Bio
A neurotic 20-something with very little free time on my hands. And yet I still manage to find time to complain and do a little 'creative whining' on...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why aren't we consuming?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I sit and type this while my email inbox is deluged with sale notifications: Buy one sweater get one free! 30% off already markdown prices! 40% off! Deepest Discounts ever! All of J. Crew is FREE! Meanwhile every other commercial on television is for $17 diamond baubles because if you weren't buying diamonds before this recession then clearly NOW is the time to stock up. And if I see another blaring ad for ridiculously low prices only between 6 and 7 AM on Black Friday, my eyes are going to pop right out due to extreme pressure thanks to incredulity.

Incredulous because according to a Forbes list of Twenty Reasons Why We're Not Consuming the number one reason is that "The U.S. consumer is shopped-out, having spent for the last few years well above his means." Ding, ding, ding! Yet here we sit being inundated with offers from companies hoping that decreasing prices will increase consumer spending especially with the holidays less than a month away; a time when people are easily swayed by anything sporting a red tag. Though I must include myself in that group of people easily wooed by the prospect of buying when there's a sale, but I know my limits. Stores are finding that more and more people are now realizing their personal finance limitations and reeling in their spending. Though it might be a little too late for some, others are finding ways to cutback and it shows.

After being 'shopped out', other reasons for why we aren't consuming include:

2. The U.S. consumer is savings-less, as the already low household savings rate at the beginning of this decade went to zero/negative by 2006 and now has to rise to more sustainable levels.

8. The credit crunch is becoming more severe as the recent second quarter flow of funds data and the Fed Loan Officers' Survey suggests: It is spreading from sub-primse to near prime to prime mortgages and home equity loans; and from mortgages to credit cards, auto loans and student loans. Both the price and quantity of credit are sharply tightening.

9. Consumer confidence is down to levels not seen since 1973-75 and 1980-82 recessions.

12. Employment has been falling for 10 months in a row and the rate of job losses is now accelerating. In the last recession in 2001, which was short and shallow (eight months from March to November 2001, with a cumulative fall in GDP of only 0.4%), job losses continued all the way until August 2003 - with a job loss recovery and a total cumulative loss of jobs of over 5 million from the peak. In this cycle, job losses have, so far, been "only" slightly over a million, while labor market conditions are severely worsening based on all forward-looking indicators such as initial and continuing claims for unemployment benefits. Massive job losses and concerns about job losses will further dampen current and expected income, and further contract consumption.

You can read the rest here but the underlying reason for why we are consuming less seems to be a two prong effect of fear and lack of money after so many years of biting off more than we could chew and now we're forced to sit back and learn the hard way why overspending is - to put it nicely - a very bad thing. So we spend less even though we're being lobbed sales and rebates and the like all the while waiting for it all to blow over which means turning the Holiday season into a more reflective time than watching our available credit shrink to nothingness. Shockingly enough, I'm all for the latter. Of course that doesn't mean totally giving up and not shopping but here are some additional tips on how to curb holiday spending, make a budget and wear to find awesome handmade gifts.

Black Friday Deals from Etsy

A Christmas budget from Stacking Pennies

Six tips for smarter holiday shopping from MSN money blog

How do you plan to curb your spending over the next month? I'm looking for tips. Seriously.

 

Heather B. also writes at No Pasa Nada. She and her family will be having a 'kindler, gentler' Christmas this year which means more for her to spend on herself or stash away in an ING account. Whatever.

  • 9
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
christine89 5 pts

HeatherB - i w-i-s-h everything at JCrew were free lol!  

well i signed up for my own online shopping website portal a few mos back, because i get cash back rebates on all my shopping made thru the site. i did it for a few reasons - it keeps me out of the stores so i don't come home with $100 bucks worth of stuff i don't really need. and UPS is driving around anyway so my car can stay parked. i'm now a more 'targeted'-efficient shopper. i can still apply all the coupons that hit my inbox (unreal this season! but all the free shipping is awesome) and get my rebate for shopping thru the site. 

www.shoptoearn.net/go4green ( http://www.shoptoearn.net/go4green )

at the end of the day, your time and attention are what's important. people remember how you made them feel. not the thing you bought them. 

