Bio
Creating Motherhood. Seven years of almost daily posts and photographs: includes thoughts on being a single mother by choice, navigating the world of...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

I Didn't Look Like Me: Where Does Feminine Come From?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

A few weeks ago, I went to a party and there was a professional photographer there. A few days after the party, the organizers started tweeting a few photographs as a teaser. The images were beautiful. People that I had stood around and talked to had been captured perfectly: soft, glowing, and still authentically the people that I remembered meeting.

When the e-mail came that more photos were available to see I was excited to click through to look for photos of myself. That is something you will rarely find me say. Towards the end of the collection I saw the photo. Me. Standing at an island in a kitchen. Obviously a plaid shirt. Obviously my hair was pulled back into a messy nest of a bun. Obviously my face had no make-up on except for the party red lipstick I thought I was going to wear so well. My plaid messenger bag, the only "purse" I have that isn't a diaper bag or a backpack, was flung across my chest. And in my profile I looked hard. Tough. Maybe even mean.

And the part that caused me to literally choke up? I didn't look the least bit feminine. I didn't look like me. Or at least the image of me that I had of me in my head. The one that I thought that the world was seeing. I think I thought the world was seeing some sort of Earth Mother type. Amazon Woman type. Round and red. But seeing the image of me through the lens of a stranger proved otherwise.

This led me to do some serious thinking. Which led me to realize something that is going to be hard to admit but it is the honest truth -- I think I turned in my Woman card the minute I decided to become a single mother. Or maybe I stopped being a woman when I became a full time caregiver. The moments happened almost on top of each other so it is hard to know which is chicken and which is egg. All I know is that 2003 is the year I stopped feeling feminine.

Sure I had a couple moments left in me of party dresses and high-heeled shoes, but the walls of womanhood were swiftly crumbling down. And the tricky part is that I have no idea what it is that was behind the fortress of my femininity. No idea what I am now that that part of me has crumbled away and turned into shiny pebbles scattered about.

What I realize though, as I struggle to comprehend this loss of a part of myself, is that I want it back.

This is where I am totally and absolutely and 100% lost. Because where does feminine come from? Does it come from boobs? Hair? Shoes? Makeup? Having a small butt? I'm at a total loss. Once upon a time my femininity came from other people. I felt like an attractive woman because I dated men that told me I was attractive and being with them allowed me to feel more attractive and I was just all that and a bag of peppermints.

And then I got a career and I stopped really caring about dating because I knew it would be there for me when I was ready -- like a scarf that one is forever knitting. I would reach a landing pad within my career path and then I could relax and I could focus back on dating and marriage and family and apple pie.

Except my life didn't take that path. It did a bit of a zig and then a bit of a zag, and the next thing you know, I'm practically having a virgin birth.

And motherhood didn't make me suddenly feel like more of a woman. If anything it enhanced my inner schlub to a pretty scary degree. I now had a total legit excuse to go an extra day or two between washing my hair or changing out of my yoga pants. Speaking of hair, I can count on one hand the number of times I have worn it down since W was born. And the freakish insanity that happened to my body through fertility treatments to pregnancy to post-pregnancy certainly didn't turn on any Aretha Franklin anthems.

Most of the time, I see my body as part failure and the rest of the time I see it as blah. It's

  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
saraplain-n-small 5 pts

your post hit a major nerve with me. too much angst has written itself all over my face and i really, REALLY don't like it. like you, it was photos taken by others that made me aware of it - i totally don't see that person in the mirror every day. but she is there in too many pictures taken at family gatherings, even when i think i'm doing well, having fun, being happy.

really not sure what to do about it myself other than to continue with the yoga and counseling i began this summer. i'd love to know what you come up with and will check others here who've commented on your post to see what things they recommend.

thanks again for sharing. you may not be aware but it was very brave and giving of you to write that, and some of us probably appreciate it more than you know.

best wishes to you and congratulations on winning at motherhood - which you obviously do!

