Bio
I am a twenty-five year old who lives in Boston, MA. I graduated in 2007 from The College of Wooster with a BA in English. Since then, I've spent my...
 
ADD YOUR NAME!
Sign the Own Your Beauty statement of belief.
Share a picture with Own Your Beauty!
THE HOSTS OF
OWN YOUR BEAUTY
12 TIPS
80s icon Molly Ringwald shares her favorite tips on living agelessly with BlogHer.
 
 
 

Most Popular

Thoughts on Being A "Pretty Fat Girl"

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 42
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Own Your Beauty is a groundbreaking, year-long movement bringing women together to change the conversation about what beauty means. Our mission: to encourage and remind grown women that it is never too late to learn to love one's self and influence the lives of those around us - our mothers, friends, children, neighbors. We can shift our minds and hearts and change the path we follow in the pursuit of authentic beauty.

So the other day I was having a conversation with someone about their body image an feelings of self worth –- feel free to imagine me doing this all day everyday, as that is basically accurate.

The conversation went kind of like this:

“I just feel bad about myself all the time. I am fat and ugly and no one wants to date me. I’m getting to the point where I just don’t know what to do.” [Her]

“I know EXACTLY what you mean, I used to feel like that every single day and it led me to make all manner of terrible decisions because I was constantly on the prowl for external validation to fill the deep dark hole of my self loathing.” [Me]

“No –- You don’t understand, because you’ve always at least been beautiful.” [Her, emphasis mine]

Huh. Now, this isn’t the first time that this has happened to me. The “but you’ve got such a pretty face” write-off. As if my face discounts the size of my body, or my life-long struggle with weight. As if we are existing in some sort of hierarchy of fatness, where pretty faces sit at the top and everyone else has more of a right to hate their bodies than, let's say, I do.

Is there a hierarchy of fatness?

Now, as I’ve mentioned, many, many times before -– actually body size has little to no impact on your mental processes of self-worth and body image. The insidious and dangerous thing about having a negative self image is that it can happen to ANYONE and is very rarely connected with actual size. Instead, size is relative. Someone could very likely feel just as badly about their body at a size two as I have at a size eighteen -– and the emotional patterns are the same.

It is almost unbelievable. But it’s true.

And those feelings of diminished self-worth, the ones that dig down really deep and get caught up around your heart, threatening to take up permanent residence there if you don’t actively seek to starve them out -– those feelings can happen to anyone. Those feeling are the ones that will get you. They are the ones that breed in shame and secrecy and will bring down even the bravest person, should they be allowed any sort of acknowledgement or authority.

Sometimes, you have to dig down deep to scratch away at the layers and layers of hurt that you have accumulated throughout your life. And sometimes, even when you think you are entirely done eradicating all of the built up layers of shame and trauma, something will trigger you and you will realize just how much work is left to do.

Now, when I was younger. And fatter. And entirely consumed with self-loathing, people would frequently address me in a pitying tone about my looks, say, but you have such a pretty face, and meaning, it’s too bad you are wasting all of that beauty in that fat body.So needless to say, this conversation was a bit of a gut-puncher for me. I relived, in typical dizzying flashback panic attack format, a slide show of mean-spirited people who had said that to me during my life.

And what I wanted to say was [please insert 14-year-old whine] -– but I was still FAT! No one wanted to be my BOYFRIEND (or girlfriend or WHATEVER)! No one wanted to even be associated with me because I was so repulsive! I hated my body JUST AS MUCH AS YOU DO NOW.

But what I did say is -– the actual mass of your body or your proximity to ideal beauty standards or your fashion sense or anything else –- pales in comparison to how you view yourself. When I felt ugly, I was ugly, because I allowed myself to live under the thundercloud of my self doubt and anxiety. Once I decided [because, yes, it was a choice] to be beautiful –- I started to be more appealing to people, and NOT because my physical looks had changed, but because my attitude about myself had changed.

You need an example, don’t you?

