Why one size (diet) does not fit all

not enough to eatIt happens to the best of us. Maybe your favorite jeans are getting hard to button or the skirt you haven't worn in months is suddenly way too tight around your butt.

When you get up the courage to step on the scale, the cold, hard truth stares you in the face: Yup, you've gained a few pounds. 

So now you're ready to grab the latest diet book or pick up a magazine with a screaming headline about "effortless" weight loss.

Fair enough. But before you give the latest popular diet a try, I want you to think about whether it's going to provide enough calories.

See, many diet plans for women recommend somewhere between 1,000 and 1,300 calories a day, and that simply isn’t enough energy for you to exercise, protect your lean muscle tissue, and stave off hunger. That is, unless you’re a very small person or have a slow metabolism.

Maybe you’re thinking, But I’m in a hurry to shed this fat---so if I cut more calories, I can get lean faster.

I understand that you’re hot to fit into those jeans again, but cutting calories too severely is likely to backfire because

  • You’re going to feel more hungry and deprived---and thus will be more likely to cheat.
  • You’ll lose not just fat but also lean muscle, the engine that drives your metabolic rate and helps you burn more calories all day long.
  • Your levels of the appetite-regulating hormones leptin and ghrelin will get out of whack, causing an increase in hunger. And who wants to end up after a diet with less muscle, more hunger, and a slower metabolism?

Have I gotten your attention? Good. Now I’m going to explain a better, smarter way than following a “one size fits all” diet plan.

Gathering information

Using a quick online calculator, you can get a fast and fairly accurate assessment of your total daily energy expenditure (TDEE). That’s the sum of the calories you burn just existing (basal metabolic rate) and through physical activity.

You can find one right here. It’s free, fast, and super-easy to use.

The calculator will ask for your height, weight, age, and sex. It’s also going to ask you to choose an activity level, from sedentary through extremely active. The activity levels are defined as follows:

  • Sedentary---person doesn’t exercise at all
  • Lightly active---person does light activity or sports one to three times weekly
  • Moderately active---person does moderate activity or sports three to five days a week
  • Very active---person does hard exercise or sports six or seven days a week
  • Extremely active---person trains intensely more than once a day or performs a job that is very physical

Once you plug in the numbers and select an activity level, you’ll get an instant estimate of “average actual metabolism” (your TDEE) and resting metabolism (the number of calories you'd burn if you performed no activity at all).

Yes, there is individual variation: some people require more energy (calories) than the estimate; some need less. But the number gives you a good place to start. You can always adjust as needed if you discover that you seem to burn more or fewer calories.

Figuring out how many calories to consume

Now that you’ve got your estimate, you can make a smart decision about how many calories to cut.

The most sensible strategy is to reduce calories by a specific percentage: 15 to 20 percent for a moderate pace of fat loss, 25 to 30 percent if you want to be more aggressive. (I'm indebted to fat-loss guru Tom Venuto for this concept.)

You can safely be more aggressive if you have a lot of fat to lose and do not have a history of crash dieting.

If you’re smaller (and have 20 pounds or less to shed) or have been on and off diets for years, the more conservative approach is preferable.

Grab a calculator, and let’s figure this out.

The “average actual metabolism” (TDEE) number you determined above is your maintenance level---the number of calories it takes to keep your weight steady. Decide which percentage of calorie restriction you want to use: 15, 20, 25, or 30 percent.

Multiply TDEE by the percentage. If, for example, your TDEE is 2,200 and you want to cut calories by 25 percent, that’s 2,200 x .25, and the result is 550. That’s the number of calories to cut from your daily intake.

Subtract that result from TDEE to get the number of calories to eat daily while on your diet. In this example, that’s a TDEE of 2,200 – 550, which equals 1,650. At that rate, you should burn a pound of fat about every 6.4 days (subject to individual variation).

If you want to lose fat more quickly, consider increasing your activity level rather than cutting back on food.

Make sense?

Does this sound like a whole lot more food than a lot of diets permit? And, um, do you think it might be easier to stick to than that 1,000-calorie-a-day plan in your women’s magazine?

Please share your thoughts and experiences in the comment box. Let me know how your diet's going!

 

Recent Posts by maryweaver

Comments

In order to comment on BlogHer.com, you'll need to be logged in. You'll be given the option to log in or create an account when you publish your comment. If you do not log in or create an account, your comment will not be displayed.