Most Popular

Recent Comments

"Well, I'm Glad I'm White"

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

For MLK day last week, we watched this simple, kid-friendly  Brainpop Jr. video about Dr. Martin Luther King. After it finished, I briefly synopsized it to make sure the kids, especially the younger ones, had a good sense for why we celebrate his birthday. There was a short, weighty pause while everyone let that chunk of history sink in. And then this innocent 4-year-old cherub that I teach took a deep breath and said, "Well . . . I'm glad I'm white." 

It's rare that one of the kids leaves me speechless. 

Image Credit: flyingroc, via Flickr

The older kids, ages 6, 7, and 11, immediately jumped all over the wee preschooler with all sorts of "It doesn't matter what color your skin is" reprimands. I calmed them down and we discussed it a bit more. But it really got me thinking.  

This 4-year-old is being raised in a Baha'i family, where race unity is not only accepted, but is an actively taught belief. Her mother, who is half Iraqi, was raised in West Africa. They have friends of all different races and cultures. From every standpoint, this kid is surrounded by messages of equality. 

And it's not as though her response was inappropriate for her age. Not having a real clear sense of time and history, it's understandable that she would simply see that the people who looked like her in the story were not the ones being mistreated, and feel some relief in the idea that she'd have been on the safer end of things if she lived back then. 

But it underscored for me the importance of proactive education in overcoming our country's racial history. Because really, this "I'm glad I'm white" notion probably lives deep inside most of us white folk, whether we are conscious of it or not.  

What if this little cherub didn't have the upbringing and education to check that automatic response? How easy would it be, even subconsciously, for "I'm glad I'm white" to gradually morph into "It's better that I'm white" and eventually to "I'm better because I'm white" if there wasn't a strong message to counter that?  

And I wonder if a black child watching the same video, or learning about that same chunk of history, might have the opposite gut response. I'm sure there's some pride there in seeing someone like Dr. King doing such courageous and world-changing work. But at the same time, they're seeing that 1) people that look like them were seen as dirty and inferior, and 2) people that stood up for change, though they had support, were doubly mistreated and eventually shot and killed. I always think of civil rights movement education as inspiring. But maybe there's another layer to it that I have - in my white ignorance, perhaps - never considered. If a white child thinks "I'm glad I'm white," could a black child think, "It sucks that I'm black?" 

I watched a video interview of Dr. Joy Degruy, author of "Post Traumatic Slave Syndrome," where she explained very clearly how much our country's racial history still affects blacks today. African Americans in general have had to fight not only the white status quo, but their own slavery-era ancestral habits in order to climb toward equality.  

Take, for example, education. If you were a child of a slave, and you were caught knowing how to read, you'd be beaten. Or your family would be beaten. Or separated. Or worse. Education had horrible consequences for blacks for a very long time in this country. So parents taught their kids to act dumb in order to keep them safe. The dumber you talked, the safer you were. Those were truths - not assumptions, not ignorant habits, but truths - that got passed down for generations. Fear - especially fear for one's children -  is a powerful and insidious oppressor. 

We've come a long way, I think, but we still have so much vital work to do in this area. The civil rights movement really wasn't that long ago. One generation from me. Two generations from these kids I teach. There's a lot of subconscious junk that is still quite fresh in the larger scheme of things. Maybe it's not enough to teach kids that skin color doesn't matter. Maybe we need to dig deeper than that, uncomfortable as it might be. 

The Baha'i teachings call racial equality between blacks and whites America's most challenging issue. And the suggestions for what needs to be done to solve it really boils down to doing our own work, both internally and externally: 

(Note: This was written in

  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Joliedupre 6 pts

"Because really, this "I'm glad I'm white" notion probably lives deep inside most of us white folk, whether we are conscious of it or not." ~~

I'm 49 years old and black. Stand me next to a 49-year-old white woman, and count how many wrinkles I *don't* have. That's a positive not a negative. I hate to break it to you.

motherhoodandmore 7 pts

Joliedupre Oh, I believe you. I don't generally go around saying I wish I was black because there is a whole lot that could be misconstrued with that statement, but as far as skin itself goes, you definitely have all of the advantage. I am as fair as fair can be, and my skin shows every blemish and blotch, not to mention it burns easily. And I've got German hairiness to boot. My skin is definitely not my favorite feature. My best friend has a daughter who was born in Haiti - her skin is TO DIE for. So smooth and silky and chocolatey and gorgeous. I don't mind saying I'm totally jealous of the perfection of her skin.

