Bio
The inner bully can be a real bugger. A heinous bugger is more like it. Agreed? Hi. I'm Tre and I help people just like you squelch the bully within....
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Why I Chose Not to Spend the Holiday with My Mother

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

So it’s Monday after the holiday and I’m writing today to share a bit of the why behind why I opted to spend it on my own.

And while a few of you may accuse me of being selfish or inconsiderate, a few more of you may nod with me and maybe even wish you’d given yourselves similar permission.

And it’s for that possibility I want to offer this:

This Christmas, I gave myself permission to spend the holiday on my own.

Translation: I consciously chose not to spend it with my mother.

Breathe. Pause.

As I type, I’m sitting at my computer, in my sweats, in the aftermath of the holiday.

No tree, no presents, no décor. (That’s her thing).

No hurried rush rush last minute book a flight obligatory madness craze out of  “must go see mom because you know, it’s the right thing to do.” (that’s my ‘old’ thing).

Breathe.

Why did I choose this?

Well of course I’m a selfish, relentless, ungrateful daughter who wants to ruin her mother’s holiday.

No, of course not. Though I’ve been accused of such, it is not that.

I chose to celebrate the holiday in my cozy nook with my candles aglow and my thoughts unencumbered, open to possibility because…

On December 14, 2009, just a few days ago, I turned 41.

And I decided it’s time to let go the decades of guilt and frustration that I’m not the daughter “she” wants me to be.

Pause. Breathe.

It’s time to stop punishing myself.

It’s time to stop feeling saddened or sorry that the who I am appears inadequate to her.

And it’s beyond time I give myself permission to think I’d be able to dodge the comments, ignore the sneers, or exist under the regime of the way things are when you return home playing a role that you can’t ever play honestly, yet trying to save face because that’s the ‘what I’m supposed to do.”

Beyond done with thinking that choices I’ve made out of obligation--or not wanting to hurt her-- serve me.

They haven’t. They don’t. I need a new way.

Pause…Breathe.

But here’s the truth:

I love my mother, truly. Yet,  I don’t know what I need or want from our relationship anymore.  And so I’m taking a huge major pause to just breathe.

There’s a few things I know for sure:

In my attempts to show up and make sure her holiday or her whatever goes as she wants it to, I put myself on autopilot just to ‘deal’ or ‘cope.’ And that’s never healthy for me. In fact, it’s like self imposed suffocation.

I know we can only impact how we choose to respond to someone’s actions, as we can’t make them change.

But I’ve not nurtured myself enough. And autopilot mode just to save face does not lead toward healing. Ever.

That’s where I am this holiday season.

I know I’m at a place where, while I hope for healing, there’s still a lot of memory that hasn’t been forgotten.

It is difficult to forget constant criticism, the constant “Why aren't you married by now? Or , “why haven’t you provided me with my next career as your children’s grandmother?”

That indirect blame and guilt and shunning is really her own voicing her emptiness, her fear of the unknown. She was brought up thinking by now she'd be a grandmother to her daughter's children.

And none of my choices would heal that. And I know this.

But hearing her constant wishing my life were different is still painful for me…not because I can’t take criticism. And this is the kicker: It’s painful for me because I ache to know my mother is hurting in any way and I want to heal that.

Yet, I know that I must let go my desire to personally hold responsibility to fill up my mother’s heart and give her a way to self fulfillment.

I know that no matter what I choose, my choices are not the means through which she’ll find completeness.

I know that – now – the best I can do is walk the walk that I must for me…and hope in some small measure that to the degree I make a practice out of nurturing my heart and what I need that in some small way, she maybe will see the who I am.

But this practice of nurturing me is finally not about mom.

This year it’s about me.

And bear with me,

  • 18
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Tre - 5 pts

Hey and hugs to each who read and responded to this post....

Mom in fact responded in a few ways that have caused me to pause even more...What I'm asking this little community :) of women who can relate to the mother/daughter struggle....

What would be helpful for you to hear next? Her response? My thoughts about it? A bit of both?

You're helping me navigate the next step...I'd drafted a buncha "show them where I've come to this point" and truth, that may have a place but it felt a lotta bit dumping on mom and a lotta a bit look at me....

I have zero desire to rant or moan. I have every desire to talk about the struggle (stupidity?) of constantly going back without setting up a scenario for change.

Now that I see what's changed since my mini hiatus I'm so sure that the pause was exactly what was needed......

So I'm flooding with ideas to share...but I also want to know what pieces would be helpful to ya'll to hear....if that makes sense.

It can be luring to drum up the drama....there's a lot. But again the goal I seek is to show the turningpoints..the choices that have been made a long the way that have resulted in some shifts...the post above was perhaps a dead end choice for me b/c I broke. I just couldn't go back to what's always been. So even my choices in the past haven't been perhaps radical enough. Or my needs have shifted.

