Bio
I have been writing about family, parenting, politics and religion since 2000. My work has appeared on Babble.com, Literary Mama.com, in Adoptive Fam...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

A Police Officer Yelled At My Daughter: White Privilege Doesn't Rub Off

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 34
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

A couple of years ago, Harvard professor, Henry Louis Gates, was arrested on the front porch of his Cambridge, Massachusetts home. At the time, I wrote a piece for Babble.com (which was also reprinted in Adoptive Families Magazine) about what the incident meant for parents of Black children -- especially, perhaps, white parents of Black children -- and what such children ought to be taught about the police.

Police

I had two small Black daughters and was torn between how to represent the police to them. Should I tell them that Officer Friendly was there to help them? Or teach them to avoid uniforms whenever possible?

It was still a theoretical question until yesterday. Yesterday, my six year-old got a personalized lesson about who the police are when she met her very first police officer, face-to-face. Here’s how it went:

My daughter was sitting behind me in the car when I pulled into the street on my green light. Once I was in the middle of a very busy intersection (Route 1, in Lower Bucks County, Pennsylvania), an unmarked police car hit its lights and siren and came into the intersection, cutting me off.

I stopped to wait for it to pass, assuming it was going after some car in the cross-traffic. While I waited, however, several cars followed it, against the light.

The cars were not marked in any special way, and I suddenly became worried that the green light wasn’t my light after all. I was puzzling it out when a huge slam hit the window of my door. It was a police officer’s hand.

My daughter burst into terrified tears and began sobbing and begging me “what’s going on, Mama Shannon?”

I rolled down the window, wondering what was happening, and the cop who had hit my window, his partner just behind him, began shouting at me, calling me a [bleeping bleep], telling me to get my head out my [bleep] and didn’t I see this was a funeral procession?

(Honestly, no, I didn’t see that. As I said, neither the police car, nor the procession cars were marked in any way. I suppose their lights were on, but so were mine and everyone else’s because it was overcast and raining. The cop car only hit the siren and lights after I was in the intersection.)

The police officer and his partner continued to harangue me -- at the top of their lungs -- asking me what the [bleeping bleep] I thought I was doing.

My daughter continued wailing and began to hyperventilate, still begging me to tell her what was happening.

Throughout all this I was very calm. I realized now that I had made an honest, and fairly understandable mistake, rather than stupidly blundered into traffic against my signal. I vaguely wondered when the police would get to writing me a ticket but was mostly concerned that my daughter was hysterical and that if these men knew they were shouting curses not just at an adult, but a little girl, maybe they would take it down a notch and reassure her in some way.

I (stupidly, regrettably) rolled her window down and said, quite calmly, “Please don’t speak to me this way in front of my child.”

The second cop, at this point, waved his fist in my daughter’s general direction and shouted, “I don’t care!”

By now, the cars in the funeral procession had passed. The light changed and now I was sitting in the middle of a busy intersection in front of a red light. The cops looked at me and my daughter, shouted, “sit there in the intersection and I hope you get hit!” got back in their car and drove away.

Of course I didn’t snap a phone photo of the car. Of course I didn’t even notice what jurisdiction they were from. Of course I didn’t ask for their badges or names (not that I believe they would have given me that information, seeing as how they neither ticketed me, nor helped me cross the intersection safely and in fact, wished aloud for me -- with a child in my car -- to be hit.

It took about an hour for me to calm my daughter down. “But Mama Shannon, we didn’t take off our seat belts!” she wailed. (This is the most important traffic violation she knows of.) “That man looked at me very mean and said ‘I don’t care! I hope you get hit!’”

So much for Officer Friendly. My daughter now has her own opinion of the police and she has

  • 34
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Shellireads 17 pts

Tell your children that policeman can be good or bad. That they have good and bad days much like anyone else and that the best thing to do is to try to obey what they tell you and keep calm when talking to them. 

 

To tell your children that the police are their friends is to do them a serious disservice. Some police officers are racists and it is better for your children to be a little cautious than for them to be too vulnerable, which they would be if they trusted the officers too much.

