Bio
Stacy is an editor, writer, author, mother, blogger and former magazine editor. But her fancy title is editor in chief of BlogHer.com.
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

When A Mother Loses A Child

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 39
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

The unimaginable happens. A mother loses a child. This happened just now. To Anna See who blogs at An Inch of Gray. And because we are all so connected, by our stories and our words and our electronics and our RSS feeds and Tweets, the news goes around like an electric shock, touching not only those who knew her, her family, her writing, but also spinning out to so many of those who didn't.

But regardless of which circles we travel in, the reaction is practically the same: hand to mouth, palm over chest. We cannot speak that these things happen; our heart cannot bear that this could actually be true. How could a young boy who was headed off to first day of school on Wednesday—grinning and sweet and so alive for the camera, in the photos posted proudly on his mother's blog—not be here today?

And how can we reach out and touch her, and buoy her up in a mother's unspeakable grief? We leave notes on her blog. We watch the stream on Twitter, hoping to learn more about her, about her son, to make them fully-fleshed characters in our minds, as if by doing that we can carry them somewhere safe, where they're always together. We close our eyes and send brainwaves and love and strength, and then we pray, or shoo away the specter, lest we invite it in.

A woman grieves

But I wonder sometimes if we should be offering privacy in these searing moments of public grief, circling the wagons and turning away. Is it unwelcome that we lean forward, even if we come with full hearts and best intentions? Instead of offering solace, are we instead chasing away our own fears that our own life could be the next one to be touched with such a brutal force, changed instantly by fate's meandering storms? Is it fair to involve ourselves with her story?

I take a moment and try to imagine how I'd react, but it's impossible to touch such an experience until you are there. And in the end, perhaps, this is the one thing we must know about other people's tragedies: We can't possibly imagine what they're feeling. It belongs to them alone. Nor can we speed up the process of moving through the grief, shorten the labor involved in starting again. And we can't take it back.

And so maybe that's why we lean forward. To bear witness. To give the seismic event its due attention. To acknowledge its bigness and draw her into our communities, all of them.

The loss of a child seems too much for one woman to bear. And so maybe it's okay that all of us instantly reach in, and to try to carry our share.

  • 39
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
joyfulchallenge 28 pts

We lost our 14 year old son in 2008. I will forever treasure those who reached out to us - even when I could not speak and chose to ignore them, I still appreciated the gesture. What hurt is those that did nothing. Reading your posts helps me realize perhaps they did nothing because they didn't know what to do...what to say...etc. I need to move beyond the pain that I still carry from those I feel "let me down" during this journey. What I can offer is that the support I received online, from my blogging friends and neighbors, is what carried some days. I realize this post is somewhat dated but I can share that this mother STILL needs support. Pain from child loss never goes away. It is a loss that most only give support to in the first few months. Those first months though are the ones that you are most numb. It is the one year anniversary, the milestones and the moments after in which you need the most support. Or, at least that's how it has been for me personally. I don't know Anna but I offer my prayers to her as she faces this new reality.

betherann 8 pts

I think bearing witness is important -- others seeing the loss, seeing the pain, is so validating.  Especially with pregnancy loss, which is often treated as inconsequential when really it is one of the greatest, most unfair, most senseless losses.  My daughter was stillborn in November, and I want people to know our story, to see, and to see God working in the midst of it.  Anything less would render our already senseless loss even more senseless. 

leiasmommy 6 pts

I gave birth to my daughter in October.  We found out a few days before this that she was dead. Dead in my stomach.  I had to deliver her dead.  It hands down is the worst thing I've ever done in my life.  I am a changed person because of her.  It has only been 4 months, and the grief is still unbearable.  We want to try again soon (I'm almost 36) and pray it ends better.  www.letterstoleia.ca

betherann 8 pts

 leiasmommy My daughter was stillborn this past November.  We are in a similar place, I think.  A terrible one.  Big hugs.

jollymilly 6 pts

Losing a child is something unimaginable for me. I have two children and they are the light of my life even though they may be difficult at times. I could never advise anyone how they should bear the loss of a child. I have a religion and so I would use my faith to help me and believe that they have gone to a better place. It is a such a tough thing to come to terms with. All the best for those who have suffered such a loss.

SusanPutman 9 pts

Stacy,

Such a nice post, thoughtful and kind.

