Bio
AV Flox is a Peruvian transplant living in Los Angeles. She is the editrix-in-command of Sex and the 405, a site that shows you what your newspaper w...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Vampire Fiction Is Popular Because Straight Women Secretly Want Gay Men? I Don't Think So.

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Last week, Stephen Marche, author of Esquire's A Thousand Words About Our Culture column, regaled us with his latest epiphany: “Vampires have overwhelmed pop culture because young straight women want to have sex with gay men.”

I'll be the first to say Marche makes a few good points. There is a correlation between desire and the vampire phenomenon, but it has little to do with sexual liberation and even less with a secret desire harbored by heterosexual women to hook up with gay men.

If you were a foreign species paging through the rubble of a post-Apocalyptic Earth to get a sense of our species at this particular time period, and stumbled on Marche's piece, you'd think we were all sexually aware and liberated. We aren't. There is still repression, there are still many shameful things: let us not forget the abstinence-only curricula, the gay-rights battle we're still waging, the fierce come-back of the born-again virgin and chastity oaths, the prominence of the XXX Church at porn conventions, Apple's refusal to even devote a section of the iTunes store for 18+ adult entertainment applications, the ghetto in which sex bloggers reside on the web, Australia's mandatory internet filtering system, the fact that science still doesn't understand female desire—do I need to go on?

We're not an orgy of wild, good times. We're not, as Marche claims, processing “a newfound acceptance of what so many once thought strange or abnormal.” There may be a sexual revolution underway, but the battles are still being waged and we're caught in the crossfire socially and emotionally. The conflict that is delineated by themes in contemporary vampire fiction is two-fold: as I elaborated above, we know there are many ways to enjoy sex but we are not all quite there yet, and neither is society—by a long-shot. Secondly, we have discovered the zipless fuck isn't exactly enough for everyone in terms of in-depth sexual exploration.

Oh, the zipless fuck, the purest thing there is, the great encounter of sex for the sake of sex, free of emotion, commitment, motives and a whole lot of information about the other person. Don't get me wrong—that was an important step in getting to where we are, and a modus operandi that continues to work for many. But the themes in vampire fiction point to a specific need for something more.

This “something more” involves a concept with which many people in BDSM (bondage discipline sadism and masochism) are already familiar—that of aftercare. I'll explain: BDSM experiences are intense, often pushing participants to the limit physically, emotionally and psychologically. Aftercare is the period following one such experience, during which all parties cool down and provide one another emotional reassurance and tenderness. The trend in vampire fiction highlights the importance of aftercare, but it goes further: it explicitly demands respect, devotion, and loyalty.

Let's go over everything vampires are and work our way back to that last point.

The vampires in our two most popular chronicles, Twilight and True Blood, are much older than their human counterparts. By having lived so much longer, they walk into sex with the level of experience that makes it comfortable for us to go to that place where our deepest desires hide. With them, we can go there, not the same way our husbands or boyfriends let us go there, when they agreed to try it out, blindfolded us—half-giggling—and tried to figure out how to tie us to the posts of our beds. Our vampires know the ropes with the certainty and comfort of someone who has been practicing shibari for a lifetime—and then some.

And yet despite having lived dozens of lifetimes before meeting our heroines—and enjoyed at least a million trysts during these—our vampires never go in with the jaded look of someone who's done it all and is simply waiting to be surprised. Our fantasy demands that they relish in it every time. And they do.

In Twilight, which Marche uses to make his point about women's apparent desire for gay men, the vampire Edward is repulsed by the human Bella only because he desires her so intently that he fears he may kill her. He can hardly kiss her because the experience is so transcendent, he can't entirely control himself. Sex is rampant among our contemporary version of vampires, yes; but despite how common it is, these vampires give themselves so wholly to it, they nearly lose themselves every time.

This is not a man who is panting over you, worrying about whether he is pleasing you or not,

  • 6
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
goddessdreams 5 pts

I think it is a mark of the  Western world view that any man who displays behavior associated with femaleness or femininity is gay. As women we tend to echo this sentiment when we list characteristics in men that we want or disdain, i.e. enjoying romance movies, shopping, deeply engaged conversation, and most especially that spiritual connection that is associated with what all women want.