Calliope 5 pts

Just wanted to thank everyone that left such kind and insightful comments on this post. All were incredibly helpful - even if to make me realize that I am not alone in this struggle.

Calliope blogs about Alzheimer's, Infertility, and Single Motherhood at http://creatingmotherhood.com

At Home Parent 5 pts

I'm not a single mother, but I am the At-Home Parent of a 3.5yo and a 10mo old. Girl, it's EASY to get out of the habit of looking feminine when you are up to your elbows in parenting!

My surefire remedies:

1. A supportive bra. Get fitted and buy a pricey one.

2. Clothes that fit - whether from the thrift store or department store, make sure what you buy is right for your body right now.

3. Most important of all: Spend time on yourself. Send the baby to grandma's or hire a babysitter, but damnit, you need to reconnect with your body! Take it for a nice long bath/shower accompanied by the relaxing beverage of your choice. Soap it down, feel it up, see where it leads, but most of all treat yourself like a woman needs to be treated from head to toe!

BeyondPrenatals 5 pts

Debra

www.BeyondPrenatals.com ( http://www.BeyondPrenatals.com )

Glad to help! Please be in touch and let me know if you need help, want an article on this topic, or just let me know if fixing the thyroid problem worked!

BarnMaven 5 pts

I think the concept of 'femininity' is very amorphous and impossible to pin down. Is it having long flowing hair? Perfect makeup and nails? A swan-like neck? Being thin? Being curvy?

Being a woman is more than having the plumbing to prove it. But women are so diverse in their appearance and in their mindsets that I think it comes down to the individual person and what's important to them.

I'm a single mom, I have horses and chickens and irrigation to fix and stalls to clean. I have housework to do and a yard to mow, a garden to tend. Sometimes I wear skirts but mostly I wear pants. When I'm out fixing fence in jeans, a t-shirt, a baseball cap and work gloves, I don't look very girly, but I revel in the fact that I'm a strong woman, who can do things on her own. When I dress up for the Christmas party and some of the guys line up to ask me to dance and they smile at me, I revel in the fact that I can be pretty and...gosh darn it, SEXY even! I'm a whole package.

As are you.

Mary a/k/a BarnMaven blogs at http://www.barnmaven.typepad.com about single parenting, living with ADHD, too many animals to count and dealing with ADHD/Bipolar kids.

TickleFest 5 pts

This has been going around in my brain lately too. I love the Own Your Beauty campaign, and I have even been trying to take pictures of myself periodically through November as part of the assignment. But, honestly? I feel like I am really lucky my husband thinks I'm so hot.

Most of the time, if I catch of glimpse of myself, I have my hair in an unruly ponytail, and I'm almost always wearing scarves to disguise that I am a few sizes bigger than I'd like to be. However, when I see pictures of myself with scarves, they don't really hide as much as they draw attention to.

So - I have this image in my brain of what I looked like oh, a couple years ago, and that is what I cling to. Is that wrong? I leave my house at 7:30 in the morning, and get home at 6:00 at night - just in time for dinner, bath time, some snuggles, stories and bed time for my two little guys. Then my hubby and I have a chance to catch up and hang out a little. Then it's to bed and start all over again. I envy people who have space in their days to go to the gym. Trying to even fit in a walk for health reasons is a stretch during the darker winter months.

I don't really know what makes me feel feminine. Although the jeans I bought at the Cowboy store sure do look good on me and when I wear them I feel like I have those long legs of my youth. I strut a little in those jeans. And I like my broad shoulders.

And yesterday I got everyone new toothbrushes - cause you're supposed to trade new ones in every month or so - and today my smile feels especially bright! So - there - I ended on a positive.

I feel pretty - oh so pretty!

Liesl Garner, Fashion Marketing Writer for the FleeceFootwear UGG Boots Blog ( http://fleecefootwear.com/ugg-boots-blog/ )

Let's start a BeautyRevolution ( http://somuchmorethangoodlooks.tumblr.com/ )!

