Blog
Snoodlings
About
This BlogHer Spotlight was picked by the editor as a post you'd love to read. Learn more about the BlogHer Spotlight program.
 
 
 
 

Sweet Vindication for Parents: SpongeBob Is Bad

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 27
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

We have a SpongeBob Squarepants ban in our house. It's less about the "fast-paced" nature of the show, which reportedly makes our children dumb, and more about the fact that it annoys the non-square-pants off of me. And something about the language. We also ban slow-paced shows because of the annoyance factor. See also: Max & Ruby.

Annoying banned shows aside, people sure are talking about this new study claiming that fast-paced cartoons -- like the Bob-Bob, as my oldest son used to call him -- are bad for our kids' developing minds. It was all over the morning news circuit this morning and not surprisingly, all over the blogs this afternoon. There are many opinions -- some complete dismissal of the pseudo-science and others rejoicing. But one by Whimzie at Snoodlings made me laugh. There's nothing better than science on your side when explaining to your kids why they cannot do something they want to do.

Whimzie starts out her post with a bit of gloating:

SpongebobMom friends of mine, I want you to take just a moment today to celebrate a small victory with me. We spend many minutes of our day making unpopular decisions our kids don’t understand. We are sometimes perceived as the cosmic killjoys in our family’s universe because we insist on such trivialities as clean underwear, brushed teeth, and limits on time with devices that require batteries or have to be plugged into the wall. But once in a long while the method to our madness is revealed in such a way, we have to ask the whole world to pause with us for just a moment to acknowledge our rightness. This morning was one of those moments for me.

Almost every morning I turn on Good Morning America while the kids are getting ready for school. Until Phineas and Ferb includes a news crawl at the bottom of the screen, my morning time with George, Robin, Sam, Josh, and Lara will probably be my only chance at knowing what is happening in the un-animated world. I get the weather forecast so I know whether or not to send the kids to school with a jacket, I hear the latest news stories, and I might even find a recipe that will help me solve my daily dilemma of what to make for supper. But today I received something unexpected: sweet vindication.

Today Josh Elliott reported what I’ve been telling my kids for years: Watching SpongeBob makes you dumber.

Photo Credit: npobre.

Read more from This Just In: Spongebob Makes You Dumber at Snoodlings

  • 27
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
April Byrd 15 pts

I Watched the video. I also believe this study did'nt consider all the right factors or age groups. I take away lessons from Spongebob all the time: http://www.breathoflifedaily.com/2012/05/spongebob-lessons-captivation-of-being.html However, It is clearly stated that the show is meant for entertainment. ...and I'm also just bias because love that little sponge!:)

Little Tots Big Ideas 6 pts

I say, "Give me a break." Who is doing research on this stuff? Seems that makes people dumber. My kids love SpongeBob. Aren't we taking this stuff too serious? Honestly, research? Really?

jacq-- 5 pts

i think more parents should try a TV-less household. It's amazing how much a young child can learn from a parent's attention. :)

hlsblue 9 pts

My household loves Sponge Bob. I seriously doubt the show actually makes anyone dumber. If you don't like the show, don't let your kids watch it. Just because research shows up on Good Morning America doesn't make it valid. Maybe we should quit watching the news and believing everything we see or hear

ajwilson412 9 pts

Wow! This was really interesting to read! I actually used to enjoy spongebob (yes, I'm a grown woman...lol), I thought it was funny. However, I stopped watching it after awhile (not just cause I started to "grow up") but also because many of the jokes are inappropriate for the children it's aiming itself at. So I refused to support it. Now to see this...wow! Definitely something that's good to know! Thanks for this post, I will share it with everyone I know!

Expat Mum 16 pts

My 8 year old is now into Tom and Jerry and all things Loony Tunes. I tell you, that cat and mouse are far worse then Sponge Bob. Forever racing around to manic music and hitting each other over the head with shovels and worse.

My Son Has 2 Brains 8 pts

I also think this research is junk. Maybe the kids were distracted after the 9 minutes because they wanted to finish the entertaining show instead of doing a boring exercise with the research team. Can't one make the argument that driving in a car is bad for kids' developing brains because the images outside the window are moving too fast and aren't "natural". When books first came out, people believed they were evil too because all kids wanted to do was read all day. It's funny how that perspective has changed.

Conversation from Twitter

alliee_LB
alliee_LB

CheElizaga mch... .l. ¬¬

Conversation from Facebook

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

I've been saying it for years! The only kids who I ever knew that watched it would be boys and would be constantly impulsively bouncing off the walls and the parents would say "boys will be boys". That's not what boys are like, I have a brother. He respects women, works hard, is creative, kind, full of deep thought, and can control himself. He also grew up on Sesame Street and not until we were older did our parents allow us to watch GI Joes, Indiana Jones, Star Wars, etc. and would sit with us and talk about good vs evil and acceptable behaviour and values. Spongebob would never have flown in our house growing up.

Lisa Graham Art
Lisa Graham Art

I knew it!

Brooke Harshbarger Schmidt
Brooke Harshbarger Schmidt

Hahahaha. Good one, Gina. As long as our government and FDA are in bed with our politicians, our food supply and drug supply will keep being toxic. We might as well save our kids from SpongeBob. :)

Gina Citelli Moser Lmt
Gina Citelli Moser Lmt

Give me a break! U think spongebob is too violent? Don't let your child watch it. It would be great if they focused their studies in the crap in our kids vaccines and food system !

Brooke Harshbarger Schmidt
Brooke Harshbarger Schmidt

We have never allowed SpongeBob in our home and never will. My kids are 5 and 3. As for the argument, it's no worse than Tom & Jerry or whatever we grew up with, maybe not. But my kids aren't watching Tom & Jerry or whatever I grew up either.

Jane Collins
Jane Collins

A SpongeBob backlash...really? It's one of the best written (and most sophisticated) animated series outside of The Simpsons. Not violent but also not for 4 year olds. Anyway, I'm devastated I love the Sponge dude and his friend Patrick. I also think this research is junk.

Anne-Marie Ross
Anne-Marie Ross

But.... how can it be bad? He LIVES IN A PINEAPPLE UNDER THE SEA!?!?!!!!???!!

Michelle McFarlane Crain
Michelle McFarlane Crain

This study is kind of dumb. It claims the attention spam of 4 year olds is less after watching spongebob. Duh. ANY kid has less of an attention span when or after watching a show they like.

Valinda Linarez
Valinda Linarez

Can't be any worse than tom and jerry. They were always trying to kill each other.

Julianna Paradisi
Julianna Paradisi

Sigh. I miss Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood.

Clea Shannon
Clea Shannon

never a fan...but then again Looney Toons might not be great either...and I grew up on those

Dina VanDecker- Tibbs
Dina VanDecker- Tibbs

thankfully at 6 my son has tired of him, at 4 it did its damage. it's funny how the creators response is the show is created for 6-11 year olds, unfortunately its only four year olds who love it.

Rachelle Pavao Goldenberg
Rachelle Pavao Goldenberg

Uh oh....spaghettio's Oh wait, it seems everything is bad for you.

Michelle Welsh Giguiere
Michelle Welsh Giguiere

Now, if I could only convince my husband of this....

Allison Zurinski
Allison Zurinski

LOL, I feel better for not putting it on my house!

Jo L Smith
Jo L Smith

OMG .. I have been saying that for years!!! Now I have the proof to back it up!!!! Finally!

Tammy Larson
Tammy Larson

duh! that's a no brainer!!! All cartoons these days are nothing but violence!

CrunchyVTMommy
CrunchyVTMommy

I FREAKING KNEW IT!