Bio
Crabby can be found whining about health and fitness at her blog Cranky Fitness.  She also pimps her coaching services at "Live a Little" Life...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Recent Comments

Whole Grains: What's the Problem, People?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 16
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I'm old enough to remember when "brown bread" was something exotic and vaguely threatening that only the hippie family down the street was brave enough to eat. As a kid, I assumed there was only one "normal" kind of flour: white. Same thing with rice. And the only variety we got as far as grains were bowls of Cheerios, Cornflakes, or Raisin Bran. But most often, we got our grains in the form of Wonderbread, Oreos, and Poptarts.

Fast-forward a few decades: scientists have learned a lot more about nutrition, and we've all been urged a few hundred thousand times to eat more whole grains because they are so damn good for us. Like many of you, I got with the program. Now I try to save refined grains for treats, not fill up on them as a staple.

So why are most people in this country still eating like I did as a third-grader back in 1968? And an even more important question: Why are the desires of all these ignorant third-graders still controlling what the rest of us can get at restaurants and grocery stores?

OK, so those aren't really questions--they're complaints. I don't actually care why a huge majority of the population keeps shunning whole grains. Probably because it takes a lot less effort to eat familiar white fluffy foods than to acquire a taste for healthier, earthier fare. And I know perfectly well why the preferences of the unhealthy masses dominate the food and restaurant industry: Welcome to capitalism, Crabby! It's also the reason we have Big Macs, Barbie Dolls, and The Real Housewives of New Jersey.

But I'm not sure what's worse: the general unavailability of whole grain options (unless you want to make things from scratch all the time, ick) or all the Fake-Healthy Not Really Whole Grain products out there. Most people are fine with these choices, because they are not equipped with enough grouchy skepticism to read a food label and then curse the lying sonsabitches who are trying to fake everyone out. Normal people just find a product they like that says "multi-grain" or "now made with whole grain," and they say to themselves: Awesome, I'm all set!

Of course these folks don't realize that a healthy-sounding ingredient like "organic wheat flour" still means "white flour," and that the crap they're eating is 98% refined flour and sugar, with maybe a pinch of bran or a single rolled oat thrown in there somewhere.

And if people want to eat mostly white flour and a few of these fake options too, knock yourselves out! But it would be nice if there were more options for us stubborn whole grain folks too. I'd love to have brown rice available at a Thai restaurant, or the option of a real whole grain roll at a bakery, or more choices at the supermarket when it comes to breads, pastas, crackers, etc. (And Whole Foods? You guys are the worst when it comes to your bakery. Where the hell is the healthy stuff? Last time I looked, it was virtually all desserts packed with refined flour, butter, and sugar. What's so "whole" about that?)

So Why Are Whole Grains a Healthier Choice?

According to the "world's healthiest food" people, there are a ton of great reasons to eat whole grains. (Note: These folks tend to be an optimistic bunch, but they do at least cite a bunch of studies).

Some of the research they've pulled together suggests that eating whole wheat or other whole grains can help with: weight management, metabolic syndrome, diabetes, inflammatory conditions, gallstones, gastrointestinal issues, heart disease, childhood asthma, breast cancer, dropsy, plague, possession by the devil, and vapors. (OK, so I was just messing with you on those last four. Well... who knows? Anyone driven out the devil with a bowl of oatmeal lately?)

But Some Folks Refrain from the Grain

Even if it's a whole grain and not refined one, there are some people who would just as soon give it a miss. If you have celiac disease, for instance, and must go gluten-free, then that lovely blueberry bran muffin that I have my eye on is gonna be Very Bad News for you. There are serious health consequences for people with this condition if they eat wheat, rye, barley, or anything contaminated with gluten. However, there are apparently some good gluten-free whole grain alternatives, like brown rice, wild rice, amaranth, millet, buckwheat, sorghum, quinoa, and even popcorn. (Oats

  • 16
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
TheSmartCook 5 pts

I recently "developed" a "go-to" formula for making quick & easy grain dishes using whatever you have on hand, and getting in all of the nutrients you need...

G + V + P [n (C)] (which I like to think of as a chant...G,V,P 'n C!)

G = Grain     V = Veggies     P = Protein

and the optionals...

n = nuts     C = Cheese

For more explanation....check it out here:

Singin' In The Grain ( http://thesmartkitchen.blogspot.com/2010/03/singin... )

Sarah @ ( http://twitter.com/ ) The Smart Kitchen

http://thesmartkitchen.blogspot.com

zibilord 5 pts

I'm still amazed how easy it is to make your own hot cereal/oatmeal in the slow cooker. You can throw in you favourite whole grains with some water, juice and spice, which takes all of 5-10 minutes. Press start and wake up to a wholesome breakfast.