  • 42
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
bibliophile21 10 pts

Ah this is beautiful! A few years ago I was having issues with my weight where I couldn't maintain any, and no one but my mom cared because obviously skinny people can't have weight problems. Now I'm in a better place in my life and going the other direction- I'm not"fat" but I am overweight and I know I'm not being healthy and treating my body like I should. I think people are trying to be nice when saying that I shouldn't worry about it...but I know if I don't do something now then it will get to a point where I *am* both physically and medically disturbing. I know that when I make an effort to exercise and treat myself properly I feel better, and I totally agree that it makes me look better as well. Love how you phrased it and acknowledge the hierarchy of fatness.

mylife-in-stories.blogspot.com 5 pts

Thank you so much for your post. It was wonderful. I am a larger person but I have definitely noticed that attitude and feeling good about who you are makes all the difference. Just wish I had learned it at a much younger age. Wonderful post.
Donna @ http://mylife-in-stories.blogspot.com

Noelle Aloud 5 pts

You hit the nail on the head with the "hierarchy of fatness."
......................................

Noelle is the broad behind Baby in Broad ( http://babyinbroad.blogspot.com ).

HarrietM 5 pts

"You'd be so pretty, too, if it weren't for all those wrinkles."

"I can always diet, but you? Even a face lift isn't going to help that mess."

Since I am becoming old myself, I can guarantee that these comments will *smite* the old biddy who didn't have enough manners to keep her meanness to herself.

Of course I have never been able to zing anyone who wasn't an active friend. My own brand of self-loathing won't let me return their "honesty" with some of my own.

But I am working on that!

;-)

desperatelyseekingcoffee 5 pts

You know what, I'm five foot two and 216, and celebrating a recent 10 pound weight loss. It's all about perspective. I've weighed 125 and I've weighed 230.

But honest to goodness it's been a hard road to be confident in my own skin. I feel better about myself right now than I did when I weighed 125 so many years ago. (Plus, I'm a big Italian/Irish girl. I looked sick as hell at 125)

I DO feel bad about my weight. So I'm doing something about it, eating right and exercising.

I think body image, for me at least, is something that's gotten easier as I've gotten older. An insecure 18 is worlds away from a sassy 25 :D

And you're beautiful by the way :D

P.S. Yes there's a hierarchy, but there's systems like that set up everywhere and in everything. Screw everyone else and do what makes YOU happy

<3 The Mad Housewife

The Mad Housewife and Mad Merlot Mama blog at Desperately Seeking Coffee @ http://javainmyveins.blogspot.com/

deedeesew 5 pts

I am 49 yrs. old and I've been overweight most of my adult life. I always was on a diet and I saw myself the same as you did. I finally decided that I wasn't gonna lose the weight and I needed to be happy with who I am.

I started by changing my hair color from brown to blonde and you wouldn't believe all the positive feedback that I received. I also went and bought me some new better fitting clothes. I took my 20 something year old daughter and she was a big help. She too is a large girl and dresses in the lastest clothing. I bought jeans that have an elastic waist, but they look just like regular jeans and they fit great. I bought some lighter tops and free flowing thinner sweaters to go over the tops. Don't forget the bling. I bought some large earrings and got some pretty watches(they don't cost alot)and lots of pretty shoes, too. I also bought me a couple of purses that are in the bronze colors and that's my new outfits.

So that's what I've done and I get compliments every day. I love the compliments, don't you?

Don't be afraid of making some changes. Make them and be happy.

Debbie

IWantThursdays 6 pts

You are so right in that it is a choice to be beautiful. Sometimes, some days that choice is a hard one. I felt that way yesterday.

I'm really short; 4'9" to be exact. I try to be confident about it, but sometimes I really struggle with that. People take me much less seriously because only my nose and eyes are above their counter top. At first glance, I can look like a child. I work in a professional industry and I am very lucky that people get to know me and my skills over the phone and email first because I have been brushed off very easily because of my height.

Not that you need my affirmation, but you are pretty just as you are.

tara

More of me at: http://iwantthursdays.blogspot.com

Rachel Vdolek 11 pts

 IWantThursdays I'm at 5'2" and people think I'm still in jr. high. I have already graduated with a 4 yr degree and have been working for a few years as a professional, yet when people first meet me, they are so quick to judge me as 15 or 16. It's really hard to get over that first impression, yet once people get to know me, they realize mentally I'm closer to 30.

 

I try to be ok with it, but sometimes people don't take me seriously or think I'm some naive 16 year old and it really gets to me. Glad to hear that I'm not the only one out there with this issue!

bliss565 5 pts

I literally got a small tear in my eye reading this because this is EXACTLY how I have felt over the last few years. I was skinny all my life and then all of a sudden, in the span of about 2 years, I gained 40 lbs. I have no idea why I had such rapid weight gain. I still eat the same way I did before. The only difference is I went from being a waitress to having a desk job so I do not move around as much but I didn’t' think it would make such a huge impact on my weight. Anyway, I have been really down on myself and have had a terrible self image. My husband always tells me how beautiful I am and that he thinks I'm just as sexy as the day we met, which helps. Your post has such a good perspective to it that it really did make me feel better. I write for a health blog that is focused on making people "feel better". I wonder if I could have your permission to repost this on the dimmi blog (the blog I write for). Here is a link if you want to check it out: http://blog.dimmi.com/ I really think this would be inspirational to our readers. Thanks again for the great post!

