Bio
I'm a woman, a wife, a mother, but first and foremost, I'm just a person trying to figure out how to be human.  I was raised in an extremely con...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

Your Faith, My Loss

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

There is a weight that is hanging on my shoulders today.  There is a loneliness that is palpable in the air.  I am totally absent from the every day.  I'm distracted and spending way too much time online trying to fill the feelings.  I should meditate.  I should at least exercise.  I have piles of laundry and lunch to clean up.  The kids are finally napping, so I should be working.  But my breath feels heavy.  My soul feels burdened.  

Last night I had a conversation with my sister, an evangelical Christian.  Despite our differences of faith, over the past few years we've grown very close as she's gone through the most troubling time of her life.  She was broken.  I was broken.  We related and talked about everything we were learning.  She's been a tremendous support to me.  However, as the clouds have lifted for her and therapy and determination and work have brought things around for her, she's become a lot more distant.  Her faith has taken center stage.  She firmly believes that God has brought her through this difficulty, and her faith in Jesus and the message of the Bible is all the more resolute.  Meanwhile, I have moved further away from Christianity and have found a spiritual path through meditation.  I have had an intense year of immense personal growth as well.  She knows this.  She's heard me tell her about all I've learned.  However, over the last couple months, as I've really begun studying Shambhala and meditating and learning, she's grown more distant.  Finally I confronted her about this.

Her response, "I cannot be happy for you.  Your beliefs are wrong."  

Wow.  I had just listened to her tell me, for 20 minutes, about all the God is doing in her life and in the lives of those around her.  I listened and appreciated all she's learning.  I try to understand.  I do mostly praise her for her effort and for being honest and present and for doing the work needed in her life.  I cannot give all the credit to God, as I don't believe he's all that involved.  But I listen and try to understand and am seriously happy for her and for how much she's learning.  But, because of her beliefs, she cannot do the same.  Christianity does not allow for that.

I grieve over these lost relationships.  Having grown up in a Christian community, I have so very many Christian friends who all feel the same way.  I'm a lost sheep who they are desperately hoping will come back home.  There is no validation for my own path, my own beliefs.  It is isolating and lonely and terribly saddening.  I know things would be so much easier if I just believed in Jesus as my savior.  I just cannot.  I feel I've seen the myth for what it is and cannot make the leap of faith that far.  Plus, the idea that God made this one path is one of the major reasons I do not believe.  It makes no sense to me.  I'm not rebelling.  I'm not fighting.  I just cannot believe nonsense.  

Well, there I go, I guess, doing the same thing.  Judging.  I'm judging her beliefs.  I'm not really as open as I think I am.  I just don't see GOD in the division that arises from such concrete faith.  How can he ever have devised such a divisive and hurtful plan?

I know we'll never know for sure.  My husband thinks that when we do find out the TRUTH, we're all going to be wrong.  Whoever or whatever is the energy behind this universe(s) is not something we've come up with on our own.  There is still so much we don't know about the universe and what it means to be human.  Surely, as we learn more, we'll begin to rule out some of these myths as real possibilities.  Just like we were able to rule out a flat earth and a sun god, we'll rule out many of these world religions.  

Until then, my relationship with my sister is now and forever will be barricaded by her wall of faith.  Or is it my wall of doubt?  I am so very sad to know it will never be as it could be.  Our entire family is severed by faith.  It took my parents to another country.  It made them leave their children with strangers.  And now it is keeping me from having a deep and meaningful relationship with my one and

  • 25
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Shannon LC Cate 5 pts

Your SISTER's version of Christianity may not allow for it, but many Christians are happy to leave well enough alone (and/or be happy for them) when other people are finding other ways.

"All that you have is your soul." Tracy Chapman

theoutcast 5 pts

I love how you pointed out the fear factor. That is the most troubling aspect of religions in general. Fear is so limiting and debilitating. I had not considered it's importance in our current context before.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.

noveleats 5 pts

We have gone to at least two or three Unitarian Universalist churches and have found them to be wonderful in terms of openness and community. There is a part of me that just has a hard time with the feeling that they are following the format of Christian church too much! I find my mind wandering and getting distracted almost exactly the same as in Christian churches. That said, I do appreciate their songs and poetry. It's interesting to hear those things in that environment. If we ever have kids we've thought that UU would be great to join. I love the idea of raising children in a safe environment where they can explore their beliefs and come to their own individual truths without being afraid of chastisement.

