When Men Breastfeed, What Does It Say About Gender Roles?
by Suzanne Reisman

"If women were meant to work outside the home, men would be able to breastfeed." This is more or less one of reasons that many uber-conservatives give for why women should be at home with the kids while men support their families. (Usually there is also something about God made it that way.) Except that men can lactate, and sometimes breastfeed.

Think about the biology behind humans. Until the Y chromosome asserts itself around the 9th week of development, all fetuses are genitally female. Human genitals are essentially variants of each other: a penis is an elongated clitoris. And, of course, men have nipples. Years ago in a science class, we discussed why men might have nipples if they couldn't breast feed, and my teacher explained that it was because we all begin as female. Yes, after the Y chromosome kicks in male and female bodies diverge. Both men and women have "male" and "female" hormones, albeit with different proportions and impacts. Understanding how much more alike men and women really are than different, when I found out that men really can breastfeed, it made perfect sense. I just wondered why I never heard about it before.

According to Wikipedia, there are several causes of male lactation. Sadly, one reason is the use of prescription drugs that contain hormones. Men who are given hormones to treat prostate cancer will often lactate, and some anti-psychotic medications also produce milk as a side effect. Worse, men under extreme duress may begin lactating. This was observed in people who have survived the Holocaust and POW camps. In more positive situations, it is a culturally induced ability. When gender roles are interchangeable, men tend to lactate naturally in order to care for babies.

At Double Visioned, Hiram writres:

I was reminded of the myth of how Zeus gave birth to Dionysus, after the original mother Semele died. Zeus carried Dionysus inside his own thigh. The myth does not mention breastfeeding, but based on what I now know the myth was probably incomplete.

Hiram also links to many other sources of information on male breastfeeding, including Milk Men, a short film about men who lactate. Director Peter Templeman asks "...what impact would [male laction] have on a father's relationship with his child, with his friends, and with the child's mother?" I find this fascinating because we always hear about the important role breastfeeding plays in bonding a mother with her baby, and society spends enormous amount of energy valuing mother-child bonds, but not father-child bonds, at young ages. How would our world look if both parents breastfed? I think it is an incredibly exciting possibility.

One clue to this question is found within the Aka pygmy society, a community of approximately 20,000 people who live in Central Africa. Not only do Aka fathers suckle their babies, but in 2005, The Guardian reported that:

Aka fathers are within reach of their infants 47% of the time - that's apparently more than fathers in any other cultural group on the planet...

What's fascinating about the Aka is that male and female roles are virtually interchangeable. While the women hunt, the men mind the children; while the men cook, the women decide where to set up the next camp. And vice versa: and it's in this vice versa, says Hewlett, that the really important message lies. "There is a sexual division of labour in the Aka community - women, for example, are the primary caregivers," he says. "But, and this is crucial, there's a level of flexibility that's virtually unknown in our society. Aka fathers will slip into roles usually occupied by mothers without a second thought and without, more importantly, any loss of status - there's no stigma involved in the different jobs."

Not that life is perfect in the Aka culture. The article goes on to note that leadership roles are all male. However, the lack of stigma and flexibility found within the culture is a salient and critical aspect that is missing from most other cultures. That type of arrangement allows children and both parents to benefit from physical closeness.

Again, I asked myself why on earth I never heard of male breastfeed for the Aka people until now. Then I remember it is because I live in a world where "gender differences" and exaggerated and emphasized above all else. Mir recently noted a recent study and New York Times column about on BlogHer about this very topic.

Rock Star Maternity is also pondering the idea of male breastfeeding. I find it interesting that the first comment left on her post (which also links to many sources of information on male lactation and breastfeeding, including a widower who breastfeed his baby after his wife died in childbirth) opposes the phenomena, saying that men should be men. But that's the point - men are men, and men can lactate. We only socially condition ourselves to believe this is wrong.

The idea of male lactation also makes me wonder about restrictions on breastfeeding in public. Since we do not tend to sexualize male breasts, if more men breastfed, would people object so strenuously if men whipped open their shirts to feed a hungry baby in front of other people? Would it change how we look at female breasts in general?

The whole idea that men could breastfeed is so mind-blowing to me in what it says about gender roles. There are so many implications. I'm certain that we won't be seeing an influx in male breastfeeding any time soon (if ever), but I love that it shows how responsive the human body is to cultural suggestions and also how the body can produce the things that the human race needs to survive. It's really a testament to the genius of biology.