Sweetbearies 6 pts

I really wish people would stop making others feel less than about their looks. I actually wrote an article about this awhile back because I am tired of people feeling they must look a certain way to have approval, or love. You must love yourself first, and flout the silly rules people have about how they think you should look. Good article, good points!

amydpp 5 pts

Seriously you are, and all I've always seen is the beautiful. I love that photo of you. The last one, of course.

Christina Linnell 5 pts

I could not agree with you more! I have always been on the heavier side but felt really good about myself.
It is an image thing. Yes, I always knew I was overweight but I didn't stop loving myself or life because of it.
I am on a weight loss track right now and love myself even more. Why? Because God created me and that is totally cool.

Christina ( http://www.aclosetwriter.com )

Nordette Adams 16 pts

The "such a pretty face" comment haunted me in my youth. Mostly people said it in reference to my weight, but I also got from a white woman one day, "You're pretty for a black girl."

Good post, and somewhat related to it are comments Raven Symone's made ( http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/01/06/ravensymone-shows-off-dra_n_805280.html ) about her recent weight loss. And she's also someone about whom people have made the "such a pretty face" comment.

Either way she has to deal with gawkers, but suggests when she was fat, at least people were looking at her, the person, and not an object.
"Actually, now I wear bigger clothes because I don't like the way people stare at me," she told People. "I liked it before. Now, you're just looking at me for the wrong reasons. Before, you were actually looking at me for a real reason."

In early 2009 Raven gave another interview to People and talked about how she handles criticism of her body.

"People come up to me and have certain words for me, but you know what I do? I say, 'I'm healthy, I exercise, I believe in myself, and I think I'm beautiful,'" she said. She reportedly lost 35 pounds later that year.
So, left still feeling very self-conscious, and that makes it hard to relax and be yourself. Society puts so much pressure on women about how they look that at either end we may experience discomfort.

Raven Symone, some people forget, is the little girl who was introduced to America on the Cosby Show.
Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile/Nordette ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

outlawserenade 13 pts

The "but you have a pretty face!" comment hit really, really close to home - like, somewhere by the patio and the opened front door of the home that is my relationship with my body. And the queries of: "why aren't you married yet?"

Thanks for letting me know that I'm not alone.

JennaHatfield 322 pts

"And it’s really not about having a pretty face. It’s about having a compassionate and loving heart and teaching yourself to accept your perceived flaws and make the absolute best out of every moment."

Mmm, yes. And loving yourself even when you make mistakes. Or have a bad hair day. And so on.

Lovely post. Lovely you.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

onblank 5 pts

Wonderful and thought-provoking article, Marzipan. And what a beautiful photo!

I grew up in a horrible household where we never had enough to eat. As such, I grew a slight frame and have always had trouble with blood sugar.

From adolescence until the last 3 years, I weighed 108 lbs. No matter what I did or ate. I'd gorge myself hoping to see some results. 108. Clothes never fit. Nothing I wore made me feel like a grown woman. Victoria's Secret was a whole store of retail shame. I hated my body as much as anybody that weighed too much. I'd wear baggy clothes to hide my pointy bones. I'd rise before my husband to put on makeup and curl my hair because if I didn't, I was convinced all strangers would see was my 12-year old boy's body and make some awful remark about how anorexia kills (which they did). And that was something that wasn't made any better 4 years ago by the unsolicited comment by a male co-worker, "You're too skinny to have kids!"

Holy shit. What??

Well, over the last three years, I am ecstatic about gaining a healthy twenty pounds. I feel good. I look good. I'm not always on the verge of a low-blood sugar meltdown. I can eat foods that are balanced nutritionally, instead of whatever I can get my hands on.

And yet, just this last Thanksgiving I heard a young (under 10) relative parrot what she must have heard from her parents, "Oh, I know why you don't have kids. You're too skinny to have babies." WOW. Really? Is that what people think when they look at me? Still?

