Blog
JustLinda
Bio
Profession: Astronaut.  (Additional Information: Not really an astronaut.)Things I Care About: Cheddar Bay Biscuits and World Peace; of course...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why Comments Matter (to me)

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I find the sociology behind social networking online fascinating.

Quite likely, if you post an article here that has to do with blogging or social networking in general, I will have an opinion that I feel compelled to share.  I will hope that the comments section of your article will burst to life with riveting discussion and dissenting opinions.  I love that stuff.  Truly and well.

Recently, Loralee wrote a piece called Hey Jealousy:  Every Blogger was a Newbie Once which had that very thing happen.  And though I was a little late to the game, I was in it - I made several comments and got into the discussion with others about this topic.  The cool thing about Loralee's article is that she was right there in the comments section replying to people, giving the discussion the care and feeding it needed to really take off.

I love when that happens.

Sometimes my brain gets all zombie-ish Need American Idol or perhaps Time to Make the Doughnuts or something.  And something like this type of discussion (or maybe sex or chocolate!) will titillate my brain cells, wake them out of their coma, incite them to action.  I can actually feel the hamster of my brain start to run in its wheel.  And, people, it is a squeaky wheel - make no mistake.

(Also?  My hamster is prone to short bursts of energy and then mostly just lazes around on his little brain-sofa watching his little brain-TV.  He's just 2 notches up from worthless then.  But when he's running in his wheel?  He's a maniac.  Personally, I suspect he might be bi-polar.)

Anyway, back to the topic at hand (holy cow, maybe he's got ADHD too - that could explain the rambling disjointed nature of how he makes me write, couldn't it??) - Loralee posted her piece and the comments section lit on fire and it was a great discussion.  (Also?  I think she is going to write a follow-up piece so watch for that.  My hamster is already anxiously tapping his foot in my head.  Or perhaps I had too many Jello shots last night.  Either way...)

Some of the comments were about comments (just so meta!) and got me thinking.  About comments, naturally. 

Are the people who want them and need them and seek them out with fastidious determination shallow and vain?

Are the people who don't care about them more secure or superior?  Are they fooling themselves that they don't care?  Are they in denial about caring? 

(Do they have brain-hamsters that are simply depressed and apathetic???  That's the real question, now, isn't it?)

I do not know the answers to these questions but I find it interesting to ponder them.  I can, however, answer from my own perspective.  Well, OK - I'd be willing to answer on behalf of the hamster too, because he's watching SpongeBob right now and just can't be bothered.  {rolling my eyes at my hamster, what in the world do I keep him around for, anyway?}

I am most definitely shallow and vain.

Or maybe I should re-phrase.  It's quite likely that I am shallow and vain OR - I could just be a human being who seeks validation and who struggles with insecurity.

I recently wrote a piece called Why We Write (Which?  Zero comments.  After I cried real tears and tossed myself prone on the floor to kick and scream and lament the injustice of it all, I finally got over it when I was distracted by chocolate.  Sometimes having a hamster with ADHD works to my benefit, I think.) in which I state that I write for acceptance, to be known and loved (or at least liked) for who I am.

Like many others, this is my way of putting myself out there.  And I do put so much of myself into my writing (like so many of you do, too).   It's scary to do this, risky even.  It's the same as "What if I throw a party and nobody comes?" 

That is what my personal blog feels like - throwing an online party and hoping that others will find that they want to hang out with me at my house because they like my company. 

I also understand that people are busy and have tons of things competing for their time and attention and I don't take it personally when they don't come to my house for my party each time the music starts to play.   I want people at my party, but I understand that the onus is on

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Ginger Leigh 5 pts

Thanks!  It is actually the name I perform under... when I started working for the sex toy company it just sort of fit!  Please do check out the blog.  Of course contest promoting is going on now, but you can find educational posts in there too!  I'll have to check you out as well!

