Bio
Laina Dawes is a contributing editor for Blogher and is also a music journalist whose writings can be found at Exclaim! Canada and...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

This Week in Race(ism): Serena, Kanye, Joe, Mark and The Bad Lieutenant

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I think we can all agree that this has (well, the past couple of weeks...hell maybe this year) has been a difficult one. Things have been said that cannot be undone - even on this website. People have showed their ass, and  the phrase 'forgive and forget' seems to leave a bitter taste in our mouths.


A couple of days ago, I wrote a post on Serena Williams and Kanye West over on my blog. Before these two incidents of "bad behavior" there was Rep. Joe Wilson's outburst and later, last Monday night, "Tea Party" leader Mark Williams lost it on CNN when it was revealed that despite his consternation that people were calling the Tea Party organizations racist, seemed to think he was perfectly just in calling President Obama a Indonesian Muslim and a welfare thug (damn, you can go to Harvard on Welfare? Become the President of the United States? I gotta check that...).


But that's not racism, is it? Because white people can't be racist unless another white person says they are. Like President Jimmy Carter. And hell, even then a white person...or in this case, the White House can refute it and then we can all go back to our merry lives in denial and self-imposed ignorance. Free at last!


But some white folks don't like the fact that Carter shared his opinion. Here's a (very scary) comment from Hot Air:



This “racism” business is not off-the-cuff idiocy by a deranged anti-semite and supporter of terrorism, it is a planned and orchestrated campaigne to radicalize the American electorate and incite political violence.


By morphing political dissent into racism it makes hatred of political opponents not only acceptable but lauditory, thereby radicalizing democrats. It also provokes a strong backlash among dissenters, thereby radicalizing conservatives.


Violence is certain to follow.


The next demonstation in Washington will surely be larger and angrier than the last. Radicalized leftists will show up, shots will be fired and the ball will be rolling. Dissenters will be “enemies of the people” and everyday Democrats will cheer their incarceration. The American Republic will collapse as darkness descends on the continent.


Jimmy Carter knows exactly what he’s doing.


Mr. Obama nods in agreement.


Now, while Kanye - whom to be honest, nobody really cared about his previous media-whoring escapades, jumping on stages and pulling temper-tantrums when he didn't win awards, until he embarassed a white female country singer. He did not pull a racist act (even though some opinions will differ) and people were justifiably annoyed, but I was still disappointed when a number of hashtags appeared on Twitter, such as #Kaynenigger and #Kayne_is_nigger. So, let me get this straight...it's not okay for a black or person of color to accuse people of racism but it's okay to do it yourself? On the other hand, there was a swift action by primarily black Twitters to block all attempts at these people from "friending" them.


Yesterday, a man was arrested after he allegedly beat a black woman in front of her daughter a restaurant, calling her a "black nigger bitch" for um...asking the man to 'watch it' when he opened a door to a restaurant, nearly hitting her daughter. I just watched CNN and Rick Sanchez interviewed her, and - yes, I know, he is doing his job - actually asked her if she thought he punched and kicked her because she was black.


As part of the Toronto International Film Festival, I attended the Gala screening of The Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans and my bad week got worse. Sure, I saw Nicolas Cage in the flesh - he's taller than I imagined, and more importantly, I saw Director Werner Hertzog whom I greatly admir(ed), as I had caught a few of his films.


But the movie? It was awful. Bad acting, weak writing and while Hertzog applied his signature weird 'artistic' touches in the form of hallucinations of Iguanas (don't ask) it didn't work. It was instead confusing and lame. However, a bad movie is a bad movie, but what bothered me was the audience response to the scenes of blatant racial stereotyping.


Granted, I walked in knowing that when you are doing a film on New Orleans, you are bound to see things that you don't really want to see, but what I was disappointed was the uproarious laughter when the stereotypical images of black people came on the screen.

  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
BellaSophiasMommy 5 pts

And further more..... how could you say that Kayne has been subjected to racism? Have you heard anyone in the country music industry say that they wanted to kick that n's a or so forth. Or that stupid n had no right to do what he did. Just because this story has gotten coverage doesn't mean that he is being attacked simply because he is black. The responses that I wrote would be a form of racism simply covering the news isn't! Further more, if anyone was subjected to what seemed like a racist attack it was Taylor Swift. Kanye couldn't handle the fact that a white, country music artist won the award and bottom line that is what is was about.

BellaSophiasMommy 5 pts

And further more..... how could you say that Kayne has been subjected to racism? Have you heard anyone in the country music industry say that they wanted to kick that n's a or so forth. Or that stupid n had no right to do what he did. Just because this story has gotten coverage doesn't mean that he is being attacked simply because he is black. The responses that I wrote would be a form of racism simply covering the news isn't! Further more, if anyone was subjected to what seemed like a racist attack it was Taylor Swift. Kanye couldn't handle the fact that a white, country music artist won the award and bottom line that is what is was about.

BellaSophiasMommy 5 pts

And further more..... how could you say that Kayne has been subjected to racism? Have you heard anyone in the country music industry say that they wanted to kick that n's a or so forth. Or that stupid n had no right to do what he did. Just because this story has gotten coverage doesn't mean that he is being attacked simply because he is black. The responses that I wrote would be a form of racism simply covering the news isn't! Further more, if anyone was subjected to what seemed like a racist attack it was Taylor Swift. Kanye couldn't handle the fact that a white, country music artist won the award and bottom line that is what is was about.