 

I tell my children that the police have authority and it is best to avoid them whenever possible, as one can never know if they are racist, mean, or just having a bad day. Any combination can spell disaster for a civilian but especially for a civilian of color.

dana2222 7 pts

Really, Skip Gates? He's a racists as is Obama. Bad comparison. FBI investigated the officer and turns out he was a boy scout and did nothing wrong. It did go to show that Obama isn't for all people. it played a HUGE part (I live in MA) in the special election where Scott Brown won.

kbriski 5 pts

Sorry to say a lot of cops are like that to ANYONE black white or otherwise....it's a power trip....this had nothing to do with your child's....they were just a#$%&&^%. I have come across quite a few in my day....and it's only gotten worse. I remember officer friendly in kinder-garden but as a

pre teen and teen cops were bad news....and I'm a white kid from an affluent suburb....

hilljo 7 pts

ALL people have to live with the fact that the law is personally regulated by those in position to do so (cops, judges, etc) and that they are also just people. Their job has nothing to do with how they are; they're just bad people to begin with whent they act like this.

direiter 6 pts

I couldn't quite understand the connection between the officers behavior toward you and the fact that your child is black, either. The officers' behavior was unexcusable, but at the same time, give them (and anyone else displaying erratic, angry behavior) a break. With their job, you have no idea what they may have encountered the night before... violence, domestic abuse, or a fatality at an intersection maybe?? You just don't know.

My husband is a retired EMT Firefighter and trust me, the situations that firefighters, paramedics, and police officers are exposed to are beyond what some people can imagine.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

direiter The connection is that this experience made me realize how sheltered I've been and how I need to teach my daughter something different from what I was taught. As for what the cops might have been through, there was absolutely NO excuse for their behavior. Slamming into my window? Screaming curses in my face and my child's? Abandoning me in an intersection they had trapped me in by their own behavior and hoping I get hit? No.I know EMTs and firefighters too. They would never, in a million years treat someone the way these guys treated us. I'm surprised you would associate your husband with this kind of behavior. Any public service worker should be ashamed of it and put as much distance between themselves and these guys as possible.

And as for them ever being on a domestic violence call, I would hope to God they never are. They struck me very much as abusers themselves. I hope they don't have partners or children of their own.

Alexandra Bartologimignano 6 pts

I get it, I totally get it. I have adopted kids from Russia who were old enough to know that the police were the bad guys. And over there, oftentimes they were. So every time they heard a siren here, they would quake in fear. (And we live in the city.) You're right-- it takes time and effort to train them for their future.

jacqueline.allain 22 pts

Wow. That's awful.

I'm sorry to self-promote, but I actually wrote about something similar to this a few days ago. As a white person, I have been dealt with in a gentler manner by the police than I suspect I would be if I were a person of color. Unfortunately, so many police officers are rude and entitled that I've had plenty of bad experiences.

My friend getting illegally searched, the UC-Davis incident, Sean Bell...these aren't isolated incidents. They are symptoms of a profoundly unjust flawed system that makes police officers feel like they have the authority to do whatever they want.

Graylin Whitts 23 pts

I've read this and I don't know what to make of it. It seems to me that you are just desperately trying to connect with the black experience. The fact that the police officers yelled at you, a white woman, first before even realizing you have black child, makes the title of your post...disingenuous. Just about as disingenuous as the rest of the post reads.

This incident, the way you describe it, had nothing to do with race. I'm black and I have had my share of "real" race problems with police officers. And it's really annoying that you tried to add this insignificant (in terms of its relation to race and police officers) incident into what is an important topic.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

Graylin Whitts Though I I can't say this incident would have gone differently if my daughter had been white, the upshot for me was that it got me thinking about the fact that this is something I need to start thinking about teaching her overtly. it isn't so much that this was a racial incident as it prodded me to think more about the problem.

Graylin Whitts 23 pts

Shannon LC Cate Here's the thing. You, again, imply that your daughter's race could've, might've, maybe have been a factor in the incident when clearly it was not. According to your account, the police officers were already angry and cursing at you before they even saw your daughter.

The police officers were so angry in fact, that they sped in front, blocking you off, then immediately hopped out of their car and began cursing you out. They only made an off-hand comment to your daughter after you told them not to talk to you that way. It's more like she was an innocent bystander that got in the crossfire.

So, if there was anything to talk about here, with this particular situation, I would think it would be more along the lines of- "The police weren't mad at you, they were mad a me and sometimes when people get angry at one person, they take it out on other people." Because in this particular situation that you described, that was the reality of it.

But you didn't see the reality of the situation. Instead, you chose to connect this incident with white privilege and the relations between black people and law enforcement? That along with the way the post reads, almost like fantasy, adds a bit fanaticism. And it's a little off putting to see you romanticize about a real problem, with real consequences, that affects real people in real life.

I hope your daughter never finds herself in a situation with the police where she is being targeted because of her race. Hell, I don't want anybody to find themselves in a situation where they are being treating unfairly by a police officer. It is truly one of the most powerless feelings you can ever.