Jennymoomeow 5 pts

Boy did you hit home. After having kids, something changed for me too. Some days you go for "comfy" and some days you go for "attractive and other days your look is pure "mom putting the kids first."

For me, feeling feminine means getting fixed up. I do something with my hair besides the usual pulled back do, put on my make up, wear a lacy push-up bra, don't forget to shave, and then get out there. Stand up straight with some confidence and a smile. Make eye contact with strangers and somehow it clicks.

theoutcast 5 pts

I actually thought alot about this post last night. :)

One thing that I find very feminine is when women advocate for each other, like you see happening in this conversation. Social partnerships among women exist naturally in ways that are uniquely feminine.

This includes at the workplace. I gave an example earlier about a co-worker who was uniquely feminine. I always remember that she could stand her ground with her male boss, advocating for herself and paying women in the office fairly. Among the women she encouraged independent home ownership, valued a loving marriage, enjoyed nice things, etc.

Being around her taught me that feminine energy really shines in women (and even in men who identify strongly with the feminine)who really notice the beauty in themselves, others and the world around them.

The most feminine women I have known seemed to feel free to express themselves in ways that improve the lives of everyone around them.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

Palaverer 5 pts

I feel like a woman because I have the body parts that society says belongs to one. I feel like a woman because I sometimes engage in behaviors that society says are essential to one who has the body parts that I do. If society did not tell me I was a woman, I wouldn't know that I was.

I suspect that, without society's labels, none of us would "feel" like a particular gender. Differences in body parts could be likened to differences in skin tone, body shape, or height. Behaviors that we put in gendered boxes could instead be (correctly) recognized as sheer difference in personality.

Bottom line: stop letting society dictate who you are. You don't need their labels.

JennaHatfield 10 pts

Girlfriend, I want to come over, eat some cake with cream cheese icing and give you a big ole hug. Times twelve.

For me? Hmm. I'm not 100% certain. I do totally understand what you're saying. There are days when I don't feel feminine. At all. Like, uh, today? I stayed in my PJ pants, an old college T-shirt and a hoodie from our last vacation to NC. I was barefoot, too, even when I went to get the mail. My hair still had one bobby pin in it from when I washed my face last night, but the hair was kind of twisted and sticking straight up. I was a class freaking act, my friend. I did shower before I went to rehearsal this evening. I even put on makeup. So, there's that.

But my femininity doesn't come from makeup. Or the cute skirt I bought earlier this season. Or the necklace that I wear on Steelers Sunday (or, this week, Monday night). It doesn't come from the sexy pictures I had taken -- for myself as much as for my husband. It doesn't come from high heels, because I don't wear them. It surely doesn't come from a small butt because I checked that at the door in 2003 as well.

But it's there. Within me. I am a woman. Sometimes I'm a sexy woman. Sometimes I'm a down home woman. I'm always an intelligent, loving, caring, compassionate, giving, woman. (And sometimes I'm a snarky woman, but that's a different comment.) And maybe, just maybe, that's where my femininity comes from. (The compassionate part, not the snarky part. Or, really, maybe both.) Not that my very-male husband isn't compassionate. But my inner me, my love for the life I'm living, my me at my very core... it's feminine. Even if I really, really, really like sports and getting dirty and toys for boys more than toys for girls.

It's in there. And yours is too. And I bet it's tied to how you treat others and how you interact with them too. (

And girl, plaid shirts are fine. Hush yo' red-lipsticked mouth. ;)

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

Mrs. Yeater 5 pts

In high-school, I was attractive and the boys let me know, but I was NOT feminine. I was a bit like Katherina of Shakespeare's "The Taming of the Shrew." A beautiful woman, sure, but Not feminine. It was only when I accepted my physical femininity and dressed and behaved accordingly that I became feminine. It is an identity and a choice to be feminine- something I have to remind myself. Many times, however, especially with single mothers and mothers in general, Feminine stops calling as often and Maternity takes its form in Labor. I do not have children of my own, but many of my friends are mothers, and my own mother was a single parent of two, and I have great respect and sympathy for the hard work that goes into caring for the family in all its ways. As we got older, and consequently certain things were easier, I remember that she made a point to Dress even to go to the supermarket- just to feel feminine and like the gorgeous woman she is.