Yes, I'm biased, but I can't help but share a good thing when I've found it :)

Zibi http://freshslowcooking.com

DebbieB 5 pts

I made a double batch of brown rice on the stove last night but next time, I will try the baked method. It's good to change things up sometimes.

CrystalsCozyKitchen 5 pts

Although I do not eat totally all whole grains, I do try. I make brownies and cookies with half whole wheat and half unbleached white flour. I actually love the taste of whole grains better, I love brown rice more than white and I love whole grain bread and tortillas better as well. It is hard to switch to it (I had to switch my hubby over to whole grains when we got married), but definately worth it!

CrystalsCozyKitchen

http://crystalscozykitchen.blogspot.com

Hedonia 5 pts

...it's not a whole grain. It's itty bitty pasta, made from semolina flour. If you've got a good natural foods market nearby you can get whole wheat couscous, which is nominally better for you (and tastes worlds better than most whole wheat pasta), but at the end of the day all couscous is made with one or more type of wheat flour.

Debra Roby 5 pts

I'm all over the steel cut oatmeal and the home-cooked brown rice.  (btw, I cook mine in the microwave instead of the stovetop.  But I will try Alanna's baked version this weekend.) Each time in a Thai restaurant I ask for brown rice -and my local favorite is now making it on weekends.

But every time I try I quinoa I think: grass.  It's tastes much too "green" to me. 

Someone will ask if I do a or b- and truly I don't recall.  I was so displeased with the taste that I don't venture back.

I also suspect that if more plain whole grains were available in standard grocery stores more people might eat them.  But then, the stores need more people to want them before they stock them.  Vicious cycle.

I'm not a huge grain person-so maybe I will just stick the oatmeal and rice.

Debra A Stitch In Time ( http://astitchintime.blogspot.com ) Weight for Deb ( http://weightfordeb.wordpress.com )

Maria Young 5 pts

I think it stems from me being raised on whole wheat bread. White bread makes me nauseous, just to think about eating it. I only recently started eating brown rice, and I'm a big fan of the nutty flavor and heartier texture, but I do think that some things taste better with white. I'm making more of an effort to move to whole grain pastas, which I find the hardest to stomach because of the extra chew.

- Maria Young

immoralmatriarch.com ( http://immoralmatriarch.com )@maria0305
( http://twitter.com/maria0305 )

Keira 5 pts

I think food must be cheaper in the US. I'm in Australia, and here its soooo much more expensive to buy pre-mix stff, that I don't they're really very popular, except with very busy people, and people who really can't cook.

So it means that here, if you're not using wholegrains, its most likely a preference thing, rather than a time thing.

At my house we've been undertaking the great grain experiment, trying to diversify the grains we use. I love quinoa, its pretty easy. I use milett too, although its not my favourite. You can use it instead of cous cous, but you cook it more like rice. We also use barley sometimes instead of rice (works well in salads, too), and sometimes use oat flour, rye flour, etc in baking.

CherylK 5 pts

I love quinoa.  It's easy to make and just delicious.  It seems to compliment just about anything you pair it with.  Also, I much prefer brown rice and hearty whole grain breads instead of the white, processed varieties.  I love the chewy, nutty texture of whole grain breads.  Very satisfying.

I think white bread is tasteless unless it's sourdough or some other artisan bread which I love but save for special occasions.

"If you find a path with no obstacles, it probably doesn't lead anywhere"

Lake Mary Musings ( http://www.lakemarymusings.com )

Maria Niles 5 pts

Alanna's baked brown rice recipe produces amazing, addictive rice that you will want to devour straight from the pan. Totally changed my life :)

In terms of time saving, I think her point was that microwave rice which Crabby mentioned is faster but substantially more expensive and thus might be worth reconsidering (not that baked is a time/energy saver over stove top cooking).

BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/maria-niles ) PopConsumer ( http://consumerpop.typepad.com/popconsumer ) Beyond Help ( http://mariax.vox.com/ )

foodiemama 5 pts

I grew up on fluffy white Italian sandwich bread, and pretty much shunned "whole wheat" products until my mid 20's. So I can vouch for the fact that it's an aquired taste, but it's not THAT hard to change your taste buds if you really want to. I am not a hardcore grain eater by any means, but I no longer crave that pure white fluffiness. Now I actually prefer a little heft and texture to my bread, muffins, pancakes, crackers, etc.

