Bio
www.herbadmother.com www.thebadmomsclub.com
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

“Abortion Doulas” Take a Job Few Others Will

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Here's an idea that is, I think, long overdue: doulas for women who are having abortions.

Doulas, of course, ordinarily provide support services to women who are having babies. I had labour doula for the birth of my first child, and she was invaluable: she was there to advocate on behalf with the nurses and doctors, to help make sure that things were going the way that I wanted them to go, and to provide moral support and foot rubs when my husband's energy lagged during the 36 hour labour. All things that could be tremendously useful to a woman undergoing an abortion, not least because odds are pretty good she's not going to have a morale-supporting, foot-rubbing husband at her side.

Scratch that: these services might not just be useful - they might be critical. Health-saving. Psyche-saving. Because even though some would have you believe that having an abortion is as easy as getting a pedicure, that's simply not true. For many women - for many girls - having an abortion is a profoundly difficult experience, not least because it is, even in the most straighforward case, an invasive medical procedure. It's uncomfortable at best; horribly painful at worst. But it's more than this: even a woman who is really entirely clear about her commitment to her decision to have an abortion is probably going to experience a lot of confused and confusing emotions. Abortions are hard. Let no one tell you otherwise. So the idea of doulas providing support services during that experience is a tremendous one.

LaToya Peterson at Jezebel describes the experience of a labour doula cum abortion doula as she related that experience at the website RH Reality Check. Mary Mahoney relates her experience with two women undergoing abortions in their second trimester:

"Since patients are normally under general anesthesia during this procedure, doulas spend the majority of our time with them before they enter the operating room. The first woman I supported that morning was in her early 30s, Spanish-speaking, religious, and scared. I spent my time with her holding her hand, wiping her tears, and telling her it was going to be ok and that she would be safe, in my own broken Spanish. My next client was having strong cramps from measures that were taken to dilate her cervix, and so I gave her a lower back rub and massaged a pressure point on her hand. After her procedure, at her request, I went to the waiting room to tell her husband and sister that she was fine and would be discharged in a couple of hours. The next woman I met mostly wanted to be alone, so I checked in with her every few minutes to see if she needed anything and pulled the curtain closed around her bed.

The support that she offered ranged from emotional support to the provision of basic comfort. In both cases, however, I've no doubt that that support made all the difference in the world to the womens' emotional well-being.

When I had my abortion, my mother was with me. She held me and cried with me and told me that she loved me, and this was huge for me - but I could also have used some measured support from someone who was there just to support to me, someone who wasn't affected by what I was doing, someone who cared only about making sure that I was okay and that I was comfortable and that my feet were well-rubbed. And if my mother hadn't been there? I really would have wanted someone there to hold my hand.

Check out The Doula Project for more information - or just to tell them that they are, really, doing something awesome.

We may not come to an agreement on abortion. However, it is my belief that honest discussions through experience can help make the conversation more civil.

Catherine Connors blogs at Her Bad Mother and Their Bad Mother and The Bad Moms Club and everywhere in between.

 

  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Her Bad Mother 5 pts

A reader sent me this comment and asked me to post it for her, anonymously:

I had an abortion when I was 19. I was a junior in college. Finally on track after some wandering. I got pregnant the predictable way: didn't use birth control. Of course, I knew better. When I decided to terminate, about 2 seconds after the positive test, I was clear in my decision. I'd been told all my life that this was my right. But no one told me that I was supposed to feel horrible and guilty about it. That didn't occur to me until I had my mandatory counseling sessions and was treated like a freak, or someone out of touch with her feelings, because I wasn't conflicted or berating myself. The worst was the clinic volunteer who accompanied me (not that I asked her) during the abortion. Afterward, I was relieved it was over, and thanked her kindly for her support (again, not that she did anything). She replied, "I've never seen anyone smile after this." She judged me. I felt like I was emotionally defective. I actually believed I was for a long while.

My saving grace was that I was at a women's college and surrounded by women who'd been in my situation and understood. It's not that I never felt anything. In the subsequent months and years my abortion has meant something different to me depending on where I was in my life. But I never felt guilt or shame or regret. Except when I think about the people who were supposed to support me, and how they failed me.

An abortion doula, who is sensitive to the range of experiences, circumstances, and reactions to the procedure would, I'm sure, be so comforting to so many women.

Her Bad Mother 5 pts

I read your post, and was moved by it. Have been thinking about how to respond.

For now, I'll just say this: thank you.

candicess 5 pts

I think that this is a great idea.  As one who went through this life-changing experience, I can definitely see how having a doula could make a world of difference.  It is a decision that I live with every day of my life and I often feel so alone. 