Mrs. Yeater

I love my husband, I love my home, and I love to write ( http://mrsyeater.blogspot.com ).

Theresa Milstein 5 pts

I think we get to a point when we remember ourselves at a particular time, even if we don't reflect it in our daily lives.

I've seen others who have "given up" after having children. I also know people who go through too much trouble and it shows because they look fake. I shave my legs, wear some makeup, and make an effort to dress nicely. I don't wear heels, but I don't wear yoga pants unless I'm exercising. I imagine what I'd look like if I was photographed, and that usually gets me to make an effort.

http://theresamilstein.blogspot.com

mamacat3 5 pts

I don't think there is any one magic bullet, but this is what worked for me today:

wearing a fragrance I love.

reading this poem: http://www.poemhunter.com/poem/phenomenal-woman/

jenn-adou 5 pts

My femininity comes from within... not from what I'm wearing or how others perceive me.

I am a woman. I AM a woman. And I can be anything I want to be. I can be a frump. I can glam it up. I can rock it out with my kids while wearing day old yoga pants.

Being feminine, to me, is all about being true to myself - all of myself - the good, the bad AND the ugly because really, what else can I be?

Gwenn 5 pts

Recently a gay man who had seen some of my video blogs emailed me to tell me that, as a natural blonde, I simply HAD to wear make-up. While I found it both funny and infuriating that someone who has probably been judged by old-fashioned ideas of what's socially acceptable on a regular basis would do it to me, his comment did bring home a point for me:

I am feminine because I present myself as I like to be seen and not how anyone else thinks I should be seen.

The key for me is choice. As long as my appearance is a choice as opposed to a frumpy look that I'm sporting because I'm too tired or sick to do anything else, then I feel feminine.

Great post and lots of interesting comments!

painting every person's portrait, www.onefaceatatime.com ( http://www.onefaceatatime.com )

Calliope 5 pts

Beautiful site! Looking forward to diving in.

Calliope blogs about Alzheimer's, Infertility, and Single Motherhood at http://creatingmotherhood.com

Calliope 5 pts

(my profile pic is from year 2 of my fertility treatments- meaning 3 years before I became pregnant...so, ahem, me too)

Calliope blogs about Alzheimer's, Infertility, and Single Motherhood at http://creatingmotherhood.com

Calliope 5 pts

I actually have been recently diagnosed with a thyroid disease (woo!) but I hadn't thought about it linking back into hormones, etc. Interesting...

Calliope blogs about Alzheimer's, Infertility, and Single Motherhood at http://creatingmotherhood.com

NancyRoxanne 5 pts

First I just want to say while reading your post I personally found you beautiful and your words moved me to tears. And sure it's easy for me to tell you that beauty is within but I'm the woman who won't meet up with old friends because I'm embarrassed by the extra weight I carry from my last pregnancy 20 months ago ( 25 years after my first and 17 years after my last)....after going through a divorce when my oldest 4 children were only 9, 5, 2 and 6 months I never anticipated being a single parent for the next 15 years- but I was. My confidence and femininity came at that time from the fact that I was a survivor of an abusive marriage and that I didn't "need a man"....And now here I am happy and loved so well by this beautiful younger man who is an amazing father to our daughter and all I can concentrate on, at times, is that I will always be older and how my jeans no longer fit...what a waste of time I know! I too hate seeing pictures of myself (especially since I am a photographer) since it doesn't match how I feel inside...(and btw my profile pic was taken a month PRE pregnancy lol!)...I try to do little things like fix my hair and put on a little make up even when I am just at home on mommy duty to make myself feel good and 'feminine'....lucky for me my guy makes me feel like he only sees me as beautiful all the time but if I do not feel it myself it puts a damper on it. Ugh! How sad that as women we do this to ourselves! But in the end I wouldn't trade my life's journey and the wrinkles that came with it or my 5 pregnancies and the extra pounds that came with them for all the temporary outer beauty in the world! So to answer the question, what DOES make me feel feminine is the power I have gained in being a strong independent woman and the 5 children I have brought into this world who are currently making it a better more beautiful place!

