Bio
Humor writer, mother, blogger & columnist living in the great city of Austin. I'm also a founder of TheMouthyHousewives.com
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

When Mom Does the School Project

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 22
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

When my son Sam was in kindergarten, his teacher asked each student to decorate a Valentine’s Day mailbox at home and bring it in for the class party. “Have fun and be creative!” her note said. “Parents are welcome to help!”

The day of the party, I walked into the classroom and saw that 90 percent of the children had mailboxes on their desks that looked like the objects d’art you’d find in a weird Beverly Hills art gallery. The mailboxes were made out of metal or wood and were covered in everything from decoupage and feathers to faux-painting and Swarovski crystals. One even played a lovely little song when you dropped in a card.

My kid had an empty tissue box that was covered in SpongeBob SquarePants stickers and Band-Aids.

It was at that moment that I realized when a teacher says, “Parents are welcome to help,” what some moms hear is, “Max out your credit cards at Michael’s Crafts and stay up until 3 a.m. hot gluing sequins onto 2,000 pretzel sticks, baby!!! IT’S GO TIME!!!”

In the years since that Valentine’s Day party, I’ve seen countless other school projects that were supposedly done by kids, but obviously done by mothers. I’m not sure if this phenomenon is because the children don’t want to do the projects themselves, or if the moms greedily take over because they’re RCMMs—Raging Craft Maniac Moms---and simply can’t help themselves. (I tend to think it’s the latter. But then again, I live in a neighborhood where women Bedazzle their dogs.)

 

school project

 

 

Credit Image:woodley wonder works via Flickr

 

The RCMMs’ fingerprints are most apparent at our school when the second graders are assigned a “community building.” This can be anything from a farm to a hospital to a Target Greatland that the kids design and execute at home “with assistance from the parents.”  This year, my assistance to my younger son, Jack, came in the form of driving him to the store and buying supplies, sitting with him while he put it together and calling my husband for help when Jack accidentally glued his fingers to the dining room table and started squealing like a drunk hamster. Beyond that, I was happy to just watch him make something on his own and have fun doing it.

However, once I saw all of the other Second Grade projects, it was obvious that I was one of the few parents who felt that way. Because next to Jack’s rather dog-eared, half-collapsed, but still very charming pet store were suspension bridges, football stadiums and five-story libraries made out of mini-marshmallows and nail polish. And then there was the pièce de résistance:  a stunning replica of Buckingham Palace made by a boy named Ethan G. Now, I’m not saying that his mother did the whole damn thing herself, but I once saw Ethan try to eat a mozzarella stick with his nose. The odds are probably against his being a 7-year-old architectural prodigy able to construct a royal balcony out of Popsicle sticks.

 

 

I admit that I sometimes feel like I should just cave in and become a RCMM, too, because it can be painful to see how crappy your kids’ projects look next to ones done with a lot of parental involvement. I also wonder if I’m hurting my sons’ chances of getting into Harvard because I refuse to sculpt a bust of George Washington Carver out of a Duraflame log. But then I remember two things.

One: teachers aren’t idiots. They can figure out what the kids did and didn’t do themselves and will hopefully grade accordingly.

And two: I'm a total crafting disaster who once maimed herself with a pipe cleaner.  Anything I make will most likely cause my kids to flunk a grade and then they'll never move out. No, they're much better off doing their projects themselves while learning to be creative.

At least that's what I told my RCMM neighbor last night while she was gluing glitter on her poodle.

 

  • 22
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
alexandraRS 16 pts

What gets me, what really frosts me: is I tell my children these are THEIR projects and then I go to the classroom and some dood with an engineering degree has put together their kid's spider habitat.

It's not right: my kid feels inferior when he gets a sight of that two story spidey penthouse, and I sit there explaining we did the right thing.

Who''s my kid gonna listen to?

It won't be me....

Wish I was in your school with you. OH, we'd do things up right.

MoreThanMommy 8 pts

I don't understand what possesses someone to do their child's project. It's not supposed to be perfect. And it's not about the final result. It's about the learning that takes place while you're DOING THE PROJECT YOURSELF. I don't believe it has anything to do with a desire to do crafts and everything to do with a desire for the perfect child. Your perfect kid may be able to get into Harvard, but isn't going to be able to handle the work because you never allowed them to do it at home. Back off, parents.

Barb H 5 pts

I hate it when parents do their kids' projects, too! It's not just moms that take over. You should see our science fair. Thankfully, it's not a competition nor is it graded, so there's no unfair advantage. I love the sweet little projects the kids do on their own. They may not have all the bells and whistles, but they are the best ones, in my opinion!

slappyintheface 9 pts

Oh I hate hate hate it when parents do the projects for the kids. We have always helped with their projects, but we have never done the entire thing ourselves. Plus we have always had the rule that if you tell us about the major project the night before it is due, then you don't get any help at all. It's called "consequences".

Grace Hwang Lynch 30 pts

Oh my goodness, I kept thinking about this post while helping my 4th grader do his science fair project. I am so with you, but it is hard for a perfectionist like myself to let the child do it his way. The papers were all glued on crooked... and I had to leave the room and find something else to do. This is the same kid who in Kindergarten colored a box with magic markers to make a "Leprechaun trap". All the other kids brought in things built by engineers with trap doors and moving parts. But he learned more than the "Ethans" of this world!

