Bio
Scattered Mom is a 40 something, west coast living, cookie baking, road tripping, key misplacing, perpetually lost blogger who can sniff out a Starbu...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

The Fight Against Child Abuse Takes More Than An Avatar

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

You may have seen this making it's rounds on Facebook recently:

Please Join the Fight against Child Abuse... Change your profile picture to a cartoon character from your childhood.. The Goal is to not see a human face on Facebook until Monday, December 6th.. please invite your friends to do the same...

At first, I ignored it as just another Facebook fad that will make it's rounds and then disappear. Facebook awareness campaigns have never been my thing. I managed for awhile, but then saw this tweet from @bumblebrie about a post @pigtailpals had written.

Right after that, was another tweet from someone that they changed their avatar under pressure from their friends, in a "There, are you happy?" kind of tone.

NEW YORK - NOVEMBER 25: The Smurf float passes by people watching from apartments and offices on Seventh Avenue, heading south to Times Square during the Macy's Thanksgiving Day parade November 25, 2010 in New York City. The 84th annual celebration featured approximately 8,000 participants including more 1,600 cheerleaders and dancers, twelve marching bands, and an assortment of celebrities in addition to 15 giant character balloons. (Photo by Chris Hondros/Getty Images)

From then on, I've become a little stabby about the whole thing, and let me tell you why. I'm speaking as someone who has lived, worked with, and advocated for abused kids for the past 18 years, and I am as protective as hell of them. Child abuse is ugly. So ugly that watering it down to something like a meme to cheerfully pass around on Facebook seems disrespectful to every single child I've taken into my home, made a hot lunch for, or worked to connect with.  What I want you to think about doing is moving from the virtual to the tangible, and here's why:

When I married my husband, he was contracting with Social Services and ran a therapeutic group home for severely at risk teenage boys. By that, I mean that often their needs were such that they could not be placed in a typical foster home. Sometimes, they were gang members. Other times, they were developing mental illnesses, were addicted to drugs or alcohol, had witnessed parents commit suicide or murder, were sex offenders, or had severe emotional problems. Sometimes they were just really messed up kids.

ALL of them had been abused in some way. NONE of them were lovable kids that you could just be kind too and make it all go away. They were ornery. Violent. They had HUGE problems.

Severely abused and neglected kids can be that way.

Despite all that, they were CHILDREN.

Their faces lit up on Christmas morning when they saw presents for them under the tree, because in their home Christmas might mean Mom having sex in the next room with a stranger, or Dad passed out cold on the floor. There would be no Santa, much less turkey or pumpkin pie. They found it odd that Hubs and I hugged each other and he didn't beat me daily. It took awhile for most of them to realize that the food was always going to be there, and they would never go hungry.

They marveled at going camping, became a bunch of excited five year olds when we took them to the water slides or to play paint ball, loved the movie theater, and dissolved in laughter at night when we'd play board games. We helped them with their homework, taught them how to be self sufficient and disciplined them when we had to, even if it meant calling the police when they had broken the law.

They screamed at night in fear from nightmares. Some wet the bed or sobbed after visits with their families. Some ran away because they couldn't stand being separated. Others had to sleep with the light on.

People, I found, could be incredibly cruel or judgmental to them, as if the kids deserved what had happened to them because, as teenagers, they weren't that lovable now. If they went missing, few people looked.

  • 13
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Lisa Morrow 5 pts

I completely respect and see your view. I just look at it a different way. If one of the 1.25 million children who are abused had been helped in some small way, then a couple of days of silly cartoon avatars are worth it. Maybe my expectation of awareness is different. I think of it as planting seeds. If just one person is moved to action and it's a rewarding experience, maybe she will do it again and recruit a friend or family member... and so it goes. Over time that becomes significant.

Respectfully,

Lisa Nicole Morrow

Smart Mamas Blog ( http://smartmamas.wordpress.com/ )

Hawkfeather 5 pts

One thing that always gets me- is something i perceive as almost a judgment when it comes to how or why people support a cause.

In the grand scheme of things- how does wearing a ribbon support a cause? You put your name behind a movement because it shows that people care in general.

Anyone can look around at how others support a cause and find someone doing "more"- does that take away from what is being offered- i tend to think it does not.

I looked through some images of my old programs- put some thought into what i liked when i was young and it really 'took me back', reminded me of what it means to be young and innocent- care free even- it wasn't a leap for me to put thought into what it is like for those who deserve the same innocence but have never reaped the rewards of youth.

Many of us have experienced abuse- but we will all still feel differently about the issues surrounding the subject.
Questioning the motives of those who are advocating a cause you believe in seems limiting to me-
if all of a sudden simple advocating is not enough- there are a lot of beautiful people out there doing wonderful things- with their morals in all the right places who are seemingly 'wrong' for the manner in which they offer their support.

Lisa Morrow 5 pts

Aliera,

I completely agree with you. Thank you for sharing your story. I am a counseling intern and I work with abused children at an advocacy center. The short window of time when awareness is raised, provides a great opportunity to discuss a subject people are usually not open to.