Maybe I'm misinterpreting what you're talking about by whole grain, but I don't think it's that hard to find convenient whole grain breads and foods in the grocery store. I like a lot of Orowheat breads, which contain "whole wheat" as their main ingredient. My favorite is the Health Nut bread, which has a variety of different grains, as well as nuts. It might not be as pure as some homebaked breads, but I figure it beats Wonder Bread by a mile.

Even Triscuits, which are available everywhere, are made from three simple ingredients: whole wheat, oil and salt. I know they're not the "healthiest" choice out there, but when compared to most of the heavily processed snack foods out there, with ingredients lists a mile long, they seem pretty healthy to me.

www.quinoaandcornchips.blogspot.com ( http://www.quinoaandcornchips.blogspot.com )

DebbieB 5 pts

... save time? On the stove it takes about 50 minutes. Your recipe says to bake for an hour. Seems like my oven would use LOTS more energy in an hour than my stove on simmer for 50 mins.  Does it taste better this way?

Also, my neighborhood Thai place does have delicious brown rice and we ALWAYS order extra to eat at another meal. Yum!

bec1987 5 pts

Quinoa is awsome as is couscous.  Couscous takes about 5 minutes to make and quinoa is pretty quick as well.  I agree with the concept of baking the rice.....when I bake chicken, I simply put it on a bed of rice and add a few lemons and some water for the rice to absorb.  Easy-schmeazy!!! 

I agree that bread is a bit more difficult, so I save my bread for special occasion meals (like I would do for a lucious dessert). 

Brown rice pasta is THE BOMB!!!!!  It cooks well, tastes amazing and is economical.  Trader Joes has it in penne, fusilli and spaghetti here in Indy.

I hear your skepticism and agree......it's tough enough as it is to make healthy choices and companies who try to deceive me into buying their product annoy me!

becky blogs at www.divorced-diva.blogspot.com ( http://www.divorced-diva.blogspot.com )

Alanna 5 pts

People want to be healthy, two primary components, diet and exercise. We wouldn't expect anyone to exercise on our behalf, so why would we expect someone to cook for us? All these fancy-pants grain/rice mixes 2X, 3X, even 10X the price. Just buy a bag of brown rice for $1.50 and bake it in the oven ( http://kitchenparade.com/2008/01/oven-baked-brown-... ). There's nothing easier to cook than quinoa, over the weekend, people went gaga over quinoa & black bean salad ( http://kitchenparade.com/2005/06/quinoa-black-bean... ). Once food becomes a "food product" with a marketing budget? All nutrition will be sucked from it. We do the treadmills ourselves, woman up and do the cooking too. ;-)

PS Your posts are great, I'd love for them to be cross-posted to Food & Drink where they are equally relevant.

PPS How do you avoid duplicate content issues by cross-posting on your own site?

Alanna Kellogg Kitchen Parade ( http://kitchenparade.com/ ) & A Veggie Venture ( http://kitchen-parade-veggieventure.blogspot.com/ )

aaustin13 5 pts

I'm mainly commenting so I'll get subscribed to future comments, because if there's a truly whole grain bread in the bread aisle, I'd like to know about it.  We're currently buying Aunt Millie's Light Whole Grain bread (35 calories a slice) but I don't fool myself that it's at all healthy, except in its lack of calories.

It's really just a vehicle for whatever else is in the sandwich, anyway.

As far as rice goes, next time you make some, make lots.  Then freeze your leftovers.  It's a lot faster to reheat it than to cook it, and doing it that way is cheaper than buying "instant" micro-rice things.

 http://prettybabies.blogspot.com

earthyoceanmama 5 pts

Quinoa is a staple in our house, and with such a high protein content, it's good for you in multiple ways. If you haven't tried it yet, start out just using it in place of rice. Super easy, super fast, super tasty. Even my husband, who probably hadn't seen or tasted a single whole grain in his life before he met me (Oh boy did not know what he was getting into!) loves it. As far as bread goes, Alvarado Street Bakery, as you mentioned, is good, as is Ezekial Bread, and Jack Sprat Bread (LOVE the sprouted grains) if you can find it. There are some fairly good options out there in the regular grocery store if you don't have a Whole Foods or Sunflower Market close by. My local Walmart carries Earth Grains bread, which is 100% whole grain, and is relatively inexpensive- bonus! -Krystal