Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Step Off My Body, Baby: I Want My Boobs Back

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When my daughter was born in 2004, I was all prepared to breastfeed. I had the bags, I had the pump. I wasn't psyched about it, but I wanted to do anything I could to ensure she had the best in life. I knew that was breastfeeding. So I asked my doctor for the absolute smallest "good" window. My doctor looked at me like I was nuts, stammered around for a while, then said six weeks. I don't know if he pulled that number out of the air or out of a medical book. I've never heard anyone ask that question before: Probably because it's so loaded.

I breastfed for seven weeks, but I was weaning in the last two, which meant mixing in formula. My daughter gained a pound a week each week I was breastfeeding, a huge and healthy baby, so I can't say I couldn't produce milk or it wasn't working. The truth was that I hated it.

HATED IT. More than the poop, more than the spit-up, more than anything. I hated it.

I was probably doing it wrong, for one thing. I had the nursing consultant and everything, but it took my daughter forty minutes on each breast to eat, and she ate every two and a half hours all day and all night. I know I didn't have the latch right, because my breasts blistered and bled, and the let-down burned so much I had to count to 30 as the tears popped out of my eyes.

But that wasn't why I quit. It was my boobs. My boobs. I wanted them back.

I know, you guys are going to hate this. So many of you have written such amazing posts and essays about the joys of breastfeeding and the right of women to breastfeed wherever they want. And my girls, I so totally support you. I thought it was amazing when Catherine breastfed on stage at BlogHer. I am so jealous of women who can get past my body issues and just enjoy breastfeeding for the bonding and feeding experience that it is.

I don't know exactly what my problem was. Part of it was my association between breasts and sex. Maybe it would've been better to be exposed to more images of breastfeeding women when I was growing up. I just don't remember being surrounded by it that much. It was the '70s, and bottle feeding was the rage. Women didn't breastfeed in public, at least not that I remember growing up in small-town Iowa. When I was breastfeeding my daughter, it just seemed so strange to have her attached to a part of me I associated solely with sex. I couldn't get past it, even though I know intellectually that it's the most natural thing in the world.

I also have to wonder if my past eating disorder and subsequent hypersensitivity to people seeing my body was part of it. The thought of disrobing in public is still horrifying to me, and whether or not you're discreet, it's hard to avoid showing stomach or boob or whatever if even for just a moment.

Finally, I just wanted my body back. Pregnancy was hard for me mentally because of the past eating disorder. I hated having to gain weight. I wanted to be able to make my own decisions about my body again. I wanted to eat what I wanted without worrying about whether it would give my daughter stomach problems. I wanted to take cough medicine without calling the doctor. I wanted to drink a glass of wine without raising eyebrows.

My daughter was on formula, which I bought at Costco in huge cannisters with joy, from seven weeks until one year, when she switched to cow milk. I felt a huge sense of relief switching to formula even though it meant washing all those bottles all the time. It was totally the right choice for me and for my wacked-out body image.

I completely support my breastfeeding friends. I see the breastfeeding choice the same as any other choice about a woman's body: her choice to use her body the way she sees fit. I felt the judgment when I declared I was so done with breastfeeding, but it was my body, and I wasn't comfortable with it. I don't apologize for making the best choices I can for my body and

  • 19
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Rita Arens 7 pts

Your comments are so well articulated.

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

bkkorman 5 pts

Really -- wow, if only someone had put it that way before! Thanks, that totally changes everything! :-)

bkkorman 5 pts

You said what I feel, only I didn't realize I felt it. Yes, I knew it was best but YES, it felt awkward, and what one other commenter said -- YES, the problem might very well be that we are too new to momminess and all that comes with it to take on breastfeeding. I think I could do it NOW....now that I have a 7 year old and two 5 year olds! But I was overwhelmed with mommyhood when mine were babies (esp. with the twins!) and breastfeeding was way, way, way too intimate for me to be able to do it.

www.kormanfive.blogspot.com ( http://www.kormanfive.blogspot.com )

Artemis Clover 5 pts

i really enjoyed your post but i do love breastfeeding! it's weird.. a huge plus for me is how awesome my boobs look right now (porn star HUGE) and i am afraid of how tiny and loose they will get when i stop. and because i am burning so many calories breastfeeding, i can't seem to keep the weight on me and just eat whatever i want. but i had issues too.. in the beginning i had a hard time latching my son on and he still feeds on demand so he completely owns me. and a week ago i had a plugged milk duct that was probably the most painful thing ever..up there with labor. i have thought of stopping many times but i know this is best for the babes and i have benefited from the perks too (boobs, weight loss, cheaper than formula). best to you.

aa2025 5 pts

Women who do not breastfeed are selfish and lazy.  We only have breasts to nurse a baby!