These traits are not inherantly feminine. I try to remember that femininity is a social construct as is masculinity--powerful social constructs to be sure. I try to open my eyes to that fact I can choose to embrace the pieces of the constructs that apply to who I am at my core and let go of what does not make me...me. Men are as entitled to this level of self examination and awareness as women.

I think that many of these culture commentaries in the popular media vehicles like Esquire serve to uphold the heternormative discourse that plagues our ability to be who we are without attaching the expectations of a culture's definition of masculine and feminine.

I also agree that the desire to be known and embraced in totality is at the heart of what  drives the so-called "love affair" with vampires.

Don’t mind the destination, don’t mind the end. Learn from the past, but grab hold of now. Now is always evolving. ~Rumi

Nordette Adams 6 pts

When vampires drink your blood, in most vampire lore, they then know everything about you--they hold within them your memories, dreams, desires--it goes back to the biblical belief that "life is in the blood," a belief that I'm sure is older than the Bible considering drinking blood or even eating another human's flesh was associated with gaining the person's power and wisdom before the Bible came to be. And so, this desire for intense communion with another, even God, is the driver.

I think women want that spiritual connection with lovers, to know them and to be fully known. Going back to biblical allusions again, to have sex is described as not only becoming one with a person but also with "knowing" the person. (And Adam knew Eve his wife.)

The Esquire guy may be straight, but I don't think that's what's stopping him from getting this. I think he doesn't understand deeper human relations and he may also be so consumed with popular culture that he's ignoring the deeper themes, the archetypes that have remained in human literature since humans started storytelling.

This kind of transcendent love is the stuff of most of our love songs, love poetry, and many of our legends. The belief that "to love and be loved in return" is an enduring need may even be at the crux of our quest for the meaning of life. It is not something confined to the venue of romantic love but seeps into tales of all types of love. Perhaps it manifests so frequently in fictionalized forms because it's hard to come by this transcendent love and nearly unconditional loyalty in the real world.
Just listen to the story told in the song "Nature Boy."

So, I think you're on the mark here, AV, that Esquire man is off his game with the gay angle.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).

MLOKnitting 5 pts

As someone who reads a lot of adult vampire fiction - and read the Sookie books when they were first out - these vampires are in no way about gay men.  As a matter of fact, many of the most popular stories are about really rugged and dangerous vampire men.  I don't think this guy has clue one about what it is about.

My theory?  The dangerous guy theory.  All of us have had the dangerous guy fantasy from time to time.

MLO / Melissa

Books, Movies, Games, Ovarian Cancer, and Life in General at http://www.mloknitting.com/

Semper 5 pts

This is an AMAZING article! So well put and insightful even beyond its direct response to Marche. I'm not even into this whole vampire business, and I connected to everything you said. This is something that will stick with me for a while.

wineplz 5 pts

that author has NO clue about women at all.  He's comparing apples to bananas.

I think you summed it up best with "but that we desire someone with whom to go to the place where our deepest unexplored desires hide. We want someone who is not only accepting and able to undertake the exploration of these with us masterfully, but who becomes so invested in the moment that even if our desire is still new and frightening to us, he is not turned off by it or by us, but is, in every sense, consumed by it—and the act of being with us. So consumed, in fact, that he might lose all control."

I don't know a single woman, personally, who wouldn't want a little more courting, respect, and devotion from her man, and to be cherished and appreciated.  These things are evident in at least the Twilight book series (I've not watched True Blood), which explains their popularity.  This Marche twit could stand to actually READ the series--he might get some good tips on how to treat the next woman he dates (if he's married, I feel bad for his wife).

Megan Smith 5 pts

I'm with Melissa when she says it's about dangerous men, not gay men.  I'd also add tortured men.  What woman doesn't want to "save" a tortured vampire male whose immortality only increases his opportunities for loss and lonliness?

Give me brooding, dangerous and tortured vampires every time.  Yum.

Great post!

Megan
BlogHer Contributing Editor, TV/Online Video ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/megan-smith )

My Personal Entertainment Blog: Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

My Review Blog:  Meg's Rad Reviews
( http://www.megsradreviews.com )

Twitter:@MeganSmith ( http://twitter.com/MeganSmith/ )