I hate to hear it when women think that being skinny will fix all of their negative self-esteem issues. Being skinny has its own issues. "Skinny" or "fat," if you don't work on loving yourself, a careless comment like "you're too skinny to have kids" or "but you have such a pretty face" is ego cancer. I like to think of myself as relatively empowered and more and more sure of who I am, but I tell you what, when it's just me and the dressing room mirror, guess what phrase I still have to work to muffle:

"You're too skinny to have kids."

Solidarity.

--Kristina

www.OnBlank.com ( http://www.OnBlank.com )

mmarzipan 5 pts

thank you Bon!! How is that little baby? Miss you guys x five million. xoxooxox

Al_Pal 26 pts

Really enjoyed this. I was a chubby kid, gained quite a bit in college [thank you, depo-provera, eating & drinking my feelings, and a bf who wasn't worthy], and evened-out afterwards. Now, I'm 5'4", size 12[ish], and quite happy with how gorgeous I am. (Might need to get a pic up, y/n? Heh.)
I'm lucky, I never thought I was less-than, even when I was a lot heavier, but I've *definitely* heard the "Oh she has such a pretty face" [with the implied, why's she wasting it on a fat body?" about myself, and about friends and family members.

I'm all about complimenting people, getting them to feel better about themselves--& I hear a lot of, "Oh, you're so nice"...well yeah, I *am* nice, but I'm not making this stuff up, it's true! :P

Part of my self-confidence is that I was consistently loved & told so by my parents, I'm guessing--& that I was smart & beautiful, too. Another part, I'll wager, is that I *do* fit a standard of beauty--I figure I'm kind of like, "average American woman-sized Malibu Barbie". Green eyes, tan-ish, blonde-ish, and my facial features are WAY similar to yours--high forehead, happy cheek-apples, nicely-formed nose, etc etc. (I do feel like I'm vain going on and on, AND I totally recognize that there are SO many different, gorgeous, unique standards of beauty out there--but I also recognize that my Western Euro-mutt heritage puts me into a widely-recognized model of beauty. Also, my confidence in HS was of the, "well I know I'm beautiful, but I don't expect the world to agree" variety.
Now that I'm older, and have had some people fawn over me, though? I totally do expect the world to agree. & I know that confidence seriously adds to my beauty!
tl;dr--Thank You for being you, and sharing yourself here!

sexlove atmosphere 5 pts

first of all, you are gorgeous.
second, when I read this I almost cried. I remember having a battle like this with myself a while ago. Now I cannot say that I was ever overweight but when I was younger I felt like I was fat and gross and when I look at photos of myself I'm wearing baggy clothes and too much makeup and I NEVER smiled.
I remember feeling the exact way you described, only you described it better. thank you so much for writing this article, and putting in there that ALL girls feel this and it hardly has anything to do with your actual weight.
again, THANK YOU SO MUCH.

@hilaryfleming 5 pts

You are such a wonderful writer. This is my first time on Blogher and your post was the first I've read. You are fantastic. So many great points and touching the way you presented the issue. You should write a book (maybe you have...) I think, regardless of weight, most women go through this awful pain of self loathing and you have so many great points on combating the issue. It really is about being comfortable in your own skin, and loving yourself, isn't it? Not that that is easy to do. I just turned 30, and it's so painful to think of the masochistic things I did (unknowingly) in my early 20's because I wasn't sure if I deserved happiness. There really is light at the end of the tunnel. Thanks again! www.healthgirltv.com ( http://www.healthgirltv.com )

bonmom 5 pts

I actually can sort of realate...my baby is now 5 months old and people say to me all of the time..."You look great! for just having have had a baby." I hate when people feel the need to throw that in at the end!

Love your blog (and you!!)

sproutingsherbet 5 pts

indeed!
What a wonderfully descriptive way to phrase it!

KristiMaristi 5 pts

<3, pretty lady. Xo

KristiMaristi

www.kristimaristi.com

Dana Udall-Weiner 5 pts

What a great post! Can totally relate to the "thundercloud of my self doubt and anxiety." I've been there. And you're right that getting out from the cloud has nothing to do with changing your body size or shape. I'm so glad you've written this, especially as women around the world vow to begin a 2011 diet, and hope to find self-esteem and happiness in the process. In my experience, it's only through accepting what is that happiness comes.

justlinda 24 pts

All I ever heard was "You're fat but you're so pretty and smart and capable and strong and wonderful and gracious and funny and SUCH a great writer and..." (I could go on and on and on...)

But enough about what I said to myself....

I have a friend who is just beautiful. Her smile, her skin, the sparkle in her eyes. She always has been. She has also always carried extra weight. I used to get so mad when people would say "You'd be SO pretty if you lost a few pounds." to her. I was like "Hey, listen. Those two things are mutually exclusive." She IS so pretty. Period. Whether or not she loses a few pounds.

I don't know why there needs to be a hierarchy, or why people need to tie one thing to the other. I don't even know why I can have a flood of confidence that gets wiped out by a drought of doubt over my weight. (Drought of doubt - did you see that? Great writer, I tell ya.)

Good article!

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

alexandraRS 23 pts

Fat or thin?

Busty or Flat?

Pretty or Ugly?

It's what people say to us.

We are who we are.

I was told all through gradeschool, and highschool, by my mother, that I needed to gain weight and that no man would be interested in a bone.

Seriously. So I'd stuff myself till I felt nauseous. And then start again.

The weight never came on.

That's just me.

We are who we are.

And you are beautiful.

mmarzipan 5 pts

Oh, I know this struggle too well. I wrote a post about where to start this morning over at Medicinal Marzipan ( http://www.medicinalmarzipan.com ), because some of my readers were asking about what the absolute FIRST step was. I believe that the first step in just about anything is just to agree to TRY to believe that you are worth working on it. These types of behaviors/thoughts/feels are so deeply ingrained in how with think about ourselves, that changing them is not an easy process - it can be slow and painful, and it is so important to be sweet to yourself through it. Good luck Mel! xox

mmarzipan 5 pts

that your mother would say that - hilarious!! I simply could not keep my life on hold a single second longer.. It was like I held my breath for the first 23 years of my life, closing my eyes, and crossing my fingers, wishing my life would get better.

now, I simply don't have the time ;)

thanks for your comment. xoxox

mmarzipan 5 pts

I love this. My sister is really tall, much, much taller than I am - nearly 6 ft, and I was always totally astonished by her courage and bravery. We are similar in size, and she would confidently strut around in HUGE heels - it is amazing. She was a total glamazon. I find that so unbelievably inspiring!

@digitaldiva 5 pts

I can totally relate. There does seem to be a bit of a hierarchy. BUT pain really is relative and really nobody should judge anyone else's pain because you can't actually 'know' how they feel. There's always going to be someone that seems to have it better in life.

I mean, I've lived my entire life hearing about how gorgeous I'd be if I just dropped the weight. And I'd have to agree. So much so that I've had lap band surgery to help me win the battle I've been fighting for 30 years (see www.digitaldivablog.com ( http://www.digitaldivablog.com )).

That being said, although I've been fat my whole life, I've never actually hated myself or my body. I've always lived my life full of personality and popularity surrounded by lots of people that loved me.I've definitely not had as many boyfriends as I would have liked and that's always been a frustration for me but I believe I've had a pretty fun filled life anyway.

I completely agree that if you're a positive person with a great heart, it won't matter how fat you are. However, I would also argue that your attractiveness plays a part in society so in a way, the fact that you've always been pretty (totally agree with that!) has helped you in some ways. You are at an advantage because of it. As I have been. The important thing is to not let your weight define you and be an obstacle.

But it's hard when (usually) some old woman will comment on what a big girl I am with such a pretty face. It hurts, it's not cool. They wouldn't like it if I judged their appearance in any way. And even if I did come back with something equally as painful it wouldn't stop the hurt.

.

RockStarMel 5 pts

If you'd just lose 15 lbs, you'd be BEAUTIFUL!!!!

If I had a dime for the number of times I heard my mother say that when I was a teen, I'd have graduated from college debt-free.

If you ask her today, she'll deny ever having said something so cruel, but then she'll turn around and reminds me that men are visually stimulated and that if I want to settle down with one, I need to do something about my weight.

At 37, I can no longer blame her for my low self-worth and I could drive myself nuts pondering the what-ifs had she not been so cruel, but the fact is that her own self-worth was (is?) so damaged that she simply didn't know better. She thought she would save me from a lifetime of the pain she's suffered as a fat woman.

So then the question becomes, how do I break the cycle? As a mother (and a single one at that), how do I ensure that my son grows up with not only a healthy self image for himself, but with a healthy idea of what makes someone beautiful?

I owe it to myself to get over my self-worth, dysmorphia and image hangups, but it's more important than ever that I get over them so that he has a GOOD example, because I'm a firm believer that our children learn more from the behaviors that we MODEL than the behaviors we instruct.

