Bio
Unwilling to fully abandon my Chicago-area upbringing, I live in Manhattan with my husband, my teddy bear, and a 10 lb. rabbit, but insist on calling...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Recent Comments

Would the American Economy Collapse if Women Stopped Hating Their Natural Appearance? A Look at Makeup

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Last week, I mentioned how pleased I was that douche no longer seems to be a mainstream product in the United States. I thought that this might be a sign of progress: women are no longer accepting that their natural vaginal scent is something to be covered by perfume. A comment from Julie Artz of Chezartz.com stopped me in my tracks. She asked:

How many companies rely on us feeling crappy about our bodies to sell more product? If we all loved our bodies the way they are, douche companies wouldn't be the only ones going out of business--the diet, health & beauty, pharmaceutical, and cosmetic surgery industries would suffer as well!


Think of the money we could save if we loved ourselves and accepted our bodies in their natural state.



Consider some basic statistics:

Cosmetics/Makeup
• The cosmetics industry is a $30 billion industry with an annual growth rate of 20%
• Cosmetics are recession-proof
• They are an affordable indulgence. And a necessity for some!
• Cosmetics are a high-margin product
(Sources: Franching.com; a PBS American Experience documentary on the Miss American pageant notes that the American cosmetics industry was $25 billion in 1999.)

What makes me nervous about the facts listed above is how it makes women look like suckers. Here we are foolishly throwing money away during recessions because we think of makeup like food: it's a basic necessity. Given that women continue to earn approximately 78 cents to every dollar a man makes for doing the same job, every penny of ours counts.

I tried to find reliable statistics on how much the average American woman spends on makeup per year, but the best I could find were estimates ranging from $200 - $5,000. Cosmeticsdesign.com reported that a survey of British women by New Woman magazine found that the average amount spent on cosmetics is "a whopping £3,000 (€4,300) a year" (including hair products).

Is it really worth it to spend our hard earned money on things that make us look stereotypically beautiful? Many would argue that makeup is, in fact, a bargain. Helen Johnson, the editor of New Woman magazine, explained the survey results by noting that, "Just buying make-up and anticipating putting it on makes women feel good." What's the harm in spending a couple of hundred bucks a year to make ourselves feel good? It certainly is cheaper than therapy!

Silicon Valley Blogger at The Digerati Life explored whether she should begin wearing makeup, which would cost her about $356 per year:

…should I upgrade my appearance or should I continue to scrimp on cosmetics and clothes? It’s the age old question for women: how much should I fork over to make myself look attractive?… I’m happy to say that I’m content about how I present myself to the public, and for the most part, I haven’t offended the public yet either, so I guess that’s all that matters. For now, I’ve decided to invest my money elsewhere but who knows, the time may come when my female vanity rears its dormant head; and given how fast time flies, that moment may just be around the corner!

In her article "Why Vanity Keeps Us Poor" at Sirens Magazine, Molly Faulkner-Bond writes:

Seriously, I could be rich (or at least get richer faster) if I gave up my beauty routine. Currently, my daily self-prepping involves the following: shampoo, conditioner, shower gel, face wash, toothpaste, body lotion, face moisturizer, blusher, a bit of glimmer for my cheeks, eyeliner, mascara, lip gloss, and perfume. And I’m a basics kind of gal. Most American women also add in regular salon and spa stuff like spray tanning, waxing, highlights, haircuts, manis, pedis, microdermabrasion and Botox.

At any rate, if women collectively decided that we were fine with our faces without makeup enhancing them, it would certainly cost the American economy an enormous amount of money and thousands of jobs would be lost. It is disheartening to think about how much the economy relies on us to hate our natural appearances (only 3% of women in the British survey felt that they were naturally beautiful).

Suzanne also blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants and usually looks like a slob because she's too cheap and lazy to wear makeup

  • 10
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
dishthehappyfish 5 pts

I choose the middle path.  I can take it or leave it.  I used to be zealously anti make up, anti feminine, anti frills.....but I grew up and realized I had missed some fun!  I am getting too old to miss any more of the good stuff.  Just stop me before I don the purple dress and red hat....yuk....that is going to far.