I do hope that if you daughter does find herself in a situation that happens to everybody, regardless of race, gender etc that you can see the reality of the situation and address it appropriately and not turn it into something it's not.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

Graylin Whitts I'm sorry to hear it reads that way. I certainly have no investment in romanticising racism. I do however, have a huge investment in getting it right when raising my kids. There's a lot to think about getting right when you're as unusual a family as we are. I don't take anything for granted.

SeattleMoon 8 pts

I'm sorry for you and your daughter's bad experience.

There is a chance that you were treated badly because you were a women but that shouldn't matter. Police should not or anybody should not treat another human being like that. And if the police have "power", they should be held to more higher standards. They are supposed to "protect & serve", after all.

When my husband was driving (he's a Caucasian), he was stopped by a police who seemed to just want to flex his muscles. There are those in every profession.

As you say a "healthy dose of skepticism" won't hurt. There are even people who pretend to be a policeman and commit crimes. I'm sorry that your daughter had to learn the lesson so quickly but it might be for the best. And it might be for the best that at least you were there to comfort her.

Sally G 16 pts

Well said; very true, indeed. SeattleMoon

BBNeedsShews 5 pts

I've never met a cop that I liked or trusted. And I'm white.

Susan Sterikoff 8 pts

What a horrible experience. I think the idea of taking your daughter to the police station and having her meet friendly cops is a good idea, though. It is hard to teach that there are good and bad people in every walk of life, but it is a lesson that needs to be taught.

Anne Kimball 15 pts

Thanks for posting this. As someone with a few officers in the family, I've always thought of them a s the "friendlys", but I know that's not always true. Shame on those two for giving cops such a bad name and for behaving so horrifically in front of (and to) your child.

Gena Haskett 27 pts

There are rules of engagement. You have to learn these rules in order to survive where hostile policing is encourage. This transcends race because the current police climate is so tense these might not be effective anymore. To start:

1. The goal is to have the police officer move on. Keep your mind on the goal.

2. Limit your communication with officers; be polite and answer the question. Yes, they will still cuss you out but you want them to move on.

This is no time for attitude; this is a time for trying to be as safe as you can while talking to an angry cop. Do what you have to do to extract yourself from the situation safely. Listen for the question or direction. Remember the goal.

Let me be clear; Cops can kill and get away with it. Some cops lie. Some like playing with power. You do not know who you are dealing with. Safety first.

3. Get the number. The car number or the badge number. Don't ask for it. That can be dangerous.To the best of your ability try to remember it. Some of the police are starting to cover their badge numbers so that might not work but give it a try.

There are hundreds more rules that you and your daughters must learn. There is no master rule book. It is an sad oral tradition of rules for non-white folks but the good news is that they are seemingly becoming more open to being haters to all. This is not a good thing.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

Gena Haskett The other problem as far as badges went in this situation was that they were wearing dress uniforms. I was scrutinizing them all along trying to figure out how to "read" the unusual uniforms. But I could really kick myself for not picking up my phone and snapping their tailgate as they drove away, then I'd have the license plate.

I wished they had ticketed me at first, but then I realized they were from outside the jurisdiction and that could be why they didn't.

Clearly, they just wanted to bully someone for jollies.

Thanks for a quick rundown. It's so hard not to get all righteous back when someone is abusing power. But I realize the idea that I could safely argue with them is an assumption based on privilege (which I have a bit less of, frankly, now that I'm one of a mixed-race family).

Gena Haskett 27 pts

Shannon LC Cate It isn't so much about privilege as it is about power. You may have been yelled at but a Black or Latina woman could have been frisked, arrested or had the car impounded. If it was Philly cops then in a sense you got lucky because they couldn't do anything outside of their jurisdiction. It is a scary way to co-exist but you do the best you can.

There are good cops. It is the stinkers that give people acid in the stomach.

Sally G 16 pts

Very, very true. Gena Haskett Shannon LC Cate

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

 Gena Haskett Much later, but thank you again, Gena.

 

My kids asked some pointed questions about the police this morning while driving to school. Nat still hasn't forgotten her terrifying experience and brings it up often when we see cop cars. And after months of processing it both consciously and subconsciously, it was your list that came to mind when I addressed their concerns this morning.

 

It suddenly felt perfectly reasonable to tell my young kids that sometimes police officers are nice and polite and sometimes they are mean and rude. But I also told them that the police have guns and sometimes shoot people if those people scare them or are rude to them and that it is best to always be as polite as you can to a police officer and then to get away from the police officer as soon as you can.

 

My angst and ambivalence are just gone these days. Maybe it was the Trayvon tragedy, but all of a sudden, I'm just gonna tell my kids to be safe and how to do it.