Also, I get that creepy feeling, too. I am not sure if I will ever entirely let that go because it was so drilled into me that everyone outside the church is wrong and I would be wrong to follow any other belief systems, but I do believe that I'm on this journey for a reason. I think that many who have moved beyond their religions into a new spiritual experience find themselves feeling this!

Discover how delicious and simple a plant-based diet can be by visiting www.noveleats.com ( http://www.noveleats.com ).

freshmints 5 pts

It took me over 10 years to really let go of the fear of damnation. I sometimes still get this creepy feeling, that's how entrenched I was, having grown up with missionary parents and a pastor uncle.

I recently attended a Unitarian Universalist church. They welcome people of all faiths and teach about all different paths. I really liked it. The choir sang George Harrison's My Sweet Lord which really made me love it. :)

My friend recently said, "In my opinion, the energy in the Universe is too vast to fit into one religion....I think of it like a wagon wheel....if we all got onto one spoke walking inward, it would break under our weight so there are many paths." I like that, and it really makes sense with the physics of the universe.

I wish you peace on your journey.

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

ebyrdstarr 5 pts

I do love my sister. We were really close growing up. But the thing I have had to come to terms with over the last 10 years or so is that if we weren't related, we would not be friends. I'm frankly not sure I like her that much. She is just a very rigid person in general, which definitely carries over into her religion specifically. I see others being friends with their siblings and it does make me sad that I don't have that, but I think (I hope) I'm done beating myself up over it. We're just too different.

Preaching to the Choir ( http://rantsofapublicdefender.blogspot.com/ )

freshmints 5 pts

Thank you, I will check out that book. You know, I was doing so well and so happy...I guess I just deceived myself into thinking she was more accepting than she is. I set myself up for the fall, but it feels good to read these comments and feel like I'm in a community of outsiders! :)

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

noveleats 5 pts

I'd also recommend Dance of the Dissident Daughter by Sue Monk Kidd. I am still in the midst of reading it, and while I don't entirely identify with her specific journey, I find her process and her relationship to her lifelong church to be eerily familiar. It's fascinating.

Discover how delicious and simple a plant-based diet can be by visiting www.noveleats.com ( http://www.noveleats.com ).

noveleats 5 pts

Your story is so interesting to me because I have been going through a similar spiritual transformation. Over the last several years I have basically just ignored my spiritual self, after being raised in a conservative Christian home, church and all of my education was also in similar environments. I suppose you could say I was taking a break. It's really only been in the last 9 months or so that I have been giving my spiritual self attention, and I can tell you that I feel so blessed and rewarded. It's infinitely better than any other spiritual experience in my life.

I haven't really discussed any of this with my family because they are still so entrenched in conservative Christianity. I am afraid that we'll have the same conversations you mention where they will say that I am in the wrong and I am in danger of losing out on eternal life. I genuinely don't believe that I am in danger, and I guess I haven't really thought how best to approach a conversation like that. I'm just not prepared.

At the same time, you're right - it's easy to also think that *they* are in the wrong. But I have come to the sincere belief that there are many ways to the Divine or to spiritual enlightenment (or "the truth") and everyone has a unique path that only they can travel. What is best for you or me may not be best for your family or mine. I admit I have hoped that there would be more people in my life to have a similar spiritual journey like mine, but spirituality is so personal and unique that it is impossible to expect that. I think that is one reason why I have disliked organized religion - it doesn't always allow for you to stretch your spiritual wings and explore.

I wish you luck and I hope that you and your sister will be able to come to a place of understanding and respect again!

Discover how delicious and simple a plant-based diet can be by visiting www.noveleats.com ( http://www.noveleats.com ).

freshmints 5 pts

I'm so glad this has resonated with so many. It makes me certainly feel less alone. I think my understanding of family is changing...I'm always holding on to this dream of being this tight-knit/catalog family, and, hopefully I can help to create that with my children. But maybe I can just allow my sibling relationships to be what they are and stop expecting more. I sure do love them though.

