Bio
Persuaded by the adage "Even if you're not interested in politics, politics is interested in YOU," I came to Washington after college to work for a c...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why does it matter if we teach our children to be 'good citizens?'

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Did you see former Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor talking about this last night on the PBS NewsHour?

She said the No Child Left Behind law provided no federal money for history or government classes, so “many schools have opted not to teach them anymore.”

But, she said, “We got public schools in this country to begin with because of the concern about the need to teach young people how to be good citizens, how our government works, so that everybody could participate.”

So she’s founded a website called iCivics that she hopes middle schools will use. It involves games to help children discover the way the executive, legislative and judicial branches work.

I'm a former congressional staffer turned journalist. I tried the games out last night and will be recommending them to middle schoolers I know. I think they're good at showing the way the government works.

But I'd like to see them do more to help kids understand why anybody should care about the government in the first place.

I like that old cliche, "even if you're not interested in politics, politics is interested in you." From the day we're born until the day we die, the government is involved in nearly every aspect of our lives. Laws and regulations govern the doctor who brings us into the world and the funeral director who ushers us out.

Everybody disagrees about the degree to which government should govern our lives. But that's why our kids need to know about it — so when they're adults they'll be able to weigh in when they think the government should do more to protect them and their families or when they think it's gone over the line and is being a nanny state.

I was surprised, actually, by the huge amount of enthusiasm for Barack Obama's "change" message in 2008, and now I'm surprised again by the clamor for "change" in the other direction. And I wonder if it reflects a misunderstanding about the way our government is supposed to work.

I was riding in a cab a few weeks ago. The driver said as we passed the Department of Motor Vehicles, "I voted for Obama, and I thought he'd fix that." He dismissed my comment that, well, the DMV is a part of the city government here in Washington, and the federal government doesn't have a say in it.

I wonder if, like that cab driver, some people may have had unrealistic expectations of what Obama could change.

Everybody talks about the dysfunctional government. I agree that the hyperpartisanship in Congress is making it hard to get anything done and that America's future is at risk if we can't get past it to do something about the deficit, for example.

At the same time, it's hard to get anything done because that's the way the founders of the country wanted it. All those checks and balances are to avoid tyranny — so a lot of people have to agree before changes are made.

I wonder if some of us think the president has more power than the founders of the country ever would have been comfortable giving him. And if we need to do a better job of teaching our children what we can expect from our leaders and what we can’t.

What do you think?

  • 7
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
xstaticadventure 5 pts

I agree both ways. I feel that we definitely should be more educated on how government really works, but, as it has been mentioned here, all of the promises that the political campaigners throw out should be starred with a little note at the bottom of the page/speech saying "if I can get the rest of the people in the government to agree with me and pass my plan into law."
It's funny, though, that this should come up - I bristled when my daughter brought home a coloring page from 3rd grade that said "good citizens obey all of the laws." I also reminded my 8 year old (who probably thought I was nuts), that it's also the job of good citizens to question their leaders and question laws they feel are unjust. Which she, of course, promptly recited to her teacher the next day....

KMayer 5 pts

We have an obligation to create good citizens. When we don't, we have Madoff and Enron and mortgage fraud and racial profiling and hate crimes and a society that see only individuals, and not the group that binds us.

Kathy (p/t copywriter, f/t mom)

Diary of a Return-to-Work Mom ( http://returntoworkmom.blogspot.com/ )

CitizenCartwright 5 pts

I do think that if schools don't teach citizenship skills, it's up to parents. There's material on current events and government for children and parents to read and discuss together at sites including www.weeklyreader.com ( http://www.weeklyreader.com ),
http://www2.scholastic.com and
http://bensguide.gpo.gov/.

www.citizencartwright.com ( http://www.citizencartwright.com ) is a blog for informed and want-to-be-informed citizens.

thegetsmart 5 pts

It's really unfortunate that schools are able to cut such important subjects right out of their curricular. If the school can't afford to teach certain subjects, do you think it is the parents' responsibility to fill in the gaps?

LA Fuller | Blogger + Social Media Marketer
The Get Smart
T. 617.863.7617 | www.thegetsmart.com ( http://thegetsmart.com ) | Twitter ( http://twitter.com/thegetsmart ) | Facebook ( http://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Get-Smart/118160... )

NSane 5 pts

I completely agree. This particularly resonates with me in California at the moment because I get the feeling that people have no idea how our government works. I'm tired of hearing how candidates for governor are going to fix things and how they will bring things together. I don't think they got the memo that California is a weak executive state that there aren't many powers available to the governor to make people do things. It just boils down to a lot of talk.

Natalie writes Almost Never Clever ( http://almostneverclever.wordpress.com ), a deviant scrapbooking blog that just might surprise you.

NotJustAnotherJennifer 5 pts

It's partially the politicians' fault for why people think they can change some things they can't because of how they campaign. But citizens need to be educated so they aren't hoodwinked!

Jennifer Barr is a wife and working mom of two beautiful girls, 3 going on 13 and 9 months, which means she's sleep deprived but constantly kept on her toes! Most of those experiences are chronicled on her blog, http://midwestmomments.blogspot.com.

Kathryn W. 5 pts

I did not see the PBS segment, but I couldn't agree more that when it comes to how the government works, we definitely need a more educated public, and schools seem to be the best place to start. It doesn't matter what party you are in, or even if you don't identify with one, you still need to know what you are really voting for or against. There is nothing worse (or more dangerous to a president's approval rating - regardless of party) than an uninformed voter (I would like to point out that I am not advocating not voting, I am advocating education on the way government works and the issues for all people).

Thanks!

----------------------------

The Soap Box ( http://www.blogher.com/andthatsmysoapbox.blogspot.... )