Bio
Rita Arens authors Surrender, Dorothy and Surrender, Dorothy: Reviews. She is BlogHer.com's senior editor.  Her parenting anthology and BlogHer'...
 
 
 
 

Swipe Fee Changes Equal Goodbye, Free Checking

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

[Updated 10/28: Banks appear to be caving left and right on adding additional debit card fees following the backlash on Bank of America. This editor still plans to leave Bank of America, because, people, please.]

[Editor's Note: Ruh-roh. Looks like Bank of America finally took its frustration about caps on swipe fees out on the little guy. And we saw it coming months ago. Here's my post from June 28 -- looks like that only took three months.


 

Guess what? New fees are coming. Let's look at the list of checking account fees already possible at my own bank, Bank of America.

Back in April, BlogHer Contributing Editor Wellheeled wrote about the two sides battling it out in Congress over swipe fees -- the small percentage that retailers pay every time you use your debit card. She wrote:

Both sides have hired lobbyists and written letters to Congress to advocate for their position. If these fees were slashed as the merchants want:

  • Small business could prosper. Lower fees will help merchants grow their business and have more money for hiring and investments.
  • Small banks and credit unions will lose a big source of their revenue and may even fail.
  • The consumer could lose perks such as free checking accounts as banks try to make up for the lost source of revenue.
  • If debit card fees are lower than credit card fees, merchants might encourage consumers to make purchases with debit.

Earlier this month, the Senate rejected an amendment to delay some changes to reform, according to Nation's Restaurant News. Apparently, restaurants and other retailers were really excited about this because it means the fees per transaction can be capped and controlled.

With banks holding assets of less than $10 billion exempted from the swipe fee reform, we're talking about the big dogs here. My cynical side knows they're not going to take a huge reduction like that in stride.

The Washington Post notes the reduction in income from swipe fees for big banks could be nearly 70 percent.

 

bank advertisement

 

 

Credit Image: Aranami on Flickr

 

 

Guess what? New fees are coming. Let's look at the list of checking account fees already possible at my own bank, Bank of America. The list includes: overdraft item fee, extended overdrawn balance charge, overdraft protection transfer fee, non-suffient funds fee, foreign ATM fee, check enclosure fee, check image service fee, stop payment fee, late fee, returned item fee. I found out the hard way I can't even take money out of my savings account more than three times a month. Of course, when I went to look at its competitor Citibank, I couldn't even find a complete list of Citibank checking account fees. And since Chase doesn't offer checking in my ZIP code, I couldn't find their list of fees, either. Sneaky, sneaky. My least favorite bank, Capital One (full disclosure: the one that enticed me to make a balance transfer then immediately cut my credit line to exactly that amount and raised my interest rate -- I petitioned to have the account basically suspended to freeze the interest rate, which did work) says they have no fees! Only a list of Capital One special use charges.

And, of course, banks are testing new fees. From Susanna Kim at ABC News:

A Bank of America spokesperson said today, customers will not be able to avoid a monthly service fee in the new "Essentials" account, even if they maintain a minimum balance amount or by using direct deposits.

"Many of our customers choose to have a monthly fee. They like that predictability," said Susan Faulkner, Bank of America Deposits and Card Product Executive, during a press conference today.

So. What's the best thing to do? I have no idea. Do you?

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak. She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
gracecourage 5 pts

Another vote for banking at a small, local bank. My little, regional bank has been around for over 100 years and is highly rated. They don't charge me a fee when I use my debit card at ATMs from other banks, and REFUND ME any ATM fees those banks charge me--this is with a low-level, no-minimum-balance-required account--AND the $10-a-month charge for this account gets waived with direct deposit. To this bank, even my little account matters; I get treated like a valuable customer (even when my balance is $11.79, LOL) and not like an inconvenience.

estelkenobi 5 pts

Join a local credit union! That's what my husband and I decided after a bit of research and a lot of frustration with BofA and other banks. Credit unions are, I was surprised to learn, actually not for profit so any profits they do make get returned to you as high interest checking AND (drumroll please) few IF ANY fees!

hokis pokis 5 pts

Why don't you blame the Senate with their micro managing the banking system.

Durbin passed a bill that limits what banks can charge as fees. Naturally the fees will be now charged to the account holder not the store or restaurant that uses your card. The standard fee on credit cards is about 2.5 percent, Durbins bill does not allow that fee!

Gena Haskett 10 pts

hokis pokis You don't see the total problem? Why should a retailer or vendor have consistently pay more and more money for an electronic transfer or verification?

It was unfair to merchants who were being squeezed.

Those that opted out had little signs by the registers that said there was an additional .50 cent or .75 cent fee for the sales transaction. I know I wasn't going to pay that fee and stop going to those vendors.

