Blog
Sweetney
Bio
I'm a geeky Gen-X writer and parental unit from Charm City, USA. I blog about my life and interests at my personal blog Sweetney, am the founder/co-ed...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Why Rihanna shouldn't stand by her man

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Doubtless by now there's nary a soul living in the continental United States who isn't at least vaguely aware of what happened early Sunday morning between singer Rihanna and her boyfriend Chris Brown. And though the details may still be somewhat sketchy, what is known for certain is that, shortly after leaving Clive Davis' pre-Grammy party late Saturday night, Brown and Rihanna fought in Brown's rented Lamborghini in L.A.'s Hancock Park neighborhood, and police were called by a person in the area who heard Rihanna's screams. Comparing various reports about the altercation, it's clear that the injuries Rihanna sustained at Brown's hands were significant and serious -- contusions, bite wounds, black eyes and bruising have been mentioned in almost every noteworthy report -- and that Brown both threatened to kill Rihanna and choked her into an unconscious state. But as the days pass what's also becoming clear is that Rihanna may not be cooperating fully with authorities, and may also be reluctant to press charges against Brown. And, like many of you I'm sure, hearing that makes me profoundly, profoundly sad.

Let me state up front that I don't think any woman should ever be forced to press charges against her abuser, whether he's a boyfriend or husband or some other sort of relation. I am very much aware that domestic violence is a profoundly complex, highly charged, incredibly sensitive subject, and that each instance of abuse is unique and individual, and probably only completely understood by the woman going through it. Why women stay in abusive relationships, why women protect and refuse to prosecute men who would hurt them... honestly, I do get it. Beyond emotional attachment, there are often other financial, legal, and child-custody matters that lead women to feel they have to or should stay with their abuser, that lead them to feel they are trapped, alone, helpless, without support or options. I feel deeply for these women, and have an enormous amount of empathy for their plight. I also understand that abused and disempowered women may feel having to stand up publicly and testify against their abuser -- particularly if they don't have the personal support or resources to carry them through such an emotionally wrenching experience -- would simply prolong the trauma for them, and would prefer to simply put all of it behind them, to quietly move on and past the horrors they've endured. Again, these women have my deepest, most sincere sympathy.

However, these women are not Rihanna.

Rihanna and Chris Brown

And though I don't pretend to know intimate details about who Rihanna is as a personality -- what constitutes her persona or identity or her sense of self -- there are many things I do know about her that set her apart from most all other women on planet earth, and would -- were I in the position to do so as a friend, confidant, or advisor -- compel me to urge her to not suffer the violence she's endured silently or without pursuing legal action. In brief:

1. RESOURCES. Rihanna has a staggering array of financial and legal resources at her disposal that most women could and would never have access to. Her position in the music industry as a multi-platinum, Grammy-winning, number-one-single hitmaker puts her in an incredibly privileged position even among the elite of that industry, and there is little question that she would have access to the best legal counsel available and receive additional support from her label and the greater music community.

2. SUPPORT. Rihanna has a literal army of supporters, and is already being inundated with emotional encouragement and offers of help. Fans have been filling her MySpace page with words of support. Radio stations have been pulling Brown's music from their on-air rotation and even staging protests against him in support of her. Former Def-Jam President, mentor, and close friend Jay-Z is said to be enraged over the incident: "'He hit the roof,' a source close to [Jay-Z] told Us Weekly. 'Chris is a walking dead man. He messed with the wrong crew.'" (For the record, I'm not suggesting Chris Brown deserves to be murdered (or threatened, for that matter), but rather mean to demonstrate the powerful feelings of loyalty and protectiveness friends feel for the singer.) Even professional wackadoo Kanye West has publicly professed his allegiance to Rihanna, saying on Ryan Seacrest's radio show Tuesday: "I feel like that's