Giyen 5 pts

I had no problems breastfeeding but damn it! I totally want my old boobs back. Seriously, my boobs never recovered. It's so sad.

www.baconismyenemy.com ( http://www.baconismyenemy.com )

DePriest Mom 5 pts

I absolutely LOVED breastfeeding, especially with my first born, I was a natural at it and I had no struggles at all (yay for me, I know) I could probably have solved the hunger problem for an entire 3rd world counrty. With my daughter it was more challenging, there was no leeway, she would ONLY breastfeed whereas my son was very agreeable to either bottle or breast.  With my daughter there were horrible issues of thrush as well, but still compared to most, it was very smooth for me.

However I would NEVER assume to be in a position to have the right to impose my experience and opinion on another mommy.  Is breast milk best? In a relaxed mommy who is able to enjoy the process, absolutely, but if it is stressful and makes mommy anxiety ridden and unhappy, then buy the formula sister, motherhood is hard enough. I have a unique perspective because I am also the mother of an adopted child and in his case breastfeeding wasn't even an option.  I cannot say I have seen any significant long term differences other than my adopted child was never one as a toddler to reach up under my blouse and grab my boob.  Both my breastfed children did have occasion to try.

 With obvious exceptions, the good Lord gave us each the children He did empowering us to make the best decisions for our kids.  If we are doing it with their best interest in mind, then we need to let go of the guilt of the militant mommies and card carrying La Leche league members and be at peace with our own decisions.  With each of my breastfed kids I intended to do it for a year.  My oldest son got a cold at 8 1/2 months old and didn't want to be bothered anymore and weaned himself.  When my daughter was 10 months old I took my first weekend away from her and my husband battled out the bottle and got her to take it with me gone.  When I got back I desperately needed her to breastfeed (for relief) and she refused, she never really went back.  After a tough couple weeks my body caught on and we all worked it out.  I feel no closer to my breastfed kids, they are no healtheri than my adopted son.  Bottle or breast, it's your body, your kid and your decision.

Diana

http://dianalovestowrite.blogspot.com ( http://dianalovestowrite.blogspot.com/ )

http://depriestdays.blogspot.com ( http://depriestdays.blogspot.com/ )

Megan Smith 5 pts

Hi Rita,

Good for you for being so honest.  More Moms need to be honest about their feelings and not try to pretend they feel the constant joy and elation that "real loving mothers" are supposed to feel.

Feeling the way you did didn't mean you weren't a loving mother.  It just meant you were human and humans feel differently in different situations.

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/megan-smith )

Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )
Video Runway ( http://twoliablog.com/video-runway/ )

sugarbritches26 5 pts

I can't believe you said that! But I am so glad you did! I struggled with all the same issues as you. Wanting my body back, sore & bleeding nipples, feeling uncomfortable because I associate my boobs with sex a great deal. Not to mention my breasts are ginormous to begin with, I couldn't find a shirt to cover those babies for nothing.

I tried, I really really did. I attempted it with all three of my children. The first time I lasted two and one half months. The second time a whole three weeks and the third I made it two months. I likened it to eating beans. I try them every year and still don't like them.

All joking aside, it is a very serious topic, because of the pressure to breastfeed. I felt like I was doing something very wrong by choosing to not breastfeed, even though it made me extremely uncomfortable. I felt like I needed to make excuses other than admitting that I just didn't want to do it anymore.

Thanks for this post and the courage to say what I've been hesitant about since the birth of my eldest.

A.A.

Deaf Mom 5 pts

 I always appreciate an honest look at breastfeeding.   It isn't for everyone.    I think there's entirely too much guilt wasted and I'd much rather see a mom feel comfortable with their decision and get on with the process of enjoying their baby.

Karen Putz

 "Life is too short to pout all the time."

A Deaf Mom Shares Her World ( http://www.putzworld.blogspot.com )

Hands & Voices ( http://www.handsandvoices.org )

aftercancer 5 pts

I just wanted to cheer you on for doing what was best for you and your family. My kids did not want to latch so I pumped for 14 weeks for the first and 8 weeks for the second. I did my best and have still felt guilty about it.  Good for you to make your decision and be strong and honest about it. 