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

oilfieldwife 5 pts

My sister and I were both raised Catholic, and while neither of us really identify with that church anymore, we're still on different planes religiously from one another. I'm certainly more into Christianity than she is, and after a pretty rude comment from her one Christmas regarding my putting a bible verse on my Christmas cards, we just don't talk religion anymore. And things are great. We talk about crafting, her kids, and the silly things our husbands do. We live 1500 miles apart, so avoiding uncomfortable topics (no matter how much we, as humans, sometimes love to delve into them) is necessary, because the phone and yearly visits is all we've got. If your sister doesn't want to stop preaching to you, there isn't much you can do about that. But I think realizing that you both judge the other, and knowing that's not cool, is the best first step to repairing your relationship. Talk about the stuff you do agree on, that's always more fun anyway. :)

Liberal oilfield wife. I write, I hula hoop, I craft, and I listen to music you might hate. www.unlikelyoilfieldwife.com ( http://www.unlikelyoilfieldwife.com%20 )

jlucymuses 5 pts

Although I am not experiencing this within my family (thankfully!) I come from that background of dogma. I have to remind myself that I, too, am being judgmental. Now that I'm on the other side of it I just don't understand how "they" can possibly think that way. But we are all on our own journeys. I have come to believe we have Godde within and to use our gifts and talents for good is our Purpose.