No one is saying to the banks and credit processors that they couldn't chard for their services. They were hammering the merchants. The merchants either had to take cash only, not a workable thing in a debit/credit card world or witness a good chunk of their sales to to the banks.

There is the right to make a profit. Nobody is against that.

Constantly squeezing more and more profit at the risk of killing a business or customer relationship is stupid. And gets us where we are now.

FUBAR.

savingsmania 5 pts

When banks were forced to stop charging outrageous overdraft fees, they had to resort to nickel and diming customers. I recommend everyone check out ING.com. They are much more customer friendly.

spinneo 5 pts

Wow! You called it!

I bank now at tiny little Mascoma Bank, in Northern New England where I live. By choosing a smaller institution, I'm putting my money to work more locally. And my little bank isn't subject to the new rules, and probably won't create a fee. (I have no guarantee, of course.)

Small banks are good for the community, and--for now--better for my wallet.

Bank of America is counting on the fact that it's rather a pain to switch banks. But at $60 a year... it's probably worth it.

littlesistersays 6 pts

Credit unions are a more wallet-friendly option, but may not be as geographically convenient as the big banks. My other suggestion would be to follow the woman of my roots... http://littlesistersays.wordpress.com/2011/10/03/s...

Rita Arens 35 pts

It will be interesting to see if people will go back to using cash. I think we will.

cdrdash 33 pts

I bank with Wells Fargo and I hear that they may impose debit card fees soon. I'm hoping that the fee will apply only if I use the card for other than withdrawing or depositing cash from an ATM. Because it will be pretty easy for me to not use the debit card for purchasing but use a credit card or pay in cash instead. But if they charge a fee for being able to use debit cards in the ATM machines, that will be harder. Its very convenient to be able to get cash just about any day and any hour!

Gena Haskett 10 pts

cdrdash Last I heard you won't get the fee if you use the actual bank ATM. I have to warn folks, this isn't the only new fee that will pop up. Transition now to a smaller bank or credit union.

cdrdash 33 pts

Gena Haskett I hope its the case that I won't get a fee if I use the bank's ATM. I have lots of accounts with Wells Fargo and a long history with them (24 years). It would be painful to transition to a new bank. I'll probably wait to see if I can avoid fees one way or the other before I consider switching to a credit union or smaller bank.

texasebeth 23 pts

cdrdash

We use our debit card for purchases all the time. I pay all my bills online with my debit card. I use it as a credit card requiring signature instead of the pin code. If I get charged a fee for that, then we will definitely be switching. Most places don't take checks unless they EFT it. Checks cost money though and paying everything in cash is doable but a pain in the patoot.

cdrdash 33 pts

texasebeth I use the Wells Fargo online bill pay service and knock on wood, so far they don't charge for that. They pull the money out of whatever account I indicate. The only thing I really use my debit card for is groceries but happily the Safeway has a Wells Fargo ATM machine right inside so I can just get some cash before I shop and pay in cash. It will be a good way to stick to a budget as I shop!

texasebeth 23 pts

Who in their right mind would "chose to have a monthly fee."? Predictability be darned; what about the predictability to not have a monthly fee with direct deposit? We bank with Chase because we used to be able to earn frequent flyer miles with our debit card. We don't have any major credit cards for a variety of reasons. I have 2 credit union savings accounts but may consider switching depending on what Chase does next.

Gena Haskett 10 pts

Another voice for community banking, A Mr. George Bailey

Gena Haskett is a BlogHer Contributing Editor. My Blogs: Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook ( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )

Gena Haskett 10 pts

Think about the movie It Is A Wonderful Life. George Bailey's pop had an early version of a credit union.

The modern day credit union members pool their money into the Credit Union. This allows those same members to access buying cars, homes and other things same as banks.

You still would have a national ATM network, retirement plans and other bank like features. As an added bonus, your money stays in the community and supports local or area interests.

There is more but that is the short version. I leave it to others to make any association between banks and a certain Mr. Potter, and I don't mean Henry.

Gena Haskett is a BlogHer Contributing Editor. My Blogs: Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook ( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )

Rita Arens 35 pts

Can you explain the difference between a bank and a credit union? I've never really grasped it. Probably a good post, eh?

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy ( http://bit.ly/Qp0sS ) and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

Gena Haskett 10 pts

Perhaps the banks truly feel that they are too big to fail or be held accountable. I'd bet that if just 30% of current bank customers switched to a credit union there would be a change in attitude.

http://www.asmarterchoice.org

Many of the national credit unions now have flexible memberships that would welcome just about anybody.

Gena Haskett is a BlogHer Contributing Editor. My Blogs: Out On The Stoop ( http://outonthestoop.blogspot.com ) and Create Video Notebook ( http://createvideonotebook.blogspot.com )