Bio
I'm the BlogHer Contributing Editor on parenting children with special needs, and I'm at your service.  I am more than a parent, but with three...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

A Subarctic Autism Awareness Day Analogy

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I am weary of Emily Perl Kingsley's essay Welcome to Holland -- which likens a child's special needs diagnosis to being rerouted to Holland after embarking on a long-awaited trip to Italy -- being passed to parents by well-meaning pediatricians or social workers as the cherry atop stacks of life-changing autism diagnosis paperwork. Welcome to Holland, with its gentle visions of tulip fields, is a beautiful piece of writing, but it was written for parents of children with Down syndrome. It doesn't speak to my family's experience with autism, and I'm not the first to say so. For Autism Awareness Day, I'd like to propose a new and more appropriate geographic autism analogy:

Welcome to Yellowknife!


Receiving a child's autism diagnosis is like living in the world's most wonderful city, San Francisco, then being suddenly informed of your family's relocation to Yellowknife, a busy city in Canada's subarctic. Even parents who know only that the subarctic is where the globe turns from green to white are aware it's not a place one lives casually. If you're going to survive the long, dark, fierce winters and bug-ridden summers, you have to be prepared. You have to budget for expensive supplies and services that people in San Francisco never need consider. Yellowknife is also remote -- you may find that not all of your former families and friends are able to visit you there.

Living in Yellowknife can be exhilarating, it can by trying, it can be depressing, and it may just fill your soul with light. Accepting that your child is going to be raised in Yellowknife is not easy, but it's the first step to being the parent your child needs -- because you're going to have to step up. Though parents love their children as much in Yellowknife as they do anywhere else, life in Yellowknife is challenging. To keep your children not just safe but thriving requires effort and vigilance and consistency. Children need extreme bundling for winter, and hardcore bug evasion gear for summer. Frostbite lurks just outside your door during the twenty-hour-long winter nights. The seasonal rhythms are balanced by twenty hour summer days -- which makes perfect sense to your child, but may never make sense to you, or your child's siblings.

But, once you've settled in, you start to realize how cool Yellowknife can be. You start to see that Yellowknife is a crucible for the intrepid and the fearless, for people like the Ice Road Truckers who brave long and grueling journeys to provide subarctic children with the supplies and services they need. You find that, as in San Francisco, people come to Yellowknife from all over the world. You'll also find that not all of them will be staying.

Some people leave Yellowknife because they not only embrace their subarctic identity, but have no intention of living any place else -- so they founded their own semi-autonomous territory, Nunavut. Though they maintain government ties, they self-govern and live as they please with minimal outside interference. They also have long memories -- they remember the not-too-distant days of being treated like second-class citizens on their own turf. They do not appreciate being patronized or stereotyped, even about some members' special talents for art or communicating with animals.

Some subarctic residents don't cotton to life in Yellowknife or Canada - in fact, they reject it. They claim their children were forcibly dragged out of California, and so want to redefine subarctic living as an American condition. They bide their time in Alaska, where their resentments are kept simmering by an outspoken, glossy, self-professed maverick woman who thrives on promoting her controversial books, flogging conspiracy theories, and claiming that her experience as a mom gives her opinions more weight than those of professionals and experts. She does little positive work for the subarctic community as a whole. Many Alaskans-by-choice aren't pleased to be associated with her, and would rather she focused on issues that unite rather than divide the subarctic.

Some Yellowknife families discover that they're more comfortable closer to, though not across, the U.S. border. They move to cities like Vancouver, and Toronto, where they meet plenty of children who are like their kids, some of whom have been raised there, some from resident families of multiple generations. Vancouver and Toronto kids are often mistaken for Americans to those unfamiliar with their subtle Canadian variations in speech patterns, and

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
iiwii 5 pts

Shannon: I agree with your comments on this analogy. I just discovered this blog and I wish I had this blog and others to read when my children were younger. My Autistic child is 20 now and my 24 year old suffers from a personality disorder. At least Autism and other mental health issues are out of the closet now. Even TV shows are finally addressing the emotionally challenged among us. We need people to become more tolerant of people who are different. The Autism Spectrum is huge, as we know. Now we have to educate people that not every kid with Autism has Asperger's or can memorize a phone book like Rainman. There are many successful people among us who have Autistic symptoms.

elainepark 5 pts

Some of us aren't that taken with San Francisco.

