Blog
HapaMama
Bio
I'm the News and Politics Editor here at BlogHer. You can also find me writing about raising an Asian mixed-race family at my own blog,...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

I'm Asian, and I'm Going Camping!

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

This Labor Day weekend, I’m heading to Yosemite National Park with my family for a weekend of camping, hiking and swimming. Every summer, we spend several days camped out in a national park – no Internet, TV, cell phones, or electricity.

To be completely honest, being so completely unplugged makes me rather uncomfortable. I thought this was because, as a blogger, I’m completely addicted to my iPhone, my Twitter, my email. But a study released by the National Parks Service this summer suggests it might be because I’m… Asian. The study that reported 90% of visitors to U.S. National Parks are White, a number which hasn’t changed much in the past ten years, despite increasing racial diversity in the United States.

Image Credit: col&tasha, via Flickr

Not that I don’t enjoy – even love and crave -- nature. I was fortunate, growing up as the daughter of immigrants from Taiwan, to have a childhood full of family car trips to Yellowstone and the Grand Canyon. (One interesting note from the study: Asian and Native American are the minorities most likely to visit a national park.) While my parents took us hiking and fishing and visiting any site with a historical marker, our family never actually pitched a tent or slept outdoors. Why? When we could pull into the nearest Motel 6? And do you know how hard it is to steam rice on a Coleman stove?

My husband, on the other hand, relishes these expeditions -- the more outdoors, the better. He was raised on the quintessential American road trips – his family owned a RV and drove to campgrounds around the country, where they would while away their vacation playing cards at the picnic table.

While the expense and travel time is part of the reason behind the low numbers of ethnic minorities using National Parks, it’s not that simple. Visiting these sites is nearly free. Yosemite charges a $20 weekly use fee, and a campsite doesn’t cost much more than that. It’s pretty inexpensive, compared with taking a family to Disneyland – or even staying at a Motel 6.

In an interview with Our National Parks.org Shelton Johnson, an African American and a ranger at Yosemite, explains that recreation habits are largely learned from one’s upbringing:

“We learn to recreate from our parents, so if our parents never went to parks, as is the case with most minorities, the kids won’t even think to go to national parks. So when they go to take a vacation, the thought of experiencing the wilderness is entirely foreign.

That makes a lot of sense, as I recall a conversation about camping I once had with a Vietnamese American friend. She quipped, “Camping? We came to America so we don’t have to sleep on the ground in tents!”

The National Park Service’s plan to attract more racial diversity to its sites includes raising awareness among people of color. Oprah Winfrey took on the cause last fall, when when she and Gayle King roadtripped to Yosemite to camp and meet up with Ranger Shelton Johnson. In the summer of 2009, President Obama and his family visited Yellowstone and the Grand Canyon for their first time.

Other suggestions to increase ethnic diversity at the landmarks include more multi-lingual signage and multicultural interpretive displays. From the National Parks Service Comprehensive Survey of the American Public:

For example, althought it is relevant to interpret the significance of slavery at Civil War battlefield sites, it is equally relevant to interpret the stories of African American success, in addition to African American enslavement.

Also, there is the need to understand cultural travel habits. Asian Americans, for example, might be more inclined to outdoor recreation with a large ethnic or religious group, as opposed to just with the nuclear family. Part of this cultural sensitivity could come as a result of hiring more people of color within the parks service, where 80% of full-time employees are White.

And with exposure, people can learn to enjoy the outdoors, even if it’s not something they’re traditionally comfortable with. Over the five years that my husband and I have been taking our kids camping, I have grown to appreciate the wonders of our environment in a new and deeper way. Our bodies get exhausted from long hikes, sometimes the weather’s too cold (we hightailed it out of Yosemite Valley on Memorial Day several years ago as snow flurries flew), sometimes it’s too hot. But removing ourselves from civilization also removes the stresses of daily life. The

  • 12
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Shannon LC Cate 10 pts

I'd like to add something else to the mix.

I am white and my parents took me camping frequently as a child. My family couldn't afford vacations to places where you had to stay in a hotel and eat in restaurants. My father loved canoeing. My mother had been taken deer-hunting and camping with her own father from her tiny childhood. They were both good at the outdoors and enjoyed and taught my brother and I to enjoy it.

BUT.

Since A) coming out as a lesbian and marrying a very masculine butch partner and B) adopting two African American children, it has been hard to figure out how to enjoy the outdoors in a way similar to my childhood.

Frankly, I would not feel safe for my family in the beautiful, national park in Arkansas that my own family frequently enjoyed. Nearly every town we passed on the way to the park from our home in a major Midwestern city had a history of being a "Sundown Town" when my parents were children and even later. Racism is alive and well in that area of the country. Homophobia likewise.

