Bio
I'm the Family, Moms...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

US Census Bureau to Dads: You're No More than a Babysitter

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

The US Census Bureau has decided that fathers watching their children is “child care” but when moms watch their kids, it’s parenting. No, really. All of that “it’s not babysitting, it’s parenting” when daddy “watches” the kids has apparently been tossed out the window and set us back decades. And by us, I am not just referring to the women who are somehow deemed the “designated parent” when both parents are present in a household, but the men as well. Apparently they don’t matter.

I’d like the US Census Bureau genius who came up with this idea to show up at my house for a three-day period.

On a typical day in my household, I rise with my perennial 7:00am waking child. I get breakfast on the table, grab my cup of coffee and get to work. My husband then takes over, makes sure that teeth are brushed and gets the kids to school. After preschool, he makes lunch for our younger son and normally plays a game of Yahtzee! or whatever the four-year-old so desires. He reads a book. He answers a billion questions. He kisses boo-boos. He reminds our youngest son to let me work eight billion times. He helps with the tasks of reading, computer usage and coloring. He gets our other son from school and proceeds to break up the sibling arguments that begin as soon as they’re both in the door. He makes a healthy snack. He asks about days. He helps with homework. He chases them down the hallway like a big monster. He gives me a big hug when I finish my work day about an hour after our oldest son comes home, and then he helps me in the kitchen.

Of course, every third day, he goes to work for 24 hours as a professional firefighter, and I’m left to hold down the fort in his keenly felt absence.

But according to the US Census Bureau, I’m the “designated parent.” And he’s doing nothing more than providing temporary care.

Oh.

This Is Not Parenting

And here I thought we were finding a balance for what works for our family, both providing the parenting care that our children need in our own ways. I can’t chase them like a monster, but I can tickle them until they squeal so loudly glass breaks. I didn’t realize that I was the designated parent just because I have a vagina. I thought, as we are both present and equally awesome, that we were the designated parents. Plural. Together. A team. The two of us making sense of the parenting world -- which rarely makes sense as it is. If we’re not a team, I’m screwed and so are the kids, because I’m going to mess this up on my own.

I just don’t understand how vaginas make a parent and penises make a babysitter.

  • 20
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Rachel @ Rediscovering the Kitchen 5 pts

Very well written article. You are right, this is terrible, we need to move forward, not go back into the dark ages.

I am definitely the primary caregiver of our children, as my husband can be gone at any time of the day or night. However, the flip side is that sometimes he gets home early - and he looks after our daughter. We have agreed that when one of us is working, the other is working too, but that includes time with our daughter. He goes out and make money, I look after her. He comes home early and looks after her, I do housework that didn't get done yet. Then we enjoy the evenings off together when she goes to sleep at night.

 

He is NOT "babysitting" when he takes care of her. If he is, then I am "babysitting" all day with her. Why do we not value the role of parent more in this society?

krisandrobertadopt 6 pts

Well, I guess for some men, that's true, but for others, they're good fathers. You can't generalize like that. It gets attention, though!

msamost 5 pts

This sort of thing just gives my ex-husband the excuse he needs to continue behaving the way he does. Thank goodness he doesn't read....

photofrau 19 pts

I agree that fathers are as much a parent as mothers and that they are often given the short end of the stick when it comes to comparisons of the two. However I suppose I viewed this Census debacle in a different light. I mean, if father's are considered childcare providers and mothers are "just parenting" doesn't that imply the IRS should place more value on a father's time than a mom's and not less? Because hey, that's a tax writeoff. But if you're a mom and you are spending 20 hours a day watching your child (24 if you are cosleeping and night nursing endlessly and so not able to "hand off" to your partner) then all of that work is without value because..well, you're just a mom.

It cheeses me to no end.

JennaHatfield 297 pts

hausfrau I stated that in my post and actually tweeted it to both the US Census Bureau and the IRS. If we tried to claim my husband's "child care" on our taxes, we'd be audited in a heartbeat!

photofrau 19 pts

JennaHatfield Yes, totally. I didn't mean to imply otherwise I just meant I was just focused on something else when I read about it. :D I do totally agree that there needs to be two mental shifts... That dad is just as capable as mom and mom's time is just as valuable as dad's.

jacklynnfry 10 pts

My husband is much more than a babysitter. We very much co-parent our daughter. My husband would be very offended if someone said, "Oh so you have to babysit your kid today?" I think his response would be, "No, I'm fulfilling my dad role, just like every other day".

anneisanne 25 pts

The most ridiculous part of this issue has to be the idea of a "designated parent." WTF? It's nearly implying "real" parent. I understand that they're trying to find the most effective way of getting certain bits of information- i.e. how kids are cared for when parents are at work- but why don't they just ask THAT instead of "designating" a parent and a "babysitter" who's really the "other" parent?

JennaHatfield 297 pts

anneisanne You ask a pretty logical question. It's a shame that the Powers That Be can't look at it that simply. It would actually provide them with better information if they didn't delve into "designated" parenting.

Quizzical mama 10 pts

This is outrageous! Excellent response, Jenna! You're right; this is offensive, for men and for women. It really bothered me that the year when my husband and I split the time between ourselves writing and taking care of our daughter, everyone commented on how great they thought it was to see him with her whereas with me it was just assumed.

JennaHatfield 297 pts

Quizzical mama I have and will continue to correct people who comment on my husband "babysitting" the kids. It just boggles my mind. Cheers to your and your husband for finding what works for you!!

kjbreed 10 pts

This classification is insulting to the hard working dads out there. MY brother is a single dad, and a damn good one. Of course he isn't perfect and neither is his child but hes doing his best. In the military lifestyle I have come across dads who are the full time parent while the mom is deployed, is he just a professional babysitter?

rovingrose 13 pts

kjbreed

I can't believe I didn't think about military spouse dads (my husband just recently got out of the military)! We know several SAHDs who wouldn't appreciate this classification.

SinceMyDivorce 11 pts

This makes classification makes no sense....

Josette Plank 22 pts

I'm glad this is a topic that is being tackled more and more. No, my husband isn't babysitting for me when I'm at work any more than I'm babysitting for him. "Parent" isn't so much a verb (although there is a lot of verb to it) so much as it is a relationship. There's a lot more to it than just making sure a kid is fed and entertained until another grown-up takes over.

rovingrose 13 pts

I guess my first question is - What about the families with two dads? Is anyone the "parent"?

JennaHatfield 297 pts

rovingrose One of the blogs I linked asked about families with non-custodial parents and other makeups other than man, woman and children. These are good questions and prove that the US Census Bureau is completely out of touch with today's family.

kjbreed 10 pts

rovingrose That was one of my first questions as well!

Conversation from Twitter

FireMom
FireMom

LesbianDad I may have said a few things other than "bullhockey." But not in the piece. Ahem.