Bio
Learn more about me or just visit my personal blog or come bargain hunt with me. Writing? Check. Parenting? Check. Shopping for shoes? Check. Yep,...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Swine Flu, Seasonal Flu, and Vaccinations: Should You Worry?

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

My dog will perform a variety of tricks for you if you have food in your hand; she'll sit, roll over, and do other standard pooch antics. She will also fall over and pretend to be dead if you ask her if she has swine flu. Maybe it was in poor taste to teach that one to her, but at the time -- during the height of the swine flu hysteria last year -- it seemed really funny to us.

The flu is no laughing matter, of course. Last year's H1N1 outbreak met the criteria to be classified as a pandemic, even though it ultimately turned out to be no more dangerous than the "regular" seasonal flu strains. And there was a lot of talk about H1N1 being particularly dangerous for children, even those who were healthy prior to infection. In reality, a recent study breaks down last year's flu stats and concludes:

"We found that children were disproportionately affected by 2009 H1N1 infections, but the perceived severity of symptoms and risk of serious outcomes (pneumonia or hospital admissions) were not increased in children relative to seasonal influenza A viruses[.]"

A young boy receives an H1N1 Flu vaccine shot from a nurse at Carlin Springs Elementary School in Arlington, Virginia on January 7, 2010. The virus is currently hitting hardest in Virginia, but the vaccine has now become widely available. UPI/Roger L. Wollenberg Photo via Newscom

Now that everyone is back to school, thoughts seem to be turning to cooler weather... and flu vaccines. Last year there were two vaccines; the "regular" flu shot, and then the H1N1 shot, of which there was a chronic shortage during flu season. This year, the standard trivalent seasonal influenza vaccine covers H1N1, so only the one shot is recommended. And the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that all children over the age of 6 months be vaccinated this year. This represents a change to the prior guidelines, wherein only "at-risk" children were recommended for vaccination.

I happen to believe in vaccinations, and I'm a big believer in the flu shot. I like to tell the story this way: We never got flu shots until the year when the entire family was felled by flu, one by one. It took a full month to run through our home, by which time three of the four of us had experienced secondary infections. (And yes, as the mom, I was the last to get sick, which meant I cared for sick kids for weeks before falling ill and needing to care for well kids while I could barely get out of bed. Ah, motherhood!) After that, we all got flu shots every year, but it was tricky -- my son and I qualified under the guidelines because we have asthma, but we often had to do a bit of campaigning to get a shot for my daughter/husband (they live with high-risk patients, though they aren't ones, themselves). My kids haven't had the flu since. I've had it only once more in the intervening eight or so years, though my doctor cheerfully reminded me that sometimes that happens.

And last year, we never did get the H1N1 shot. It wasn't available, so we just got the regular shot and crossed our fingers. Luckily, we didn't have much of an outbreak around here, and we didn't get sick.

After last year's panic and propaganda about how we should all be stockpiling Tamiflu and preparing for an epidemic of Plague proportions, I have a hard time getting too worked up about it all. Every year there's flu. Every year we get flu shots. I'm glad that this year there's only one shot, and it sounds like they're not anticipating a shortage. Getting vaccinated greatly reduces your chances of infection; that seems like a no-brainer to me.

Other Thoughts on This Year's Flu Vaccination

  • Sharon at Baby Boomer Advisory Club thinks this year's vaccine is dangerous, and says she won't take it herself nor give it to anyone she loves.
  • My Life as an Asthma Mom says they'll line up to get their shots (and go out for ice cream after).
  • Strollerderby's Paula Bernstein says the good news is that there should be plenty of vaccine available, and all kids will be able to get it. The bad news, she says, is that this year's H3N2 flu
  • 14
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
MsAdventuress 5 pts

I agree with you on this. I'm so glad you shared.

Ms. Adventuress ( http://www.msadventuress.com ) is where we honor and inspire the desire to adventure ( http://msadventuress.blogspot.com/p/about.html )...

doctoramy 5 pts

I trust my body's ability to fight infection better than I trust pharmaceutical company's ideas about what should be injected into anyone's system.

karen322 5 pts

I will be getting both shots for my son, who will be about 1.5 years olf when he gets them. My pediatrician has assured me they are safe, and she has 3 kids of her own. It would break my heart to see him get really sick. :(

-Karen

www.mylifespot.com ( http://mylifespot.com/ )   Insight into Parenting, Women's Health, & Wellness.

Just_Margaret 5 pts

While I'm not anti-immunization by any means, I have never had a flu or H1N1 shot, nor have my kids or my hub.

My thinking is that yes, there's a new strain of the flu every year. Because we're all pretty healthy folks in this house, we've no allergies or asthma or other conditions to be concerned with, we basically go head to head with the outside world and the germs that come with it--we just don't get sick very often. If we do, we simply treat the illness appropriately (always lots of rest & liquids) and don't over-do things until totally back in the healthy saddle.

