Bio
A neurotic 20-something with very little free time on my hands. And yet I still manage to find time to complain and do a little 'creative whining' on...
 
 
 
 

Taking the girl out of Upstate: The Selection of Kirsten Gillibrand

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

In the midst of all the speculation surrounding the selection of Kirsten Gillibrand (D-20 NY) as the replacement for former Senator Clinton, I asked a friend from the Bronx if she knew who Kirsten Gillibrand was. "No", she replied, "You could tell me that she's the Postmaster General and I would believe you". And there lies the rub of New York politics. A state so vast that people from Manhattan are flummoxed by the idea of a place north of Albany and people from north of Albany think that the state is run by a bunch of liberal downstate politicians with no clue of the hardships that those north of Westchester face.

I am from Upstate. I was born, raised and currently reside here. Each pocket of Upstate comes with its own problems, especially moving westaward where once thriving cities have been brought to their knees. Which is why Governor Paterson's selection of Kirsten Gillibrand was a brilliant political move as if to let those Upstate know that their needs haven't been tossed to the wayside.

People will say she's one of us. Known for her monthly town hall meetings around the district which surrounds the capital city of Albany, but will she be able to bring such vastly different areas of the state together? Will she be able to advocate for all New Yorkers but especially those who are often left off the grid in a state that is laregely run by people hailing from the five boroughs? The senior Senator, Chuck Schumer, is known as a good guy from Brooklyn. He has never forgotten where he's from and has preserved strong ties to his state and neighborhood. He's been able to maintain the best of both worlds by leveraging his seniority in the Senate on behalf of his constituents. Which makes one wonder if our new junior Senator will be able to maintain her upstate roots and remember who she went to Washington to represent in the first place.

So, while we're up here in this relatively unknown area cheer on one of our own, a bit of healthy skepticism and nervousness remain. Will she be able to hold onto her seat in the 2010 election? Will she be able to advocate and bring a voice for a large section of the sstate that tends to remain forgotten and voiceless? Time will tell but for now we're up here in the snow rooting for her to succeed.

Related Reading:

Daily Gotham wonders if in a special election the 20th Congressional District will stay blue

Politics on the Hudson

On Huffington Post, the newest Senator has already been reaching out to LGBT advocacy groups

Prospect.Org wonders who exactly is Kirsten Gillibrand (via Feministing)

HeatherB also writes about living in Upstate NY at <a href="http://nopasanada.org">No Pasa Nada</a>. It's really, really cold there.

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Jill Miller Zimon 6 pts

I was just telling someone how I grew up in CT which is SO small compared to where I am now - Ohio.  But in some ways, the geographics often don't tell you just how different some areas of living within any sized state might be from others - smaller or larger.

She's certainly got her work cut out for her and from the stuff I've read, it sounds as though she will not even try to coast.

I had heard about her when she got elected because I was following the number of women running and getting or not getting elected and she was a big success story for 2006 due to the upset against Sweeney.  Plus, I knew she'd gone to some training for women who want to run.

Thanks again for taking the time to share this info.

JillWrites Like She Talks ( http://www.writeslikeshetalks.com )

HeatherB 5 pts

People from the city think that once you cross the Tappan Zee that you are upstate. I have a friend who lives in Orange County like 45 minutes from the city and he thinks that he lives upstate. But when I go to visit I say that I'm going downstate. Albany is Upstate. Kirsten's seat was definitely upstate as it streched through Warren and Washington counties (included Saratoga and Lake George) and if I'm not mistaken it went all the way up 87 which includes Potsdam and Plattsburgh (but don't quote me on that). The point is that Governor Paterson needed someone from at least 100 miles north of Manhattan to make them feel...well...included. Every other high powered position in the state is held by someone from downstate (Paterson, Schumer, the speaker, the majority leader). Upstate is often forgotten because so much of the revenue from the state comes from Manhattan. Albany is on the radar because it's the capital. 

Anyway, I'm getting a little 'inside baseball' here but I find this fascinating; not just politics but how incredibly different NY is from one end to the other and people outside of the state think it's just Saratoga and New York City. I once told the President (the current one) where I was from and he gave me a total "WTF" look. 

That ends my rant on NY state. 

Heather B.
Personal Blog: No Pasa Nada ( http://nopasanada.org )
BlogHer CE: Business, Career & Personal Finance ( http://blogher.org/topic/business-career-personal-... )

JeanLouise 5 pts

It appears that Gillibrand has a good history of constituent service, as well.  It seems like a great pick to me and I hope Gillibrand can retain the seat on 2010.

aftercancer 5 pts

As someone who grew up on Long Island, spent a summer working in Fishkill and lived in Potsdam for 8 years I am always curious what/where upstate is.  If you're in Manhattan upstate is Pougkeepsie, from New Paltz it's Albany, Albany sees it as Lake Placid. 

 Just my two cents. 

Kate

I blog at http://www.aftercancernowwhat.blogspot.com