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
urban_one 5 pts

I agree that the truth needs to be brought out before anyone offers an opinion. Because no one, even after the facts, can judge either of them. That's not our right because we're  all human. I am a female and I don't condone violence. But I am not pretentious enough or naive enough to say that couples don't argue and fight in America and every other 'civilized' nation everyday. These two are 'kids', 19 and 20, that have been hounded ridicously in the media for the last year. Papparazzi on them 24/7,  just like they did poor Princess Di. Chris has offered up a public apoligy,so I assume from that, that he knows he's done something seriously wrong. But my son showed me a magazine interview of Rihanna's, where she told the interviewer that the movie 300 was not too violent for her, she loved the action. She was the only girl of her 3 siblings and they often fought and not just verbally. The interviewer asked her who won and she answered " I hit the older one in his face with a glass bottle". To me this situation is ultimately best left up truly to Chris and Rihanna, and their families that can help guide them. I've watched Chris over the last couple of years with my kids, he is one of the most refreshing, genuinely decent young celebs I've seen in quite a while. I was so tired of the spoiled drug addicted, bulimic(or otherwide emotionally unbalanced),or  thugged out entertainers in the music industry today. So I'm gving him the benefit of the doubt and my only wish after all of this, is that they can now live their lives without the constant stress of the papparazzi. And get on with their lives. Rihanna is by no means a young lady that is going to allow someone to 'victimize' her. I think the worst pain she's going thru is emotional pain because of having to let go of Chris.Someone she has stated constantly that was her 'best, best' friend, since she has no family in the U.S and she's from Barbados.

And by the way I chose this name, because of another blog entry that made the claim that of course he hit her because he was 'urban' . They said urban was another name for you know what. So since I believe I am what they were calling 'urban', I joined this blog to actually respond to that comment. I'm sure the majority of you will say that I'm fitting into that stereotype because of my response. But I'm over 50 and I've lived long enough and experienced life enough to understand  emotions. relationships, stress, how only a sociopath can truly hide a vicious nature, our  changing culture of greed that has destroyed America(including the medai) and all the negative elements that went into this sad situation.

ErinSneddon 5 pts

I want to hear the whole truth before i make a judgement

sweetney 5 pts

Thanks so much for the comment, Allison. That's important information for sure, and I appreciate you setting me straight about the law in California.

I would add, I didn't say I don't believe any victim should be forced to participate in the criminal justice system for fear it will prolong her anguish -- rather, that I think some victims think this, and therefore choose to not press charges or cooperate with authorities. My position is that no woman should be forced to do anything, but certainly I would hope they would stand up against their abusers whenever possible.

Again though, thanks for the great comment!

Tracey Gaughran-Perez, aka Sweetney
CE, Entertainment & Culture
Author/Editor of Sweetney ( http://www.sweetney.com ), MamaPop ( http://www.mamapop.com ), & We Covet
( http://www.wecovet.com )

sweetney 5 pts

No, I hear you. I hope -- and so far there seem good indictators that this is the case -- that she has enough of a strong support system around her that it can penetrate that, the pain and the love and the fear. Time will tell, I guess. But I think she does have the resources and support *if* she can access them, so I have a lot of hope for her.

Tracey Gaughran-Perez, aka Sweetney
CE, Entertainment & Culture
Author/Editor of Sweetney ( http://www.sweetney.com ), MamaPop ( http://www.mamapop.com ), & We Covet
( http://www.wecovet.com )

Sarcastic-Mom 5 pts

We'll have to see how it all pans out.  One thing I kept thinking while I was reading your list of reasons why she's different from other women in significant ways that would make you urge her to seek help: deep emotional (and physical) pain has a way of bringing us all to our knees, where we are equal.  Knocked down, bruised, and torn apart.  Weak, vulnerable women... people.  Sometimes, love and pain blind you so harshly that you can't even see your own resources and support group.

All you can "see" is the face behind the fists.