By the way, I totally respect the whole not second guessing yourself thing.  Thanks for the comment on my comment!

http://sextoysforladies.com/

Rita Arens 7 pts

Rita Arens writes at Surrender Dorothy ( http://surrenderdorothy.typepad.com ) and BlogHer and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

Annette _Fergusson 5 pts

I love me some comments too! It reaffirms that someone somewhere reads my stuff and is trying contribute to this giant online conversation that we know as the blogosphere. It is something of a gamble to put yourself out there for everyone to read your thoughts and opinions and heartbreaking when it seems like no one is reading your work! Arrrgh! I try to comment often on my favorite blogs and random posts I read on BlogHer, but I must confess that I often get intimated by other bloggers who have commented before me and feel my comments are unworthy. Ah well, if I don't have anything earth shattering to add to the discussion I try and leave at least a "well said" or something of the sort-as a means of appreciating the wrieters efforts. I know I love when folks comments on my posts. Anyways...a very sincere "well said" from me to you. Keep blogging!

Patricellen 5 pts

Well, Linda, just this morning you were bemoaning the lack of comments on your post here, and now look!  Comments everywhere!  I have decided not to hold you to your promise on the puppy.  I couldn't sleep at night thinking about your distraught children.  I'll also let you keep the 14-year old daughter.  Been there, done that.  Love that mine are now 33 and 36.  Much more manageable.

I'm getting ready to post a new entry on my blog and thinking about comments, and I have to say that it's so much more fun for me with the comments turned off.  I just love creating the posts and putting them out there and what feedback I get seems to work for now.

Wow.  A puppy AND a 14-year old.  Both cute and both will grow up. 

justlinda 9 pts

Meet DRAGON ( http://justlinda.net/blog/?p=504 ).

My kids would draw and quarter me if I gave the little monster away... we love him, but we tend to gravitate toward mammals who make huge messes in our house, so he fits right in.

JustLinda

 fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )

Ginger Leigh 5 pts

I do this very same thing!  Perhaps about 2% of the  comments I start to type actually make it onto a blog.  I want to say something.  A post intrigues me, makes me laugh, educates me, etc but what do I say?  I then realize I am putting too much thought into it and move on. 

I do love receiving comments.  At the very least it lets me know that someone out there is reading.  They are few and far between. 

Glad to know I'm not the only one! 

http://sextoysforladies.com/

Rita Arens 7 pts

But a lot of times, I do just read, especially when I'm reading on my phone at my kid's ballet class or such. Some posts I just read, nod, and move on. And I try to remember other people do that, too.

I would like my puppy to be black.

Rita Arens writes at Surrender Dorothy ( http://surrenderdorothy.typepad.com ) and BlogHer and is the editor of Sleep is for the Weak ( http://tinyurl.com/9pg62e ). She is BlogHer's assignment and syndication editor.

justlinda 9 pts

Don't know what to say, late to the party, unoriginal, etc.  I don't comment on everything I read (not enough time in the day).

What I'd love to see happen in my own blogging is to see the comments section begin to take on a community feel - where the "regulars" know each other and banter happens.  I love blogs where the comments are more banter (especially if it's the kind that makes me laugh, though I also love to get scrappy sometimes in the heavier discussions...)

So I'm ready to postmark the puppy.  Do monkeys like puppies??  Do tell?

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )

justlinda 9 pts

Sometimes I'm reading while doing other things (multi-tasking, waiting for a report to run, etc.) and I just browse, skim, surf and I can't comment.  I may stay right in my reader too.

But when I have a chance to come out and play, I generally comment. 

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )

justlinda 9 pts

Isn't it interesting... when I am posting something that makes me feel extremely vulnerable, it's then more than ever that the silence makes me feel anxious and insecure.  Those are the ones I may feel regret over publishing if no one responds. 

The rational side of my brain understands and accepts the reality - no comments doesn't mean it's "bad" or not-funny or whatever.  Sometimes people don't know what to say on a serious topic.  I know that, rationally, but the emotional side of me needs someone to say SOMETHING, ya know? 