Thanks for posting!

kbxmas 5 pts

Thank you for having the courage to post this.  I *love* it.  I think it's a beautiful and brilliant idea.

amymarieb 5 pts

I think it is usually pretty tacky when people tout their own blog posts in the combox, but I felt like I should at least mention that this blog post inspired me to write a post of my own. I feel like if I don't mention it, that would be akin to talking behind your back.

FYI - I am a pro-life Christian, and while admittedly my gut reaction to the idea of an abortion doula is negative, you have made me do some important reflecting.  Though my heart still aches over what I consider to be an objective moral wrong, my heart also reaches out to women who have made what I consider to be such a sad choice. The core of the Christian faith is that God grants grace and forgiveness to people BEFORE they even deserve it. So why should we refrain from granting grace and forgiveness to anyone? This is what I am struggling with, and I am thankful to you for making me struggle.

Amy blogs @ ( http://twitter.com/ ) A Chase After Wind ( http://chaseafterwind.blogspot.com )

mommahardt 5 pts

As a Doula myself I know the place that a Doula holds in the birth of a child, having lost a child at 20 weeks and having to birth a still child without a Doula I know the feelings that accompany that.  This thought is not one that ever crossed my mind but definately intrigues me.  The women in general having abortions are in need of more support than any other and recieve the least.  I personally couldn't have an abortion but for someone who has made that choice the thought of someone supporting them is outstanding.  Thanks for getting the wheels in my brain rolling this morning

GreenInOC 5 pts

I went over to Project Doula in order to contact them to thank them for doing this.  Unfortunately, there is no way to contact them through their page (at least I couldn't find one).

http://greeninoc.blogspot.com

GreenInOC 5 pts

@dizwiz ( http://twitter.com/dizwiz ) "Why exactly would someone request unconditional support for the taking of a life?"

Have you ever listened to Prison Wardens who carry out the death penalty?  These are men who take lives.  They desperately need support.  Would you deny them the support that they need

Personally, I disagree with the death penalty.  However, I support wholeheartedly getting these men the support that they need, even if it's someone rubbing their feet.  Even if it's for convenient excuses like "But it was my job", "My child was in college and if I didn't do my job my child could not have continued in school", "My church's position was in support of the death penalty and I didn't feel strong enough to take a stand".

http://greeninoc.blogspot.com

AtomicMommy 5 pts

I had an abortion 7 months after the birth of my first son. My choice was due to the fact that the father was strongly addicted to drugs, and I was unable to support a second child at that time. Be sure and read the part that says "my choice," because that's exactly what it was, and I just decided to explain it to you. No, I'm not looking for support.

There was a lady there, and I'm not sure of her purpose, but she held my hand. She talked me through the procedure and held my hand, and asked me questions about my first son. She was amazing. She was also very pregnant. I remember her down to the freckles on her nose, that is how much of an impact she was on me.

So, I'm all for this. An abortion is a very trying time for any woman, and it's always nice to have a little support, regardless of the situation. Thank you, Catherine, for addressing this. It's something that people are scared to talk about anymore, and it really shouldn't be that way.

Katherine 

You can find me at:

http://atomicmom.typepad.com/

@theatomicmommy ( http://twitter.com/theatomicmommy ) on Twitter

jenniferintheus 5 pts

I had a friend who chose to have an abortion.  Her best friend was a 'strong' Christian and very anti-abortion, but on the day of my friend's abortion, the best friend chose to simply go with my friend, hold my friend's hand and take care of her afterwards.  Even though in the days leading up to the abortion the best friend had tried to convince my friend not to go through with it, on the day of the procedure, she said nothing of the kind, and was simply a loving best friend.  I thought this the best example of love I had heard in a very long time.

Adventures In Babywearing 5 pts

There should always be compassion. Steph Adventures In Babywearing ( http://www.adventuresinbabywearing.com )

statia 5 pts

I think it's a brilliant idea indeed.   I'm am pro-choice.  I am a mom of two.  I couldn't imagine having to go through an abortion.  I could never do it for myself, but I can't put myself in others shoes in that regard.  I think that, no matter what the circumstances are, everyone deserves to have someone comfort them in such a heart wrenching time in their life.  

Julie Marsh 5 pts

As difficult as an abortion must be for a young single woman, I can only imagine the agony for a woman who already has a child. I would love to hear from married/partnered women who've voluntarily terminated a pregnancy due to non-viability or limited viability of the fetus. I received genetic counseling when an ultrasound revealed a potential chromosomal abnormality with my oldest, but I wonder if the hospital or my OB-GYN's practice would have offered additional support if the amnio results had led us to consider termination.

Julie @ ( http://twitter.com/ ) The Mom Slant ( http://themomslant.com )

HeidiMarie123 5 pts

Coincidently, I was just reading an amazing post by Maria Niles on Pro-Choice.