BellaSophiasMommy 5 pts

I think this is crazy that this whole sitatuon has turned in the question of racism.... The fact that the word racism is being stretched so far bothers me. So now we are going to justify someone like Kanye because he shouldn't be given so much spot light attention. The fact that he only did is because he did this to a white girl and now out of all of this he is the one we should feel sorry for. Because, if I am hearing you right it seems like you are saying that if a white man did this to Taylor Swift then it wouldn't be getting the attention that it is.... I totally disagree. Racism isn't just about white and black and people need to wake up if they feel that way. I am white and I have been subjected to racist marks even in the last year from a black person. So the black community aren't the only people facing it. I think the problem here isn't racism it is the fact that you are wasting your breath on someone like Kanye. Why does he even deserve to be mentioned. He is not a person to waste your breath on. There are so many people in this world who desreve our attention yet they don't get it. But when someone goes out and speaks negativity into the minds of our youth in the form of music we standup and defend them for their crude actions simply because the media might be giving them more coverage possible because the are black. COME ON! This is absurd. I don't care if Kanye was blue this would have gotten the same media attention as anyone out there what he did was down right rude and unprofessional. It was all about Kanye and he wanted the spotlight on him. I don't know who he thinks he is to just take a stage like that. He acted has if he were the most important man on this planet and we should all believe his opinion and his only. I am honestly sick of hearing about racism because in my past experinces it is those who claim to be hurt so badly by racism that don't know crap about it and have rarley been subjected to it. Racism is present don't get me wrong. But try being the only white kid walking home from school in a mexican community and face the reality of getting beaten up every single day simply because your skin isn't tan. Then tell me you understand racism. So many people judge white people (which mind you not is a form of racism) simply because they may have it better or so on and so forth. We all came from somewhere and we all have faced something it doesn't make any of us less deserving of respect!

Deb Rox 5 pts

I totally felt the racism in the backlash against Kanye.  I primarily write humor on my blog, and though at first I made fun of the Kanye's ridiculous outburst while I was on Twitter, when it came down to writing about it after seeing some of the reactions, or about Serena's fit for that matter, I felt the racism rooted in the backlash and decided not to publish.  We always have to notice the context of simple events-- Kanye's rudeness was obvious and laughable, but racist reactions are not.

Deb
www.debontherocks.com ( http://www.debontherocks.com/ )blog
www.3smartgirlz.com ( http://www.3smartgirlz.com/ ) consulting

lainad 5 pts

Great comments so far.

I think that one of the problems with these recent situations is that (geez, I think I start every comment with the above line) is that how do you explain racist / bigoted / discriminatory behaviour to a population of people who have not only, not experienced it, but not even considered it? And therefore deny it?

That is why the complaints about this recent situation with Kanye is hard. NO ONE is excusing his rude behaviour, and no one is blaming Taylor Swift - because she did not do anything out of the ordinary. But these calls for his head are a bit suspicious. There are quite a number of comparable instances to not only Kayne but Serena's outburst and the media seems to have conveniently ignored. Racial stereotypes - Serena and Kanye as the loud, intimidating brutes and their suggested penalties are excessive. People can choose not to buy Kayne's albums, or go to his shows. People can choose not to watch Serena play, but this is too much.

Are we - those of us who face the repercussions whenever someone who looks like us displeases the 'majority,' supposed to pay our penance and say nothing? I think not. But when we do, we are playing the 'race card.' I think that people - those who engage in online social networking sites or watch television for that matter, need to realize that not everyone has - or should - have the same life experience than you do. 

Contributing Editor - Race, Ethnicity & Culture

Blog: Writing is Fighting: www.lainad.typepad.com ( http://www.lainad.typepad.com/ )

Writer: Hellbound: www.hellbound.ca ( http://www.hellbound.ca/ )

BrownImani 5 pts

the media storm over the "Kanye display" is certainly all about that he did it to a young, white girl ! How can anyone not see that? He has been doing this for a while and noone cared. Now everyone has a comment about the outrageousness of it ! And it was outrageous and how dare he ! No disagreenent there. (by the way, Beyonce did a classy thing later). The big point - let's not miss it- is the selective whoopla by the media and the public over who can be outrageous and who cannot and to whom. Athletes lose their tempers all the time in the heat of battle. Serena is entitled to her 1st one ! Yes, she was wrong and paid the fine. Joe Wilson was beyond wrong and will not be censured enough for me because I believe what he did was bad enough for him to be impeached ! His outrageousness is the important one and he seems to be getting a pass. The slippery slope of disrespect being heaped on my President, our President, is growing and everyone (white) wants to be in denial about the Pandora's Box of in-your-face racism that has  been opened. I am concerned about that, not sweaty athletes and silly entertainers.

mashadutoit 5 pts

Its ironic, but it seems like the very seriousness of the accusation of racism, has become an excuse for people to not face up to their own potential for racism.

What I mean is - when racism is highlighted, people often act as though they have been accused of something like paedophilia or bestiality.  The justification goes something like this:"Racism is monstrous.  By accusing me of racism, you are calling me a monster. I know I'm not a monster, therefore I am not racist."

Its important for me recognise that since I have grown up in a deeply racist world, I harbour racist attitudes.  I am racist, and can think, act and speak in racist ways.  It is important that I admit this possibility, otherwise I will never recognise racism in my own actions, and ultimately I can never change.

As for that movie, it sounds horrific.  You might be interested in this blog post ( http://asubtleknife.wordpress.com/2009/09/12/the-a... ) on District 9, which also has some very interesting race issues:

BellaSophiasMommy 5 pts

I don't think it was that Kanye disruptted a "white female country singer". I think it was the fact that this was a young girl. Someone daughter. But it shouldn't matter who it was. It shouldn't matter if it was a Smirff. What he did was wrong. It was cowardly. Disrespectful and hardly anyone I know has stood for it. He shouldn't be justified for what he did simply because Taylor Swift happened to be a white female country singer. She is still a person is she not. Did she deserve that. I thought musicans were professionals I guess not.