Bio
I am the mother of a curious, questioning, smart and funny 5 year old boy and freelance writer who only recently came to the blogosphere. In my life...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Why I'm Not A Soccer Mom

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 27
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Fall has both officially and seasonally arrived here in the North East, marked by crisp but sunny days and sweater-worthy nights. In my house fall also means outdoor weekend adventures, the occasional homemade soup and pajamas before 7 pm. For other parents in my town, however, fall is soccer season, a period of several months where their kids are bending it like Beckham three times a week, rain or shine.

Like many towns across the country, soccer is practically a religion where I live, practiced with a devotion that would put some monks to shame. Birthday parties are arranged around games, cliques are formed among teammates and more than a few parents I know have spent too many Memorial and Labor Days out of town, not at seaside havens, but in post-heyday towns like Poughkeepsie, NY or Allentown, PA, rooting for their children’s travel teams. I’d be lying if I told you I simply chose not to participate in this community cult. In fact, I’m a little envious of the bonds that are formed on the sidelines among parents who share the triumphs and disappointments of their brethren’s athleticism. It’s just that we tried our hand at soccer last spring and it didn’t go too well.

It was late March and I don’t’ know who was more excited about JP’s eligibility to join the town’s soccer league, which starts in the spring of the year you begin Kindergarten. Sure, JP was looking forward to that first Saturday afternoon but in the way a 4-year old looks forward to something that doesn’t involve sugar, with anticipation but nothing on par with say, a birthday party. My husband Jim on the other hand was beyond himself, buying my son cleats and shin guards while simultaneously shifting through his collection of FIFA jerseys to pick which country he would represent for his first official day as a Soccer Dad.

Photo by the bbp via Flickr

When we arrived on the field that first morning, excited to start the new phase of our life where our cheers for JP’s efforts would move beyond our four walls, it was a little intimidating. First off, when we went in search of JP’s team I didn’t think I’d need any more information than his name and grade, for how many teams of Kindergarten boys could there actually be, right? Well, the answer is 10. There were another 10 teams of girls. Uh oh, I thought. This might be a little more intense than I thought. My fears eased a bit when I finally tracked down and met JP’s coaches, two really nice men whose own boys were wearing the same orange shirt as my son. We each gave JP a high-five, stepped off to the side and watched our son eagerly run out on the field. Almost immediately the Dad-coaches began running drills and JP was having a blast kicking the ball, even if he wasn’t navigating the twists and turns of the orange cones perfectly. When 20 minutes later the kids were broken up into two teams for a scrimmage I was a little confused. Wait, a game? But these kids only learned the basic principles of the sport 20 minutes ago, I reasoned. How could they be expected to play? The answer was immediately evident.

These kids were no rookies. From the way they were manipulating the ball and weaving around other players it was obvious these boys had done this dance before. I looked over towards my son as he stood perfectly still in the middle of the field, oblivious to the disruption he was causing to the game. His head was down and he had his arms crossed around his chest, a gesture I know from experience is part-disappointment, part-I-am-not-moving-from-this-spot-unless-you-physically-drag-me. Jim ran out and asked him what was wrong and when JP told him that he didn’t know how to do what the other kids were doing, my husband assured him that this was how you learned the game and really, the main goal was just to have fun, even if all that meant was running up and down the field. Jim’s pep talk seemed to work and JP got back in the game. He was doing well, following the pack of boys who controlled the ball while parents cheered from afar (most encouragingly, others with an aggressiveness I found scary), until another boy scored a goal. Instead of celebrating his teammate’s success, my son took to the ground with all four appendages splayed out in

  • 27
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Adriasmom 6 pts

I tried t-ball with my daughter when she was about 5. She was great all through practice but then when it came time to play the games I had to bribe her! (Not something that I'm proud of, mind you! haha) After the second game I decided she didn't have to go back

CroMom 5 pts

I signed my 2 1/2 year old up for some in door soccer (and gymnastics) mostly to get out of the house last winter when we brought home a new baby. I thought this would be a great way to spend some quality time together since it is a Mommy (or daddy) and me type program. Just running around with a ball, playing games, no competition. My son hated it! All of it! He didn't like being in a structured setting. He was scared of the teachers.