Julie Adolf 5 pts

So timely--I'm laughing my head off! Our first grader had to decorate a "storybook character" pumpkin to take to class today. I have to admit--I talked him out of making a Clone Wars character. instead, he chose to make Rusty, a cat from the Warriors series. (Warrior cats--go figure.) Anyway, I did help him stick some pumpkins together using wooden skewers, but he designed the whole thing, painted it, put on the ears and stuffed an old orange sock for the tail. It was cute--but very age appropriate. I carried it into his classroom for him, and the kids were all so excited about their pumpkins--except one little guy. His was R2D2, and he told me: "I only got to do the white paint. My mom wouldn't let me help." So sad!

Jane Byers Goodwin 10 pts

No. Absolutely not. "Help" does NOT mean " Do this yourself." This goes for any and every kind of project that has ever been or will someday be assigned. A science project, craft project, math worksheet, essay. . . .ANY kind of project/assignment is the child's business, not the parent's prerogative. When I see a project obviously crafted/filled out/written by an adult turned in with a child's name on it, something in my heart dies a little. GOOD parents do NOT do the child's work for him/her. They stand behind or beside and offer suggestions, buy supplies, etc, but they do not put their hands on it.

I love the idea of doing entire science projects, etc, AT SCHOOL so these parents who are still longing to win blue ribbons albeit vicariously can't touch 'em.

Teachers are not seeking visual perfection with these assignments; they are hoping to see a child's understanding blossom into something tangible.

Back off, immature parents who wish they were still in school playing with glitter, paste, and backboards. You make me sick.

I'm only getting started. Some of you really don't want me to keep going. . . . .

Kathy K 13 pts

Jane Byers Goodwin I'm asking out of curiosity, but can you ever grade something down when it's obvious the parents did the work for the child? What if you could do something like this? Would you consider it?

peaceloveguac 5 pts

This drives me so crazy too. Most of our teachers make an extra point of saying, "Parents may buy supplies and offer support but it's a STUDENT project." I want to hug them. Of course, it doesn't stop some moms...who probably will be writing their kids' college entrance essays in 10 years.

kaherbert 7 pts

And this is why we in my district take home projects can not be graded.

One year we had a science fair project that was obviously parent made, because the long term sub (teacher was on maternity leave) made a mistake in documentation - we had to let it stand.

Next year the teachers were ready for this family. The 4 kids that "worked" on the project received failing grades because they did not do the work. Parents protested, vigorously.

It was hard to argue against the boys' grade, since it was based on their interview. A videoed interview. When asked to explain their project they said, "HuH HuH - We don't know Chris's father built it while we played Grand Theft Auto."

The grades stood. The other parents were ticked off. Not only about the grades but the fact that Chris's parents wouldn't let Chris go to there houses because you watch TV and might let him see something inappropriate. Then they found out their 5th graders were playing GTA at Chris's house.

On the other hand I remember tearfully confessing to my 4th grade teacher that "yes I had cheated, because Dad had cut the board for my project to size and did the soldering because I wasn't allowed to use the circular saw or the soldering iron yet. Also my cousin an engineer had fixed a motor I had purchased that turned out to be broken.

The teacher gave me a hug and told me that wasn't cheating. She told my mom that she was blown away that I knew how to use the other tools I had used to make my project.

CroMom 5 pts

The only time I remember my parents helping me with my school project was when I had my dad drive me around looking for Peppermint Lifesavers. All I remember about the project was that it somehow made a spark. But what I remember vividly was that my dad told me the book I found in the library that showed how to do this science project was stupid and that next time my project had to be made from supplies we already had.

Yeah, the teachers know...

Alex@LateEnough 7 pts

Who has time to do their kids' school projects? I'm in the middle of paper mâchéing my kitchen with biodegradable paper I made in my backyard using the Egyptian Nile method. In fact my kid might be behind one of these walls for all I know.

Stacy Morrison 8 pts

I'm actually hoping I have an RCMM neighbor who wants to help out with my son's projects. Is that wrong of me?

Conversation from Twitter

thewino
thewino

WendiAarons Trying to eat a mozzarella stick with his nose has now made my list of all-time fave phrases.

WendiAarons
WendiAarons

thewino Why, thank you! (And he did try it. Twice.)

WendiAarons
WendiAarons

sellabitmum theBitchinWife Thank you, you wonderful women.

Conversation from Facebook

Leta Hamilton
Leta Hamilton

I remember coming home from a babysitting gig as a 7th grader and my mom had made my science project board for me - it looked amazing. She did such a great job.

Carrie Jackson Matsuo
Carrie Jackson Matsuo

LOL, this is why our school is going to Science Projects Worked on AT SCHOOL only! What a huge difference it makes in the students' learning :)

Tomi Anderson
Tomi Anderson

Guilty. So very guilty. My son did, well did some of his 1st Powerpoint for a school project this week. I didn't do much *fingers crossed*

olive m'lou
olive m'lou

ahhh!!!! my biggest pet peeve... i too have kids with valentine boxes covered with stickers and bandaids, and it doesn't seem to bother them that others have jewel-encrusted/remote controlled/etc projects. i make sure it gets completed with enough blank space covered, and that's it. i'm not sure that those moms are craft-deprived, i just think that they are too competitive. aren't they also teaching their children that their ideas just aren't good enough? ok, i admit it, i have a soapbox about this...

Debbi Hager Spiegel
Debbi Hager Spiegel

How about this...on Meet the Teacher Nite, the parents were given the assignment to make a suitcase out od a cereal box!