Again, my journey is unique...yours is for you...Nothing I do is formulaic..but there's something to not giving up per se and working the problem in a new way...At least this is my hope. Please lemme know what you'd benefit from hearing next...truly would help me navigate the content delivery a wee bit (ha ha.. a lotta bit).

Baby update tho: my sis just became engaged (2nd marriage) and this is minimally distracting mom's yearning for grands.......interesting.....

Okay ya'll....I'm striving to make this my happy new me year :) so whether it sounds cheesy or not..happy new you year :) hugs.....

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Tre - 5 pts

Wow..thanks so much Kristan for your hope and expectation for not just me but all of us.

Yeah, so true. What Liz said, what so many have said is so wise and wonderful....

I know in my heart of hearts we are each living our truth...and maybe the toughest thing is that we can't always predict how someone's actions will affect us....Maybe a more practical goal is strengthening my ability to steady on....whether on my own in the gift of space or amidst all the huggabaloo of mom's life or anyone's...

How awesome to have that hope that we wouldn't have to 'lose' ourselves to someone else's drama...

And this is what I adore about Kim's and Megan's perspective too....both of you all (thank you both) seem to really have found a way to create patterns that nurture you and don't allow yourselves to react too much to the way your mom's are/have been.

I can say that better...but...:)

I think I'm realizing I've hidden a lot.

I think I'm realizing I've found strength in avoiding confrontation when that's not an honest goal. Better to grow the woman in me that steadies on...no matter how she acts or what she does.

Could it be the mom/daughter relationship is the biggest opportunity to learn and prove this ability to steady on? :)

Hmmm.....I'm thinkin yeah....for right now.

Again, all these comments have me pondering....will offer some more in another post soon.

Hugs for all this genuine heartfelt connecting.

Next best thing to cozying up in my studio w/ blankets and slippers sipping tea..:) (unless we're on a beach somewhere in flipflops) :)

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

kristanhoffman 5 pts

As someone with a "complex but close" relationship with my mother, I can totally understand this post. I don't think my mom and I have reached *quite* the place that it sounds like you and your mother have, but as the comments here show, we each have our own problems, unmet expectations or desires, etc. with our mothers. And I think it's healthy for you to gift yourself with a little peace, a little space, to step back. I think by moving away from home (for college and after) I have given myself that room to breathe, and it's actually been really good for me and my mom. Like Liz Henry said, "I think by refusing to engage in the destructive bit of the relationship, you may make space for something better..."

Certainly that's what I'll be hoping for, for you and everyone, in 2010. :)

- Kristan

kristanhoffman.com ( http://kristanhoffman.com/ )

Tre - 5 pts

No regrets....

Mind? these thoughts? lemme go grab the tissues as I write...

These comments are as healings as deciding to nurture me this holiday.

And you've zeroed into the very elements I wish now my first post included.

THANK YOU for outpouring as you have. I can't even begin to imagine what last September felt like for you now knowing you so so many times asked yourself in the moments with your mom what would healing look like.

I drafted another 10 posts last night. :) Not to deny what I'd written but to offer deeply more on the journey of where my thoughts have grown in terms of mom. In many ways, while I fight elements of her character, it's my own battle really...And yet, the biggest hurdle: I tend to rally for overcoming emotional hurts whereas mom tends to dwell  in the drama a lot. And in spite of her strides, I still sense her 20 year ache over my parents divorce.... something I've not been able to personally expunge for her. And I thought I knew this.

If I'm oober honest with me, I've been mad at myself that I can't steamroll into that heart of hers and tweak it so it's "sans pain" And she'd probably say the same thing for me...I am frustrated the woman in me can't seem to shake wanting to heal her own mom. I am not sure I'll EVER get over that...perhaps my solo Christmas was avoiding the things I can't seem to fix just as much as nurturing me...perhaps....

Trust me, with me anyway, you'll never have to apologize. I find all of this honest open with the most tender intentions expression really awesome way to flip me upside the head a bit, nudge me to breathe more...and ask me what matters most.

Sounds like you are untethering hugely. That you are even engaging in how to conversations is sooo enlightening and touching, truly.

These comments are really touching me hugely.:) Thanks all so much.

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Kim Pearson 5 pts

Dear Tre,

Thank you for speaking what so many of us have struggled with. Over time, my perspective has become somewhat more complex. I hope you won't consider this a digression.

There was a point in my life - I think I was in my mid-30s - when I really began to understand that for all of the difficulties in my relationship with my mother, a time would come when there would be no more tugs of war over who I was vs. who she wanted me to be, and who she was and who I needed her to be. I resolved that when that time came, I wanted to have no regrets.