happy holiday season gals! 

anotherjen 5 pts

My husband and I have instituted a $50 limit on Christmas, not so much because we're tempted to spend more than that in this horrible economy (we're not!), but mostly so that we know we're both on the same page and no one feels guilty come christmas morning.  It's nice to be forced to stay within our means.  It forces you to really think about what you're buying, instead of throwing more and more things you think the recipient will like on an endless pile.  Who really needs more stuff, anyway?

http://www.NextRichGirl.com ( http://www.nextrichgirl.com/ )

JC 5 pts

This will definitely be a scaled-back Christmas, and that's just fine with me.  My husband and I are planning on making some gifts.  For my son's last birthday, we tie-dyed shirts as a project.  Everyone really loved it.  Since we still have the materials, we're going to make more shirts and give them as gifts.

As for me, I'll just wrap a bow around myself and he can open his gift later.

http://www.storyrhyme.com/jcsblog

mwaters 5 pts

We do as Dawn suggests and draw names amongst the 5 kids of my generation.  We buy for all the kids of the next generation, even those over 18.  Sometimes that can be tricky but, as I reflect back over past year's gifts, I realize that my best gifts came in the lean years where I really had to think about what I was buying or making.  I've come up with some really clever things over the years.  I'm hoping for some similar inspiration this year!

Mary@SimplyForties
http://www.simplyforties.com ( http://www.simplyforties.com/ )

BookLady Alison 5 pts

So far my wishlist looks really practical:

Rebind a family heirloom book for me.
Pay for a landscape design to turn my garden into an edible landscape. I don't think this one is going to happen though as it has a big price tag!
Books, books, more books, especially ones about becoming self-sufficient. Well, there is always the library if I run out of reading material.
A web address, blog template or similar.
There are many gifts we can give that don't involve consuming. For instance one Christmas my son gave his dad an IOU for a few hours of chores.

I'm in the book business and sales are actually up this year. It seems people are valuing the fact that books are educational and fun and last better than lots of gifts.

BookLady Alison

Book guides today at Homeschoolers Guide to the Galaxy ( http://homeschoolersguidetothegalaxy.blogspot.com )
Gift Ideas for people you care about at GreatFunBooks.com ( http://greatfunbooks.com )

SkinnyCleanFreak 5 pts

I think people are finding that all the shiny toys, gadgets, and baubles just aren't making you happy. I mean, aside from the financial pressures - it's just not that important. Everyone's homes are full of things they never use.

I liked it when we used to exchange ornaments. When it's just one, people would put a little more thought into finding the perfect ornament. It was more fun and had more meaning.

Even my 17 year old is tired of accumlating 'stuff'. Which blows my mind, but I'm not complaining!

Carole

Living a simpler fuller life - CommonSenseLiving.com ( http://CommonSenseLiving.com )

Dawn6751 5 pts

Two ideas for you:

 1. Get together with your extended family and draw names for Christmas.  Set a spending limit. Then, each person only needs to buy gifts for one other person. This not only cuts down on your spending, but it also lets you focus on finding the perfect gift for that one person.

 2. Within your extended family and friends network, make an agreement that you'll only buy gifts for children under 18. 

My extended family has tried both of these ideas and both were successful.

Dawn

http://onemomentplease6751.blogspot.com/ ( http://onemomentplease6751.blogspot.com/ )

Stanford Wife 5 pts

I'm married to a generous graduate student who would get me just about anything I wanted for Christmas an this year we sat down and said 'Let's sit this year out.' Sure, I've got a job and he's got a stipend, but we're both sick of the commercialism of the holiday and the course America's on.

On Christmas morning, we'll wake up, enjoy a big breakfast and spend the day drinking cider, reading and going for a long walk. We're saying no to what Christmas has become.

But you know what? Its easy for us to do that. We live in the enclave of Stanford, California, a place full of liberals and non-Christians from other countries. We don't have kids. Plus, he's in grad school, so relatives don't expect gifts from us.

Last year I got my husband a Bose Headset thingy-ma-jig that cost $300. This year it'll probably be sex.

Stanford Wife ( http://stanfordwife.com

Writer. Lover. Partner of an unapologetic farter.