PS..I can't bring myself to wear jewelry, though.  It always looks so tacky to me.  I really need to learn not to be so judgemental about this stuff.

dunkadyke 5 pts

Let me guess, anything that could enhance a person's appearance is a no-no. Let's discuss the origin of makeup. It's to hide nature's flaws. Anything that could possibly help a person's self esteem isn't a bad thing.

And before you take it a step further and say that it's something strictly designed for the male agenda, maybe it was a gay male that created it for women to use. So does that make it wrong?

And what about the fashion designers? If you don't want to put on a dress, is it a backlash against the fashion designers of your own thread.

Should the gay females support the gay males?

It boils down to this.......A gay male's best friend is a woman and he loves men......There's no hatred in him.

Try to say that about a gay female: You can't. They love women but can't accept men.

Stop heterophobia now
SHNOW

Suzanne 5 pts

So true! While I was trying to dig up some facts on cosmetic spending, I came across a few sites that really detail the horrific stuff they put into a lot of make-up. Breast Cancer Action ( http://bcaction.org ) has an enormous number of facts and reports on parabens and other potentially cancer causing chemicals in make-up. Many of the products are the same ones used in pink ribbon campaigns to promote breast cancer awareness and research!

Suzanne Reisman ( http://blogher.org/member/suzanne ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://blogher.org/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

julieartz 5 pts

...But there's another really disturbing element to the whole makeup debate and that's the chemicals major beauty producers use in their products!

I think people tacitly understand the dangers of things like hair dye (good article on natural alternatives here: http://www.thedailygreen.com/living-green/blogs/or... ( http://www.thedailygreen.com/living-green/blogs/or... ))

But, do women really think about the chemicals they're paying good money to expose themselves to? A few minutes on the Environmental Work Group's Skin Deep cosmetics database is enough to encourage anyone to stop buying cosmetics (or at least switch to good ol' Burt's Bees!): http://www.ewg.org/featured/214

If we added the cost of the environmental impact of these products to the $30 billion the make-up industry is making, it makes looking glamorous seem like a bit of a rip-off, don't you think?

For the record, I do occasionally wear makeup, get my brows waxed, etc., so I'm no saint when it comes to this topic. It's just something I've been thinking about thanks to Suzanne's great posts on the subject...

:) Julie
ChezArtz.com
ToysNaturally.com

A Elliot 5 pts

I wear makeup, but my make up costs me no more than $30 a year: eyeliner, eyeshadow and mascara. I'm still using that free lipgloss from BlogHer which I really like. I do use moisturizer, but that's because I have dry skin. I absolutely agree with what you're saying. If we could accept the way we looked, then we wouldn't need to be spending all this money on cosmetics. However, I think that the argument could be made much larger. You can argue the same thing about clothes. Why spend a ton of money on clothes? Does it really matter if the more expensive jeans really do make some people feel that they look better? How much of things that we buy are really because they make us feel better about ourselves? Whether it's clothes, a car, a bigger house, I think that a large part of the purchases can many times be attributed to the fact that it makes us feel better. How many times are we told that we can feel better about ourselves if we go out and purchase those things?The difference is that those things cut across the gender lines, while cosmetics for the most part is aimed at women. I wear makeup because I enjoy wearing it. I like putting it on. Yes, I have noticed a difference in how people to respond to me when I don't wear it because I don't wear it every day. Usually people will comment that I look tired or I'll get called "Ma'am".
Alex Elliot, Formula Fed and Flexible Parenting ( http://www.flexibleparenting.com )

Suzanne 5 pts

I think the numbers are a real problem. Some reports are just for items I consider cosmetics: lipstick, blush, eye shadow, foundation, etc. Others include moisturizers. Others also include shampoo and soap, which in my mind is a basic need - most of us regularly use shampoo and soap - so that skews the numbers a lot. Still others add in the mani-pedi, shaving, waxing, etc. (Someone could do a very good thesis on this.) My goal was to try and keep it to the cosmetics level, which is a $30 billion industry alone, but it was nearly impossible to find pure numbers, so I tried to give a range. There will always be people like us who keep the average number lower, and there will always be Paris HIlton-types on the other end of the spectrum.

