Blog
Parentopia
Bio
I am excited to be a Family CE at BlogHer! My primary blog is www.Parentopia.com/blog . I am an author of the award winning book "Mommy Guilt:Learn t...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Mammography Office Down on Boobies in Breastfeeding Discrimination Case

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

"Congratulations on the birth of your baby and welcome back to work! We have a bathroom all set up for you to pump your breast milk. By the way if your pumping means we have to wait to use the can, we will fire your ass. Glad to have you back at work!"

Okay, so maybe that wasn't the exact way the conversation went down, but the actions of a midtown Manhattan mammography office have resulted in a complaint filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission(EEOC) by a worker who claims she was fired illegally.  What makes this case particularly noteworthy is the worker is claiming she was discriminated against by her office manager for pumping her breasts for milk at work. At a mammography office.  One would think a mammography office manager would know better  and not be such a boob.  N'est-ce pas? Mais non!

Yadiris Rivera, a 28-year-old mother, had been employed by Manhatten Medical Imaging for six years. In April 2009, Rivera gave birth to a baby girl; upon returning to work, she used a breast pump three times a day. By law employers in New York are to provide a "sanitary facility," but Rivera's employer provided a bathroom. Six months after she had returned to work and after six months of pumping her breasts in the bathroom, Rivera's office manager told her to stop pumping at work as it was inconveniencing co-workers.  According to the complaint, when Rivera wasn't enthused about that option, her employer offered her the opportunity to pump her breasts in another woman's office.  Only the offer to use  her breast pump elsewhere included in the presence of another person.  While most of us wouldn't mind sharing a lunch room with a co-worker, sharing a lactation space with a co-worker probably wouldn't go over so well.  Such was the case with Rivera who determined her employer's offer to use her breast pump in the presence of another wasn't a a reasonable accommodation. And it wasn't.

Rivera reported the problem to the New York Civil Liberties Union, which attempted to educate Rivera's employer about breast feeding discrimination.  My guess is  Rivera's employer didn't appreciate being schooled, opted for a "tough titty" approach and fired Rivera. Because according to Rivera's complaint, she was fired shortly after her employer was contacted by the NYCLU.

Following her termination, Rivera chose to file her complaint with the EEOC. According to Rivera, "I told them that it was very uncomfortable," and "I felt deep inside that it can't be right a person expressing milk for their daughter in the bathroom." While her employer didn't seem to be all that concerned about Rivera being put in the position of having to choose between her baby or her job, the EEOC is going to be pretty pumped up about making sure employers like Rivera's are not allowed to get away with violating breast feeding discrimination laws. 

Do you know the laws in your state? Have you ever experienced breast feeding discrimination?

  • 8
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Zakary 5 pts

I had to use my boss's office. I am a bartender and that was the only place that had a lock and a chair.

It wasn't really an ideal situation, but it worked.

mrsL 5 pts

that breastfeeding helps prevent breast cancer! I am assuming of course that the mammography office WANTS to prevent breast cancer.

Elena,

"If you bungle raising your children, nothing else much matters." Jackie Kennedy

sushishishi 5 pts

this really burns me!!!

I am 34 weeks pregnant and have YET to hear my maternity leave policy from work - and I work at a CHURCH. I started asking in November, and keep hearing the same thing from this group of men, "We are still researching and creating our plan." Seriously, I'm already starting to dilate and don't know if I am getting paid leave or not.

Different issue I know, but it just goes to show that there is a wide range of maternity insensitivity in this country's workforce.

I feel for this woman - that she had to resort to filing against this company. But she didn't only need to do it for her own well being, but for the issue as a whole!

Devra Renner 5 pts

While lactation rooms are awesome, and a help to moms who are nursing, they aren't actually what I would call a "benefit" only because, at least to me, to be a true benefit, it must apply to every single employee regardless of their job description, gender, etc.

A real benefit would be, as you said, offering scheduling options that not only would be made available to everyone, but actually could be utilized without having to worry about getting the stink eye from your supervisor or co-workers.

Devra Renner

@ParentopiaDevra on Twitter

Contributing Editor, Family Connections

I also write at: Parentopia ( http://www.parentopia.com/blog ), Draft Day Suit ( http://www.draftdaysuit.com ),

writeandchange 5 pts

Maybe her bosses should have been made to eat lunch in the bathroom, and given her one of their (empty) offices to pump in.

Karen Banes  (@writeandchange ( http://twitter.com/writeandchange )) blogs at ChangeTheWorldWithWords.com ( http://www.changetheworldwithwords.com/ )

badgermama 5 pts

Anyone who pumps for 6 months at work has my deep respect! I had a lactation room and still couldn't manage to relax enough for the let-down, if you know what I mean.

And I hope they nail that employer for it - firing someone for pumping at work is just wrong.

sfaithj 5 pts

go mama! we have these laws for a reason.

pinkpixel 5 pts

At my workplace, there is a clearly marked, locked "lactation room" complete with a pair of roomy refrigerators and freezers (you can request a key from your "lactation board coordinator"). And there's more than one "L" room. There's one on every floor, or every other floor, I can't remember which. This is despite the fact that men outnumber women about 3 to 1 (among the people I know, at least). There's even a little notice posted in the bathroom as a reminder, in case you get to the stall with your pump before you notice the L room. I don't think anyone on my floor is currently lactating; In general, I think that my corporation has had trouble retaining new moms, due to the inflexible scheduling options. Maybe that's why they installed the L room. Well, I'm glad they've got us covered!