All the counselors I work with used that time to discuss how people can help. I know many people who adopted families (to provide Christmas gifts), donated gifts, and donated money and time to support children who have been abused. All were inspired by the awareness spread on FB. Awareness in itself does not solve the problem, it does help motivate people to do a little more and there certainly is no harm in that.

Lisa Nicole Morrow

Smart Mamas Blog ( http://smartmamas.wordpress.com/ )

scatteredmom 5 pts

I love, love, LOVE that you bought some foster children Christmas gifts. You likely made their holiday.

Your story is one of the very few I've heard that the avatar change prompted them to do something tangible. Most people are content to just sit and talk, and as a foster parent that was one of the most frustrating things. People with talk about the kids, but nobody would ever treat them as people.

It's easy to sugar coat and use things like avatars to talk about it, but nothing changes unless people DO something. Those kids will have a better Christmas because of you. :)

scatteredmom 5 pts

I am sure there are people out there who do more than change their avatar, but what bothered me was the peer pressure among some and then the "There, I changed it, happy?" tweets that I observed.

It's fantastic that for you, it opened the door and started a conversation so that you could share your own experiences.

The interesting thing that I forgot to add to the post? The next day I was working at a high school, and the kids brought up the whole cartoon character campaign. As they talked about what character they switched their avatars to, I asked them if they knew the Kid's Help Phone Number.

Not one of them did.

scatteredmom 5 pts

Actually the original meme was hijacked. It had started out as a walk down memory lane with cartoon characters, and somehow along the way became against child abuse.

Janell 5 pts

This was a great post. Raising awareness is important, but DOING something is what makes a difference. I am a foster parent and have fostered a lot of small children and babies. I sometimes tell myself that when my kids are older and I have more experience parenting older kids, I will try to help some of those difficult to love traumatized older kids. I admire you and your hubby so much for running a group home. Now I'm inspired to see what I can do to help a little more.

MusesFled 5 pts

...can really make a difference!

So happy to hear that it's not just people in my circle of influence who were affected in this way. I'm with you...even if the cartoon characters only resonated with a handful of people, it was well worth it.

I don't think anyone was trying to trivialize the horror that is child abuse, but rather to reach out to people in a way that they could all relate.

temysmom 6 pts

I get the point that simply putting up a funny avatar does nothing to change the child abuse situation in the world. But... let me tell you something... it DID change my perspective. Most of us go on with our lives and tend to "forget" at this time of year that there are children in dire need. I forgot. I admit it. But... when the meme went around about the avatars, it struck a cord with me. I went out and found a list of foster children who were in desperate need of gifts this Christmas. I went out and bought them the very gifts that were on their wish list. Then I delivered them to their social workers. Next year, I will plan more in advance and work out helping more families.

So if the cartoon characters even pushed a handful of people to help, isn't it worth it?

Dawn 5 pts

A post I placed at my Blog and here on BlogHer went somewhat viral:
http://www.blogher.com/child-abuse-no-cartoon

Dawn Rouse

Writer, Thinker, Nap-Taker and almost Doctor of Education

I am Doing the Best I can ( http://www.balefulregards.com )

True Wife Confessions ( http://www.truewifeconfession.com )

MusesFled 5 pts

I understand where you're coming from, Scattered, but I respectfully disagree with your assessment of the awareness aspect of the campaign.

It's certainly not that we're not aware of child abuse as a society. We are. But rather the fact that the subject of abuse is still very much taboo with the general public. I think that the campaign was able to at least give people a moment's pause as they contemplated child abuse.

I had quite a few people ask me why I'd changed my profile picture, and it opened to door for me telling them about my own experiences as a survivor of child abuse.

When the general public thinks about the victims of abuse, they often have a pretty stereotypical outlook on the subject, such as thinking they're all individuals who come from broken homes, are maladjusted, below the poverty line or that they all turn to drugs/sex/violence themselves.

This movement on Facebook allowed me to change those perceptions for some of my friends and acquaintances and motivated them to get involved in making a real world difference off of Facebook and in our community.

While many people were perhaps fixated on the nostalgic nature of the cartoons themselves, it's unfair to say that all were. A lot of the people who backed the movement are individuals who are just as involved in helping children as you and your husband or survivors of child abuse like myself.

I was an abused kid and knowing I wasn't alone was a big motivator in me coming forward and taking down the bastard that hurt me (through proper legal measures). I think for kids growing up in this social landscape, the Facebook movement might have reminded them that they aren't alone, to be brave and have hope that they can rise above.

Respectfully,

Aliera

healthyperhaps 5 pts

Cloth, I completely agree with you. It does seem like those who do this want a quick way to feel like they're doing something, but really they are doing nothing but trivializing the trauma you and other victims have suffered. Either that or they don't even care about the cause, just the cartoons. It also trivializes the important work of people like Scattered by reducing the cause of awareness to something so ridiculous.

Besides, the only discourse these avatars create is nostalgia for cartoons.

I blog about the arts and health and disability issues regularly at http://loveablehomebody.blogspot.com/

clothchronicles 5 pts

As a child that grew up in an abusive home and later, an adult that worked with domestic and sexual abuse victims, all I can say is thank you!! I have been pissed ever since I first saw those posts to change profile pics. I suppose this is a quick and easy way for some people to feel good about themselves, but it does next to nothing for the actual abuse victims.