Suzanne Reisman ( http://blogher.org/member/suzanne ), Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender ( http://blogher.org/topic/feminism-gender )
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants ( http://cussandotherrants.com/ )

nellewrites 6 pts

Wasn't there a story out a month or so ago that suggested women buy more cosmetics during an economic downturn? Or am I delusional as usual?

I can see this from a couple of perspectives. Having crossed gender lines, self-esteem was a fundamental issue. Finding ways to boost said esteem was vital long term. Had the ability to make changes not been available, it likely would be devastating.

For the record, I have to wear a wig. Testosterone destroyed my hair 3 decades ago, a rather ironic happening for someone with my issues. (There is an upside - no bed hair for me.)

Make up was of huge help during the early days of electrology (450 or so hours now, and that equates to $5400 real dollars since April, 2003.) I've been lasered (for free) on six occasions, with said laser zapping me on leg, neck, face, arms, and one was photo-facial treatment. I've both waxed and zapped eyebrows, with zapping the normal means now. Then there are the adjunct things, not usually associated directly with beauty - jewellery as one example.

There is no doubt there are esteem issues out there, and how we deal with this is both good and bad - sad we see ourselves in this way, but on the other side, have ways to help us through.

I'd like to see young women not be sucked in and beholden to the beauty machine. I'd also like to see all of us have the strength to be more outspoken and confident in doing what we wish to do inside, and not be dependent on what others might think, believe, etc.

Good topic!

nelle ( http://www.nelle2nelle.org/ )

nellewrites 6 pts

a little experiment: my thoughts before reading your post, then we will come back with opinion after reading the posting.

My first thought: lmao! Amused. Might feel guilty after reading.

Stated up front, I rarely use make up, being essentially post electrology, and having decent skin. I do use a moisturiser on my face daily, because in that regard... my skin is left wanting. Perfumes? No... other than occasional use of a scented hand moisturiser given me by my sis. OK, and I use a body wash, not soap.

So there is one out of 160 million. Surely that tips the scale my way? ;-)

Now to read, and see what kind of idiot the above comments pre-read has rendered me to be.

nelle ( http://www.nelle2nelle.org/ )

Zandria 5 pts

I wear makeup, but there's no way that I spend anywhere near the thousands (or even hundreds) of dollars that these statistics suggest. Foundation lasts me at least six months. I can usually get at least 3 months out of a tube of mascara. Maybe the totals are adding in all those "extras", like manicures, pedicures, tanning, facials, etc? That's the only way I can think that the totals would be so high. (And there's certainly more expensive makeup out there than I buy, but I'm fine with what I use.)

Personal blog: Keep Up With Me ( http://www.zandria.us )
BlogHer blog: Life - Singles ( http://blogher.org/blog/zandria )

Pam 5 pts

Hallelujah, Suzanne. We're wallowing in debt, just wallowing in it, and we could, you know, find some money somewhere if we stopped buying all that STUFF to make us look unlike we look already.

Makeover shows are always sending some perfectly reasonable looking human to "start wearing makeup" to "enhance their features" but a good haircut and the right color (me of the too cheap to get a good haircut regularly sez) goes miles towards looking fab.

5000 a YEAR? A YEAR? Whoa. And your example at Sirens says she's a "basics" kinda gal? Glimmer is a "basics" item?

You could write a novel with what I don't know about makeup. Though it would take a lot less paper to describe how little I care about that particular hole in my knowledge.

Nerd's Eye View ( http://www.nerdseyeview.com )