Bio
BlogHer Contributing Editor -- Pop Culture & Entertainment   I work as a blogger liaison, project manager, and message imagineer throu...
 
 
 
 

Suspended from High School Over a T-Shirt, Teens are Fighting Back

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 0
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

It can be troubling to think about how teenagers can stray into some very risky and scary behaviors.  Like... wearing T-shirts!

Typically news stories about the issues affecting teens include topics such as drugs, suicide, handguns, gangs and unprotected sex.  But simple T-shirts have been the topic of concern this week. School boards, administrators, parents, teens and even advocacy groups like the ACLU have been discussing all sorts of cotton wardrobe-related questions:  Should the words students wear on their clothes be protected as free speech?

  • If a school district has a dress code based on subjective criteria like "offensive," how can the code be enforced justly? 
  • Do dress codes really improve student behavior anyway? 
  • Didn't today's parents listen to enough Pink Floyd to know that crazy train dress codes are just another brick in the wall? 
  • With persistent social problems with much higher stakes competing for administrators' attention, why do kids have to fight, for the right, to... wear T-shirts?

Shirt: Marriage is so gay!

Not the teen in question, but you get the point of the shirt now.

Questions have been swarming around two shirts, one in Colorado and one in Washington State.
A Colorado school back-pedaled this week after requiring student Kate Cohn to change out of the "Marriage is So Gay" shirt she wore to make a political statement on Election Day.  According to the Colorado Springs Gazette, the student has been told that the shirt is now okay to wear after a two-week ban that began when Principal Mark Carara deemed it "offensive."

According to the Denver Post, the ACLU became involved in the case:

"It was censorship of the content of speech," ACLU attorney Rebecca Wallace said. "It's unfortunate it took a letter from the ACLU to teach District 49 about basic constitutional rights, but we applaud the school's prompt correction of its violation."

Since 1969, the Supreme Court has held that students don't "shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gates."

Across the country at the high school in Washington famous for being the alma lair of the Twilight kids, students are also saying their rights have been violated over a T-shirt.   After a student was prohibited from wearing a Sex Pistol T-shirt, others banded together in response, proclaiming that they aren't going to take it anymore.

 
After a student was instructed to remove a Sex Pistols T-shirt by a Forks High School official, former student body president Devon Chastain donned the offending garment herself and refused to take it off. As a result, she was sent home. The incident sparked a punky domino effect of sorts, as nine other students then staged a protest in front of the school in support of their suspended classmate, distributing more T-shirts bearing the Sex Pistols’ fabled ransom-note logo. In turn, these students were also suspended.


In this case, the shirt was not a political statement, but personal expression through pop culture. The stakes might not be as high, but still something feels Rotten here and it isn't Johnny.  Rather that being viewed as disruptive I would think that an homage to the seminal 1970s punk wouldn't raise an eyebrow anymore -- or would count as History homework at

  • 0
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments