Bio
A single girl living the Adirondack and NYC lifestyle who likes dogs, cooking, entertaining, travel and adventure. Social media gal for TV, journalis...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Street Pets

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 16
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

People asking for money on the street is unfortunately nothing new to any large city, especially in Manhattan. But, what is disturbing is what seems to be a trend in New York City to involve animals.


Homeless Couple
Image: Franco Folini via Flickr

For the past month, I've seen the same guy standing outside the subway stop I get off of for work holding a sign asking for money. The man, who I'd say is about 50-60 years old, holds a sign asking for money next to a moving cart-like device topped with boxes, cloths and I'm assuming everything he owns.

About two weeks ago as I walked past him, I noticed he had two kittens sitting on top. The kittens were playful with him and each other, and looked healthy, clean and in good overall condition. I immediately thought to myself, "that doesn't seem right," but kept walking. I felt bad for this poor guy, who obviously hit rough times, but thought, "at least he has his pets."



But, as the day went on, I got more upset about it, because I kept thinking it was odd he --  what seemed like suddenly --  had these tiny kittens. I didn't see him for a few days, but earlier this week he was there again, and as I walked past, I noticed he had two more kittens that again looked like they were in very good condition. My intuition told me something was off, but I kept walking. Well, I didn't get further than the other side of the street when my curiosity kicked in and wanted to know more about these kittens. I walked back, but he was no where to be found.

That night a friend said they saw someone selling puppies on the street. I was horrified, and thought of those kittens again. What if they guy I saw was selling the kittens?

The next day when I was getting on the subway after work, I saw  two dogs tied to a cart-like mobile structure. As I stopped to admire their cute faces I realized there was no one around and it seemed like they were abandoned. I started looking around and bent down to pet the pups, which had collars with tags on and even had painted toe nails. When I did this, I noticed the egg crates on the cart they were attached to were filled with several guinea pigs and kittens.

I panicked, and was horrified all at the same time, and immediately reached for my Blackberry, to call someone. Not really sure who I was going to call, but I knew something had to be done. As soon as I took my Blackberry out, also snapping a photo of the pups, I guy came walking over and started to push it away.

My journalistic gut immediately told me something shady was going on, and tried to engage the guy in conversation -- all the while him turning away from me and trying to walk away.

Me: "Hi! Are these your dogs? They are absolutely adorable."

Him: "Yeah, they're mine."

Me: "The guinea pigs and kittens, too?"

Him: "Yeah."

Me: "Oh, cool. They're cute. Where did you get them?"

Him: "The pet store."

And then, he started walking faster and as I would pick up my pace, he would then turn and he wouldn't even look at me.

*Ding! Ding! Ding!* Something was not right about the situation, but I decided at that point I was in no way capable of continuing this discussion with him.

Several things crossed my mind -- he was selling them for profit, they were stolen or they were his pets and he had no where else to keep them but in those crates. All three of those scenarios killed me.

  • 16
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
chefjeff406 5 pts

After being homeless for a couple of months myself I would never have considered selling my cat/traveling companion of 23 years. When I had to, I had a fellow coworker take in my cat so that she was not having to ride out the winter as well.

She has since passed, R.I.P. Pricess, and she is the reason I volunteer some time at the local animal shelter.

alexash 5 pts

Over the years, in various cities, I have seen homeless pet owners. While I'm not quite sure what to make of the large number of pets that one person had, it is often found that these are some of the best cared for animals. And that for many of their owners it gives them a reason to live. The fact he didn't want to talk could come from fear that you want to take away his animals. I'd consider that before thoughts he was doing something sinister.

katal1 5 pts

They are all stolen and you need to report it so that they can be returned to the families that are in pain because of their lost pets. Trust the alarm in your belly, it's never wrong. If they were "his" he would be proud to talk to you about them, show off their quirks, etc. This is bad mojo and it IS illegal to sell stolen property, even a pet.

Kizz 5 pts

This used to be very common in NYC. It had lessened for a good long while (possibly in conjunction with the city bussing homeless people to NJ to increase tourism appeal) but I've seen a little more of it lately. All the scenarios people have suggested may be true. There's no way to know for sure unless maybe you stake him out for a few days and I'm not sure that's terribly safe. My gut instinct because he said, "From the pet store" is that he bought them to net more donations. And if he really did and has enough money to buy animals he may have a home of some sort that can also accommodate his furry friends.

The people I identify with most are the ones who aren't selling their pets and who are purposely not staying in shelters because they don't want to give them up. Feels too close to what could happen to me. I hope the animals you're seeing are safe. I agree, it's all really hard to watch.

mariablancoh 5 pts

Animals or people shouldn't go through the harshness of the streets but people shouldn't use animals for other purposes and risk their well being to make a few bucks.

Conversation from Facebook

Melissa Bishop Sherbon
Melissa Bishop Sherbon

I also agree with Mary up there. my husband reported an entire 'homeless' family because he found out they had made it their job. They quit good jobs to collect money from the government, then sat on the interstate on ramp with a baby, begging for money. The husband dropped the mother and child off for the day, then picked them up at dusk. We found out the entire situation because my husband worked with a friend of the people. They basically bragged about how much money they made doing nothing. Just sickening. It really makes you think twice before being compassionate. I've been taken too many times to do it anymore.

Melissa Bishop Sherbon
Melissa Bishop Sherbon

I see this sometimes around here as well as where I used to live. There was a man there that had a different dog about every three or four days...never at the same time. I personally knew none of the homeless shelters allowed pets, but the animals shelters had been advertising special circumstances for the homeless to surrender their animals, because of the economy. It's different to offer your pet for sale the one time, to find it a home, but it is totally different to keep aquiring animals for the purpose of selling them.

If I came upon hard times, it'd be the hardest thing to do, but surrendering an animal would be much more humane. My personal opinion is, if you can't care for yourself, you shouldn't have an animal to care for. I don't know what I'd do in this situation. I'm just glad I haven't happened upon it.

Renee Quick-Chapman
Renee Quick-Chapman

jennifer I think its a good thing she made it her business. (Honestly I think we need more people like her) What changes if we all look the other way or pretend not see things?

Mary E. Robbins
Mary E. Robbins

some people with pets have fallen on hard times... some are selling pets... and some... beg for a living using pets to generate sympathy...these folks may or may not actually be living on the streets...

Allison Currie
Allison Currie

would have called animal control...while its not illegal to sell pets there are certain conditions under which an animal can be kept...shelter, food, water, etc. and while this man may have options with homeless shelters the pets would not be allowed. Worse things can happen on the streets then at animal control where they have a chance at adoption.

Eryn Baron
Eryn Baron

"this loser." Such compassion.

Kimberly Gauthier
Kimberly Gauthier

Gosh, I would sure love to know where those pets came from...

Jennifer Bertrand
Jennifer Bertrand

Not sure it's any of your business to be honest.

Tessa White
Tessa White

I've been seeing this often in the last few years, especially in the Union Square area. I've wanted to call the ASPCA but don't know if they would do anything.

Maria Nicholson Smithson
Maria Nicholson Smithson

I would have called Animal Control and turned this loser in. At least in the shelter they stand a little chance of being adopted and not starved or God knows what on the street.