BeyondPrenatals 5 pts

Debra

www.BeyondPrenatals.com ( http://www.BeyondPrenatals.com )

This may sound quite simple and it is...women are supposed to have different amounts of hormones than men and when the balance is off, some women feel/act more masculine. It sounds like you have been through a lot hormone-wise with the fertility treatments, pregnancy, postpartum, and having to be super mom and super dad all by yourself. Some women have a hard time getting their thyroid and hormones back to normal after pregnancy. Here is a good book about balancing your hormones through food. You may also like to add massage or reflexology. Good luck!

theoutcast 5 pts

In my stay at home mom days, I would envy the energy other women had to put on nicer clothes. Returning to work and having a reason to dress up has helped me.

I think more positive messaging would help. Women are taught that all the sexy, pretty stages are pre-motherhood then there are few examples of where we go as women (on so many levels) after the baby arrives.

I figured things out once I had the energy and time to treat myself better. I have tips that I find help me on my blog. Look for "The Good Life" page.

Feminity is very much in how a person carries themselves, too. I worked with someone who did not look classically beautiful but she was very feminine. Similar to Jennifer Aniston in her uniqueness but She always looked clean, polished and fresh. Beautiful!

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

etowndz 5 pts

I have been a stay-at-home mom for the last three years. And now, finding myself pregnant again and my kids in preschool (i.e. I'm not taking them to one activity or another), the SHLUMPY stereotype has whacked me even harder. Maternity yoga pants and sweatshirts for days on end. I don't love it, but I'm often at a loss on what to do with it. Things that help me feel more feminine:

1. Getting my hair cut and colored, aaaahhh.
2. Pedicure.
3. Wearing a skirt, even my super-comfy-casual jersey-knit ones from Old Navy.
4. My pretty shirt that has the knotted detail at the bust.
5. My slightly-silly-but-comfortable silver ballet flats.
6. Jewelry, even just a little.

Honestly, I'm a total bum when it comes to fashion. Stacey and Clinton are going to come and arrest me. But I find the days that I put in that teensy bit of effort to look nicer, I feel better. And I feel more feminine.

So girl it up. It can be fun, even for the not-super-girly among us.

ardeeann 5 pts

I am also an earth mother type although I probably look more like someone's peasant grandmother, oh, that's right...I am peasant grandma to three beautiful children. I am short, very fat and not particularly attractive. None of that matters, I am a woman through and through because that is who I am. I don't need feminine to tell me I am woman, I just need me, my inner voice saying, I am a proud woman. That is it, that is the mystery in my book.

Good luck reclaiming your feelings of womanhood.

Ardee-ann

http://ardeeeichelmann.livejournal.com

Chicgeek 5 pts

I like your post. My moment of shock was a business trip to the far east hearing my Asian counterparts tell me that I looked pregnant (I wasn't) and needed to start putting myself first. (Many of them had never met me in person, go figure.) Although, tack is not their stongest quality, I appreciated their candor. What I discovered is that it takes baby steps to get your feminine self back, especially if we've let outselves go. Start with a manicure. You'll be surprised how feminine it makes you feel. Then go for a good hair cut and color, if it's in your budget. A pedicure works too! Throw out your grandma underwear and go for younger, prettier styles. Heels, too. Oh, did I forget jewelry. It works. Good Luck.

wellwellwellfaith 5 pts

Love your post. Recently thought some about this. I realize that single motherhood has required (or at least strongly encouraged) me to leave part of me at the door. It's the vulnerable, feminine part. I'm now in my 9th year as a single mom and I've decided that I need that part of me as well as the capable, reasonable, get-it-all-done-with-a-grin-on-my-face part of me. So I'm trying to reconnect. If you see her, send her in my direction. Thanks.