Kalyn Denny 5 pts

In 30 years of teaching school, I only had one autistic student, a lovely boy named Nick. I saw the effort his parents made to be sure he had every opportunity possible. It was clear to me that he was one of the lucky ones. I know I can't begin to understand what it's like to be the parent of an autistic child, but writing like this does help make it more clear.

Kalyn Denny
Kalyn's Kitchen ( http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com )

Welcome to Normal 5 pts

Thanks for sharing this post in your comment on my blog Shannon. I don't live in Yellowknife but I'm not all that far from it, relatively speaking, here in Winnipeg, Canada.

The thing that's always bothered me about the Holland analogy is the premise that new parents should expect that trip to Italy in the first place. I know that's the reality - that's where most new moms see themselves going - but I think that's an assumption we need to start really challenging on a cultural level.

When you decide to have a baby, you really need to start thinking about the possibility of Yellowknife. Not so that you can cancel your trip - but rather, so you can pack appropriately. It doesn't mean you'll ever be completely prepared, or even that you'll necessarily enjoy Yellowknife in the end. You may even, as you said, find yourself leaving your kids there for everyone's benefit. But it does mean that, on a cultural level, we can stop having babies because we envision them in frilly princess dresses or adorable bow ties. We need to start having them because we are committed to doing everything we can - as a community - to raise happy adults. The expectations that North American moms have for their babies is something I call "The Disney Effect". I'm planning to do a blog post on it soon, would love if you'd stop by and let me know what you think.

Caitlin

I love my family, my work, my activism and my red wine. Couldn't stop writing if my life depended on it.

www.welcome-to-normal.com ( http://www.welcome-to-normal.com/ )

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Grateful for the positive feedback from five people I respect so deeply.

I had a good time writing this, and hope it is of use.

For the record, I have relatives in non-metaphorical Yellowknife, Toronto, and Vancouver (though none in Crescent City).

Shannon Des Roches Rosa
Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com ) parenting first, autism second
CanISitWithYou.org ( http://www.canisitwithyou.org )
real tales of schoolyard terror and triumph

Shannon Des Roches Rosa 5 pts

Queen of Nostalgia ( http://queen-of-nostalgia.blogspot.com/ ) posted this comment on my personal site; I like it so much I'm reposting it here:

Hi! I just read your essay on BlogHer and think it is just wonderful! You are so right- having a child with autism isn't a simple process of getting acclimated to a new culture (like the lovely Holland essay) or learning a new language. Having a child with autism is a bitter/beautiful battle, each and every day. Seeing the beautiful Northern Lights doesn't change the fact it is negative 50 degrees. But we don't pretend it isn't cold, do we? We add another layer, keep fighting the cold, and fiercely look for ways to make our babies warmer.

Thank you so much for this essay :)

Sincerely,
Kristen
mother to twins with autism

Shannon Des Roches Rosa
Squidalicious.com ( http://www.squidalicious.com ) parenting first, autism second
CanISitWithYou.org ( http://www.canisitwithyou.org )
real tales of schoolyard terror and triumph

Karianna 5 pts

Thanks for a terrific piece - and especially for the informative links at the end.

XO,
K

www.kariannaspectrum.com ( http://www.kariannaspectrum.com )

VickiForman 5 pts

And this is the best post on what it's like and what it all means I've ever read. Plus it's just plain genius, like you.

Mir Kamin 6 pts

Simply lovely, Shannon. So much great information/links and I absolutely love the metaphor. Remember that whole conversation about what it's like to have a kid who can "pass?" I think we're spending the bulk of our days in Toronto. ;)

Yellowknife is a lot less scary than it used to be, though....

--
Mir Kamin
(BlogHer contributing editor)

Personal: Woulda Coulda Shoulda ( http://wouldashoulda.com/ )

Having it all with less: Want Not ( http://wantnot.net/ )

jennyalice 5 pts

...and we are champion curlers.

Thanks Shan.

www.jennyalice.blogspot.com ( http://www.jennyalice.blogspot.com )
www.CanISitWithYou.org ( http://www.CanISitWithYou.org )

Thedomesticgoddess 5 pts

I've never quite thought of it that way! Well put!

And, for the record, I've never been a huge fan of Welcome to Holland. It's OK and all. I'm a very positive person but it just never spoke to me. I'm more of a "WELCOME TO VEGAS, BABY!" Kind of person. Never sleep, bright lights, intense and overstimulating!

Domestic Engineer, Total Babe and SAHM