Sarcastic Mom ( http://sarcasticmom.com )

"Because Survival Requres Humor"

Wilma Ham 5 pts

I absolutely love the tone of your post.
We indeed don't know what is going on, although that doesn't mean what happened is okay, however that also doesn' t mean we need to be ready to judge and make it worse by talking about it in judgmental way.  

I have done things in my life that were not okay, not as drastic as that or violence . . but we all do things wrong and it is absolutely lovely when people show compassion to help you forgive yourself and help you to do things differently.
I hope that will be the case for both of them, 19 and 20 is such a young age.
They deserve compassion and a chance to process what happened for their own good without having whole hordes of people breathing down their neck in a nasty condemning way.
That is why I love your tone.

Wilma Ham

www.wilmasblog.com ( http://www.wilmasblog.com/ )

conversemomma 5 pts

I don't think it's preachy. I think it is important. I took some time to ask my middle school students how they felt. What made me saddest of all was how many of them wanted to somehow blame Rihanna. They told me they couldn't believe that someone like Chris Brown could do it. I helped them to make some correlations between this case and other cases where every day women suffer at the hands of someone they love. How many average women don't tell, stay in the relationship for fear they are to blame or won't be believed, or don't have a choice? Rihanna does seem to have more resources and therefore you would hope more courage to chose to leave. I wish her and every women who has experienced this, all the luck. Great article!

Peace,

Kelly (conversemomma)

http://www.ordinaryartblog.com

allisonhaley 5 pts

My name is Allison Haley and I am a domestic violence prosecutor in the Napa Valley. Had Mr. Brown assaulted his victim on his way to a winery rather than in a neighborhood in L.A., this case would have landed squarely on my desk.

To clarify an error in your essay (and I mean it in the spirit of understanding with no venom or useless hairsplitting intended...) victims in the State of California do not press charges. The decision is never theirs to make. While I, as a district attorney, am always interested in what the victim wants as a resolution in a case, I never ask her permission in representing the plaintiff in any criminal matter: the People of the State of California. While she may want to walk quietly away from a history of horror (and believe me, I have heard some doozies) my clients consider any crime to be an offense against the community and not just the individual victim.

 You state that you don't believe any victim should be forced to participate in the criminal justice system because you fear it will prolong her anguish. I can tell you that  I regularly prosecute cases with uncooperative victims and I treat them as I would hope someone would treat me in my darkest hour: with quiet compassion and kindness.  There are many good men and women whose life's work is dedicated to providing the very systems of support you mention to help all victims bravely face their abusers.

I am one of them.

lauriewrites 6 pts

And it drives me insane.

It's also possible that she fears him - regardless of finances or celebrity status. (And I know she can easily get protection, of course...but still, if someone tears you up that badly, wow, I can't even imagine. An isolated, MUCH less serious incident with an ex tells me I would always be afraid he would do it again.)

It saddened me to read this story and it was surprising to me that they were so young, for some reason. I had no idea that Brown was 19 and Rihanna only 20. I hope for her the same things that you do, that she'll find whatever strength she needs to stay away from this person who did these (in my opinion too) unforgivable things to her. These situations always remind me that fame and celebrity do nothing to remove common problems, but I'm hopeful her resources will help her (and help her make that statement to other people, as you said.)

Laurie

LaurieWrites ( http://lauriewrites.typepad.com )

Nordette Adams 6 pts

Thanks, Sweetney.

Nordette ( http://blogher.org/blog/nordette ) is a BlogHer CE, personal blog WSATA ( http://bigsole.blogspot.com ). Also @ Twitter ( http://twitter.com/nordette_verite ) and The Urban Mother's Book of Prayers ( http://urbanpsalms.blogspot.com ).

shanbrentris 5 pts

You make an excellent point, Sweetney, and I hope that you are right.  And for the record, this is the first I've heard about this.  Hi!  I live in a cave! :)

Mr Lady www.whiskeyinmysippycup.com ( http://www.whiskeyinmysippycup.com )