Kate

I blog at http://www.aftercancernowwhat.blogspot.com 

MrsWsKitchen 5 pts

It's like you've read my mind.  I've long known that I could never be a breast-feeding mama.  I'm horrified at the thought--and I KNOW the benefits to baby.  I understand all of that--but continue to be horrified nonetheless.  Thanks for an article that shows me that not everyone is cut out to breast feed.

Amanda
Mrs.W's Kitchen ( http://mrswskitchen.blogspot.com )

Atena 5 pts

 I breastfed my daughter for 2.5 years.  And it was awesome until about 2.25.

When she was a baby, once we got going it felt fine, I made enough milk, she'd eat anywhere - it was everything good that I knew it could be... until she got older and feedings actually started to trigger me (being a sexual abuse survivor), because nursing a 2 year old is different from nursing an infant.  It was really hard, until I soon realized she'd gotten what she needed, and I could let it go. So I weaned, and she was actually more ready than I anticipated.

 I have no regrets, and I plan to do the same with the next one. 

Rita - I appreciate that you went into the experience in good faith.  Thank you for sharing your story - so often these discussions of breastfeeding are so all-or-nothing.  There's a lot of gray area to think about.  The physical experience of breastfeeding isn't always that great for every woman.  We have to be honest about that.  It won't be relaxing and soothing and empowering and roses every time for every body - the consistently good results are for the kids, not for us.  Do what you can for as long as you can, and don't make yourself suffer.

(But if you're suffering because it physically hurts, please get some help.  It's really not supposed to - like sex or pooping - the situation improves dramatically with the absence of pain).

Assumptions, Biases & Irrational Fantasies ( http://antibias.wordpress.com )

MomsAgainstBullying 5 pts

pushing their ideals on other moms. Especially when new moms are in need of support and advice as in Alyssa's case when she called La Leche League and was made to feel badly that breast feeding had to be discontinued to survive! Hello! Honestly, do some people hear themselves speak? Some people are so driven by their own agendas that they end up bullying others who dare to disagree with them. La Leche League can do better than that.

There needs to be more tolerance and understanding from those who find themselves at both extremes of breast feeding. 13 years ago when I breast fed my oldest daughter, public breast feeding was looked down on. I see that not much has changed. American society is still making women feel ashamed of feeding their babies. On the flip side, women who are unable to breast feed are being made to feel guilty and ashamed by the breast feeding movement. What's that all about?

Clamo88 5 pts

http://alittlemorecrazythancool.com

I'm on my second child and I fed my first a year and have intentions of doing the same with this one- 5 months left!

I'm a supporter of it, but can also TOTALLY relate to the MANY reasons as to why people quit. You name the problem, I had it. With each kid. It's not always magically easy the way some people make it seem it is. It's hard...REALLY hard. I've thought about quitting more times than I can count but for now I'm still going one day at a time!

As for the boobs- they're definitely gone. LONG gone. I miss them.

alyssaroyse 5 pts

Determined to be the first every successful hippie who wears Prada, I was bound and determined to breast feed my child while looking glamorous as hell and strong as a Pine tree. I am woman, watch me leak.

Not so much.  First off, my daughter - who has known her mind since the moment she was born - hated my breasts. They were, in her strong little mind, utterly inefficient and doing the one and only thing they were there to do - dispense her food when she wanted it, and quickly at that.  She would grab my breast with her tiny little fingers, squeeze as hard as she could, shake them madly, look me in the eye and scream. 

I, however, had a will stronger than hers, and no daughter of mine was going to be formula fed!

Then my appendix burst when she was 6 weeks old.  And I mean burst, on death's door kind of thing. (BTW, the pain from that is MUCH worse than childbirth!) I wound up in the hospital on a (yummy yummy) morphine drip for 4 days or so. I grabbed my pump on the way to either the hospital or death, whichever came first, but all that pain, surgery and morphine, well, pumping my breasts didn't even occur to me.  And by the time it did, it was too late. There was nothing there. 

My body, it seems, decided that saving my life was all it could handle. No more milk.

