Bio
40yo Mom of two boys, ages 13 and 11, affectionately referred to as the Owl and the Rhino. Insecure, neurotic, creative and passionate, my blog is for...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Why You Won't See A Post Pushing Breastfeeding from Me This Week, or Any Week

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I just commented on this, but I feel it's important enough to write a post about.

Apparently, this is 'breastfeeding week' and Moms are invited to 'Go for the Gold' by basically pressuring new Moms to breastfeed their kids, give them the number for La Leche League, etc.  This is supposed to generate awareness about breastfeeding.

I really don't think there's any problem with awareness in this country about the benefits of breast-feeding. I think that point has been hammered in often enough.

In fact, I think there's an almost militant stance by some pro-breastfeeding organizations, like La Lache League, that borders on making women feel inadequate and ashamed just for having problems with breast-feeding.  Or, even worse, if they end up using formula instead of breast-feeding.  Actually, I think they DO make a lot of new Moms feel ashamed if they don't say how wonderful breastfeeding is.

My oldest son wouldn't nurse, and I thank God for the formula companies out there, because even with the help of the "lactation consultant" in the hospital, he simply wouldn't take my breast milk.  He started losing weight, and we would have to wake him up every two hours just to try to feed him. We went to the doctor EVERY SINGLE DAY for weigh-ins.  He was labelled as "failure to thrive."  I felt like a horrible Mother. Finally, when I was completely falling apart, my husband and Mother, who were supportive of ME AND MY BABY, convinced me it would be okay to go to bottles.

And I am SO glad we did.  Formula-feeding made him into a strong, healthy, happy little boy.

I don't have any problem with breast-feeding.  If you can do it, that's fine.  I know that there are all kinds of benefits to breastfeeding as well.  But don't look at Moms who aren't breastfeeding like they are pariahs, either.

Because, the thing is, EVERY SINGLE MOTHER I have ever spoken to personally has found it is far more difficult than she was led to believe to breastfeed.  Some were able to breastfeed successfully after trying and trying and beating themselves up over it and feeling, as I did, that they were somehow not good Moms.  Others, like me, could not.  So they fed their kids formula.  And I think that's okay.

There's a movement to keep formula out of hospitals?! Wow.  That's real nice. Way to support women's choices and let them make decisions about how they raise their own children, people!

Shame on you.

I was a bottle baby.  So was my husband.  We're good, honest, conscientious, well-educated people.   

So I would much rather see some REAL stories about how difficult it can be to breastfeed, and that it is okay to feed your baby with formula if you need to, than more stories pushing breastfeeding onto women as if it is something they MUST do or fail as a mother.  We have enough of those already.

  • 5
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
a_m 5 pts

For me and my son (11 months, still nursing) was never being allowed to tell others, especially not mothers-to-be, that nursing worked very well for us. My comments were always obliterated by those around who were quick to say that "well, nursing isn't the same for everybody" or "well, you're lucky you have it so easy." Obviously, nothing is the same for everybody. But I think it would help immensely if women could be honest about their success as well as their struggles. Nursing is not universally a grit your teeth, tough it out, experience.

babybeatnik 5 pts

The difficulties of breastfeeding fall under the title of "Things I Never Got Told About Being a Mom." Most definitely. I tried to breastfeed my first daughter. I tried to get help at the hospital, and it wasn't available. I would have talked to my friends and family who did it, but I was among the first of my friends to have kids and I've never really been close enough to the women of my family to ask them how they got their kids to suck on their boobs. (I realize it's NOT LIKE THAT - but that's what it felt like when I breeched the subject with them.)

After about a week, I realized what the problem was. When my milk came in, I swelled so badly that my areolas pretty much enveloped my nipples - giving my little girl nothing to latch on to. My body was physically telling me not to do this. It turns out that that was a really good thing, but for reasons I can't discuss. 

Later when I would talk to other women about it, I got some of the dirtiest looks I've ever received. I actually had one girl tell me that she didn't want to spend time with me or my daughter anymore... It was like I was being booted out of the mommy-club. I was no longer good enough to be seen in the presence of the "good mommies."

It was incredibly disappointing. Despite their attempts at making me feel like a failure, I never did. But I did feel ashamed for these women. It sucks that they could be so discouraging. 

But, here I am pregnant again. And I can tell you this, despite the boot I received from the Mommy-Club I will be trying again. And I hope to succeed where I didn't last time. But I also know that my daughter who will be 4 this month would be no smarter or more special  had I breastfed, and I know that my new daughter will be just fine if it doesn't work this time too.

Atena 5 pts

 There are some people who just don't know how to honor the experiences of women who've had difficulty breastfeeding, or families that were not able to make it work for them.  That is a shame.  There is no single perfect way for everyone.

Formula will always be available in hospitals, because some babies will need it.  But that's different than a marketing stratgy where formula companies provide seemingly harmless little gift packs full of formula samples and advertising to new moms and dads who are exhausted and overwhelmed.  The time after a baby is delivered is very raw and vulnerable, and they exploit that.  And it works. 

There's a whole industry that is invested in breastfeeding failing as often as possible, because that means they sell more product.  That's not a value judgement, that's business. 

Does that mean that the people who use and need formula are somehow to blame for these predatory business practices?  Of course not.  There are a lot of victims in the crossfire of the breastmilk vs. formula wars.  And much like the 'Mommy Wars', it's a pretty useless battle.  These are personal choices, and there should be support for everyone's choices.

Breastfeeding support and respect for formula-feeding families do not have to be mutually exclusive. Jerks who support breastfeeding don't make breastfeeding a bad idea.  Please remember this in case you ever have the opportunity to support a women who does want to breastfeed and just needs a kind word of encouragement.

 -Atena

Assumptions, Biases & Irrational Fantasies ( http://antibias.wordpress.com )

madeintaiwan 5 pts

My first daughter hated breastfeeding, just hated it. I tried so so hard for 4 months but she would consistently pull off and scream bloody murder. I finally just let her have the bottle full-time and she was happy as a clam. My next two kids were the complete opposite - would have nothing to do with the bottle at all and breastfed into the second year. We just do the best we can as a family to work these issues out so that everyone is relatively sane. ;)

http://watermelonmama.wordpress.com/

Chaney 5 pts

It wasn't easy breast feeding my son at first.  I went back to work part time and couldn't pump enough milk for the time I was away so he also go formula.  At 6 months he seemed to lose patience for the breast and started preferring bottles most of the time.  To each their own and their decisions are theirs and theirs alone and not for us to judge based on a brief encounter.