 

If cops don't want kids to fear them, that's on them, not me.

LetThemEatGreat 116 pts

Gena Haskett I agree that the issue does transcend race in more instances these days. Just look at the unarmed, seated UC Davis students that got pepper-sprayed recently.

And I agree with other posters that your incident doesn't seem to be racially motivated. I'm wondering if it was a high-profile funeral and the cops felt the need to be extra aggressive? (Though they could be like that on any given day, too, of course...)

LetThemEatGreat 116 pts

Sorry, this is for Shannon LC Cate, too...

Gena Haskett 27 pts

LetThemEatGreat I have to say we don't know what ticked off the cops in this situation. It could have been the funeral. It could have been seeing a black child with a white woman. It could have been 1,000 things. We don't know what was in his head.

Now because of OWS police violence on captured on video it is not such a hard sell that cops commit crimes under the color of authority. Now that white youths, women and protesters that are catching hell there is greater awareness of the problem.

It it about power and who has it. Cops have power. If a person is assaulted by a police officer by culture and statute we believe the officer before we believe the citizen making the charges.

If the society see you as a person of lesser power, i.e. women, minorities or other groups that primes the pump for cops to whacking on your head a bit more than folks in the suburbs. Race/Gender/Orientation ties into multiple issues that for police officers doing their daily duties get hooked into. Remember a NYPD Facebook officer page on West Indians? They felt entitled to call people animals and wished that bombs could be dropped. They felt empowered by their position and status to say stuff like that. Very complex issue.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

. Gena Haskett LetThemEatGreat It isn't even that I'm saying this was a race-inspired incident. I think I say that in the piece. But it led me to think about what I'm going to have to teach my kids that is different than what I would have to teach white children.

Though I have to admit, I am kind of with Gena in that white children ought to be learning this stuff these days too. Not because they are at as high a risk as Black people for police brutality but because to think they aren't at any risk is a pipe dream.

But the fact is, that whatever reason this happened, I am 42 years old and nothing remotely like it has ever happened to me personally. That is luck, maybe, but the outrage and shock of all my middle-class white friends seems to indicate that people like us are, by and large, not abused by the police as often as others.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

LetThemEatGreatGena Haskett

I wondered about the funeral, but seeing as the police car was unmarked and there were no others in the procession, and seeing as the funeral procession itself was not flagged in any way, except perhaps with headlights (and like I said, everyone's headlights were on anyway) that didn't seem to add up.

Sally G 16 pts

And, for better or worse, you are right—the police seem to becoming more abusive (overall policy more militarized, NOT that there are not good cops; there are). Zuccotti Park had handmade signs reminding people of what living under surveillance means, and some of the considerations when dealing with police; the same type of things posted above. As the country gets more polarized, and with such laws as the NDAA being passed, I doubt much that it will get better (started to type “soon”, but “ever” suits my current outlook more).Gena Haskett

VirginiaW 7 pts

Please write letters to the editor of every local paper you can about this incident. This is unacceptable behaviour! I'm so sorry this happened to you and your girl but I do hope you keep contacting police stations and newspapers--this is just so wrong.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

VirginiaW The cop at the local station suspected it might have been Philadelphia police. He told me they would throw away any official complaint I tried to file. But maybe the newspaper...

Sally G 16 pts

If you are willing, absolutely a letter to the editor. Also mention that it seemed as though it might be someone outside his jurisdiction, and that the local police suspected as mjuch—the locals will still be on notice, and your letter will alert neighbors to the more likely perpetrators. Sending the clipping to the Philly police might be an idea, though more challenging than you may want. Shannon LC Cate VirginiaW

DeclassifiedAdoptee 8 pts

((hugs)) I am sorry that happened to you and your daughter. I can't help but wonder if it wasn't a gender issue. On one hand, the police are there to help and protect. On the other hand, they are also human beings with their own flaws, privileges, and biases. It is a shame for our generation of women to have to pass on this truth; women still have to work twice as hard (at least) as men to be respected and black women 10 times (at least) as hard. People who should respect us won't always and it's always something a woman, especially women of color, have to be prepared for.

Shannon LC Cate 32 pts

DeclassifiedAdoptee I do have my doubts they would have used that level of violence (slamming against the window, shouting as a conversation opener, etc.) if I had not been a mom in a station wagon. It was frankly, stupid policing. It easily might have created a dangerous situation out of a neutral one if I had been a less pacific type of person.

edavis 351 pts

What a disturbing experience! And it sure does speak to the problem of how we regard the people who are there to help keep things safe.