Bio
Melanie Notkin is America’s premier Savvy Auntie, empowering the nearly 50% of American women who are not moms to celebrate all they do for the chi...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The Truth About Childless Women

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Nearly 46 percent of American women through age 44 are childless. That's up from 35 percent in 1976.

All reasons this generation of women are not bearing children at the same rate their mothers did are valid. Some are young women and just not at a point in their lives where motherhood is a choice they'd like to make. Some are 'fence-sitters,' not sure about whether or not they want children. Some are childfree by choice. Some are gay and need to take a potentially longer and less traditional route to motherhood. Some are suffering from biological infertility. And some, like me, are what I call "circumstantially infertile."


EmptyStroller
Image: ndanger via Flickr

I want children. I always have. At age 12 I purchased baby name books in preparation for the son and twin daughters I dreamed to be a mother to one day. I was a nanny, camp counselor and frequent babysitter. I would make up songs to sing to the kids I babysat that would become 'our thing' or visit the kids even when I wasn't officially working for their parents. By age 21, I was hosting teen tour girls in my home. Motherhood was always a path I felt ready for.

At age 23, when interviewing for my first job in New York City, I inquired about maternity benefits to make sure it was the right place for me. I focused my career in the non-profit sector, hoping it would give me more flexibility in dating, marriage and motherhood. I dated men with traditional family values, men who have since gone on to be fruitful and multiply.

By my mid-30s, now in my third job working for some of the best companies in the world to make enough money to live in New York City, I was still unmarried. I wasn't a mother. My work hours were longer, some days were spent overseas, and I was beginning to suffer the prejudice of being an 'older' woman. At 34, I was approached by a male friend who said he wanted to set me up with a friend our age but I was just 'too old.' At 35, a man said he would date me if I agreed to freeze my eggs. At age 36, another man told me he'd (reluctantly) date me since I could probably still 'pop one out.' Now we all know these are exceptional instances but they were nevertheless embedded in my psyche.

The grief over not only not being a mother, but now also suffering from feeling 'less than' because I just simply hadn't found love (or mutual love), was at times overwhelming. And as I saw couples younger than I getting sympathy for their biological infertility, I wondered why all I got were accusations of not doing enough, not trying hard enough. Trying too hard. Being too picky. Not being picky enough... And the hardest comment to defend: "You better hurry up!" (Hurry up and fall in love?)

While I have not suffered from biological infertility (as far as I know), I imagined my grief was at least as deep as couples trying to conceive as I didn't have a love who shared the grief. Heck, I often didn't even have a date to get closer to trying! Every month that passed, I grieved a loss. But I grieved alone. I have no husband (or male partner) to grieve with me. And lamenting my infertility to close friends who are parents or to family was never well-received.

Generation X is the first generation of women who have a choice to wait for love. Unlike many of our mothers, we earn enough to take care of ourselves (please don't call us 'career women' as careers are as much a choice for women as they are for men.) But still, the assumption is that all women who don't have children don't want children. There is a place between motherhood and choosing not to be a mother. And tens of millions of American women are there.

I'm 42 and still single and I have come to acknowledge the truth: it's very possible I won't have children of my own. I've grieved and have found my happiness on the other side. There are days that are still hard for me (Mother's Day, the day a friend announces her pregnancy, when I hear a guy won't date me because I'm too old to have kids, my birthdays, my monthly reminder...) but most days I'm happy. Very happy. I'm not in the wrong life

  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
CleverFTW 6 pts

BRAVO. Thank you so much for saying all this. I am 35 and deal with the same things. I am not even sure I want children but I hate the fact that not finding someone to share the journey with has robbed me (potentially ) of the choice. There really is no one to lament this to because a new BF won't care (or will run) and your paired up friends just assume you don"t want to. I know I know we could all be single moms but ya know what? That is just not the right option for me, either time or money-wise and emotionally I want a family not just a child. Thanks again. And "hurry up" Yeah that one KILLS me.

childlessstepmother 5 pts

Bravo!

www.childless.stepmother.blogspot.com

meg127 5 pts

Thank you for putting into words what many us are feeling! I was biologically unable to have kids and went through many infertility treatments. It still leaves a hole in my heart, but we have wonderful nieces and nephews that look to us for advice and that fills a large void.

And kudos to bellesouth for drawing attention to large demographic of people who don't classify themselves as a "mommy blogger". I would love to see companies target us more often; we have a lot of influence and buying power, too!

LibrarianLizy 5 pts

Thank you so much for this article. I, too, always wanted to be a mother. I've been babysitting since I was 14, I routinely take my cousins for long weekends, and spend as much time with my friends' children as possible.

I am circumstantially infertile at the rip old age of 25. I know that I'm still young and that it shouldn't be a big deal but it is. I am from Alabama where everyone marries and has children young. All but two of my close friends are married or engaged, and babies are starting to come around. I'm not dating nor do I have any prospects at the moment.

But I WILL be a mother, whether I get married or not. I have made a commitment to adopt or get pregnant when I turn 30. Yes, it will make it harder for me to get married and I know I'll be committing myself to a life full of hardship, but being a mother is more important than that to me.

I refuse to be circumstantially infertile, just because I'm not married or in a relationship. I want to be a mother and I will be.

But thank you for your words on how you don't have to be a mother to be motherly. That helps a lot as I try to get through these next 5 years.

NotJustAnotherJennifer 6 pts

There are so many women in this situation. I have friends who are, and I think it's horribly cruel for people to tell them they need to hurry up. Though it's difficult, you've made the right decision to embrace your life as it is and appreciate it. And who knows? With your ability to love others, maybe you will find a man who already has kids, or you'll end up adopting some.

NotJustAnotherJennifer is a wife and working mom of two beautiful girls, 3 (going on 13) and 1, which means she's sleep deprived but constantly kept on her toes! Most of those experiences are chronicled on her blog, http://midwestmomments.blogspot.com.

bellesouth 6 pts

I'm turning 34 this year and have gone through a lot of the same experiences. I had about a dozen friends on Facebook become pregnant at the same time. I expressed my happiness and continue to love and adore their children with all my heart. But there's that tiny inferiority complex that creeps out when I log into facebook and my news feed is filled with sonogram photos and darnedest-things kidquotes.

I blog for a living and am a part of several "mommy" blogging groups. For some reason, sponsors don't see unmarried, childless women as a key demographic. I think you've inspired me to blow off a little steam. Off to write now. :)

Denise 22 pts moderator

There is certainly a difference and I appreciate all stories by women - whether they are childless but want them or childfree because they choose not to have them.

We need messages and stories about all women so that these misconceptions are gone, once and for all.

~Denise
BlogHer Community Manager
Life. Flow. Fluctuate.

kpeterson32 5 pts

I'm 34 and have never been married. Most of my friends are married and either have children already or are in various stages of trying.

It used to be hard. I used to feel like I was left out of this mystical having-a-family-of-my-own thing, but I don't anymore. I realize how lucky I am. I'm surrounded by amazing kids and I get to have all the benefits of being close to them without all the dirty diapers and the sleepless nights and the worrying as I hand over the car keys.

Life is really good.

Maegan Tintari 6 pts

I'm 35 and childless because for some reason, the husband and I just can't seem to create a life inside of me. I too have grieved and mostly feel like I'm on the other side of it but melt down for the exact same reasons you do ...Mother's Day, monthly period, etc. But my "infertility" is more accepted I suppose than yours because we've "tried and failed" but obviously, it's still the same emotional state. Though I have the added "am I a woman if I can't have kids" and feeling like my body has failed me emotions to boot. But I have friends in your exact position and they don't have the same forum to talk about it as I do because everyone assumes they've made their life choices instead of life just being life & sometimes it's not easy to find the right person to have kids with.

I bet you'll find it someday though, when you're least expecting it :)

BlogHer Style Editor Maegan Tintari {@loveMaegan ( http://twitter.com/#!/loveMaegan )} is a Fashion, Home & Lifestyle blogger from Los Angeles. Go to ...love Maegan ( http://www.lovemaegan.com ) to find out more!

SuzanneMW 5 pts

I'm truly glad that SavvyAuntie's efforts have brought more positive press about being childless. But to me, I have to admit that I think it perpetuates that stereotype of 'every woman without a child must be a woman who can't, for whatever reason, have one.'
Many, many women are childFREE by CHOICE, a point that seems missed. I don't seek out time to be around kids, I turn down all offers of babysitting, etc.
And you know what? That's okay, too. And that's the message so many people are still missing.

lauracarroll 5 pts

..to write a post on your candid and thoughtful article--saw it before it appeared here...

http://www.blogher.com/being-childless-childfull

Love term and your ideas on "child-full"!

Laura Carroll

Childfree author of Families of Two

blogging at La Vie Childfree http://lauracarroll.com ( http://lauracarroll.com/ )

Shannon LC Cate 6 pts

For years I wasn't a mother due to similar circumstances--compounded by being poor. Then I fell in love with a financially and emotionally stable person who wanted kids. So here I am.
But before that, I had many important relationships with women who were not my mother and one or two men who were not my father and I myself was a step-mother for a while.
Kids really do need people who aren't their parents to round out the adult influences in their lives. And I think kids need people who aren't even parents AT ALL, to really round them out. Because parents think like parents. Non-parents think like non-parents. It may be a subtle difference, because both may be excellent guardians and caregivers, but it's a key difference--especially for older children and young adults.
So good on you. You didn't fall short of anything, even if you aren't living Plan A. You are right in the bull's eye of a critical part of family life--whether biological family or chosen family.

Shannon writes about family at Peter's Cross Station ( http://peterscrossstation.wordpress.com/ ) and about writing at Muse of Fire. ( http://shannonlccate.com/ )

The Daily Snark 5 pts

I love this post. You eloquently put into words what I've been feeling.

I am also circumstantially infertile. I always wanted to have kids but I married a man who already had kids and was done. As much as I love my husband it's something I struggled with for a long time. I knew what I was giving up but I never expected the feel the amount of grief I went through. It was overwhelming.

I'm 41 now and adore my stepkids and the two granddaughters they've given us. It wasn't an easy road to happiness but I finally feel like I'm there.

laurapacker 5 pts

As one of the many women in this position (43, spent my 20s with a man who said he didn't know if he wanted kids, my 30s with someone who already had them and a vasectomy) I'm so grateful to find my feelings well articulated here. I always wanted children of my body. I have none. Instead I have stepkids who may have children of their own, friends' kids and others.
The most painful part for me, now, is my parent's grief that they are not grandparents.

TheFSFoodie 5 pts

Such a beautiful article. I was just chatting with a friend this past weekend about our turning 35 this year. She feels she's past the point now, on the downward slope. As we've all been harshly told, "Get on it before it dries up!" It just made my heart hurt.

I have babysat for years, still do because it is fun, and I remember long ago one of my "kids" saying, "You'd make the best mom. I wish you were mine. Actually, no I don't. I probably wouldn't like you as much if you were my mom." Silly but wise and true.

Like you, I have been mom-ish to so many in my life and I feel blessed to be able to offer up my love and then leave when there is a tired meltdown or a diaper to be changed. I also have a super cool aunt in my life and if I am lucky enough to be an "Aunt Linda" someday then I'm living a darn good life.

JChandler 6 pts

I can see your post touched a chord with many, including me.

The first half of my adult life was spent with someone who needed too much parenting to add another child. I had to grow up too; the timing was off. For many years now I have been in a marriage that would have supported children but infertility surfaced in my partner. He and I have learned to accept that children are not going to be a part of life and frankly being childless can look really good when you see some of what other parents struggle with. :)

I really appreciated your reminder to everyone that "You are maternal whether or not maternity ever comes." Beautifully written. Those of us that are childless still have much to offer the children of the world.
Thank you for your post.

rayvingraychel 5 pts

Thank you for such a beautiful, honest and hopeful article. I say hopeful, because it really shows that women, like yourself, whether they want children or not, can achieve a successful and fulfilling life either way.

Wonderfully written. One of the best posts I've read on BlogHer in a while. Thank you!

Read Rachel's Tel Avivian rambles, raves ( http://therayve.blogspot.com ) and rave reviews at: http://therayve.blogspot.com

ari_1965 5 pts

The title of this entry "The Truth About Childless Women" makes it seem as though the post is about ALL childless women - covering all the different reasons why women might be childless. Instead, the post only covers one scenario -- just one of the reasons why a woman might be childless.

I can't recommend the post because of the title. It should have been titled something like One Woman's Truth About Childlessness.

Kayoh 5 pts

What a beautiful article and thank you so much for not only sharing your story, but for being an inspiration. Your words and your work are definitely appreciated by this PANK!

Andrea

www.Kayoh190.com ( http://www.Kayoh190.com )

LifeOptimist 5 pts

Great article!

(And just FYI, your link to your site in the footnote has one too many v's in it and doesn't work unless it's corrected)

Kelly, @LifeOptimist, blogs about family life at http://onequartermama.blogspot.com

hobomama 5 pts

Thank you for speaking so compassionately for the many friends and relatives in my life who want to have kids but are circumstantially infertile. I know they are worried and grieving, but I hope they know how much it means to me to have them in my sons' lives. You don't have to be the biological mother to help parent.

Inja1148 5 pts

I don't know where you live, but recently a call went out here regarding a desperate need for Foster parents. I am not sure if the economy is causing this or not. But I think if someone has the yime, energy and space, it would be a rewarding thing to do for these kids.

Alexandra Bartologimignano 5 pts

Lots of great kids out there in the world looking for warm and wonderful parents... Adoption is another option. :)

plogan721 6 pts

I was like you at some point. it was between the ages of 20-29. I wasn't picky, I was just afraid of if a man would have patience with me. then it happened, I became biologically that way, and had to have a partial. I was made at my doctor for 5 years for not saving it, but the fibroid was way too big (at one point, I looked like I was 5 months pregnant. There are parts of my psyche that have not to this day excepted that I cannot have children. I am also financially infertile, meaning that I do not have the thousands of dollars needed to adopt.

I started my need to be a mother at age 12. I even because a preschool teacher.

So again thank you for the article.

Julie Marsh 5 pts

I was fortunate enough to have two savvy aunties (my mother's younger sisters) who played such an important role in my childhood. Your essay reminded me (tearfully, I'll admit!) how important they were to me, filling a role that my own mother could not. It's a whole different relationship - a complementary one - and I'm so lucky to have benefited from it!

Julie Marsh ( http://www.juliemarsh.net )