One of the best things said to me was, "I can never know how you feel, but I want to be there for you." It's a special grief, bigger than most so she'll need lots of quiet time. And there's a lot riding on her because she has a living child who is grieving too. And a sweetheart who just lost a son. Now all will gather and support in loving ways. But in six weeks the black cloud will roll in and she may wonder if she has value or life itself has value. That's when my friends true colors showed themselves most beautifully, the daily calls, the laughs they forced from me as we remembered my child together had me coming back into the world we all inhabit together. Yes hang in there for her Bloghers, for her it will not fade away, so I will wait a month and then send a little message of hope and condolence, perhaps something riotously funny if I can find it, every week for a while that she might have the courage to go on.

jw27 9 pts

Stacy,

This is such a thoughtful piece. I lost my daughter as an infant and so many people tried to push their way into our grief, thinking they knew what we needed most. Along with grieving our daughter we were left with unhappy relatives and lost friendships because others just did not understand the way that we needed to grieve. I think the most important thing every can do for Anna is give her space and time and let her know that we are all here when she needs us.

Thank you for writing such an important piece.

Jessica

alexandraRS 23 pts

Oh, believe me, I thought about this as well.

But, then, I thought: maybe we can create a village around Anna, one posted comment at a time.

And, when she is ready to read: in 6 months or 1 year or 2 years...when she is ready, she'll feel this love.

Her son's life is validated, he's made real, our love for him is palpable: I think to be alone, with no ripple felt in the universe at such a seismic catastrophe, I think that would be worse.

I'd rather err on the side of showing too much love, than not showing enough love.

Stacy Morrison 147 pts

Anna's good friend Kate, @BigPieceofCake, wrote a wonderful post about Anna, about the community's reactions, about where Anna finds peace and solace, about how people can help, about what bloggers can do, how we can reach out to her and let her know we are thinking of her. I'm so happy to give Kate the "final word" on my musing about how we can reach out, and whether it's okay if we do it. Here's the link to her post: http://www.thebigpieceofcake.com/2011/09/for-anna-see.html

And here's the sisterhood that is motherhood. There's nothing quite like it. May no mother ever feel alone.

southmainmuse 16 pts

I can imagine incomprehensible grief. My prayers are strength for the family to endure the next few days, weeks and months.

kyranp 6 pts

There are no words. So sad. I offer my prayers, but I think I'll refrain from clicking through at this time, because I didn't know Anna or her blog before, and it would feel like I was intruding. I wouldn't walk into a visitation simply because I read a stranger's obituary, no matter how much it moved me, and it feels right to let the same sensibility be my guide here.

As for those who consider themselves to be Anna's virtual neighbors and acquaintances, I imagine it as important and as appropriate to communicate support and presence through blog comments as it is to come bearing food and flowers in the offline neighborhood.

I agree that situations like these really show up how rapidly our definitions of community and friendship are changing. Faster than the social code can catch up.

fnfkathy 5 pts

You could not have spoken with more truth than what you have right here. I lost my brother, sister-in-law, best friend and husband within a short time from each other...When people chimed in, especially those I did not know that well I was taken and offended by the public drama. I resented those that did not know me trying to jump on the band wagon. Thank you for your thoughts which provide healing after all this time..."It truly was more than one (I) could bear and I never realized until now that perhaps more people related to my grief than I realized" and wanted to send their wishes of love and peace. I cannot imagine losing a child...

FarewellStranger 14 pts

I can't even imagine. My heart feels physically heavy in my chest. I don't know Anna - I hadn't read her blog - and yet it's all I can think about. Unspeakably awful.

I think I would want to be surrounded by that cyber love, but you're right that we can't know. I can only hope that by sending love and thoughts and prayers we can each lighten her load, just a little.

RottenMom 5 pts

Your last two sentences are why I left my prayers on Anna's blog. It's far too much for one woman to bear.

K A B L O O E Y 7 pts

Thank you for being able to articulate what so many are feeling. I think the outpouring of deep feeling stems from 2 places: those who knew her, even if only through her writing, could tell what a kind, generous person she is and we love her for the way she wrote about things that mattered most to her with grace and humor. And second; we moms put ourselves in her place, at the abyss, and know it could have been us. We think of the moment before the pain and can't imagine ever feeling whole again. My thoughts and prayers are with her now.

Lady Jennie 15 pts

I knew exactly what this was about when I saw the title, as it's all I can think about. This post expresses it perfectly. But even though we cannot speed up the grieving process or keep the spectre at bay, we must close ranks around the gaping hole. For even if she looks down and sees nothing but black, she shouldn't see that when she looks around.

zookbooknook 8 pts

Thank you for saying what is in our hearts and minds. I am praying for Anna and her family, hoping in some way all of our prayers and thoughts for her family help to carry her through this time.