This is a kid who isn't happy unless ESPN is on tv and he has a ball or a bat in his hands. He is a high energy, sports guy. But I realized that he didn't like the structured setting. Take him to his dad's soccer practice (he is a college coach) and he plays with the college guys. So we quit (I think they are too little to understand the "you made a committment speech). today he is in pre-school and doing great. I see a huge change in his ability to follow directions and take turns. I think we will give it more time then try again. My neighbors mostly agreed that their kid(s) were the same way.

Good luck.

EllenBailey 6 pts

CroMom Thanks for commenting. I also agree that the "commitment speech" is a bit premature which is why I ended up trusting my gut and not the judgmental remarks from some friends. I keep learning this lesson over and over, that I know what's best for my child. Will I ever really get it?

mdilloway 7 pts

I think you totally did the right thing.

In the olden days, (like the 70s and 80s), I don't think kids played competitively until they were around age 8. Most may not be ready for it before then, and of course if you start really young, you may risk burnout or injury. I think Bruce Jenner said he didn't even discover he was good at sports until high school, which would be *ancient* by modern standards.

My kids hate team sports. That's okay.

EllenBailey 6 pts

mdilloway You are not the first to cite age 8 as the "ideal" age to start sports. I think it's so funny that most kids are on a travel team by then in my town. Crazy!

Ultimately I don't care if JP ever plays sports, I just wan to expose him to as much opportunities to have fun as possible. I know most parents think similarly. Sometimes I think my ego is in this somewhere. Thanks for commenting!

Jenfluke 5 pts

Hi I'm not a mom but I have coached 7-10 year old girls and boys. I'd love any tips from other coaches or parents on how to avoid putting kids off. My gut feel is that learning how to run around with the ball at their feet and having fun are the most important things at that age. I would not introduce anything but fun games until they were probably 7.

EllenBailey 6 pts

Jenfluke Sounds about right. I also think it's about recognizing each child's experience and skill level and working with them from where they are. I'm sure that is hard if you are the only coach and I don't envy all the time you dedicate to our kids, so thank you!

What about other parents? What do you think?

SHembree 12 pts

Great post! I definitely agree that too much too soon can be just plain too much for kids! While it isn't a sport, my daughter froze before a ballet recital -- it was awful. It's great that you recognized that it wasn't the right time for your son -- kuddos to you!

wksocmom 5 pts

Ugh, that's just crazy. Competitive sports and 4 years old do not belong together. My husband is a professional coach and he just got lectured by a dad about wanting his 8yo son to win so he would not lose his confidence. My husband told him he might want to quit the league as they are about development, not winning. In other countries you don't start keeping score, do competitive team play until at least 12. If you can find a YMCA or other clinic with professional coaches you might try that. They are really about having fun, learning the game, development, never worrying about the score and dealing with every level. I promise those 4 year olds who already know how to play are probably going to be burned out by 10. My son is an amazing player right now, thanks in part to good genes and an extraordinary about of patience from his dad. We sent him to a fun clinic run by college athletes when he was 4 and he spent all but the last session in his dad's arms :)

EllenBailey 6 pts

wksocmom Thank you for your post. You are not the first person to suggest the YMCA and I think I'm finally paying attention. I really appreciate your perspective from the wife of a coach. I also sent JP to a fun clinic this summer and he was on my lap more than the field! Thank you again for chiming in!

MoreThanMommy 7 pts

Our son isn't in soccer (or any other team sport), either. Our little guy had gross motor delays that still impact his physical fitness and coordination. Watching him play hockey with his peers was incredibly painful because he just couldn't quite get it. And I remember the exact same wonderment that we had failed our son so completely that he didn't even get the concept of that type of sport. But I also know something else. While he may someday choose a team sport, he may not. It simply isn't for everyone and I can't say that I'm sad to not have to deal with the constant driving around and team activities. We decided on karate for our son. I chose a dojo that has a tight-knit family atmosphere, is supportive, and focuses on individual achievement. He gets the sense of rooting for his "team," without feeling the pressure to keep up with them. Even so, the poor thing still can't figure out how to run through a row of orange cones...

Four is oh-so-young for team sports. I'm glad you decided to give him some more time and space to grow and mature.

EllenBailey 6 pts

MoreThanMommy Thank you so much for commenting. I remember how conflicted I felt when my gut was telling me to let my son sit out his first season but my head wouldn't let me. I even had one friend give me the "tsk tsk" look when I said I wasn't going to make him play anymore. I let her judgements cloud mine. Never again. Thanks for sharing your son's story. He sounds awesome!