At some of the most contentious moments with her after I made that resolution, I often asked myself, "If this is the last interaction I have with Mom, will I have regrets?" Sometimes I also asked a corollary question: "If healing were to happen, what would it look like?" In making my decisions, I looked for signs of healthy interaction that I could encourage. Usually, the regret-check buttressed my decision to hold my boundaries firm. That helped a great deal last September, when (why is so hard for me to write?) she died.

I think about this issue also because one of my children is 25 and the other is about to be 18. This untethering is a dance that is every bit as sensitive as the cutting of the umbilical cord when they were born. My friends and I think a lot about how to make sure we successfully manage our own rites of passage into empty nesting. I hope by the time my children are in their 40s, they won't need to do their own "regret-checks" before deciding whether to call or visit me.

BTW, I still appreciate Candelaria Silva's post, Parenting Adult Children ( http://www.blogher.com/parenting-adult-children ) on this subject. I think it's kind of an interesting complement to yours.

Wishing you peace and joy in the New Year,

Kim
BlogHer Contributing Editor ( http://blogher.org/blog/kim-pearson )|KimPearson.net ( http://kimpearson.net )|

Tre - 5 pts

wow...wow. wow. wow. wow. ya'll.

i'm sooo touched, moved, blown away really by the outpouring of response today here on this post and on the blogher facebook fan page and on my home blog where i first posted this.....

i'm just pausing. in gratitude and awe....it's kinda hit me upside the head ...

WE ARE ALL DAUGHTERS.

hello mcfly.why have i kept to myself one of the most important topics to my heart?

probably b/c it's not pretty, it's not at all where i want it to be. i'm no where close to experiencing the kinda relationship w/ mom i wanna.

but here's what i do know....i'm trying. i'm writing about it. i'm sharing ideas and views and YOU all are pouring forth yours.

maybe i'll just tuck up this feeling for now that I've always known this topic matters...our lives matter. this is a huge topic for me in ways.

Where I got today: in mommying me...(i use that phrase cuz it's gentle and ya'll i've had tons of harsh top down authorities in my life)....i'm more able to keep whole, keep strong, and keep on trying...because mom matters so deeply muchly to me. And at the end of the day I have to answer to that nudge that says keep at this girl it matters to you.

Not sure where I'm gonna go next with this....but that's the wonder of sharing our stories:)

Hugs, ya'll.....

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Tre - 5 pts

megan your insights are bold and a bounty of substance. love your mom but don't have to like her. how fabulous...it's not about all or nothing...it's about balance. i know i've know this....to some degree.

love the no guilt thing. you know why that comes up for me sometimes? cuz i don't want her hurting in any way shape or form. i often am 'mommy' to her in ways that is a bit loo loo. but you'll get this i'm sure.

would value hearing more about your dialoguing w/ your mom...how you guys worked thru issues...or maybe you didn't but sounds like you tamed/subdued her need to control so much..yes?

really helpful insights..hugs muchly for offering your view. and yes to the being honest about our view of our moms;)

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Tre - 5 pts

"although I do wish they could see past my financial marital and medical and see me"...

that is so it isn't it...that desire to have our loved ones, moms and and and SEE US...truly SEE US....grateful to hear your desire to never give up either.

it sounds like you could add much to the choices you've made to protect your heart and keep on and stay true to your core.

i think --i know-- i'm learning that as i strengthen my conviction in how i see myself....this yields trust that those who need to will. denise once helped me so much..you did too. both of ya'll said 'just blog. those who don't get it don't matter. those who get it do.'...not meaning shun the world...but it's a small metaphor that helps a lot. with everything.

love hearing about how you and your mom have 'happened' to grow closer. that is a story you could think 'bout sharin with us if you would ever wanna :) hugs.

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Tre - 5 pts

Wow. You've experienced some tough situations and made some defining choices and patterns of living for yourself. Kudos to you...I'm so touched by how you are connecting...My mom is spoiled. ( I tend to think anyone in developed countries/western culture is) surely. Mean, not intentionally. She respects me deeply...but the control and parenting sees me as little girl often. Thanks for your salute of press on.

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Megan Smith 5 pts

Do not feel guilty.  Do not fall into the trap of what others think--they do not walk in your shoes.  Do not try to make your mother into someone she is not because it's impossible.

All you really can do is exactly what you have done:  do what you need to for yourself.

People think that unless adult children--especially women--always speak of their mothers in glowing terms, they're horrible, ungrateful, dishonorable and don't deserve to live.

They're wrong.

I know I've probably said this is comments elsewhere on BlogHer but it's worth saying again.  I gained a major amount of freedom when I came to the realization in my 20's that I could love my mother but I don't always have to like her.  It took me several years of not being around her except at holidays to actually grow into what I needed to be instead of what she needed me to be.