That doesn't work for everyone, nor would I suggest that others should necessarily follow my family's lead. It just seems to have been working thus far for us. Now that I've written this, however, I'm sure that we will all come down with virulent cases of the flu this winter and I will eat my words!!

~Margaret

Just Margaret ( http://maurhoffbarney.blogspot.com )

midgetinvasion 5 pts

This is just our experience, and I only believe it affects our family. I think everyone should do what is right for them.

Years ago, we got every vaccine in the book, on time, like clockwork. It seemed my kids were still sick all the time. Then one year, my husband got the new fangled nasal mist flu vaccine, and since it's a live virus, me and the children all got the flu. It was bad enough that one of my children ended up at the hospital on breathing treatments, and still has breathing issues sometimes, 6 years later.

It changed my thinking a little bit. My daughter only got so sick, because of the strain of flu that was in the vaccine, which WASN'T one of the strains floating around. (Oh the irony of it all!) We decided to try a winter of the children and I not getting the flu vaccine. You know what? It was our healthiest winter up to that point.

We haven't gotten the flu shot since, and in general, my children have fared winter better since we made that decision. Maybe it's just a coincidence, but it's working, so we're sticking with it.

My husband, being military, has no choice and is forced to get it. Luckily for me though, he requests the actual shot each year so he won't get the nasal one again.

mariamuir 5 pts

www.mariamuir.com ( http://www.mariamuir.com )

www.innocentvoicesuk.com ( http://www.innocentvoicesuk.com )

I can not understand how you can disregard the chemicals that are used in such vaccines and allow it to be injected into your body and still think its perfectly safe. If anyone cared about their families they would at least do the research and learn exactly what you are being injected with. Australia banned the vaccine after children suffered serious side-effects, Finland suspended swine flu shots after they were linked with neurological disorder, and the Telegraph reported on links between flu jabs and “fits” in children under 5.

'There is not a single shred of evidence in existence today that scientifically supports the myth that H1N1 vaccines reduce mortality from H1N1 infections. The best evidence on vaccines that target seasonal flu indicates a maximum mortality reduction effect of somewhere around 1% of those who are vaccinated. The other 99% have the same mortality rate as people who were not vaccinated, which would suggest, quite simply, that the ‘vaccine’ is useless.' http://www.sovereignindependent.com/?p=7533

Nobody wants to be Ethel 5 pts

As a health care provider I get the flu shot every year.

There are blogs going around that healthcare workers should be fired if they don't get the flu shot due to the risk they are posing to their patients.

I get the flu shot to protect myself, my family, my patients, and my co-workers. Once you have had the flu you know how sick you can get. I have gotten the flu a few times and I got really sick.

I know that there is a small population of people who hold onto their freedoms and don't want anyone to tell them what to do. But being in the medical profession and seeing really sick people, you can understand why all these vaccines are promoted. To prevent an societal outbreak but also to save money on health care costs.

Patty

JennaHatfield 9 pts

We don't. We won't.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

Kelly Salasin 5 pts

I've done lots of good work during the flu--left a job, decided on another baby, and realized that sons make terrible caretakers:
http://emptynestdiary.wordpress.com/2009/11/22/flu...

Mominboyland 5 pts

Getting the swine flu is no different then any other flu virus as long as you have proper medical benefits. I don't trust Big Pharma or the list of poisons they claim that we NEED in order to make their pockets grow. Do your research ladies, we get pumped full of so many harmful agents, and for what? To get sick anyway as some women above said. That's just crazy to me. Check out this video about how we were bullied and misled about the Swine Flu. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t9HamW8sH8Q

texasebeth 6 pts

we all will. Hubby didn't last year because he works from home and isn't very exposed to germs. This year he's working PT at night at a local grocery store - a true germ fest - so I'm making him get one.

I also ignore all the naysayers about this and every single vaccine. I can agree to disagree with dignity and respect for others. :)

We each do what we think is best for our families.

Elizabeth

@texasebeth ( http://twitter.com/texasebeth )  and My Life, such as it is.... ( http://texasebeth.blogspot.com )

feelingbeachie 5 pts

I have gotten the flu shot for the past 15 years or so. Before I took the shot, without fail, I always got the flu. Fortunately, since one of our BFF’s is our doctor, I was able to get the H1N1 shot last year as well.

Susan Getgood 5 pts

We always get flu shots, and last year because of all the travel I was doing I got H1N1. This year, I'm also considering TDAP for pertussis -- my tetanus is due, and once again I will be travelling a lot.

Susan Getgood blogs at Marketing Roadmaps ( http://getgood.com/roadmaps ), Snapshot Chronicles ( http://snapshotchronicles.com ) and Snapshot Chronicles Roadtrip ( http://snapshotchronicles.com/roadtrip ).

Judy Laquidara 5 pts

Like you, we never got the shots til we all had the flu. Thought we'd never get over it and since, we all get the shots and will do it again this year.

Judy Laquidara
http://www.patchworktimes.com