I wonder what writers did before they were able to get instant feedback via the web.  I mean, some of my favorite writers have syndicated in print, newspapers and stuff.  Obviously, their comments came in the form of fan mail delayed by the postal process.  Hmmm...

JustLinda

 fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )

sassymonkey 6 pts

I often start and then backspace my way all the way out of the comment box. (To be honest I just did and then made myself open the window again.) 

I have itty-bitty blogs. They generally get itty bitty comments. Hardly any really and it's not unusual for a blog post to get none. Can I tell from my blog stats that people are reading? Sure can. Does it bother me that they are not? Not really. Because I'm a crappy commentor. I get it. Sometimes you want to say something and the you just don't know what to say. Or you decide what you are going to say is all wrong. Or you don't have time. Or you feel unoriginal. Or you tell yourself that you need to sit on it awhile and then never quite get back to it. Or the post is a few days old and you feel like maybe the time to comment has past. 

Don't get me wrong, I love getting comments (I think the vast majority of us do) but I just don't think that I'll ever be the kind of blogger that gets lots of comments. I'm ok with that 99% of the time. (The other times I'm like you on the floor pounding my fists.) 

Contributing Editor Sassymonkey also blogs at Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca ).

justlinda 9 pts

The puppy I have is as cute as can be but dumb as a box of hair and isn't yet housebroken. 

Do still you want him?  hahaha

(Thanks for chiming in!)

JustLinda

 fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )

Deb Rox 5 pts

I like leaving comments, and getting them, but I am a horrible convo tender.  I tend to be online in spurts--even if that spurt can be a day long, though it rarely is.  I often simply can't tend to a conversation, much as I want to.  I know I pay the price for that by missing engaging discussions and in having more comments on my own blog, but I can't seem to balance it otherwise.  The alternative it to post less often and only when I have time to engage, but that doesn't make sense for me as a writer.  I do make an effort to get out of my RSS Reader and comment, though, more and more.

Deb
www.debontherocks.com ( http://www.debontherocks.com/ )blog
www.3smartgirlz.com ( http://www.3smartgirlz.com/ ) consulting

Hey Jen 5 pts

unless it is potty trained. I hate it when dogs pee and poop all over the house. 

I can go either way with comments. Sometimes I like them, sometimes I don't. And when I don't its not necessarily because of the content/troll/good reply/whatever. Sometimes I just feel like I'm exposing myself and I don't want to know that someone read it and even want to comment on it. 

...not that it matters right now since I just restarted my blog. haha woo! three posts that have nothing to do with anything! I'm gonna go pee now. thxbye

Patricellen 5 pts

Thank you for commenting on my post about disabling comments and oh, how I feel your pain here.  There is something so validating about getting a comment and so horribly rejecting when they don't come.  Yes, online therapy might be in order, but it all feels rather normal to me.  Validation and inclusion are primal drives and it's amazing how they get played out in the blogging world.  I appreciate your candor and validate your feelings.  How do I get my puppy?

justlinda 9 pts

That is a limited time only offer.

After I run out of puppies, I might give away children. 

Please send me your address so I can forward your puppy (or child) posthaste!!

(In other words, thanks for the comment.)

JustLinda

 fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )

veronicamd 5 pts

I hear ya, sister.  My heart breaks into tiny little pieces when I put myself out there and I get zero comments.  

Veronica

http://veronicamarcettidimick.blogspot.com

justlinda 9 pts

Anyone who writes a blog about sex toys for women ought to be named gingerly.  hahah  It's perfection.  I love it.

(See?  A thought pops in and I make a comment.  It's just because I'm rather bold and I don't second guess myself too much on this sort of stuff... )

Now I simply must check out your blog.  But - not from work.  It'll have to wait until I'm at home the the kiddos are tucked in for the night.  {wink}

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL ( http://twitter.com/JustLindaSTL )