Is Your Son Acting Like a Boy? Is Your Daughter Acting Like a Girl?
by Rita Arens

I've had at least five conversations with moms lately in which they say, "I just wouldn't know what to do with a girl," or "he acts like such a BOY." I actually believe nature is often more influential than nurture in long-term development, but is our early childhood behavior really so defined by gender? Are we helping anyone out by making comments like that? No, we are not.

Andi at Poot and Cubby writes:

Sometimes I will tell those who ask what it’s like to have a boy those things, because that is what they expect to hear.  That boys are one-sided, kamikaze tornadoes that roar through your life.  Sometimes I want to keep the other moments to myself - those moments that are the opposite of off-handed remarks like “boys will be boys”.  Those moments are mine.

What is it like to "act like a boy"? Does it mean the child is especially active, especially physical, especially muddy? And girls, of course, are quieter, tidier and more talkative, right?

Sometimes, sometimes. I have a girl who "acts like a girl" in all those ways, but then again, she "acts like a boy" when she runs shrieking through the house after the cat. I don't think either the stereotypical boy behaviors or the stereotypical girl behaviors are bad behaviors, but we have to be careful about how we label our kids, how we talk to them about being a boy or a girl. At least, we do when they're younger. At least until they're old enough to decide for themselves how they want to act.

Some children act like both, like RunningMom's son:

When my son was little, he used to want me to paint his fingernails and toenails and he also liked to wear a tutu (like for ballet), lol. In addition, he was facinated with trucks, trains and sports. He no longer wants me to paint his fingernails or dress in girls clothing, but what if he did?

 

Laura of Autism is Beautiful writes:

I’ve noticed that my son doesn’t fall into specific gender roles, even
if we promote it. And, I love it! I love that we have an “excuse” to
“allow” our boy to play with whatever toys he chooses. I hate it when
people tease boys about playing with dolls or toy kitchens. Why the
outrage? Most boys will grow up to be husbands and fathers, and most
boys see their own dads cooking or caring for children, soooo…it only
seems natural that they would choose to emulate that in their dramatic
play. Yet, there still seems to be a stigma associated with little boys
in sparkly dressup clothes, playing with dollies, and cooking up
plastic food in the Fisher Price kitchen. Even in families like ours,
where it’s a houseful of girls and one little boy.

Whether boys act wild or sit quietly and whether girls terrorize the block with sticks and stones or idly brush their Barbie's hair, we must remember never to insinuate "acting like a girl" is "acting weak or inferior." I could care less how kids act, but it really pisses me off that when I went to Google blogs and searched "acts like a boy," I got a ton of loving descriptions of romping children, and when I searched "acts like a girl," I got rappers going down and the definition of "pansy," which I won't justify with a link.  Clearly, acting like a girl is still bad or wrong, even in the year 2009. Or that's what people are writing on their blogs when they write of acting like a girl.

We can change that. The women of BlogHer are effective writers, broad-based and from all walks of life, all races and sexual orientations. We can write about our pride in our daughters AND SONS for acting like girls, not for playing with tea sets or giggling, but for behaving the way we've taught them to behave, with compassion, foresight and intelligence. Behaving as a woman should behave. Women are multi-taskers. Women are achievers. It's time for "acting like a girl" to mean something new.

Comments

 

ruhroh and cough!

Obviously this is something I am attuned to, but most often blow off, such is its prevalence - it would basically be something like nelle vs the world (OK, I exaggerate, there are lots of queer and non-queer folk who address this, as you have.)

For lots of reasons I defy such stereotyping, but so too my daughters. Our youngun could trash her bedroom in less time than it takes me to write this post. Her best friend through most of her childhood years (she is 17 now) was the song of a friend, they were virtually inseparable for a long time. Most often she played what he wished to play.

When I was younger, OK, maybe I sucked at baseball, but was decent in basketball, and spent what seems like half my life in a tree - any tree, point me towards one. Had my physical sex been correct at birth, I'd get pinned with a 'tomboy' label.

The messages we convey on gender are at once subtle in the observing but powerful in cumulative effect, and too often the entrenched attitudes do serious damage when the pubertal years roll around.

Boxes are best left to choosing. 

 

llhaesa

 

Choosing your own way

I have a 4-year-old daughter who, in spite of my efforts to be neutral seems to embrace everything 'girly'. It's her choice, and I've made my peace with it. I am certain that she will evolve into her own person regardless of her current love of all things pink and sparkly.

And now I have an infant son. And he idolizes his big sister as far as I can tell. His eyes light up for her. And of course he seems to be drawn to all things pink and shiny too. And I think that's great. Of course he looks up to her, she's the 'big kid' and she does the big kid stuff that he wants to do, too. Compared to him she is very powerful.

It's my hope that my son is able to choose his own identity, just as my daughter has chosen hers.

~ Amber

www.strocel.com

 

Wish Less Emphasis on 'the roles'

I wish there was less emphasis on the whole role thing. My youngest dresses in dresses and is pretty 'girly', and my oldest is a tree climbing runner. I want them each to have the possibility to express themselves the way they want and to try anything they want. Oftentimes there are comments about what a 'girl' or 'tomboy' one or the other is - the stereotypes really begin so young.

Kathy

Allbusiness:Working Mothers

Mama Marathoner

 

 

Embracing Who They Are

What a telling thing that Google search is and what a terrific post. But the solutions to stereotyping our kids aren't easy or straight forward.  I've raised one of each and although neither was rambunctious or sweet, they did tend to gravitate toward what we might think of as stereotypical behaviour.  My son obsessed over baseball and computer operating systems, my daughter wore pink for 2 years and loves dance.

More and more, I'm coming to believe that we need to embrace our kids for who they are.  Sure you can give your son a doll and dress him up in pink or sign your daughter up for rugby, but that isn't going to change the world.

Instead, I like to support my kids in being who they want to be and encourage the world around us to accept them for that.  I couldn't agree more with yo, Rita, when you say thatit's time for acting like a girl to mean something new.  We have to change the world's perceptions not our kids.

Jill

Hailey Hacks

Story2.OH

Running With My Eyes Closed