I am studying religious recovery for my graduate thesis and I just read a fantastic book which may help. "Leaving the Fold" by Marlene Winell. It really explains the evangelical/fundamental Christian mindset and how those who have left can heal themselves.

~~~~
Joanna
http://wisdomwithinink.com
Creative Change Coach & Certified Journaling Instructor

Quiet Dreams 5 pts

I converted to Judaism after growing up in a family that sounds like yours. Things have gotten better than they were in those first couple of years, but there are many things we don't talk about, and I find that my family has a certain view of the way they think I should be practicing Judaism, though they know very little about it.

I really agree with your husband. I don't think any of us know THE TRUTH though we may get slight glimpses of it at times. I think we will all be surprised.

fouragainsttwo 6 pts

I have noticed, and gone through myself, that when a person first becomes a Christian that they are very ridged with their beliefs. As your faith grows you are able to be more open to others.
Unfortunately for many Christians today they are so afraid of everthing that they are blinded by the true love of Christ. I call it "Americanized Christianity" where everyone sits in there own perfect world and everone else is wrong, evil or muslim! I don't see alot of growth in these Christians.
Please don't think all Christians are so closed minded! I hope you and your sister can work things out and become closer.

Mandy W.

FourAgainstTwo.com

Crystal Dempsey-Gillum 5 pts

I can very much relate to your post. I grew up in a Baptist household and I just do not believe the same way. It is a big barrier between my mom and I. We are very close but I keep feeling this will all blow up some day and cause a rift. I mostly keep silent about religion with her.

christyfarr 5 pts

I loved this post. Thank you for being so open.

I grew up feeling like a weed, like I didn't belong anywhere I was supposed to fit in. Nothing made sense about being this person. It took a long time for me to realize that I wasn't a weed at all...

I was a wildflower planted in a rose garden.

So, I got out of the comparison game. I let go of the people who loved me for the person they thought I was, and created a community who understands what it feels like to be not like the others. By doing the self-discovery work and speaking our truths, we are able to find one another.

Lastly, in writing my coming out story over the last few weeks, realized that I've "come out" about a great many things, not just sexual orientation. I asked around and found that for my Wildflower community, women had the experience you've described around everything from the way they eat to political position, and from spirituality to being a survivor of rape and/or domestic abuse. The list went on and on, I was amazed.

Among my coaching clients, I've seen a great deal of coming out around their superpowers - especially the healers (of all kinds) really struggle to admit to themselves that they have these spiritual gifts. Once they have it can be scary to share it with the world.

I think self-acceptance is the most God-like thing you can do. So, rock on.

Check out my blog: Thoughts on Life... and How to Change It.

http://christyfarr.blogspot.com/

freshmints 5 pts

I hope I can do what you do and keep on loving the same despite her feelings. That's such a great perspective. It's hard to accept a faith that counts me out, but I guess I need to love my sister and not her faith. Thank you.

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

freshmints 5 pts

That's it, isn't it? The hardest part is the inability to change it. And I freaking LOVE my sister. She is so great. I normally call her every day...now I feel this deep sense of loss. I know I need to come to terms with my lack of ability to control it...but for now I just feel sad. Boo.

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

freshmints 5 pts

Funny that you mentioned that quote. I've been thinking a lot lately about embracing difficulty because I know, for sure, that it brings growth. I read this quote yesterday by Wendell Berry...amazing.

"It may be that when we no longer know which way to go that we have come to our real journey. The mind that is not baffled is not employed. The impeded stream is the one that sings." — Wendell Berry

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

Nobody wants to be Ethel 5 pts

You know my sister and I are completely different on a lot of fronts. One time we talked politics not really knowing what the other one's position was. She said something nasty to me about my opinion. I didn't speak to her for quite awhile. Lucky for me she brought the olive branch by just being my sister. We don't talk politics anymore AND I don't judge her. I just let her talk about her life and I listen.

Patty

JennaHatfield 9 pts

I sparkled TW's comment above because it's true. I was raised in a Christian home. My mom, despite her own short-comings, has accepted my differences on opinion on various subjects. My brother, however, has a very, very narrow view of what Christianity can/could/should/etc mean. We clash because of it. I don't know why/how he acts/feels the way he does when we were raised in a very different way. I'm confused and hurt by it often.

But I keep on keeping on. I love him. And I know that my faith is my own. And his is his own.

Contributing Editor Jenna Hatfield (@FireMom ( http://twitter.com/FireMom )) blogs at Stop, Drop and Blog ( http://stopdropandblog.com ) and The Chronicles of Munchkin Land ( http://thechroniclesofmunchkinland.com ). She is a freelance writer and newspaper photographer.

CherylK 5 pts

I've been there, too. Here's what makes me sad...I don't believe there is a bad religion, per se. I believe that if you live your life in the best way you can, no matter which deity you worship, you are right. It's what's in your heart that counts.

I'm afraid that organized religion is harmful to that end. Organized religion encourages intolerance of each other. And I just don't "get" that. And it makes me sad.

But...thinking positive and seeking inner peace makes me happy. There's so much beauty in the world that focusing on that, I'm convinced, is the way to go.

My faith is more akin to that of our Native Americans and I think Buddhism is the most beautiful of faiths. But those are just two of many. Those are good places to start. You can't get more spiritual than that, I'm sure.

"If you find a path with no obstacles, it probably doesn't lead anywhere"

Lake Mary Musings ( http://www.lakemarymusings.com )

TW 6 pts

unfortunately, it just doesn't work that way for all Christians for some reason.

Retro-Food.com

ebyrdstarr 5 pts

My sister and I are also divided by this wall. She is an evangelical Christian and I am an atheist. I don't even know if she knows I define myself this way because I have kept it from her. I fear the conversation that would result if I didn't. As a result of our vastly differing world views, I feel I can't talk to her about anything. I see other people talking to their siblings in a way I just can't and I am sad that she and I have this barrier. But I don't think there is anything I can (or should I say am willing) to do about it.

Preaching to the Choir ( http://rantsofapublicdefender.blogspot.com/ )

freshmints 5 pts

Thank you for your comment. I am way too obsessed with feedback to not read my comments! :) I am starting to feel more confident about my own faith or lack thereof. My husband is great about helping me shake loose that self-doubt and need for validation. I just really wish things could be different with our family. Maybe one day...

Check out my blog about life and motherhood and learning to be present.

www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  ( http://www.freshmintings.blogspot.com  )

theoutcast 5 pts

I hope you read your comments. I've noticed many people don't.

I really appreciate what you have written about here. I have explored religions and settled on my own personal faith. I meditate in the car while listening to SPA on the XM and when the clock has a series of 11010 -- you are definitely not alone!

It's troubling that so many women/moms feel they need guidance from books and religious leaders that do not even speak to her personal experiences. She clearly did something right for herself and may be something greater helped along the way. Who really knows? It's all very personal.

She may have been raised to feel bad about owning her power (as women -- especially in religions do). Unfortunately, they risk becoming manipulated and controlled.

You are not alone. I say own your greatness and find your peace! If it is working for you, you are doing the right thing.

Heather blogs about Motherhood & Other Offensive Situations at http://www.ultimateoutcasts.com.