Suzanne also blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants and is the author of Off the Beaten (Subway) Track: New York City's Best Unusual Attractions.

Comments

 

I'm sorry, but this is the

I'm sorry, but this is the most pointless post I've ever read. 

 

fascinating!

I have to disagree with thlsralv on this post, I though it was really interesting. I've never heard of male lactation and the implications that you describe for gender roles are definitely thought-provoking. 

 

In Between Words

http://jessicaschafer.wordpress.com

 

Fascinating!

I find myself wondering if the social evolution currently happening as gender roles evolve and more and more men become stay-at-home dads will someday have more physical manifestation.

And I'd missed Mir's post, so I'm off to read that now!

Liz Rizzo

I blog at Everyday Goddess.

 

Pointless? But male lactation is not really
the point, is it?

It's about relaxing gender role definitions and being flexible enough to allow both genders to perform the same tasks without being admonished by society. 

I actually think it's getting better. Stay at home dads were unthinkable 20 years ago. And dads are more involved than ever. 

There's still a long way to go, but it's getting better. And the best thing is, dads LIKE to be more involved.  

---

I blog at MomGrind

I manage my kids' activities at UpToUs

 

Breastfeeding men are awesome!

I'm all for it.  If it works there is no reason why not. I think you are wrong, though, Suzanne, that it would make breastfeeding more acceptable. Instead I think that the mainstream would focus a lot of very strange misognyny and homophobia on the men trying it out.

If men could just carry the pregnancies too that would completely rock my world.

 

-----------------
Liz Henry
lizzard@bookmaniac.net
Contributing Editor, World and Latin America

 

Not sure how it would affect breastfeeding

Actually, I'm open to any thoughts on how it would affect the ability to breastfeed in public. I wasn't sure if it would help or hurt, but I agree with you that it probably would be viewed with fear and suspicion, as evidenced by the first comment on this post. :)

Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants

 

What does it say?

I have 2 comments:

First, I'm not sure if I want to try this more to freak people out and make them challenge their assumptions or to bond more closely with my child or just so I don't have to wake up my partner to do the feedings at night.

Second, what does it say about the changing body image issues of men that my second thought was what will this make my chest look like and will it be perminant?

 

wow

I'm with you Suzanne, how could we not have heard of this before??

I'm going to tell my husband.  I think I could get him to volunteer for this : )

 

Call me selfish but breast

Call me selfish but breast feeding is something I love, and hold dear as a women.  My breast are my favorite part of my body and giving milk to my babies was the best.  Knowing men can do it takes away from my "Superpower"  

Now selfishness aside it is conforting to know that if a man was deserted on a island with his newborn he could provide the nutriution the baby needed.  

~Susan                                                                                                                   

http://lilmomthatcould.com/

 

A man breastfeeding?

I've never heard of such a thing. Its such a specaial thing for a mom to do with her baby, I bonded with my son, he was nursing every hour or so. Can you provide evdidence, I mean where did you hear of this men being able to lactate, let alone enough to feed a baby?

 

The whole post is evidence

The knowledge about the pygmy tribe in which men regularly breastfeed was in science and anthropology journals, and picked up by the mainstream British press. (My post has links.) It was also in the news around the world when a man, who I think lived in Southeast Asia, but I may be remembering the wrong location, whose wife died breastfed his child. (The links to that story are in the bloggers that I link to.)

I think it is spectacular that you bonded with your baby while breastfeeding. It is something special, and I'm glad that in some parts of the world, men have this wonderful opportunity to be close to their babies as well.

Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants

 

Everything Old is New Again

Those of you who are shocked by this post must (a) not know your history of the feminist movement, or (b) been born in the last decade or so of the twentieth century.  In either case, you missed that the men lactating story was all the rage in the 70s.  I can remember using it in debates with those unenlightened ones who insisted that only women could truly nurture a child and that the ability to breastfeed proved unequivocally that men and women were different.  

Here's another factoid of that ilk: prior to the 20th century, pink was the color for boys.  It was considered too "hot" for girl babies.  Of coruse that was when they still thought that it was heat that made the male sex organs drop outside the human body.  And that is the genesis of the admonition that nice girls kept their legs together.  

If you study feminism and sexuality, you learn all sorts of fun things like this!

By Jane

http://byjane.blogspot.com

http://midlifebloggers.com