Bio
I'm awesome. I think. Pretty sure. Maybe not. You tell me.   Something you didn't know and never would have guessed: My first crush was on Adam...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Young (White & Thin) Hollywood

  • Share This Post
  • submit
  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

I feel like I should first begin with telling you all that I love Vanity Fair, and I love Annie Leibovitz's photos, in general. I find the articles interesting and pictures beautiful. Alright, that's enough of a disclaimer.

I'm pretty unhappy with Vanity Fair, and the "choice" of ladies they've put on their cover this month. I'm sure the moment you see it, you'll see what's irking me.

Cover Girls March 2010

[img source.]

Really, Vanity Fair? This is Young Hollywood? These are the It Girls? These pale, bony girls? That's all we have going for us? If that's the case, we've basically been watching the same film over and over, because save for the hair colors, I can barely tell the difference! All dressed and made up the same in muted colors, all with the same vapid expressions. Where's the variety? Do we not have any in Hollywood nowadays?

Oh, that's right -- we DO.

This year was pretty great for young women of color, and two in particular. With the breakout roles of Gabourey Sidibe of Precious (who happens to also have something none of them except Carey Mulligan have: an Oscar nomination for Best Actress) and Zoe Saldana of Avatar and Star Trek, women of color starred in two of the most talked-about films of the past year. Their performances garnered more attention than any of the girls on this cover, which supposedly highlights the best and brightest of our new talent. Other than Kristin Stewart, who blends in so well that you barely notice her -- and whom if it weren't for Twilight, you wouldn't know either -- can you name any of these new stars? I wouldn't think so. I couldn't, and I've seen almost every single film they've acted in this year.

I'm usually not so quick to play the race card, to point out the lack of brown skin, but it's just slapping me right on in the face here. It's almost like Vanity Fair did it on purpose, like they want to piss us off. I don't consider this an oversight, or a blatant slight necessarily, just a conscious decision by the editors of Vanity Fair to send us a message that what is pictured is what they feel is worth celebrating, and nothing else. It's not just in the photos, but in the descriptions of the ladies, such as this one:

The Cupid’s-bow lips, the downy-soft cheeks, the button nose: 27-year-old Abbie Cornish has those Ivory-soap-girl features we’re so familiar with..."

You're damn right we're familiar with it, so we don't need you showcasing it nine times over on the same magazine cover! It doesn't seem like it'd be that hard to toss in some fuller lips, rounder cheeks and wider noses to me, and I'm just flabbergasted. When are these magazines going to start treating us all equally? When are they going to stop force-feeding our young women the "pale and thin is best" agenda? I for one am sick and tired of it.

  • 11
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
cshel718 5 pts

...you don't expect the rampantly caucasian editors of Vanity Fair to actually acknowledge the fact that there's a talented and/or plus-sized and/or black person who possibly has a future in Hollywood?  I'm sure they're just hoping she'll go away...'cause if she doesn't, they might be forced to put her on the cover in the future...and how many magazines would that sell, right? 

Great post!

www.coppolawords.com ( http://www.coppolawords.com )

Rolling 5 pts

Thank you so much for this post. I'm an avid Vanity Fair reader, so I would have thought Graydon Carter had his finger on the pulse of current a little more accurately.  This looks like rising Hollywood from... never, actually.  There have always been actors of color on the rise (if not at the top).  These days, actors from other countries making a name for themselves in Hollywood is commonplace.

I expected WAY better.  Thanks again for the well-written post. 

WordyDoodles ( http://www.wordydoodles.blogspot.com )

Tre - 5 pts

a day when there's as equal (b/c to say instead of is not practical but i can wish it) a pull to promote women in:

science

education

technology

non profit leadership

humanitarian aid

business

motherhood

healthcare

clergy

environment care.

and every. other. role. women. live.

or is there some indirect message that young women should ONLY aspire to become thin and pale skinned and famous celebrities

it's surely a phenomenal point about cultural background Maria...but for me its the promotion of hollywood as 'the goal' for which we must aspire.

where's: a new decade: and what the women are doing...

but then again, that is why we have blogher.com.

Tre~

tw:   @tresha ( http://twitter.com/tresha )

fb:    http://facebook.com/treshathorsen

e:     tre@thoughtbythought.net

blog: http://thoughtbythought.net

Gina Carroll 5 pts

So Vanity Fair, what's so Hollywood new about this cover? You are so right on, Maria! There's nothing more to say...except the picture on Ebony's cover is Gabulous!! I love that girl!

( http://www.proactiveblackparenting.blogspot.com/ )

Think Act: Proactive Black Parenting ( http://www.proactiveblackparenting.blogspot.com )   and   Tortured By Teenagers ( http://momhouston.com/torturedbyteenagers )

Maria Young 5 pts

Damn good way to put it.

- Maria Young

immoralmatriarch.com ( http://immoralmatriarch.com )@maria0305
( http://twitter.com/maria0305 )

Megan Smith 5 pts

WTF Vanity Fair!  Come on!

As you said Maria, Zoe Saldana, or maybe Freida Pinto. 

God knows they would never put Gabourey Sidibe, Oscar nominee for "Precious."  We all know why that is.  And if you saw how lovely Gabby looks on the cover of Ebony ( http://gossiponthis.com/2010/02/03/gabby-sidibe-eb... )this month, you'd once again have to say to Vanity Fair, WTF?

Megan

TV/Online Video Contributing Editor ( http://www.blogher.com/blog/megan-smith )

Megan's Minute ( http://www.megansminute.com/ )

Meg's Rad Reviews ( http://www.megsradreviews.com )

Rusty Hoe 5 pts

I have nothing against these girls (not that I could name one of them) but it's a bit like looking at white noise (pardon the pun).  They are interchangable.   If this is supposed to represent the furture of Hollywood I find it puzzeling why the young girl from  Precious was not included.  The buzz surrounding her performance is incredible and she surely represents the highlights of Hollywood regardless of colour.  I wonder if she had been a skinny stick girl would she have been included despite colour?  Its time that Hollywood and the Media  celebrate the brilliant diversity we see in society.   As a society we like to think that we have moved past this obsession with this particular vision of beauty and success, but images like this demonstrate just how stuck we are.

candiacrew 5 pts

I'd have to say that everyone of these girls could easily be interchangeable for each other with a little hairdye or haircuts. There's no variety of shapes, there's barely a variety of hair colours.

There are plenty of beautiful talented women of different ethnicities that need to be featured. It's a real shame that more of them don't get the leading roles based on blind casting instead of everyone fitting in the same cookie cutter mold.

Erin Groh 5 pts

...when I saw this cover.  I find it very hard to believe that this just "slipped past" them, because, as you said, it goes beyond the choices of actresses themselves - they've even styled them to look pale and identical.

DListed had an entertaining post on this too (http://dlisted.com/node/35874) and also mentioned Gabourey Sidibe.

Very disappointing indeed.

Erin Groh

erin@blogher.com

Nordette Adams 6 pts

When I first heard about this and saw the picture, that's what I thought, "insular whiteness." And then a lot of other adjectives came to mind that i can't say on BlogHer. :-)

Good post, Maria.

Nordette Adams ( http://www.bookotopia.com ) is a BlogHer CE ( http://www.blogher.com/haystackprofile/viewprofile... ) & you can find her other stuff through Her 411 ( http://her411.com ).