have a history of not making good on his promises:

My therapist ordered a bunny from him (and paid him) because she admired what he was doing. that bunny never arrived either and it has been about three months. Every time she emails she gets a new reason why it hasn't happened. I didn't lose anything because my entry was free -- I just gained a little disappointment -- but my son's therapist lost money. How many others did too?

I really hope that the Marissa's Bunny iPad debacle is truly a legal horrorshow rather than a scam. I hope someone can vouch for Marissa's dad's credibility, or even can proclaim themselves the happy beneficiary of the numerous raffles and giveaways that Marissa's Bunny has hosted in the last two years. That the over $4,000 dollars raised via the iPad giveaway page isn't a separate donation black hole. I hope all this because I want our community healed, and also because I want Marissa's dad to be able to get back to the business of providing his adorable daughter with the care she needs.

In the meantime, I would advise us all to be careful about making donations to causes someone you trust cannot vouch for, or entering unverified giveaways. It makes me sick at heart to write

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Chrisphil129 5 pts

Please do not support Gary James and A4CWSN any longer. He has collected money over and over and promised iPads, but takes weeks, if not months to deliver. Now he is asking for money to file the necessary paperwork to obtain tax-free non-profit status from the IRS. This man lives in a $500,000 house, he needs $850? Also, he is vile, profane and ugly to anyone that questions him about where the money contributed goes. Transparency is NOT part of his plan. I won't even mention the pornographic video he dared former facebook members to post. The man has a history of scamming people.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 8 pts

Chrisphil129 I have publicly withdrawn my support for A4CWSN due to Gary's extremely unprofessional behavior as @A4CWSN on Twitter.

Gullible 5 pts

Ahhh looking more and more it seems a scam , his own comment to someone questioning the delivery of the ipads;Marissa's Dad " Raelene - I didn't think to get pictures of the iPads going out (as it seemed fairly mundane and ordinary, but upon reflection, maybe it's not), and we do have pictures of some of the recipients! I'll get them posted this week. Monday, July 4, 2011 - 11:28 AM"So he stated in that comment "we do have pictures of some of the recipients" --- yet elsewhere he admitted to never getting ipads? So did he send one batch of iPads and no more? or did he NEVER ever send any iPads?

Gullible 5 pts

He is also about to Migrate the site to a new Host , hope that is not a hint that everything will disappear forever!

Gullible 5 pts

Oh God does this man even have a child with special needs? can anyone, somebody confirm and clarify that he does? I think I may have fallen victim to donating and also applying for one. I don't care about the money but I care about all of my childs information he now has including photos of my child. He did you see state to include photos to help the application along more so naturally I included photos and oh so much information about me and my child. Anxiety levels overload now , I feel heart palpitations coming on, and I am usually the most careful of scammers and even though this may not be one of them how could I be so gullible? Answers please, that will help me sleep a bit more at night knowing this guy really has a child with special needs and its only about money.thankyou

TracyRosen 6 pts

I love this line you wrote:

"I keep reminding myself of the difference between losing faith in our community (I never will) and losing faith in individuals."

I hope that Marissa's dad is telling the truth, though the stories I am reading seem to point in the other direction. Even so, focusing on what gives us hope - like the work that Gary James is doing with a4cwsn.com - will keep the community positive.

--

Come pay me a visit :)

Leading from the Heart ( http://leadingfromtheheart.org )

Camping Out with Tracy & Jack ( http://campingout.tracyrosen.com )

Ottawa Special Education Examiner ( http://www.examiner.com/special-education-25-in-ot... )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 8 pts

I really appreciate all the work you have put into AWC4SN, and refer people to your site, frequently.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Gary James 5 pts

Shannon, I am as disgusted by this as any father of special needs children should be. I also would be skeptical about things, especially after reading this. I do want to say one thing, what I am doing with a4cwsn.com is real and you only have to join us on FB to see that, I try to keep everything open and even post videos of the iPad deliveries. I am doing one this weekend in Boston and hopefully next weekend in Canada for 3 families. I also just send one iPad to California and an iPod to Florida.

I am here to make a difference, Shannon, you already know this. Thanks for all you do.
Gary
www.facebook.com/a4cwsn ( http://www.facebook.com/a4cwsn )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 8 pts

I'm heartsick too, for many of the reasons you listed. So I keep reminding myself of the difference between losing faith in our community (I never will) and losing faith in individuals. And I'll keep donating and supporting these online fundraisers, as long as someone I trust vouches for the person/cause.

Yours in cockeyed optimism (which means I've now got South Pacific tunes in my head, not a bad thing),

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 8 pts

And I have to admit, what would I do for Leo if we didn't have the resources to support him? Especially if it wasn't technically illegal?

Crossing my fingers for resolution. And toes too.

Shannon Des Roches Rosa ThinkingAutismGuide.com ( http://www.thinkingautismguide.com ) | BlogHer.com ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/shannon-des-roches-ros... ) | Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com/ )

Niksmom 5 pts

As one who has benefitted tremendously from the generosity of both friends and strangers via the internet, I am also heartsick over this situation. The cockeyed optimist in me wants to believe it's all a terrible misunderstanding, but the logical, rational part of me suspects it is not.

My greatest fear is that this will cause such a backlash that it will make it that much *more* difficult for already strapped families to get help in providing things which might help their children. It's already so difficult to ask for help; to ask for help and not know if you can trust the person holding out their hand? That's scary.

http://maternalinstincts.wordpress.com ( http://maternalinstincts.wordpress.com/ )

LoveThatMax 5 pts

Excellent post, Shannon. This story has taken over my head and heart for the last few days. I can only imagine how it feels to someone like you who has done fundraising.

I just want this resolved. I am not sure it will be.

I keep thinking about Marissa.

Ellen blogs daily at Love That Max ( http://lovethatmax.com ), a blog about kids with special needs who kick butt