Bio
I'm a 50 something "jill of all trades" who has worked in education, publishing, consulting and industry while keeping myself sane with crafting in my...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

The State of Crafting in the New Economy

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It's a little conflicting to consider crafting these days.  Individuals and families are cutting back on expenses, but the creative outlets of crafting can help relieve the stresses from other parts of Life.

What are the choices that the crafter might be making?  One obvious choice is to spend time with the supplies and materials we've already acquired using our stash to feed our need to create? Many have materials we purchased because we love them.  Getting to know them again and see the original visions we had develop is a great thing.

Deb at Fearless Fiber decided to consider a somewhat different track. In Knitting in Rough Waters,  she discusses that a culture of instant gratification contributed to our economic problems and also led to a crafting trend of "quick and dirty" projects.  How many books are written with "EZ", "Quick" or "Fast" in their titles? 

She predicted that the knitting trend toward lace might be a move away from instant gratification and toward complex challenges.

we are a culture of instant gratification. We want it all and we want it now. The American Dream of home ownership has morphed into a dream of home ownership now. No time to amass a significant down payment. No starter home in a questionable neighborhood will suffice. We will stretch to the max and take great risks to reach the dream.

...I'm keying in on (instant gratification) now only because this minor factor interests me when thinking about knitting trends.

I think this little seed about the dangers of instant gratification that are planted somewhere deep in the recesses of our minds will continue to sprout and grow. We as a group will move further toward projects such as lace work as I mentioned previously. I think we'll see more larger projects, such as afghans and sweaters. Intricate cables. Challenging construction. Generally, more complexity and a slower pace of achieving results, but a greater pride and satisfaction in the end. We'll always have the occasional need to whip out a quick and simple hat or scarf, of course, but I think generally we'll see larger and more complex projects take center stage.

How much do we really need to consider this? 

Claire Cain Miller, writing for the NY Times, discovered For Craft Sales, the Recession Is a Help.  During the past holiday season, it seems that many chose to cope with the economy by purchasing supplies and making their own presents or by purchasing the goods of small independant makers.

Craft stores, from giant chains like Michaels Stores to small scrapbook supply shops, are reporting that sales are higher compared with the last holiday season, and online marketplaces for handmade goods, like Etsy, are seeing a boom in listings and transactions.

In Knitting Through the Downturn by Glenn Collins emphasizes the optimism of one craft-based manufacturer with Lion Brand's opening of a Manhattan bricks-and-mortar store:

A time of looming recession might seem a bizarre moment to open a high-end Manhattan store that sells a low-tech product: yarn. “But I see this as a perfect time,” said David Blumenthal, president of Lion Brand Yarn Company, which on Tuesday is opening the first retail store in its 130-year-old history as a wholesaler.

“Knitting has always been recession-proof,” he explained. “In a recession, people are cocooning. So for $5 or $10 in yarn, you can have a great weekend and come away with a scarf that would cost $60 in a store.”

David Keeps, reported in the LA Times how Craft-making grows among artisans.

But clearly consumers' belt-tightening and environmental consciousness also have set the stage for a new form of home economics. As young, cash-strapped shoppers get turned off by over consumption and disenchanted with homogenized, mass-marketed retail, more are shopping for one-of-a-kind pieces -- or are crafting their own.

"They may not make an afghan like their grandmothers did," said Tina Barseghian, editor of Craft magazine, "but they will take the technique and apply it to their own home."

Clearly there is no crystal ball that can accurately predict the future success or failure of crafting.  For myself, I've created during good times and bad and I expect to continue doing so. I see a blending of purchasing decisions, too.  While I'll continue to draw down the amount of materials I keep in my stash, I also believe that several great projects will warrant spending some of my cash.  New interests and techniques are calling to me.  How about you?

Debra Roby blogs

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Debra Roby 5 pts

Belinda,

I have to agree that sensible spending is the key. Buying what we need and want but not mindlessly consuming.

I spent 6 weeks this past fall helping organize a sale of quilting/sewing supplies for a family; my friend died of cancer, leaving her family with lots of bills. You know that bumper sticker "She who dies with the most XXX wins"? Jill won.

We figure her stash cost her about $40,000; if we could find people to purchase it all, they might get about $15,000. While the creating time made her quite happy, the excessive acquisition has put a number of strains on her family.

Living through just organizing the sale of this one stash was the inspiration for the 2009 stashbusting call here...

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Weight for Deb ( http://weightfordeb.wordpress.com )

Debra Roby 5 pts

Kathy,

I think I started crafting as a little girl.. and it stuck. I think it's important to encourage our children to start being creative as early as we can. Good on you!

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Weight for Deb ( http://weightfordeb.wordpress.com )

Liz Rizzo 5 pts

Yes! I've never been one to have a huge stash, but I'm definitely focused on knitting up what I've got (although I'm going to an event at a knitting store tonight, so scheduled total fail there.)

I'm also working on a couple lace shawls, so that will definitely slow me down for sure.

Liz Rizzo ( http://blogher.org/blog/liz-rizzo )

I blog at Everyday Goddess ( http://everydaygoddess.typepad.com/ ).

Debra Roby 5 pts

Rochelle,

I agree that while we need to be responsible for our own crafting habit, it's important to support our local craft suppliers.

Maybe part of the solution would be a personal promise to use these small businesses first, sourcing our supplies there before turning to the "big box" craft businesses?

Debra
A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com )
Weight for Deb ( http://weightfordeb.wordpress.com )

Creatively Belle 5 pts

I think people who love making and creating will always keep making because of the inner drive. Whether they go out and have big spending sprees on supplies they mean to use but tuck away is a different thing.

But I completely agree with the decision to actively continue to support small businesses both locally and online with continued shopping during the hard times so they survive. For money to work it needs to move around society.

Sensible spending will still be possible for most people, hoarding money and fearing spending it will create even harder times.

Working through stashes is a great thing but also adding a little new things to a project is also really important to look after each other and our communities.

Kind regards and all the best,

Belinda

Great Earring Holders - great presents and no more messy jewelry tangles! ( http://www.creativelybelle.com/stands )

Kathy333 5 pts

I find it is a great, inexpensive way to keep busy and make things for others. I have two young girls and we crafted many of the gifts we gave away this year, from photographs that I took and edited and put together to our holiday cards, small ornaments, and even a jewelry box. My daughters love to spend hours coloring, painting, gluing, beading, etc, and it is a low cost way to keep them busy and show them how to make things with their hands. We always go to Michaels, and i use coupons when they don't have a sale running on what I need. Right now I'm into making cards.   I do have a huge stash of scrapbook accessories that i've bought over hte years so I am trying to use this up first before purchasing anything else!

Kathy

Allbusiness:Working Mothers ( http://www.allbusiness.com/specialty-businesses/wo... )

Mama Marathoner ( http://www.mamamarathoner.com )

ninepoems 5 pts

Very interesting post! Obviously going to one's stash is the best way to save money and use what you've got. I'm sure that will be a trend this year. It's always something that I'm trying to do. But then I was thinking about my LYS that I love so much and rely on and how I would hate to see them go out of business. Then there's also my Creative Memories consultant who I buy scrapbook supplies from. I would hate to see her family struggle. But I don't want to struggle either. I think it's important not to abandon our local craft suppliers in these troubled times, but do what we can to support them while we tighten our own budgets and use what we have.

Rochelle | Nine*Poems Blog ( http://ninepoems.com ) | Twitter ( http://www.twitter.com/ninepoems )