Deb Rox 22 pts

My prayers go out to Anna and her family.

Mama One to Three 18 pts

This is so well said. I think we would all bear a part of each other's burden if we could. It's impossible of course when the pain is, as you said, seismic. thank you for writing this tonight.

My Son Has 2 Brains 8 pts

Incredible post, about unimaginable pain.

Julie McGuire 6 pts

It's just unspeakable. My heart and prayers are with Anna and her family.

DesiValentine4 646 pts

I agree with Mom101 I think the best we can do is be present and accessible, and do our best to honour the wishes of the bereaved. Grief is such a personal journey. Loss is such an excruciating education. Respect, and grave, are all that remain to give.

Mom101 10 pts

This is so beautifully written Stacy. I think we all grieve and heal in different ways--some are comforted by solitude, some by company. The most we can do is determine what the bereaved wants of us. Even if it goes against our own inclinations. That's the part I find hard.

Judy Schwartz Haley 37 pts

this is so heartbreaking. it just takes my breath away.

I think it's important to remember that everybody grieves differently. Some people are buoyed up by the outpouring of love, and others feel oppressed by it. Some feel abandoned if they don't receive that outpouring.

There are no easy answers, other than respect what she state's specifically. If she asks for privacy, honor that. Otherwise, send more love. Also, remember her months from now.

I heard a quote once, related to my own cancer battle, but it fits here "people give you three months to grieve, and a year to have cancer. then they expect you to just get on with your life." for my part, that has been extremely true.

Please don't make this quote true for her - remember it 6 months from now, a year from now... there is no "just get on with your life."

Stacy Morrison 147 pts

Judy Schwartz Haley Beautifully said, Judy. Thank you for sharing. I wish you peace and strength on your cancer journey. I'll be rooting for you.

janasthinkingplace 7 pts

As a mother who has lost a child, I can tell you that anyone who reaches out and shows their love is healing. My heart hurts for her and I pray that she allows her IRL friends and her online friends to wrap her in hugs and love and finds comfort in knowing that so many people love her and will cherish the memories of her son.

BlondieChicago 24 pts

How odd -- I just wrote about this topic on my blog this morning: http://talesfromclarkstreet.blogspot.com/2011/09/bravest-women-i-know-on-loss-of-child.html

It's been my experience with my 3 local friends who have lost children that the most powerful thing we can do is listen. Hugs also help.

lauriewrites 27 pts

And I just have to add that her son was just a gorgeous boy who looked to possess the sweetest heart. That alone? Worth shouting from the rooftops that he was here. He was here and mattered, and always always will.

lauriewrites 27 pts

I think if I lean in with careful attention to how the person responds, not offering judgment or filtering the event through my own lens, and prepared to lean back if that's what they want? That's okay.

It's hard to know what to say to someone who has experienced something for which there are no words. But in my worst moments of pain, which have not approached anything this crushing, it was always better to know someone was there than to feel that no one cared or was avoiding me.

AnnsRants 11 pts

I had this same fear about respecting her privacy, and then I remembered that death is painfully public and so at least we can usher some support along with it.

Also, I heard from her close friends that they are a deeply religious family and that prayers are appreciated. As mothers and bloggers, and on the cusp of the 9/11 anniversary I know that so many of us are sharing in this pain today--a pain no person should have to every carry.

Rita Arens 266 pts

AnnsRants Good point, Ann. I just said a prayer for them.

Stacy Morrison 147 pts

AnnsRants Agree, agree. And yes, many, many prayers for them and the long road they have to walk together. Grief is such a malleable beast, and yet, sometimes it's good company, too.

Conversation from Twitter

kyranpittman
kyranpittman

bklynstacy lemead FarewellStrangr mom101 crazy-busy-hustle day. Looking forward to reading this as my reward!

hellokirst
hellokirst

bklynstacy this has made my heart ache. I don't know them, but I can't even begin to imagine.

Conversation from Facebook

Rubber Chicken Madness
Rubber Chicken Madness

All I can do is hold this family in my heart and prayers. I cannot imagine the sorrow. I simply cannot.

Janet Forrest
Janet Forrest

I'm so very very sad. I cannot even begin to imagine the depth of her grief.

Chelle Newton
Chelle Newton

This was the son of someone who went to my high school. And I have a 12 ear old son. It's so very sad.