Bio
Cynthia Samuels is currently Managing Editor of Care2/s Causes Channels, which serve 14 million members and cover 11 subject areas.  She has...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Star Trek, Friends and the Passage of Time (Just a Little Bit of a Spoiler)

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I'm writing this right after seeing Star Trek because I don't want to forget. By the time you read it though, the film will be more than a week old. The film is lovely - sweet, in fact. It includes an appearance (slightly more than a cameo) by Leonard Nimoy, as an aging Mr. Spock. The film skids back and forth in time, much as our own memories do -- and between the young Spock played by Heroes' Zacharay Quinto and Nimoy as his older self.

For me, as I suspect for many, there was a wonderful subtext to this dashing film: that of life moving on, lessons learned, friendships nurtured. Spock of the future, bundled up in a snowy cave, explaining to his junior self* about their relationship and the passage of time. Megan Smith of Megan's Minute, tells me that many of her friends have described their pleasure, on a whole other level, upon introducing their kids to the Star Trek they knew and loved. When William Shatner was Captain Kirk, not a lawyer with a failing brain or travel agent/kidnapping Priceline spokesman.

One example: Jennie Rigg of the UK, who describes seeing the film with her small daughter. It's really lovely.

Nordette Adams, who blogs at The Examiner and BlogHer, has written about Shatner as a novelist in her own meditation on the film. In the same post, she wonders why we saw so little of Kirk's mom while Spock's, played by the radiant Winona Ryder, was so, well, radiant. She also links to many of the major Trek sites, so the post is a real multi-tasking bonanza.

Also raising questions is Melissa Silverstein of Women and Hollywood, who wishes that women were at least as represented in the film as they were on the TV series. True, although I was having so much fun I forgot to notice.

On another front, the GameGirls offer four perspectives - all of them positive and a couple dealing with the joys of the time-travel portion of the plot. They're young women and they don't altogether relate to the slight melancholy that accompanies a long friendship as live moves on, but they are four smart women with great perspectives on the beloved Star Trek - then and now.

Far from the world of GameGirls is a media literacy teacher and advocate in Culver City, CA who is also a nun. Her blog Sister Rose, is full of remarkable observations on the film, including several about time, friendship and -- well, listen to her:

It may be sci-fi but it is also “psy-fi”. It’s about character, how
everything in life stems from learning empathy, discovering self and
one’s identity, emotional intelligence, and the integrated personality,
love and self-sacrifice for others, family, ethnic diversity, community.

In other words, not surprisingly, many of the women who saw Star Trek love the film as much as the guys - maybe more - and for vastly diverse and interesting reasons. Just perfect for the world Gene Roddenberry sought to create so long ago.

 

EDITED TO REPAIR DUMB MISTAKE:  JRose48 reminds me that Spock was talking to an older KIRK not to himself.  Clearly a little too much what the shrinks call "transference" at work here.  Sorry and thanks to JR for the help0.

 

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Csamuels 5 pts

Oh my gosh!  You're right.  I'm going to fix it.

Thanks.   Dumb.  Too much thinking of MY younger self, clearly.

Cynthia Samuels, Partner
Cobblestone Associates, LLP
Blog and Media Strategies and Content Development Online and on Television   

Don’t
Gel Too Soon ( http://dontgelyet.typepad.com/dontgeltoosoon )

alyssaroyse 5 pts

I was afraid that both my love of the "real" Star Trek and of the (hot hot hot) Sylar would ruin this movie for me, but I loved it. LOVED IT. 

The great joy, however, was taking my 10 year-old daughter and telling her about all the characters, their cultures and the adventures....  We got to have my favorite conversation, which is that Star Trek is the ultimate textbook for teaching sociology. We spent more than an hour talking about culture, people, interactions, love and war. I am not even kind of a science fiction geek, but have never seen anything science fictiony in Star Trek, it's always seemed like the most accurate portrayal of "warring" cultures and personality types. And how we can get along, and what will happen when we don't bother to try. 

Love it. 

JJ Abrams nailed it, as did all the actors. Can't wait for the rest, which I'm sure are coming. :)

____________

Alyssa Royse

Just Cause It: ( http://www.justcauseit.com )A Web Site To Save The World

READ the magazine ( http://justcause.ziniooffers.com/ ) on Zinio

Megan Smith 5 pts

I felt the same way about the Uhura character in the movie, but if you think about it,  the whole movie was about setting up the three main male characters.  How they met, etc.  In a two hour movie, there really wasn't much more time than that for other character development.

As I said in my own review, ( http://www.megansminute.com/2009/05/star-trek-back... ) especially because J.J. Abrams tends to be very conscious of strong women characters, I'm thinking and hoping that will be rectified in the sequel.

Great post, Cynthia! 

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/megan-smith )

Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/

JRose48 5 pts

"Spock of the future, bundled up in a snowy cave, explaining to his junior self about their relationship and the passage of time."

Spock of the future was talking to young Kirk in the cave, not his junior self.

JChandler 5 pts

Possible Spoilers:
I saw the movie this past Friday. A fan of the series and movies,enjoyed this one too, overall.
However, I left the movie feeling the ball was dropped with the Uhura character and I couldn't shake it off. With the extremely brief appearances of three other actresses it was my hope that the regal, intelligent and professional Uhura would fill the female void.
Instead, we received two snippets of her strength and knowledge and then were thrown into a girl in love scenario. Somehow my identification with her character was lost between her locking lips with Spock and discussing crucial info while stripping down to her underwear.
Hopefully, the next movie will develop her character a little more. Otherwise, it was good and I'm glad you enjoyed it!
:)