Now I deal with her with my own boundaries in place.  She doesn't get to say what those boundaries are because if she did I would suffocate from her need to control everyone and everything in her orbit.

Not that she hasn't tried to be a good mother, she has.  She's just not the mother I need.  And she never will be.  I've had to find what I need from other people in my life when I can. 

So once again, bravo for you!

Megan

TV/Online Video Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/megan-smith )

Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Meg's Rad Reviews ( http://www.megsradreviews.com )

Catherine Morgan 5 pts

Hi Tre.  This is a beautiful post, and I think it is wonderful that you are choosing to be true to yourself.  I often find myself reflecting on why certain members of my family feel so comfortable judging me, my choices, and my life...And whether it's wrong for me to distance myself from said people.  In my situation, these family members see me as beneath them, therefor justifying their disrespect and judgments of me.  Although I do wish they could see past my financial, medical, and marital status (and see me)...I've stopped being surprised or disappointed when they don't.  I still sometimes struggle with thoughts that I might have been able to do something differently to preserve these relationships, or that maybe I am the one at fault...But I've come to believe that it's more about my personal self-preservation than who's to blame.

You asked in your post...

Is it possible that mothers and daughters can co exist and find strength in a renewed sense of respect for one another?

I would say the answer is yes.  I don't think you can force it, but I also don't believe you should ever give up on it.  In my case, although I didn't have a bad relationship with my mother, we weren't really ever as close as we are today.  But in the last three or four years things happened (good and bad) that naturally brought us closer as mother and daughter...It was nothing that we could have predicted or manufactured, it just was.  However, if one of us had been closed off to the possibility, it could never have developed the way it did.  And because we have become closer as mother and daughter, we are also now better able to except and respect the many ways we are different (without judgement). 

Anyway, thanks for sharing your story...I think the message of being true to yourself is an important one.

Contributing Editor Catherine Morgan
Also at Catherine-Morgan.com ( http://catherine-morgan.com/ )

Southern Grace Gourmet 5 pts

removed myself from most of my family and in laws, the ones surviving anyway. I grew up real poor and in a difficult situation. Those family still engage in activity that is beyond healthy or even legal. I and my hubby had to sever all family ties, exect for my one aunt, to stay out of trouble. So from my perspective it seems like your mom is spoiled and mean. Parents sometimes just don't respect and show love to their kids, i've been there. I learned very young we have to demand respect, and if we don't get it, punish them with our absence, its the only way to get their attention. Thanks for sharing your story and horray to you for standing up to an overbearing mother, its not her life, its yours. You do whatever makes you happy. Seems like your mom is embarresed of you because she is insecure with herself. Just guessing by reading between the lines.

Tre - 5 pts

Love this idea. love the warm island idea too..as adults..wise choice. Last time i tried that she cell phoned her husband every hour b/c i think i make her nervous. hee. well, i'm all for something new...surely muchly deeply :) soo grateful you resonated with this. we each have to figure out how to take care of ourselves don't we? :) i'm a tad of a turtle :) hee hee. happy new year!

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Liz Henry 5 pts

Tre, I respect this so deeply! I think by refusing to engage in the destructive bit of the relationship, you may make space for something better...  fly her to a warm island beach somewhere, not on a holiday.  Then the expectations that smother possibility might be replaced by a new pattern...   meeting as adults outside of a negative role...  Anyway, I believe that your idea will work and it's great that you took care of yourself this way.

-----------------
Liz Henry ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... )
Composite: Tech & Poetics ( http://liz-henry.blogspot.com/ )
lizzard@bookmaniac.net

Tre - 5 pts

Step by stepping healing our hearts is a happy holiday no matter when we choose to do it yes? :)

Hugs back.

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Tre - 5 pts

Aww. What a good friend you are to one another. And...bless his heart that he knows he needs to do something different...for him.

In neat unexpected ways, this step gave me lots of moments to pause and give where I wouldn't have been able to.

But I'm not 'with new strategy' by any means...Just step by stepping how to fine tune what I need while still hoping to somehow reinvent how mom and I share moments together...holiday or otherwise...

Grateful for this perspective...want/would love to hear more from others...maybe many have already chosen to shake it up a bit and tend to their own needs more....ah for that place where we could voice our needs to our folks and meet in the land of compromise...ya know that place? yeah.....sigh...:)

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Elisa Camahort 5 pts

I spent the evening after Christmas with one of my oldest friends, one who has spent a lifetime trying to be the good son. Every year I invite him to spend the holidays with my family, because every year his sound miserable and tense. 

This year he finally said: Next year, if I give you the same line, "It'll be fine. It's what I should do", just slap me upside the head and don't let me do it."

And we're 45/46 years old...so obviously you are not alone :)

Elisa Camahort Page BlogHer elisa@blogher.com My BlogHer profile ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) truly shows you everything I do online...Check it out!!