Miss Disgrace 5 pts

I think this is a very good idea, and a very brave topic to address.

Miss Grace's Disgrace ( http://www.missdisgrace.com )

Disgraced Shopping ( http://www.shopdisgrace.com )

 tweet @grace134 ( http://twitter.com/grace134 )

nissanicole 5 pts

There are so many things that can be discussed when talking about this particular subject and you have hit one major nerve with this. I didn't have a supportive woman with me when I had my abortion.

We shower women with support when they have babies (and that's good) but when it comes to abortion and adoption - heads are turned.

I know many women whose mothers, sisters, or best friends were with them and while it's not a happy fun place, they know that there's someone there with them who can understand the volume of what's happening - through a woman's eyes - because women are the only ones who can truly understand it.

I would absolutely in a heartbeat do this for another woman, with hopes that I could give her what I didn't have.

And this isn't about being pro-choice - it's about support. It's not about having a cheerleader, it's about having someone to make sure you get through it alive. In fact, I think there should be adoption doulas, too.

Sign me up.

averygoodyear 5 pts

Women should be comforted and supported through all the phases of their reproductive lives not just during the times when they're birthing babies.

Exactly.  The decision to have an abortion is NOT an easy one, and the women who make it deserve support and care to match any other woman.

http://averygoodyear.net

adjunctmom 5 pts

It's funny, because I don't find much civility in what you're saying. If you haven't had an abortion, then I'm not sure how you're discussing through your experience. And I'm not sure what you're after here, either? Are you saying that you feel if a woman chooses an abortion for a reason that you don't approve of then she should be denied comfort and support?

I think, as women, we would fare far better in the larger political sphere if we would stop turning on each other and each other's choices. If you wouldn't choose an abortion after having children and realizing the profundity of that experience, that's wonderful and I wholeheartedly support your choice. What would be nice, though, is if you would also come to the realization that other women are facing difficult choices and deserve support for those choices whatever they are.

I think abortion doulas are a brilliant idea that is long overdue. Women should be comforted and supported through all the phases of their reproductive lives not just during the times when they're birthing babies.

mariabird 5 pts

I had a birth doula with both labors.  The first volunteered her time with unmarried teens in labor.  The second volunteered her time as a doula for women delivering a stillborn child.  Women in the doula profession seem, to me, to be caring beyond comprehension and I don't think it would be an unthinkable leap to support a woman facing an abortion.

It was brave of you to say this here.  I know it's a tough topic.  I completely agree with you though.  When it comes to abortion, I feel fortunate that I've never had to face the kind of horrible situation that would force me to make a decision like that. 

-Maria

http://www.mommymelee.com

dizwiz 5 pts

"Controlling one's reproductive process" means not having sex unless you are prepared for consequences and results...we are all aware of how human bodies function.

Remember this is a civil conversation.  I am discussing honestly through experience.

I used to be "for abortion rights".  Then I became a mom.  To ponder:  Why exactly would someone request unconditional support for the taking of a life?  And you want your feet rubbed too?

The services of a doula would certainly be applicable in cases where the mother's life was in jeopardy....possibly some others.  But procedures for convenience, such as in statements like  "But I'm not ready to be pregnant...."?  Really?  Comfort and support should be given to whom?

Melissa Ford 5 pts

I think the most powerful point is the idea of having someone there who isn't part of the situation--who isn't affected by the loss.  Someone who is there to give unconditional support.  It's something I had never considered before, but it's a brilliant idea.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

idyllicchick 5 pts

Brilliant idea! My then-boyfriend-now-still-a-friend was with me during my abortion, and he was wonderful and invaluable. I am so thankful that I didn't have to deal with it all alone. But had he not been in the picture, I would have loved, perhaps even needed, to have a doula with me. 

Jaded16 5 pts

I loved the idea of a doula for abortions. That would be great. Your post gave me a lot to think. In fact, I came up with this (http://www.blogher.com/someone-needs-take-negative... to all the thinking you had me do. Great post :) 

~ Jaded16

http://jaded16.wordpress.com/

val at PPNNE 5 pts

....by the compassion of this blog post, but also the outpouring of support from all you commenting women!  I am positive that women undergoing any procedure in the pregnancy spectrum can only benefit from kind, non-judgmental support. 

http://consensualtext.org    www.good-chemistry.org   ( http://www.good-chemistry.org   ) www.facebook.com/ppnne ( http://www.facebook.com/ppnne )

www.twitter.com/ppnne   ( http://www.twitter.com/ppnne   ) www.ppnne.org ( http://www.ppnne.org )

nissanicole 5 pts

You are NOT alone! Remember that! :D