Actual, literal safety from violence is a key factor in our decisions about where and how to travel as a family.

Right now, we are looking for a good place to take the kids where we will be literally safe and also "safe" from the children being the Only Ones (who are Black) in the area. That's another major factor.

Anyway, all this makes me sad, because I miss the camping trips of my own childhood and really want to teach my children outdoor skills. We will find a way, but these are important factors for the Park Service to consider.

Grace Hwang Lynch 14 pts

Shannon LC Cate

That's a good point about racism and homophobia <em>en route</em> to the national parks. I was talking about this with some friends while camping over the weekend, and they were questioning why someone would feel unsafe or unwelcome in a national park.

Personally, I think it is more of an issue with the travel to the areas where many parks are located. While we were in Yosemite last weekend, I'd estimate AT LEAST HALF the tourists I spotted were people of color. But Yosmite is very unusual in that it's within easy driving distance of San Francisco, LA and Sacramento.

As an adult, I worked in Southern Idaho, not too far from Yellowstone, and there were times when I travelled to rural areas where I did not feel welcome.

Thanks for adding your insight, Shannon!

jenburden 5 pts

Yes, that's me, World Moms Blog! Thanks for remembering! :)

I like this culture section that you guys are doing!

jenburden 5 pts

Interesting post, Grace!

I grew up in the US playing basketball and then I went to a big basketball college. My husband and I like to travel to watch NCAA college basketball events and tournaments. It is actually the only thing we have left our children behind for more than one night to do and we've been parents for over 4 years! It's the excitement of the roadtrip and the game at the other end.

On a separate note, my husband grew up in England playing and watching soccer. His culture led us to see the World Cup in 2002 in Japan.

Jen :) (Btw, we met at BlogHer '11 at the International Scholarships Awards Ceremony!)

Grace Hwang Lynch 14 pts

jenburden

Yes, Jen, I remember you-- World Moms Blog, right? Thanks for reading and commenting.

HomeRearedChef 41 pts

I read your blog out loud to my husband, Grace, and we both really enjoyed it. It brought back great memories for me. As a young child, my father (my adopted white father) loved to camp out, and it was, as you say, a very inexpensive way to entertain the family. Funny thing, though my husband is a real outdoors-everything type of man, we've never camped out on the ground. We've roughed it in a cabin. Maybe its me, I am too much of a Princess, afraid of bugs. LOL!

Grace Hwang Lynch 14 pts

HomeRearedChef

What an honor to have you read my post aloud to your hubby. It's good that you can enjoy nature, but know your limitations ;)

DesiValentine4 60 pts

I always unplug on vacation (which might be why I vacation so rarely). But I do not camp. My mother (who is caucasian) took us camping six weeks out of every summer from shortly after I was born until I was old enough to move out. Outdoor pursuits? Yes! Biking, hiking, kayaking, canoeing in our gorgeous national parks? Hell yeah! But when I'm done for the day, I want a soft bed with clean sheets that is proximate to a spa shower. And a quality restaurant providing room service.

Grace Hwang Lynch 14 pts

DesiValentine4 How did you camp for six weeks every summer? My secret for enjoying camping is to go no more than twice a year. Just enough to have fun, but wanting to come back for more. I think that as I get older I'll be pushing for a hotel. My favorite kind of "camping" is the kind with cabins and a dining room, like those Catskills resorts in Dirty Dancing.

Jumbo 5 pts

I'm an Asian outdoor enthusiast as well. The 90% statistic isn't surprising based on my experience. But I wonder, does anything need to be done about it?

From the park point of view, I understand the desire maintain connection to the American people. But from a societal point of view I don't know if minorities need to be doing something just because white people do it.

Grace Hwang Lynch 14 pts

Jumbo

That's a good point, maybe the whole concept of valuing outdoorsiness is from a White perspective? Although, I have to say, with growing disconnect of ALL races from nature, probably a good thing to make it available to everyone. Thanks for your thoughts, Jumbo!

Shannon LC Cate 10 pts

If we start thinking of the natural world as a "white" thing, we will be in big trouble. The kind of valuing of ecological diversity and overall environmental health that outdoor leisure instills in people is going to be needed by everyone in the first world, if we are to save the whole planet from ecological collapse. We can't afford to consider "nature" a luxury or a culturally specific thing. Environmental racism and classism are real and might be more effectively addressed if the people it harms were more welcome and safe in the places that teach appreciation for a healthy planet. Jumbo