Think Before You Pink
by GreenGirlyGirl

While October is National Vegetarian Month, it is better known as Breast Cancer Month. We all know the pink ribbon and these days it is hard to go to the shops without seeing something that has been pinkified.

While the pink ribbon campaign has raised millions, not all is kosher. An organisation called Think Before You Pink seeks to uncover those companies that are Pinkwashing. Pinkwashing is basically saying you are going to do one thing (help find a cure for breast cancer) while you actually do another (either raising very little money or actually producing products that might actually cause breast cancer).

Let me give you an example. This year in the US Yoplait is running a pink campaign where you send in a yogurt lid and 10 cents are donated to Breast Cancer. Hmmmm. It costs 39 cents to mail the lid?! You would need to eat 100 yogurts to give $10! Wouldn't it just be easier to donate $10 directly? Plus the yogurt contains dairy product from cows that have been given rBGH (a growth hormone) which may be linked to increased rates of cancer (according to Think Before You Pink, Wal-mart and Starbucks are already making their dairy products rBGH free).
Perhaps the biggest concern for Think Before You Pink though is the cosmetics companies. True, they are amongst the largest fundraisers. But they are very profitable (Estee Lauder sales are over $8 billion; its donation to Pink Ribbon campaign in the US - on the back of selling product - was $500,000). Estee Lauder, as well as every other major cosmetic company, has refused to sign the Compact for Safe Cosmetics. According to the Environmental Working Group in the US only 11% of the 10,500 ingredients in beauty products have been tested. Even of those tested there are those ingredients that have been linked to increased risk for cancer. For example, paraben, a very common ingredient in beauty products, is estrogenetic. The greater our exposure to estrogen, the higher the risk of breast cancer. The cosmetic industry would say that they are present in very small quantities in each product, but it is the sum of all the stuff we put on us that matters.

Pink can also be not very green. Think about Mt. Franklin (owned by Coca Cola) water here in Australia and their pink cap promotion. First, plastic can leach dioxin (particularly if you leave your bottled water in the sun and then drink it) which has been linked to increased rates of breast cancer. Add to that the waste of plastic bottles (see Plastic Water Bottles or Jimmy Choos? ) and it is not very pink or green.
Perhaps the best answer is not to buy the pink stuff but to raise money the old fashioned way and write out a check to the National Breast Cancer Foundation. xxx
Photo credit: Jenny Yoo Bridal Collections.Source: Think Before You Pink website. Gorgeously Green. Not Just A Pretty Face. The Ugly Side of the Beauty Industry

Comments

 

speaking about pink and mammograms

Speaking of pink, I design my for-free-download PDF magazine, Gorgeous Inspirations, in pink for its Oct - Dec 08 issue, though the theme is about fun. But it's the Breast Cancer Awareness Month, anyway :) (uh-oh... do you think this is exaggerating or something...?)

Oh btw, talking about this reminds me of mammograms. Mammogram is PRICEY in my country, Indonesia. What about in your country?

Diar Adhihafsari, www.gorgeousinspirations.com

 

Mammograms cost, yes, and genetic counseling
is $$$$$

Hi Diar,

I've got health insurance now, at 41, but I can confirm that I delayed getting a mammogram at 35 because of how much it would have cost me.

Now I wish I had spent the money, because it turns out breast cancer runs in my family and one family member just spent a shocking $3k on genetic counseling. It wasn't covered by anyone, it's an opt-in she had to pay for herself.

I agree with you -- there is a definite crass opportunism to some of the Pinkification of October. At the same time, I need to share that as I sit here, I'm wearing a pink plastic bracelet in honor of my family member, which my son brought home from a school fundraiser. I'm sure this bracelet's made of something potentially toxic but, truth be told, I love it because it reminds me of what she's struggling with every second -- the discomfort, the fear, the embarrassment, the hope. And it helps me feel a part of what she's going through. And, to your point, I will probably be writing checks to this cause for a looooong time... :)

All good food for thought...thanks.

Lisa Stone
BlogHer Co-founder
Surfette

BlogHer is non-partisan but our bloggers aren't! Follow our coverage of Politics & News.

 

Wearing my pink ribbon as I write

Green Girly Girl www.littlegreenstilettos.blogspot.com

Dear Diar and Lisa,

I am very sorry to hear about your family member... I am sitting here wearing my pink ribbon pin to support women like her. I completely agree that we need to keep supporting the cause and I love the ribbons and braclets because the money goes directly to research and at the same time increases awareness...it is unfortunate that a few companies try to exploit the success of the program.

In Australia (where I am from), I feel very lucky as we have free mammograms for any woman over 45 (and for those at high risk under 45). I just received the all clear last week.  Wouldn't it be a great world if women had that access everywhere?

Cheers,

Patty 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Re-watching Christina

Re-watching Christina Applegate's interview with GMA- Christina is starting a fondation that will provide testing for women who are high risk, family history, for Breast Cancer.

 

~Susan

http://lilmomthatcould.com/

 

Thanks for the Tip

Hi...Thanks for letting me know about this foundation. Will keep an eye out for it.

 Patty

 

Very Happy!

Thanks for sending through your link...a beautiful magazine and very inspiring. 

 Pattyxxx

Green Girly Girl www.littlegreenstilettos.blogspot.com

 

Very Insightful

I have always had a problem with organisations that tell you to buy something that costs $5 but will only donate 5 cents of that. The products may have been expensive to produce but they surely can do better than less than 10% of the cost of the product. It is very easy to get caught up in the glamour of 'charity' purchases and I appreciate you bringing up the issue and citing the Yoplait example.

 

Thanks!

Green Girly Girl www.littlegreenstilettos.blogspot.com

 

Thanks for your comment! I am new to Blogher and am enjoying meeting all these great women.

Cheers,

Patty 

 

 

was it for me? :)

Dear GreenGirlyGirl,

Owh, you are SO LUCKY to live in a country that understands women's needs for mammograms. While it's kind of ironic in my country that the Health Minister always encourages women, especially in October, to get mammograms as early as possible, but the cost isn't modified to fit all economic levels.

Btw, when you said "Thanks for sending through your link...a beautiful magazine and very inspiring.", I wonder if that was referred to my PDF magazine I mentioned earlier, Gorgeous Inspirations :) (because if yes, I'd definitely want to get your permission to include the said comment on my blog and upcoming issues of my magazine). Thanks :)

Oh, and I'm preparing a green issue for my quarterly magazine (for the Apr-Jun 09 issue, to be exact). Maybe you're interested to write for the said issue, please let me know, thank you :)

Diar Adhihafsari, www.gorgeousinspirations.com

 

It was for you!

Hi...It was for you! Would love for you to include the comment on your upcoming blog....the more who know the better.

Let me know what you had in mind for your magazine and I am sure I could contribute something.

Pattyxxx