Erin Bella 14 pts

Annie,

I'm glad I read this. I have to say, the title was attention grabbing (nice job!) but for all the wrong reasons. In the wake of MLK's birhday, I thought this post would be about White pride and superiority. But then I had to ask myself a question, "Am I glad I'm Black?" Yes. "Am I glad I'm a female." Yes. Am I glad that I'm short, liberal, far-sighted? Yes, yes, and yes.

It's me. And I'm glad I'm me. And I can't imagine any four year old not being glad or proud of being exactly who they were created to be. The tricky thing is making sure that pride doesn't turn into superiority, that it doesn't create a sense of inferiority among others.

You hit it dead on the nail. I'm happy to be Black. I'm proud of my Black ancestry. I stand in awe at their ability to live in an enslaved society or Jim Crow society and march on, hoping that one day there'd be a generation full of pride and completely out of touch of what those sacrifices were really like. And still, there was a sense for me -- I'm glad I was born in the 80s. I'm glad my grandparents valued education and didn't mind sending their children off to school and away from the shelter of their Black communities. Because in talking to my older family members who ARE proud, I think they're prouder today than they were growing up. I think they were proud back then, but also afraid and frustrated that Whites walked around feeling unnecessarily superior and living the good life.

It makes sense to me why so much of our history in the US is shameful, why a generation or two after the Emancipation, some people refused to teach their children about how they came to this country. Because you don't ever want to plant the seed of inferiority, not even in a lesson. Not even if it was done with almost 250 years ago. The lesson I received was, don't ever think for one second that you're less than them because you're not -- but you have to work harder and be smarter to be accepted as equal. That message breeds inferiority, too.

Maybe I'll figure out how to have these conversations before I start my own family.

SunbonnetSmart.com 802 pts

Erin Bella Beautiful! Each of us should be proud to be whomever we are. I can't exclude that child, just because he is white. Pride is not something one race bestows upon another. Pride is something that every person and every race should grab and display with gusto, while rejoicing in the beauty of everyone else's pride as well. Putting white guilt on a four year old is a stretch for me. Thanks for a post that was attention getting and made me think. And thanks to Erin for balancing it back to center. I am looking forward to more from both of you. Glad to e-meet you today. Fondly, Robin

motherhoodandmore 7 pts

SunbonnetSmart.comErin Bella Glad to e-meet you, too, Robin. :) The notion of pride is an interesting one. I've never felt proud to be white, I don't think. Relieved, perhaps (which is what I think my student's response was about). Or appreciative for not having to deal with a lot of the struggles that other races face, perhaps. But not pride. I think of pride as something you feel for an accomplishment of some sort. Since my race is not something I've done anything to have, I don't feel pride in it. I'm wonder how others feel about racial pride. Thanks for bringing it up. :)

SunbonnetSmart.com 802 pts

motherhoodandmoreErin Bella Whoa! Not all whites grow up in majority white areas. All races are capable of discriminating and being unkind. Why? Because all races are human. To me, people feeling above needing to take pride in whomever they are, do so because they feel superior. They don't "need" pride...they are better anyway. I know what you are trying to say, but putting one race down to raise another up is unfair and unpleasant, no matter who is sitting on either side of the see-saw.

Denise 996 pts moderator

Erin Bella I love this part of your comment, "The tricky thing is making sure that pride doesn't turn into superiority, that it doesn't create a sense of inferiority among others." -- That's HUGE and exactly right!

Denise

BlogHer.com Community Manager

motherhoodandmore 7 pts

Erin Bella Thank you, Erin, for your thoughtful response! I've been discussing this post with some friends over the past couple of days, and it's been so helpful to have open dialogue about this stuff. I think so many times we're afraid that we're going to offend someone, so we don't talk openly, but that doesn't really help the situation, either.

One of the difficulties I have is figuring out the balance between honoring the history and stories of those who lived and struggled and suffered during that whole horrid period, and making sure to not overemphasize that struggle for fear of perpetuating messages of inferiority. And then also trying to figure out what my role as a white person is in that whole thing. I certainly don't want to make anyone feel inferior, even unintentionally. I also don't want to dishonor or downplay the enormous struggles and challenges that black people have had to overcome. Is it just a delicate balance we have to find?

@gerovani 6 pts

So much work to do! Inwardly and outwardly. Let's start by looking within, Michael Jackson said it best "I'm starting with the man in the mirror, I'm asking him (her) to change his ways!

Let us work while it is day, starting today!