BBernard 14 pts

PS. I believe it is the American Academy of Pediatrics that suggests delaying competitive team sports until the age of 8. Interesting tidbit.

BBernard 14 pts

Our family doesn't follow any professional team sports. My husband is a cyclist a la Lance Armstrong which doesn't make for festive TV watching together. So, my 5 year old barely knows the difference between various sporting equipment, and he is certainly not interested in competing! He recently asked to take piano lessons and I JUMPED on it. Not all boys are cut out for sports, and I wish our society was more OK with that. Great post, Ellen. I am totally OK with not freezing my butt off on a field every Saturday morning for the next 14 years!!

sharongreenthal 8 pts

My daughter had a similar experience with softball at the age of four. After a few practices, it was obvious that the only thing she enjoyed about softball was when she got to leave at the end of each practice session. Imagine our surprise when, at the age of five, she began to play again (this time with friends on her team) and wound up loving it - playing up until she started high school. Half way into your story I was screaming in my head "wait another year!" His commitment to his teammates at the age of four isn't nearly as important as his feeling safe to say "I don't like this."

EllenBailey 6 pts

sharongreenthal Thank you Sharon. I agree with you! We don't know what next year has in store and ultimately, I don't care, as long as he finds something he feels good about. Thanks for posting!

Amanda_Magee 8 pts

We are treading very lightly, with three daughters (3,5 and 7) we want them to follow their own interests and not be pressured by our preferences or that of their sisters. Any of them can try anything, but after one experience with out oldest freezing on the lacrosse field, it is going to be up to them when, where and how. The hard part will be how to balance trying vs quitting, but we aren't there yet. Phew.

fouragainsttwo 10 pts

I have noticed that there is very little practice and instructions with team sports anymore. It is taught to kids so young now that Kindergarten is considered late to learn a new sport. Very sad really. My oldest was so excited to be able to play golf this year and instead of getting instruction she was put with four other girls who already had been playing for years and were really good. My hubby had been taking Meg out for a few years during the summer to teach her somethings, but these other girls had had actually golf lessons. They are in the sixth grade. It's almost like if you are aren't the best by 7 you shouldn't play :(

EllenBailey 6 pts

fouragainsttwo I feel that pressure too. And while I try not to let it influence my parenting decisions I can't help but wonder if I'm putting him at a disadvantage by waiting another year, when the kids will be even better. Thanks for your post! Really comforting!

radar5 6 pts

I can totally relate, mama. My oldest (who is now ten and currently the star of his travel soccer team) is a perfectionist and his first soccer practice at the age of four went a lot like your son's.

Only my husband was the coach, so it was extra embarrassing. I'm sure the other parents were wondering what the heck my husband was going to do coach their kids if he couldn't even get his own to move. lol

The key for our son was a lot of time outside of team practice and games for him to practice his skills where no one else could see him if he messed up.

EllenBailey 6 pts

radar5 Wow, radar5! While I secretly hoped he had a chance for redemption, I didn't actually believe it! That is amazing that your son went on to love the game (and be really good at it too!) Thanks for your advice. I will share it with my husband.

Conversation from Facebook

Nickie Cleveland
Nickie Cleveland

My daughter asked to start soccer last fall. And their first game was the funniest thing ever! They had their first 'practice' 20 minutes before the game, and seeing a field of short little people run the wrong way was awesome!!
She ended up just not getting the game and quit, which I assured her was just fine. She wants to try again in the spring, and has developed quite a powerful kick. Go, Rain!! :)

Jennifer Flueckiger
Jennifer Flueckiger

I've coached boys and girls soccer and would really like to avoid putting kids off in this way. Any coaches or parents have any tips?

Polish Mama on the Prairie
Polish Mama on the Prairie

I want to be a soccer mom. Not exactly a soccer mom by the minvan scream at your kid from the sideline while sipping Starbucks sense. But having my kids in sports. They are both talented in it and need it but we can't afford it. :(

Kylie Menagh-Johnson
Kylie Menagh-Johnson

Oh, this is sooooo familiar.

Sara Milligan Tennent
Sara Milligan Tennent

We just put our daughter in soccer this year... at the age of 3. Big mistake... huge.