Thank you, MM (and commentators)for the food for thought, the "me too" stories and the love.

amberpagewrites 5 pts

I know that in my head. If only I could make my heart believe it 100% - instead of just 50% - I'd be a happy woman, indeed.

cchinsethagid 5 pts

I got the same thing as Chris about being tall. Especially from my sister who is one foot shorter than me. She admitted that when she was thinner, it was so much easier to be pretty, but now that she has put on a lot of weight in the last ten years, she would prefer to be taller because she feels it would make her look better. (and she gorgeous!) Sigh.

Personal perception is really tricky.

Good luck women!! And good luck women in training; I hope life hands your better tools for dealing with self worth than we were handed. Albeit, I don't think it's going to be easier given how society portrays "beauty" in the media.

Grace@Haven 8 pts

You did a great job expressing what was on your heart. And I agree with you about the pictures---the you in the second picture looks so much more alive and happy.

ladyestrogen 5 pts

Haha.. I laughed at the similarities!!
I've actually used that in some stories I written: You've got such a pretty face - BARF.
LOL.

You look great, btw!

adventuresinestrogen.blogspot.com ( http://adventuresinestrogen.blogspot.com/ )

blissparty 5 pts

Love your blog, MM. My whole life- have gotten that quote from total strangers, family and friends.

"you're so pretty, but you're so fat"

My Mom came up with a come back when I told her once how many times I have heard that statement. (It does not even phase me. It hurt my sweet Mom's feelings big time.)

She said, well you should just say "how come you're so skinny, but you're still ugly." HA HA. Go Mom.

I wish ALL WOMEN would just SEIZE THE DAY and stop worrying about what other people think. All that matters is what we think about ourselves. If we love ourselves, then we can be loved.

So many women are waiting to lost that last 10 lbs.... I have one friend who's been putting a lot of her life on hold for the better part of 15 years trying to do all of those fun things on her list once she loses those last 10 lbs. It's just nuts.

Confidence is beautiful. Confidence is sexy. I have learned to ignore the haters and it makes me giggle at how rude they are being and have no idea. Then, I sort of feel sad for them. What a sad sad existence that you could FEEL that way and then verbalize it. It makes me think they are filled with self hatred.

Keep on rocking in the free world, MM. You are stunning by anyone's standards and even better, imagine how many women and girls you are helping with this wonderful blog.

Sex Expert, Pleasure Coach Chrystal Bougon http://www.BlissConnection.com is our tasteful online romance store where we always feature better toys for better sex Tune into our Award Winning Radio show at http://www.Bliss-Radio.com every Wednesday mor

Rita Arens 253 pts

Rita Arens authors Surrender Dorothy ( http://bit.ly/Qp0sS ) and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

CookTheStory 16 pts

I hear you! My version of the fat hierarchy had everything to do with height. I am very tall for a woman (6 feet barefoot).

When I express that I am feeling bad about my weight, people say, "Oh, but you're so tall! You hide it better. It's much harder if you're short." That made me feel as though my feelings weren't as worthy as those of a short fat person.

There was also always this underlying, "If only you were slimmer because you're so tall...you would be like a model!" thing that never felt honest. It felt like a weird consolation prize (if you had been born with a smaller frame and if you could keep the weight off, maybe you could have been a model. How weird is that?).

When I was younger, people made a big deal about my height as though it was this wonderful thing. Instead, I was taller than all the boys, nobody wanted to date me, and when I was overweight, I felt HUGE in EVERY DIRECTION.

Nowadays, I know I'm feeling good about myself if I slip into a pair of high heels before heading out the door. Day after day of flats is a warning sign....

Thanks for this post. The idea of such a hierarchy is very intriguing.

Chris @ Cook the Story ( http://cookthestory.wordpress.com )

Why Cook the Story ( http://www.cookthestory.wordpress.com )? Because stories that make you drool are better than those that don't!

LeeRadcliffe 5 pts

 CookTheStory

 Being overweight myself I've had the dreaded comment ; 'but your so pretty so thats ok' Its not 'ok' and doesn't make me feel good. I had a stepfather in my youth who wanted me to be a model, but, ' you would have to loose weight first'. And another relative who advised me frequently not to loose too much weight when I was dieting. You cant win!  However, I take great pleasure in the fact that no one has ever said 'you've got a lovely figure but your so ugly'!