I was distraught, called the Le Leche League for comfort. She had, after all, had a good 6 weeks.  They, instead, made me feel horrible.  Assured me that my daughter and I would never bond, that it would lead to both physical and psychological problems as she aged and - i kid you not - the beeyatch on the phone actually said to me, "mam, they have drugs that will make men lactate if you really cared."

I hung up the phone, made a bottle of formula and grabbed a bottle of scotch. :) 

That formula was great! My husband could do the middle of the night feedings, it was always there, no pumping.....  I'd do it all again! (Well, except the emergency surgery part.)

Here's the deal. You do what you can do. Seriously.  Your body. Your choice. And as long as your child is fed wholesome food - no matter whose udders it came from - and loved and cared for and sheltered and guided lovingly thorough the adventure that is life, then you're doing your part. 

The fact that you did everything you could in order to do something you didn't even want to do, but you did it for her, speaks volumes. 

Sure, I can make all the arguments about how healthy breast milk is, and how natural breast feeding is.  But I think that stress free and happy parents are better than even the best breast milk. 

There are enough things to worry about as parents. If you can breast feed happily and healthfully, then by all means, you go for it with all the glory of mother earth herself. But if you need or want to bottle feed, you go for it too - with all the glory of a woman who gets to choose such things for herself. 

Well done! You did what was right for you, and will be able to stand on solid ground as you rasie children and teach them to be tru to themselves. 

Oh, and yes, I still want "the girls" put  back where they used to be. :)

____________

Alyssa Royse

Just Cause It: ( http://www.justcauseit.com )A Web Site To Save The World

Start Her Up: ( http://www.startherup.com )A Blog for Women Ent

rebellious thinker 5 pts

I would think that anything that inherently makes us uncomfortable is not healthy for us. Perhaps the hardest thing about breastfeeding is that we need to do it before we have developed our momminess, we're still so new to the whole concept that we are doing too much of what other people say, and not enough of what we intuitively feel is right for our child and ourselves.

I breastfeed both of my daughters for a year each in Israel, where it was pretty evenly divided amongst the bottles and the breasts. I never felt uncomfortable anywhere. Then again, I did not thrust my breasts out anywhere. There was one memorable breastfeeding foray opposite the Mediteranean Sea, which she promptly spit up all over me, still opposite the Mediteranean Sea. Oh well, memories are what happens and not what we want to happen.  

Laura, www.RebelliousThoughtsofaWoman.com ( http://www.rebelliousthoughtsofawoman.com/ )

Florinda 5 pts

 ...for 24 years. I didn't even attempt to nurse my son as a baby, but I've never quite been brave enough ti articulate why not to anyone except myself. But my reasons were very much like the ones you've mentioned here - associating the breasts with sex, and general body-image issues (although I have never had an eating disorder). I was also very young - only 20 when he was born - and I think that was another part of why I wasn't able to embrace breastfeeding; I just wasn't ready to see my body that way.

I know the arguments in favor, and I would never discourage anyone else from nursing. But I will say that my son was an exceptionally healthy baby on formula from the get-go, and was completely weaned from bottles before he was a year old.

 Thanks for posting this. Even after all this time, and knowing that it bottle-feeding felt right to me and was fine for my baby, I've felt uncomfortable about my reasons for that decision, and I'm so glad to see them articulated.

Florinda

Blogging at The 3 R's: Reading, 'Riting, and Randomness ( http://www.3rsblog.com/ )

MomsAgainstBullying 5 pts

Don't feel guilty. You had an awful lot going on there. I was raised in the 60's and my mother flipped out when she learned that I would breastfeed my babies. She became irrate when she saw that I intended to breastfeed to the one year mark. She eventually got used to it.

Mine was a great experience, but it is not a great experience for all new moms such as yourself. If I had the pain, blistering, and bleeding that you had to endure, I would have cut it off much sooner than you did!

To answer your question about the 6 weeks. I think it is just common for doctors to give that number as the "safe" amount of time to breasfeed in terms of the health benefits to the baby via the mother's milk. So, you did a great thing for your child!

I did breastfeed my babies in public, but no one ever saw my boobs! Nor is there any need to whip them out and show the world. A light blanket covers up baby and mom providing baby with peace and quiet (even in the middle of a bustling mall) to concentrate on eating and sleeping. Passers-by know what's going on and are usually kind and supportive. Whip 'em out at your own risk. Unfortunately, you will get a hostile reaction from those same passers-by. It's purely cultural. Not right, but American culture nonetheless.