Bio
Learn more about me or just visit my personal blog or come bargain hunt with me. Writing? Check. Parenting? Check. Shopping for shoes? Check. Yep,...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why I'm Happy When My Son Lies, But Frustrated When My Daughter Does

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I am fascinated by lying. Seriously. I always have been. I was a theater major, for Pete's sake. The act of pulling on a persona has always been appealing to me, and my parents are only too happy to remind me that I was something of a pathological liar in my youth. I do recall sometimes saying things just to see if lying would work, and of course can think of plenty of times I simply lied as an attempt to get out of trouble.

This may or may not be on my mind because yesterday, after I posted about our SUPER FANTASTIC morning and my caving on taking my child to school because it was so very important... it turned out that she'd lied about needing to be there.* (Of course. Should've seen that one coming.)

The thing about lying is that we all do it, to some degree or another. Did you know that this guy says we all lie regularly, maybe as much as three times in ten minutes of casual conversation? Kinda makes "the truth" seem like a unicorn.

Anyway, the older I get, the more I value honesty. I don't have a lot of patience for game-playing when it comes to communication. I have no desire, anymore, to be anyone but myself. I like it when you're YOURself, too. And I like it when we're all honest, and no one has to figure out if you really meant something else or whatever.

Enter the lessons of raising humans: Children's brains aren't fully formed, you know, and their honesty centers tend to be... well... a little malleable, let's say. Just because I now truly believe honesty to be the best policy, doesn't necessarily mean they agree with me. To say the least.

Sister (12-13) and brother (10-11) sitting back to back

Now, when Chickadee lies, I'd venture a guess that it's pretty age- and temperament-appropriate for her. I'm most likely to believe her if the lie comes along with a big show of emotion, so her best zingers (like yesterday) are generally accompanied with tears. She lies to get her way. She lies to try to get out of trouble. She lies whenever she thinks she'll be better off lying than telling the truth, even though caught lies evoke the harshest penalties 'round here. While I'm not pleased that she does this, I'm also not quite ready to declare her irretrievable, because she's only 12, and I was once young, dumb, and conscienceless, too.

The funny thing to me, though, is that this is where raising an Aspie gets truly interesting. Monkey didn't lie for most of his life. I think maybe he didn't understand how to. He told the truth always, often at his peril. He's still not very good at understanding the whole concept of tact, but we're working on it.

Nowadays, though, as his social skills improve, so has his lying. And part of me wants to be mad, but -- as with the situation detailed in Jillsmo's post this morning -- it's hard to be upset when it represents a developmental milestone. And for him, it really is. Sometimes I turn to Otto and say, "I'm just so proud -- our precious little Monkey is turning into a liarpants!" He now occasionally lies to try to get out of trouble. Most often he lies because it makes the story more interesting and he realized that he CAN. Of course, he's still just so terrible at it, I was telling a friend yesterday that I often find myself saying, "Really? I don't think that's true." It's the kind of thing I used to say to Chickadee when she was four. And I have to try REALLY REALLY HARD not to laugh when I say it to Monkey.

Let's compare and contrast, shall we?

A typical Chickadee lie:
Her: *sobbing* I have to be at the meeting today or I can't get on a team and then I can't go to competition and I've just been working so so so hard and I really don't want to miss out on this, Mom. It's such a good opportunity and I've done all this work and I can't believe I'm going to sacrifice it all just because I made one mistake. Please, please please can't you make an exception? I swear this is super

  • 4
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
lovelifeproject 5 pts

Ooooh...the "come up with your own punishment" punishment. Harsh, harsh, harsh! (I agree with you...she deserves it!) This is a fascinating post. For some reason, I've been reading a lot of blog posts lately about parenting kids with Asperger's. Really interesting, and you have such a great sense of humour when describing it.

andrew@sympoz 5 pts

The biggest problem I've found is giving my kids guidance on when lying (white lies) is okay and when it isn't. They catch me lying on the phone (to get out of some form of solicitation), or when I'm trying not to hurt someone's feelings. I think this tends to confuse them, and perhaps leads them to lie when they shouldn't.

DesiValentine4 27 pts

My brother has Asperger's syndrome, and I remember how difficult middle school and high school were for him just because of his plain inability to lie. Now married and a father, he still claims that learning to lie was the biggest, most difficult and most rewarding of his social milestones. But when my daughter lies to me (she's four), I totally forget that this is necessary social behaviour and lose my mind, instead. Clearly, I have some learning to do, too!

zchamu 5 pts

Have you ever read any of Po Bronson's stuff? He wrote a great article on why kids lie: http://nymag.com/news/features/43893/ Your post made me think of it, especially the 'milestone' stuff. Very enlightening.

Visit my blogs at ThreeSeven ( http://www.threeseven.ca ) (all that's irrelevant and amusing) and
ecochick ( http://www.ecochick.ca ) (all that's green, cool and Canadian).